It's the most wonderful time of the year (okay, second most wonderful this year - 50th anniversary and all that) - Doctor Who fans get an extra special, hour long episode of their favourite show, just because it's Christmas. The Doctor Who Christmas Special has been a staple of many a Whovian's festive season for nearly a decade now, with the yearly treat about to hit its 9th episode. And this one looks to be one of the most intense yet - the much-dreaded departure of Matt Smith's 11th Doctor, plus promise of the culmination of all four years of his Doctor's ongoing, open-ended plot strands neatly tied up to make way for Peter Capaldi, who will be debuting to millions of gobsmacked, slightly tipsy geeks on the 25th. We'll all likely be on the edge of our seats if the expected Christmas-dinner comas don't render us submerged into our sofas. But how do they rank thus far? Is Steven Moffat's otherworldly, Dickensian depiction of Christmas more effective than Russell T Davies' high street tinsel and turkey portrayal of the event, or vice versa? Let's have a look at every Doctor Who Christmas Special since the show's 2005 revival and find out...
8. The Runaway Bride
The Runaway Bride is by no means a bad Doctor Who episode - it just falls short because we've seen it all before - only one year before to be precise. Rustic spaceships that don't look like spaceships? Robot Santas on London high streets? Murderous Christmas trees? It's all shamelessly lifted from 2005's The Christmas Invasion - and is an early example of RTD attempting to bottle lightning twice. There are things to be enjoyed here - although not Catherine Tate, whose Donna Noble is almost unbearable for the duration (and thankfully toned down her skull-piercing shrillness and short temper when promoted to series regular for David Tennant's final series). The Racnoss' Spider web ship looks gorgeous, Tennant's unleashing of the wrathful, 'No Second Chances' Time Lord, so promised the year before, is chilling and serves as one of the most memorable moments of the RTD era, and there's some lovely post-Rose angsting (before it got a bit too much). It's a shame Davies clearly thought we'd all be too drunk and full to notice or care that this was little more than a remake of his previous Christmas story. Aliens coming to London on Christmas Day? They even make a joke of the device's repetitiveness in our next entry...
7. Voyage Of The Damned
The one with the space Titanic. I'd be willing to place this one last, but it has one thing going for it over The Runaway Bride - its originality (within Doctor Who canon at least - there's a startlingly similar episode of Futurama to be looked at). Unfortunately, like the aforementioned, Voyage of the Damned has little else going for it. Let's start with the characters - Kylie Minogue's Astrid is a personality vacuum - as forgettable as the tree statues in The Doctor, The Widow and The Wardrobe and just as wooden. Banakafalata is cute but quickly becomes irritating before he is mercifully done away with, and the snivelling rich guy is groan inducing at every turn. Why Davies elected to keep him alive is a mystery. David Tennant phones in his performance as the 10th Doctor - offering little that is memorable beyond his famous 'I'm the Doctor' speech. It's a shame, because the fun premise could have sailed (sorry) a little better with some more interesting performances. As it is, the characters are your run of the mill disaster movie fodder. Then there are the monsters - creepy angels? Haven't we seen that before? Like, really quite recently? But the forgettable Hosts are not a patch on Max Capricorn - the grinning, OTT bastard child of Davros and Anthony Ainley's Master. His teeth even sparkle when he smiles! Come on Russell, I know it's Christmas but there's such a thing as too much camp.
6. The Doctor, The Widow and The Wardrobe
Another misfire, this time from the Steven Moffat era. The full extent of this episode's shortcomings were originally lost on me as it was so hot on the heels of series 6's baffling finale (and I may have had a few whiskies), but on repeat viewing The Doctor, The Widow and The Wardrobe doesn't really hold up. It's a nice trope of Moffat to partially adapt beloved Christmas stories (although he promptly abandoned the premise after this one, which is a shame because I was rather looking forward to Home Alone: Doctor Who Edition), but why take a fantasy world as magical as CS Lewis' Narnia and suck all the life and sparkle from it? Matt Smith is on form, as he invariably always is, and Outnumbered's Claire Skinner is as endearing and enjoyable as ever, but their combined efforts can't salvage a plot-thin, forgettable episode that is about as Christmassy as a turkey sandwich on Boxing Day. As previously mentioned, the tree creatures are forgettable, the syrupy, he's-alive-after-all ending is far too convenient, even for a Christmas episode, and Bill Bailey was used far too sparingly - an admittedly uncommon criticism but a criticism nonetheless. Ooh, would you look at me - I'm whinging an awful lot, aren't I? And at Christmas time! Don't worry, I've got a lot more nice things to say from here on out.
