Doctor Who: 10 Actors Who Should Replace Peter Capaldi

The 12th Doctor has confirmed he's leaving the TARDIS, so who should be number 13?

By James Hunt /

BBC

Peter Capaldi's time in the TARDIS is coming to an end.

Advertisement

Following showrunner Steven Moffat's lead, the 12th iteration of The Doctor has announced that he will be leaving Doctor Who at the end of 2017, following Series 10 (after which Moffat will leave) and then this year's Christmas Special (which will be overseen by new showrunner Chris Chibnall).

It's a shame to see Capaldi go, with the actor really just starting to hit his stride as the Doctor, and it would've been interesting to see a Doctor work with two different showrunners over full seasons.

It also means that, once again, it's time for the speculation to begin. The bookies have already named their favourites, including the likes of Richard Ayoade (who, while hilarious, may become grating over a 13 episode series), with former Doctors Matt Smith, David Tennant, and Christopher Eccleston all in the mix too (but really, that's not gonna happen).

So who could replace Capaldi? Someone younger? Older? A person of colour? A *gasp* woman?! Let's take a look at some plausible candidates who really should be considered for the role.

10. Ben Whishaw

Why He'd Be Great

Advertisement

Based on appearances, Ben Whishaw would be a return to the tried-and-trusted Who model of handsome, floppy-haired young men that worked so well with Tennant and Smith. And to a degree that's true, and not necessarily a bad thing either.

But Whishaw, through roles in Criminal Justice, The Hour, London Spy, and the Bond films - as Q - has shown that he'd have plenty to offer. He can do the weird alien type, but can just as easily be charming, with a sharp wit. He could bring a more whimsical tone to the TARDIS, but, if challenged, could also channel a darker side too.

Chances Of It Happening

Decent. He's been linked with the role previously, and has been installed as the early frontrunner by the bookies this time around. That's a promising sign, although he did previously distance himself from the part back in 2013, because of his role as Q in Bond.

That said, his upcoming slate is fairly clear - there's Paddington 2 this year, Mary Poppins Returns next, and presumably whenever the next Bond film happens he'll be there. But he's not adverse to TV, and if he wanted a regular starring role, this would be a great opportunity.

9. Sheridan Smith

Why She'd Be Great

Advertisement

Over the past few years, Sheridan Smith has managed to establish herself as one of Britain's best actresses on both the stage and the small screen.

Since breaking through in Two Pints of Lager..., she's appeared in comedies, dramas, plays and musicals, and shown a great range across each. She's easily likeable, and an excellent comic actress, but also capable of turing in quietly powerful performances, as seen in Mrs Biggs and her guest turn in Inside No. 9, meaning she could adapt to whatever the show required of her.

Chances Of It Happening

Not bad. She's not exactly a favourite for the role, but isn't a complete rank outside either. She is predominantly a TV actor, so it's not like she'd be taking a step down from movies, though she does have a couple of dramas on the way already.

She's been linked with Who previously, and also appears as Lucie Miller in the Big Finish stories, meaning she's already a part of this world and may well be up for a bigger role in it.

8. Rupert Grint

Why He'd Be Great

Advertisement

Like many of his Harry Potter co-stars, Rupert Grint will probably never fully separate himself from his role in that franchise. But then, of all the younger actors, Grint was one of the best - a perfect embodiment of Ron Weasley.

He hasn't gone on to the success and wide variety of roles Daniel Radcliffe and Emma Watson have, and indeed is in need of the right part to show off his talents. As we saw in Potter, he's got excellent comic timing, while he'd be able to nail the more otherworldly aspects of the character. Plus they could finally pay off all those ginger jokes.

Chances Of It Happening

It may depend on how his other projects are received. Grint is really having a crack at TV, which bodes well for him being up for a leading role in a multi-part series, but means he might be quite busy.

At the moment he's got leading parts in a TV version of Snatch, and comic book series Imperial City to come. If either or both become successful, then he may not have the time and space in his schedule for Who. If they flop (or Imperial City doesn't make it to series), then his odds will surely go up (and he's already one of the bookies' favourites).

7. Sacha Dhawan

Why He'd Be Great

Advertisement

Sacha Dhawan is probably the least known name on this list, but that could work in his favour. Without too much expectation on what he'd bring, there'd be a relatively blank slate for him to work with.

In his numerous TV appearances, which include the excellent Utopia, Mr Selfridge, Line of Duty, and the most recent series of Sherlock, he's shown himself to be confident, charismatic, and incredibly versatile - all key aspects of playing the Doctor.

Chances Of It Happening

There's almost no way he'd turn it down - he's one of the busiest TV actors in the UK, and this would be the chance of a lifetime (and he's previously said he'd love to work on the show). So it'd depend on whether those in charge wanted him.

He's definitely talented enough, and they should be aware of him: one of his breakthrough roles was a fantastic turn as Who director Warris Hussein in Mark Gatiss' An Adventure in Space and Time. His fairly low profile could count against him, but then Matt Smith wasn't that well-known when he got the part.

6. Paterson Joseph

Why He'd Be Great

Advertisement

Best known for his role as Johnson on Peep Show, Joseph would easily be able to bring those comic sensibilities - humour, smugness, superiority, swagger - to the Doctor, but also has the qualities to take the character in a darker direction too.

As shown on TV shows like The Leftovers, his extensive theatre work, and supporting role in movie The Beach, he's more than capable of strong dramatic acting, with the presence and sense of theatricality to lead the show. He's also currently appearing in Timeless, a US time-travelling series, so will know his way around this kind of material.

Chances Of It Happening

Slim-ish. Joseph's name will always be mentioned whenever a vacancy comes up in the TARDIS, given he's been tipped for the part ever since David Tennant announced he was leaving.

