The Day of The Doctor has come and gone, and all in all it was a spectacular success. It managed to encapsulate just what everyone loves about The Doctor and his adventures, as well as set the stage for Christmas and beyond. However, despite the special being an amazing celebration of Doctor Who history, The Day of The Doctor did contain some elements that could have been better. Then again, there are some things that were absolutely pitch perfect and couldn't have gone better. Mixed bag as it may have been, I really did enjoy The Day of The Doctor more than I criticized it, but there are still a couple things I have to take the special to task on. Join me now, as I go through 5 things that worked about the special, as well as 5 things that could have worked a little better. So that we don't end on a negative note, we'll start with the things that didn't work.
5 Things That Didn't Work
Advertisement
5. Osgood Was A Horrible Character
First thing's first: Osgood is the Jar Jar Binks of The Day Of The Doctor. Her character adds very little to the story, except that of another hapless member of UNIT personnel just waiting to get waylaid by the baddies. As if that wasn't bad enough, she stands around praying for The Doctor to save everyone, as if he were her God or something. To top off the sundae of annoyance... she never takes off the Fourth Doctor's scarf. One could see it as foreshadowing, but I see it as unintentional product placement for Etsy, and really bad product placement at that. Yes, it helped her survive in a pinch, but it was still rather interesting to have this character constantly walking around with an oversized scarf on her person. Osgood could have been put to better use instead of outdoing Martha Jones in the category of "Biggest Doctor Fangirl On Earth", and she displays a glimpse of the intelligence that could have carried her into being a decent secondary companion. Unfortunately, she's relegated to a role that's much more impractical and insulting to the actress who played her, as well as fans everywhere.
4. The Time War Is Still Shown In Glimpses
"The last day of the Time War, the war to end all wars. The war between my people and the Daleks. And in that battle, there was a man with more blood on his hands than any other. The man who would commit a crime that would silence the universe... and that man was me." Ever since the beginning of NuWho history, we've been teased and taunted with little pieces of information involving the biggest moment in the recent canon: The Time War. When The Day of The Doctor was approaching, everyone was speculating we'd see the moment The Doctor used The Moment: the "galaxy eater" that would end the war between his people and The Daleks, thus making him the last of the Time Lords. Sure enough, we got a pretty nice look in the beginning, only to eventually see The Doctor change history and render the Time War null and void (at least, we are lead to think this more on that later). This grand, traumatic, probably expensive looking event finally looked like it was going to get its due, and finally show us the true extent of this linchpin moment of The Doctor's modern history. Only, it didn't. The Time War was once more glossed over and shown in a slice of history, rather than an extended sequence of fan service that would have at least had a purpose. There's no real excuse for this, as the special was originally announced as 90 minutes long and that still could have been extended to a 2 hour running time. It's not like the fans are going to say "Gee, this anniversary special is too long and too epic. I don't think they should have went this way." Of course, part of the problem was also in the fact that another plotline was taking up room that could have been occupied by this story thread.
3. The Zygon Subplot Wasn't Necessary
The return of classic monsters to modern Doctor Who can be a real treat. The returns of the Daleks and the Cybermen, in Series 1 and 2 respectively, managed to reinvigorate old villains as well as give them some new modern context. We had new reasons to fear these monsters, because they had modern reasons to come back. However, this sort of thing works best when you do it gradually and not too often without real purpose. Even if there were a perfect reason to justify their return, we didn't need the Zygons to return, because we had a perfect story to tell with The Last Day of The Time War. The Moment/Rose still would open the portals across time, luring 10 and 11 into helping The War Doctor not to end The Time War, and the adventure could have eventually become The Doctors trying to fight The Time War to a Stalemate. Realizing a Stalemate would be impossible, The War Doctor would still try to use The Moment, and the three Doctors could still very easily work their way to not using the device. But instead of the battle filled fulfillment of a promise made back in the Davies days, we were treated to reddish creatures covered in suckers with the ability to pull a Loki on command. Creatures that can copy anyone's likeness aren't new, but seeing a Time Lord breaking down to the point of moral compromise is something that is much more exciting.
2. Christopher Eccleston's "Omission" Is Glaring
As it has been the custom in past anniversary specials, the showrunner and the BBC will try to corral all living incarnations of The Doctor into one room and create a reason that all of these people are back together, despite the Universe-harming implications and everyone's age. However, we all know Christopher Eccleston's checkered history with the BBC has made things harder on any current efforts to do just that. Yet even when Tom Baker managed to show up, decades after spurning the last couple of Anniversary events, Christopher Eccleston still couldn't be bothered to film a day's worth of material to help bridge the gap. A quick regeneration sequence, a couple lines of dialogue, even being in the final line-up of all of the faces of The Doctor: any one of those things would have meant the world to fans worldwide. But "he didn't feel he could come back to it", and as such all we got was a shorter than short glimpse at the eyes and forehead of the man who would be Nine. C'mon Chris... you were surely in London filming Thor: The Dark World. You couldn't have taken a lunch break?