5. The End Of Time
The only two-parter on this list, and I'm not cheating because New Year's Day (on which Part 2 aired) is still part of the festive season. The End of Time, being a regeneration story, came with higher audience expectations than the usual Christmas special and as such has severely divided fandom, but looking back it's a rather fitting end for the 10th Doctor. What's bad about it? Well, the Master turning everyone on Earth into himself is a little farfetched, even by RTD standards, but that was largely there for the cliffhanger and was quickly done away with, so we can forgive that. The Vinvocci (don't call them cactuses - or even cacti) are slightly annoying and the Doctor's regenerative farewell tour goes on a bit longer than necessary. But that's really it. Bernard Cribbins' Wilfred - not-so-surprise hit of series 4 - is promoted to companion, and his dialogue with the Doctor is tremendous throughout (his response to setting foot inside an alien spaceship for the first time, aka fulfilling his lifelong dream? "I thought it'd be cleaner." Priceless). David Tennant is also on stellar form in his last adventure, gloomily anticipating his demise in quieter moments and rising to the challenge in usual 10th Doctor style when the stakes are raised. Timothy Dalton is a chilling Time Lord president (and Rassilon at that! How's that for fan service?) and John Simm plays the Master with none of the smug, smarmy, hand-clapping melodrama he displayed the first time around. Last of the Time Lords is a distant memory. Christmas is merely a backdrop for this story, and it's not really regarded as a Christmas Special so much as a series finale (as I'm sure The Time of the Doctor will also be, given its nature), but it's a great story nonetheless - epic and heartbreaking in equal measure.
4. The Snowmen
No, not an adaptation of The Snowman - despite Moffat's previous Christmas specials, this is a purely original story (although it does turn the tradition of the snowman come to life on its head in a rather gruesome manner), and an anomaly for the Christmas special in that it comes mid-series rather than as the usual standalone story between series. As such, The Snowmen had some duty to perform in carrying on the series 7 arc. Thankfully the story itself doesn't suffer from such an obligation. The Snowmen introduces Richard E Grant's cold, debonair Dr. Simeon and resurrects classic villain The Great Intelligence - a disembodied, malevolent consciousness with the voice of Ian McKellen at his most Magneto-esque sinister. All good in the villain department then, we love Withnail and Gandalf as the bad guys, but how about the heroes? Matt Smith is in a 10th Doctor style slump following the death of the Ponds from the previous episode - throwing a paddy by hiding the TARDIS on a cloud and changing to a rather gloomy desktop theme - but he's quickly won over and back to his old self. The mopey stuff is actually quite refreshing for an incarnation usually so bouncy, and also - fittingly for the season - allows for the Doctor to undergo a Scrooge-like transition when he claws back his joy de vivre. Clara too, living a double life as a governess and a barmaid, is a treat (part of me wishes the Victorian incarnation survived instead of the modern). Then we have the Paternoster Gang - namely Madame Vastra, Jenny and Strax. These three have quite rightly become fan favourites since their first appearance in series six, and they really come together as a unit that could rival, well, UNIT in this story. Strax is incapable of saying something that isn't laugh-out-loud hilarious, and the meta-joke that Conan Doyle is secretly basing Sherlock Holmes on Madame Vastra is a fun touch (does that mean Moffat is adapting his own character with Sherlock? Timey wimey...) The Snowmen isn't quite the all-out Christmas assault on the senses usually typical of the annual special, but it's a highlight of its series and a triumph for all players. And the snowmen themselves are bloody creepy.
