Doctor Who: 10 Best NuWho Episodes

With 13 seasons, 13 Doctors - which modern Doctor Who episodes are the definitive best?

By Emily Davison /

The greatest British sci-fi show in history, Doctor Who has firmly cemented itself as a cultural icon. Ever since its revival back in 2005, fans have been gifted with many incredible stories featuring terrifying monsters, exhilarating adventures through time and space, and a whimsical face-changing alien whisking companions away to other worlds.

Advertisement

Every season has highlighted the talents of a whole bunch of passionate writers, but not every episode can give all of us what we’re looking for in a good Doctor Who story. No matter the season or the Doctor, every episode will have a fan out there, but now it’s time to survey NuWho content and gather a list of the very best stories brought to our screens since 2005.

As River Song so fondly quotes: spoilers!

10. The Eleventh Hour

Kicking off with the best post-regeneration story in the revival era, The Eleventh Hour sees our newly regenerated Doctor crash land in the garden of seven-year-old Amelia Pond and Moffat mad brilliance ensues.

Advertisement

This story has one of the most inspired companion introductions, with a fantastic performance from Caitlin Blackwood as young Amelia, who we are suddenly re-introduced to as an adult Karen Gillan and 12 years have passed from her first meeting with The Doctor. The concept of an imaginary childhood friend being real makes intriguing groundwork for the relationship between The Doctor and companion.

Coming off the back of arguably the most popular incarnation of the titular Time Lord, played by David Tennant, Matt Smith and writer Steven Moffat had the unenviable task of keeping audiences invested in the character.

Smith pulled off the seemingly impossible and effortlessly steps into his predecessor’s shoes, with fish fingers and custard and who could forget the Atraxi montage of all the previous Doctors instantly making this episode a classic of the show.

9. The Girl In The Fireplace

Steven Moffat has given us some of the best stories for the modern run of Doctor Who and this next entry will not be the last credit on this list.

Advertisement

This adventure to 18th century Versailles (somehow contained within a 51st century spaceship home to killer clockwork droids) features a sinister plot revolving around the celebrity historical figure, Madame de Pompadour.

An emotional roller-coaster from beginning to end, this episode has the romance, action and thrills of a Hollywood blockbuster, with a clever and heart wrenching screenplay by Moffat and the uncredited Sydney Newman.

Guest star Sophia Myles embodies a believable elegance and grounded charm to Reinette and she shares great chemistry with Tennant. Euros Lyn directed a beautiful episode, with an authentic set design and memorable visuals that depict a huge juxtaposition in times amidst a futuristic, industrial space ship and the fashionable flamboyance of France in the past.

The monsters have a truly striking design, with a creepy clock ticking sound effect heightening the thrills and a gut punch of an ending may leave you feeling drained, but what a journey well worth investing in!

8. Turn Left

The first part of a gigantic season finale signalling the end of the current showrunner’s tenure and barely including The Doctor?

Advertisement

Turn Left could have easily alienated viewers with its companion focused story, but as Blink the previous year had experimented and succeeded with flying colours, this episode proves to be one of the most effective without the titular character taking centre stage.

Catherine Tate shines as fan favourite Donna Noble as she discovers a terrifying world where she never met The Doctor, simply by taking a different turn in her car and preventing him from saving himself during the events of The Runaway Bride.

What follows is a devastating series of events which goes to some of the darkest places modern Who has ventured to, with Donna and her family put through the hardest tests we have ever seen them face.

Brilliantly directed, led by stunning performances and a wonderfully experimental story – Turn Left is a great example of a Doctor-lite episode done right.

7. Silence In The Library/Forest Of The Dead

Moffat is back again with an incredible two-part story from the fourth series of Doctor Who.

Advertisement

A little girl whose apparent imaginary library on another world turns out to be real? Check. Terrifying monsters whose terror comes from nearly every child’s irrational fear of the dark? Check. A mysterious woman who meets The Doctor out of order in time and knows more about him than he her?

Check mate.

This episode gathers the best ideas for a Who story and blends them to create something exciting, new and engaging, with a dash of mystery lingering throughout.

The Vashta Nerada are a deliciously creepy villain with a disturbing, yet memorable catch phrase (“Hey, who turned out the lights!”) and remain a sinister presence throughout.

Forest of the Dead expanded on an already terrific first part with an existential-themed story for Donna, who finds herself living another alternate reality with a husband and kids who may not even exist.

Alex Kingston as the enigmatic River Song marks the introduction of a solid secondary character, and Moffat’s delight in playing with time travel work wonders here, with an emotional wrap up that hints for future adventures to come.

This story has it all, from terrifying monsters, to emotional gut punches and all the thrills in between – stay out of the shadows!

6. Dalek

The first story in the revival era to reintroduce the iconic Daleks to a new, modern audience, this episode sees Christopher Eccleston’s Doctor and Billie Piper’s Rose travel to an underground museum in Utah, 2012 and come face to face with the monster.

Advertisement

Even after years of Dalek-centred stories preceding this Robert Shearman-helmed screenplay, Dalek still manages to hold up as one of the best for its thought-provoking introspection on The Doctor’s most hated rival.

After years of parodies mocking the classic Who monster, this episode finally made the Daleks scary again! With a sleek upgrade and exceptional voicework from Nicholas Briggs, the lone Dalek makes a sound impression when it breaks free of its prison and goes on a killer rampage throughout the base.

