As with all fandoms, opinions on the quality of Doctor Who at any given moment will be divided. Some will think that the show in its current format is absolutely perfect and not a thing should be done that might tarnish it. Others think Moffat should sacked (if not hanged, drawn and quartered) and the show should begin with new blood behind the pen. Luckily, most people are somewhere in the middle. Whatever your opinion, it never hurts to shake things up a bit. Even Steven Moffat seems to think so, having been quoted several times as saying that with the new Doctor comes the chance for him to tweak and rework minor elements of the show as he sees fit - a perspective that is often at loggerheads with the opinion of the fans. So, from this fan's perspective, here's the five things I think Moffat should do (in terms of format and story) that would be a refreshing change of pace for the Peter Capaldi era.
5. Serialised Stories
When the show returned in 2005, the creators wisely decided to change the format and duration of the episodes from the multi-part serials of the classic era. Audience expectations of pacing and storytelling had changed drastically in the intervening years: lending itself more to a punchy, self-contained 45-minute story with the occasional two-parter thrown in. If 'Rose' had been the first episode of a six-part saga that slowly reintroduced the essential elements of the show, new viewers would likely have been disinterested and the Whovians-of-old would have grown tired of being drip-fed information they already knew. But now that the elements of the show have been firmly re-established, this would the the perfect opportunity for a run of ambitious multi-part stories, broadcast in a serialised format similar to the classic series. This would allow for complex plots to be explored in more depth without rushing, introduce and develop characters that are given more depth than the modern one-shot guest stars and give more breathing room to explore the dynamic between the new Doctor and Clara. This is ideally suited to Moffat's writing style, as evidenced by Sherlock and the superb integration of character development into what would otherwise be standard detective story fare. With twice the running time of a standard episode of Doctor Who, but nevertheless trying to tell one story, Moffat and Gatiss have managed to explore every facet of the relationship between Holmes and Watson - sometimes all in the same episode - usually without detracting from the story itself and effortlessly matching the natural pacing beats of a 90-minute feature. There are risks of course, such as a writer not being able to stretch a story across the allotted number of episodes and having to pad it out or throw in plot contrivances just to buy a cliffhanger. Plus, a casual viewer who tunes in at episode 3 of a four-part story will be hopelessly lost (though in the age of iPlayer, I'd argue that the "casual viewer" will cease to exist before long). However, in the hands of competent writers and carefully crafted scripts, the payoff could be incredible and produce thought-provoking stories worthy of the best classic serials.
4. Long-Running Male Companions
The lifespan of the average male companion in NuWho is incredibly short. Adam barely had time to unpack. The closest thing Jack got to an alien civilisation during his companion days was Wales. Mickey got little more than a parade of slightly different robots and Rory's tenure in the land of the living was so sporadic it became an in-joke. With the exception of Captain Jack (arguably), all these transient TARDIS tenants have one thing in common - they were romantically linked to the female companion. There was little doubt in anyone's mind that the writer's only purpose for the token male companion was as a springboard to develop the female companion whose usefulness would end if she decided to leave, assuming he hadn't already been ditched. I would like to see a new male character be introduced midway through the series (not at the beginning so that the new dynamic between the Doctor and Clara has time to settle) who joins the TARDIS crew because he impresses the Doctor enough to be invited along. Then he should stay on the show until either the actor decides to leave or the writers decide that he's reached the end of his arc and becomes superfluous. He should interact with and have some sort of platonic relationship with Clara, but not a romantic one, not a submissive one for comic-relief and should not be dependent on her to keep his TARDIS key.
3. An Event Episode in the Series Finale
Whatever you think of the Russell T. Davies era, the final two or three episodes of the series were always met with great anticipation. We cottoned on eventually that the final bow of the series would usually see some classic series villain reinvented for the modern age and, even if you weren't familiar with them, you knew the resulting battle would be of epic proportions. Whilst Moffat's decision to split up each series into two parts probably helped prevent this formula becoming stale, it didn't have the intended effect of doubling the number of event episodes. If anything, it reduced it to zero since the mid-series break wouldn't have enough build-up to make it exciting and the true series finale was too long-awaited to not be disappointing. This wasn't helped by making hauty promises in episode titles that we knew wouldn't be delivered upon (namely 'The Name of the Doctor'). We know now that Capaldi's first series will be an uninterrupted run of (we assume) 13 episodes, so now is the best opportunity for Moffat to make the series finale feel like an event once more. He should pick some great villain thought long-dead and weave his fiendish plot into the background of the episodes, only to be revealed at the end of the series and clash with the Time Lord. Moffat tried to do this with the Great Intelligence, but (in my opinion) the story was to convoluted to have any impact.
2. A Quest To Motivate And Challenge The Doctor
Admittedly, this has already been hinted at by the closing episodes of Matt Smith's run, but I hope that Capaldi's Doctor setting off on a quest to restore Gallifrey does become the defining motive of the series. Something that enables the standard "anywhere in time and space" fare but with a hitherto unseen aspect of the Doctor's character: travelling with an objective, rather than just random exploration. Solving the "mystery" of Clara was similar in the last series, but it never seemed to become a driving motivation for the Doctor. Instead, he alternated between intense scrutiny one minute and passing curiosity the next - only once did it seem like his choice of destination was influenced by finding a way to figure her out. The Doctor is clever and well-travelled, he can probably rattle off a dozen people or places or times with technology that can help find Gallifrey which he'll want to check out. Wacky, sci-fi adventures occur along the way, of course, but with a sense of achievement by the end having taken one more step towards his goal. Though the Doctor has been given quests (after a fashion) before, this will be the first time we've seen him travelling the stars with an entirely self-interested objective and is a great chance to show new sides to the Doctor. Maybe in one episode he's given a choice between saving the "someone he barely knows but likes" character of the week or losing a seemingly sure-fire way to restore Gallifrey, and he's tempted to be selfish.
1. Lose the Sonic Screwdriver
The BBC will never allow this, since shilling toys of the Doctor's magic wand is probably one of the biggest moneyspinners in the franchise. But, from a storytelling perspective, the sonic is a literal deus ex machina capable of doing whatever the plot demands at any given moment. Granted, most writers avoid using the sonic screwdriver to resolve the episode, recognising it as a cop-out that shows bad writing. But it'd be very interesting to see what happens when writer's can't resort to it at all. Maybe we'll see the Twelfth Doctor become an inventive MacGyver-figure, saving the Universe with a kettle and a ball of string. Though the sonic has been removed from the equation before, this could be an opportunity for the new Doctor to consciously decide not to use it anymore. The older Capaldi could berate his baby-faced previous incarnation for carrying a silly toy around and arrogantly assert that he will do just fine without. It'd be a powerful introduction to the new Doctor and put him in stark contrast to his predecessor.