1. It's Not As Happy Of An Ending As It Lets On
At the end of the episode, we see The Doctor eager to go search for Gallifrey, now hidden in a pocket universe away from the eyes of the solar system. The ending itself makes it seem like a big unknown as to what happens next with the planet of the Time Lords...except we know exactly what happens with Gallifrey. Based on how this adventure fits into the 10th Doctor's time line, Rassilon somehow comes to power and takes over the High Council of The Time Lords, thus launching an effort to bring Gallifrey back to our universe. The Doctor's period of wandering across the universe between The Waters Of Mars and The End of Time did just happen to include his fling with Elizabeth I... which means, theoretically, this adventure happens right before his fateful meeting with The Ood. Honestly, go back and listen to the events he mentions to the Ood when he lands at the beginning of The End of Time: Part I. He mentions Elizabeth I right out. So in the end, we see a hopeful search for Gallifrey or the 11th Doctor. However, we know that even if The Doctor finds it again it's going to be in pretty bad shape due to the events of The End Of Time. Of course, the silver lining is that if this were to happen, a certain arch-nemesis of The Doctor's would finally have a legitimate reason to reappear...
5 Things That Worked The Best
5. It Fills In The Story Gap Between Modern And Classic Who
Ever since it was first mentioned in the Davies era, the broadly-sketched Time War was a loose thread linking the past run of the show to the present period of history. It was a great idea that changed the way Doctor Who would play out, but it was never elaborated on enough in order to truly get a feel for how horrible the event actually was. Of course, forming a cohesive story link out of 50 years of material might seem daunting to most. Steven Moffat would merely call it a Monday though, as he seems to delight in facing down story challenges that could either make or break the fan's faith in the show. Most importantly, Moffat is giving away Regeneration scenes like they're candy this year. With that zealous attitude of getting everything on camera, Moffat made sure that we got to see a regeneration between Hurt and Eccleston, thus closing the gap in regeneration scenes and a 19 year gap of official story. Plus, bonus points for Moffat's canonization of the Big Finish audio dramas as well.
4. Two Key Cameos Made The Night
On the other side of the spectrum from Eccleston's brush off, two actors that didn't need to appear to the extent that they did made appearances that night. In the case of Tom Baker, they could have gotten him to voice some sort of quip involving the climactic sequence of all 13 of the Doctors making Gallifrey disappear from our universe. Yet there he was, hinting that The Doctor might just visit old forms for fun and curation purposes, in an appearance that was as adorable as it was surprising, despite the fact that he said he was going to be in it the week before air. But perhaps the bigger surprise was that of Peter Capaldi's eyes making a cameo during that same sequence mentioned earlier. Here's a man that doesn't technically need to show up until the Christmas special to do his job, and yet he can spare a quick glance of steely resolve to make the fans scream in delight at their TVs. Both appearances are a sure sign that while it's going to be a sad day when Matt Smith regenerates, we still have an exciting future to look forward to.
3. The Trio of Doctors Were Perfectly Matched
The Doctor, like any other person, loves and hates himself in equal turns. To have three different versions of oneself running amok , in hopes that the world will somehow be sorted in the end, is a recipe for chaos. And yet, the disarray was extremely limited with the three faces of The Doctor united against the forces of evil. What will start as bickering and confusion will eventually turn into serious conversation, which will then turn into eventual and mutual resolution of the problem at hand. Steven Moffat's writing lends itself to such conflict resolution on a regular basis, but having the trio of Hurt, Tennant, and Smith only helps additionally sell the concept. Hurt's War Doctor is the remnants of a time when The Doctor mostly took on the form of an older man who was to be trusted and didn't run around wildly gesticulating. Tennant and Smith, on the other hand, represent a gradual devolution into someone that runs round with an enthusiastic, child like persona but at the same time encounters some serious grief that they usually don't let themselves off the hook of too easily. Having Hurt's incarnation around, the other two realize just what is needed to alleviate themselves of the burden they've been carrying around for so long and Hurt realizes that he doesn't need to go against his moral code to save the day. With the balance of personalities in effect, the Doctors decide to not make the mistake of wiping out Gallifrey, which in turn spares them from the depression that decision led them into afterwards.
2. Rose Tyler's Return Made Sense This Time
The last time Rose Tyler graced our TV screens in a Doctor Who adventure, it was a case of emotional overkill. Sure, she was crossing over to save the two universes from destroying each other, but anyone could have done that. Why was Rose Tyler the chosen one? It was "resolution" to the 10/Rose story that ended tearfully in Doomsday, and should have stayed that way. Yet when photos of Rose Tyler started showing up online, people were wondering what had happened to make her look so out of sorts. As it turned out, the ultimate weapon of sentience and destruction decided to use a not yet familiar face to help The Doctor. It helped him arrive at the conclusion that he didn't need to use The Moment to end The Time War, thus absolving himself of a LOT of guilt. Not to mention, this incarnation of Rose Tyler is the smartest, and actually the most interesting one in the series. Instead of being a doe eyed love interest for The Doctor, she actually gets a bit of quirk and excitement to her as she hints towards her own future with The Doctor.
1. It Leads To Three Redemptive Regenerations
After the three Doctors leave The National Gallery, it is assumed that each of the Great Men are heading off to their well-earned new faces. At the end of Day of The Doctor, we partially see War Doctor going through his Regeneration. In 10's timeline, this event fits in right before The End Of Time, and in 11's timeline he will be regenerating in The Time of The Doctor. All three regenerations, though sad events, can also be seen as exciting changes for each Doctor. As they now have the burden of destroying Gallifrey off of their shoulders, the three Doctors are ready to start over without this traumatic event on their personal records. The Doctor has now earned the right to let himself stop worrying about what never happened, and get back to being just a little more excited about his travels, and that can only be a good thing, right? What Say You, What Culture Republic? Did You Enjoy The Day Of The Doctor? What Are Your Likes/Dislikes? Jump Into The Comments Section Below And Let Us Know!