3. The Next Doctor
This one had 'gimmick' written all over it - David Tennant had recently announced his imminent departure from the role of the 10th Doctor and, as luck would have it, the story that ran hot on the heels of that announcement concerned a character that claimed to be a future incarnation of the Doctor. It's even called The Next Doctor, in case there was anyone left on Earth whose interests weren't already piqued by those factors. It was a relief then, that amidst all the hype, speculation and quest for ratings, The Next Doctor was a fantastic story - taking an inventive premise and running with it, introducing one of the most effective human villains in the show's long history and wrapping it all up in a big, snowy ball of Dickensian Christmas cheer. I'd hazard a guess that this one set the template for Moffat's Christmas episodes. David duo Morrissey and Tennant bounce off of one another beautifully in this would-be multi-Doctor story, while the twist (spoilers: he's not the Doctor after all) gives the episode an emotional second wind that is just as enjoyable to watch unfold as the previous novelty of two Time Lords. The direction is also glimmering - with the Victorian Christmas deftly realised from the outset and haunting images of Miss Hartigan - in striking red - marching callously through the snow-laden cemetery to introduce her Cyberman friends. It's gothic, it's as Christmassy as it gets and it's quintessential Doctor Who - and it also saw the first flashback of previous Doctors (something that seems to happen every other episode nowadays) in the new series. What's not to love? Perhaps the Cyberking was a bit much.
2. The Christmas Invasion
Advertisement
The Christmas Invasion triumphantly proved that millions of people across the country would happily watch an episode of a science fiction show on Christmas Day (try telling that to Michael Grade in 1989). The nation followed up the Queen's speech and whatever episode of Only Fools and Horses was on that day with David Tennant's debut outing as the Doctor. Did it live up to the stellar first series that went out earlier that year? You bet. Russell T Davies knew exactly what his task was - prove that Doctor Who can celebrate Christmas and reassure all those new fans that this skinny stranger is the same hero last seen facing down the Daleks a few months before. Each was achieved, and then some. The Christmas Invasion is the logical, culminating celebration of Doctor Who's return - with Rose's personal challenge being to learn to embrace change, and that the Doctor will always be there even when he seems unlikely to return. It's a message that resonates with the show itself and gives The Christmas Invasion a certain gravitas that Davies' future specials lacked. The 10th Doctor is unconscious for most of the episode - a bold move: you'd think Davies would want the new guy to hit the ground running - but his absence pays off by the end, when Tennant arrives late to his own party and promptly steals the show he was largely missing from before. The man is spectacular here, proving beyond doubt that he is the Doctor and stealing the hearts of millions armed with little more than a dressing gown, a satsuma and an unrivalled charisma that rightly made David Tennant the man of the decade. The Doctor's claim to being a "No second chances" kind of man perhaps didn't quite play out (offering to forgive the Master and save Davros from his own catastrophe), but the 10th Doctor exploded onto our screens in an unforgettable way, in an equally unforgettable Christmas Special that set the bar high for all of its successors.
1. A Christmas Carol
How could anything else be number 1? What could possibly be more Christmassy and more ripe for a Doctor Who reimagining than Charles Dickens' beloved time-travelling ghost story? This was a no brainer, and it's amazing to think it took them six years to finally do it. A Christmas Carol (Doctor Who edition) is as festive as it gets - the brilliant Michael Gambon is the perfect surrogate Scrooge, while Matt Smith - brilliant as always - plays the Doctor as something between Mary Poppins and Jacob Marley. It's also, bafflingly, the first of the Christmas episodes that actually plays from the point of view of a child (who'd have thought?) and is of course rife with Moffat's trademark time-bending plot developments. All the crucial elements from Dickens' classic are there but utilised in inventive ways - the ghosts are either holograms or men with Time Machines, the 'surplus population' are captive citizens used by Gambon's Kazran Sardick as collateral from his many debtors, and the man's redemption is both a personal triumph and a typically Doctor Who, planet-saving one. It's hard to believe Moffat followed this up with the lacklustre The Doctor, The Widow and The Wardrobe, but then, Davies followed his stellar debut with a bland remake. The reason A Christmas Carol makes the number one spot is because, beyond being a great Doctor Who story, it is a pure Christmas classic: completely standalone, full of festive cheer and utterly Dickensian. It has no motive beyond being a great Christmas story, and it succeeds on every count. This is what Christmas is all about. Have a merry one!