He has previously appeared in Who, but as Capaldi's casting proves that isn't really an issue. Indeed, perhaps the biggest thing standing in his way is that he's such a fan-casting, something producers often tend to veer away from. It may also depend on how Timeless pans out, because he could be a bit too busy anyway.

5. Tim Roth

Why He'd Be Great

Advertisement

Because he's Tim freakin' Roth.

He's in the same age bracket as Peter Capaldi, so would be a fitting choice if Chibnall wanted to continue with a slightly older actor in the role, but also capable of bringing something very different.

The Tarantino-favourite is capable of bringing a huge amount of intensity to his roles, and that along with his gravitas would make for an interesting Doctor. At the same time, his love of accents could play into some sillier aspects of the character.

Chances Of It Happening

Hard to call. Roth has previously said that he'd be up for the role if it was offered to him, but that was on Reddit and it's hard to know how serious he was being. He's also much better-known for his film work, and may prefer to continue in that field.

On the other hand, he's worked on TV plenty of times before, and will be on the small screen later this year in the Twin Peaks revival. If he's willing to do one cult classic, maybe he'll be up for the leading part in another.

4. Gugu Mbatha-Raw

Why She'd Be Great

Advertisement

Gugu Mbatha-Raw is one of Britain's fastest rising stars at the minute, and is only going to continue to soar with roles in upcoming movies Beauty and the Beast, the Untitled Cloverfield Movie (formerly God Particle), and Ava DuVernay's A Wrinkle in Time.

She's shown her great dramatic talent in movies Belle and Beyond The Light, but her best audition for the role was Black Mirror's incredible San Junipero. There she's equal parts charming, mysterious, and totally captivating - plus there's sort of a time travel element - marking her out as a great candidate for the Doctor.

Chances Of It Happening

As her star rises, the chances of her leading Doctor Who are probably dissipating, and she's one of the least plausible candidates - though doesn't break into the realms of impossible or dream-casting - on the list.

She was linked with a role in Star Wars Episode VIII, which shows where she's headed, and those three movies named above are likely to be big. That said, she's worked on Doctor Who before - playing the sister of Martha Jones - and has made plenty of other TV appearances. She's making a splash in movies, but this is a leading role in a huge TV series, so maybe she could be tempted.

3. Chiwetel Ejiofor

Why He'd Be Great

Advertisement

Ejiofor is, quite simply, an actor of immense talent and standing, and would be one of the very best to ever step into the TARDIS.

His role in 12 Years A Slave showed just how powerful a performer he can be, and it's easy to imagine him delivering a typical Doctor speech. He's also shown that he's equally at home in everything from Shakespeare to sci-fi, so has the range to excel here.

Chances Of It Happening

Like Mbatha-Raw, it really depends on how the movie career is going. Ejifor isn't quite a HUGE star, so there's a possibility he could be tempted here, but he is an Oscar-nominee and now a part of the Marvel Cinematic Universe (though Doctor Strange 2 is still a few years off).

Although not confirmed, it's also widely believed that Ejifor is the black actor Moffat said he offered the role to before it eventually went to Matt Smith, with him turning it down. He hasn't - as far as anyone knows - been offered it since though, and the story is that he couldn't agree terms, not that he wasn't interested. If they can find a package that suits, this would be one hell of a casting.

2. Hayley Atwell

Why She'd Be Great

Advertisement

Atwell is an extremely talented actress, and has consistently proved over her years in the MCU just what she can do. Whether it's been a supporting part in the movies, or leading her own (sadly cancelled) series Agent Carter, she's been funny, smart, silly, and a complete badass.

At the same time, she's also shown great dramatic range, such as her haunting performance in Black Mirror episode Be Right Back. A proven TV lead, nerd credentials, plenty of range and personality, it's hard to think of anyone better suited (indeed, there's only one person). Heck, just the potential of her having a verbal battle with Michelle Gomez' Missy should be enough to land her the role.

Chances Of It Happening

Potentially quite good. With Agent Carter cancelled, Atwell is now mostly out of the MCU, save for potential cameo appearances and a voice role in the animated series Avengers: Secret Wars. Furthermore, her latest TV show - which landed on ABC after Carter was cancelled - hasn't been picked up for further episodes. So, she's available.

Furthermore, she has said - albeit only via a Twitter Q&A - that she wants the role. If she was being truly serious, now is the time to give it to her.

1. Olivia Colman

Why She'd Be Great

Advertisement

No matter what role Olivia Colman is given, she always seems to completely nail it. She's firmly recognised now as one of Britain's best TV talents, with BAFTA and Golden Globe wins for her work in diverse fare such as Twenty Twelve, Broadchurch, and The Night Manager.

Colman is capable of giving a performance of emotional devastation, but could just as easily have you falling about laughing. There's also an oddball quality to her, something that she could amplify and perfect for the role of the Doctor. She'd be weird and fun, but also strong and powerful when necessary.

Chances Of It Happening

It could happen. Again, we'll ignore the fact that she's already appeared in Who, although that does mean she's been willing to appear in the show before, so may do again. She's always incredibly busy, but somehow manages to find time for multiple projects, so there should be a way of fitting this in, especially given the challenge and profile it offers.

Then there's the new showrunner Chris Chibnall. Colman has worked with him on three series of Broadchurch, so you have to assume they know each other well and have a good working relationship. It remains to be seen whether Chibnall would want to bring in people he knows from that show, or - in a big sticking point - if he'd rather distance Who from it.

Who would you like to see replace Peter Capaldi? Share your thoughts down in the comments.

Advertisement