What elevates this story above others is how it manages to do the impossible: it makes us both fear and sympathise with the genetically modified creature inside the hardened outer shell. After absorbing Rose’s DNA, it comes to question its own existence and purpose in life, leading to some dramatic head to head moments with The Doctor.

Eccleston delivers one of his most powerful performances from his series, his fury and loathing for the Dalek juxtaposed by his intense sorrow and guilt over the fallout of the Time War.

A fairly self-contained story with a much smaller scale to Dalek episodes following this, the introspective nature of Dalek and its perfect introduction to the classic monster for new audiences is what makes this episode a special gem in the Russel T Davies era.

5. Bad Wolf/The Parting Of The Ways

After the successful reintroduction of the Daleks to a modern audience, Davies followed up this story with one of the best NuWho finale to grace our screens. Pretty impressive considering this was only the first season!

Advertisement

This two-part story sees the ninth Doctor face his match with almost a million genetically modified Daleks. Oh, and fight off against mid-2000s game show hosts. What’s not to love?

Whilst Bad Wolf has received some criticism for this admittedly dated element of the show, it nevertheless sets up a haunting dystopian future where humans are subjected to life or death games, only for the truth to be revealed that losing contestants are transported to Dalek ships to be turned into abominations.

Robert Shearman’s fascinating concept of a half human/half Dalek combination is built upon to make the monsters the most terrifying they have ever reached in the revival era (the series four finale also comes as a close second!).

Joe Ahearne gave us two of the best directed NuWho episodes, with haunting visuals and who could forget Murray Gold’s electrifying score, which manages to both thrill and create emotional resonance as we build towards The Doctor’s regeneration.

Eccleston truly was magnificent as the first Doctor to endear us to the character once again and is able to go out with a bang with a cheeky grin and his signature “Fantastic!” in a golden blaze of glory. This story reaches incredible heights, proudly earning the titles of best season finale and regeneration story all in one go!

4. Blink

Ah, we’ve finally reached Moffat’s horror masterpiece. The Doctor Who equivalent of Ridley Scott’s Alien. Yes, this episode may be overrated, but that does not mean it shouldn’t be praised for what it accomplished.

Advertisement

The first successful Doctor-lite story (sorry Love and Monsters!), season three’s Blink introduces us to the companion that should have been – Sally Sparrow, who receives a cryptic message from the Doctor about an alien species after the TARDIS.

The Weeping Angels have become iconic staples of the show, alongside classic monsters like the Daleks and the Cybermen, with Moffat once again harnessing an ordinary object like a stone statue and turning it into something scary.

“Don’t blink! Blink and you’re dead!”. This extraordinary warning is given to Sally and the audience from a Doctor who is stuck in the past. When we are introduced to Sally, the villains have already won and The Doctor is stranded with Freema Agyeman’s Martha Jones in 1969.

Moffat’s play with time travel has never been greater here, with some shocking and poignant moments occurring as a result of people who have been sent back in time and forced to live out the rest of their days in a brand new period of history.

Before she took on Hollywood, guest star Carey Mulligan made a profound turn as Sally Sparrow with a witty, heartfelt performance as the one off companion.

Blink is a modern classic of Doctor Who and it deserves all the praise it has and continues to receive for its genius screenplay and birth of one of the best villains in sci fi.

3. Heaven Sent

What could top Blink? A deeply profound, moving and riveting story by Moffat which explores the indescribable agony of grief.

Advertisement

An absolutely stunning episode, Heaven Sent is Peter Capaldi at his very best as the Twelfth Doctor, who has recently lost his companion and best friend, Jenna Coleman’s Clara, in Face the Raven.

Capaldi carries the entire 45 minutes on his own shoulders, delivering thought provoking monologues about the nature of grief itself as he finds himself trapped in a nightmarish castle haunted by a sinister Veil.

The entire episode revolves around The Doctor on his own with no companions, using his sheer willpower to fight his inner demons and escape his prison, a concept that may sound impossible to pull off, but it works.

What could be more thrilling and triumphant than seeing Capaldi’s Doctor relentlessly try and break free from his prison for millions of years, in an endless cycle?

The episode is flawlessly directed and edited, with a spellbinding sequence taking place towards the final act as The Doctor must be subjected to the torturous repeat of trying to escape over and over again.

A masterpiece of the metaphorical exploration of grief, led by an outstanding performance from Capaldi, Heaven Sent is a deeply psychological story in NuWho which examines The Doctor’s internal psyche and stands proudly as a huge achievement in television.

2. Midnight

Sometimes, the best way to scare the audience is to make them afraid of the unknown, what they cannot see.

Advertisement

The most chilling and effective horror episode in the revival era, Midnight is a masterclass in building and maintaining suspense throughout a forty five runtime and the best part is, it features a monster whose true form we still do not know and will probably never discover.

In this well acclaimed adventure, Tennant’s Doctor drops Donna off at a luxurious spa on the planet Midnight, where he decides to go along on a bus tour to the Sapphire Waterfalls, only for a mysterious deadly entity to infiltrate the holiday escape and turn everything into a nightmare.

Russel T Davies crafts a claustrophobic, disturbing setting as the entity possesses one of the passengers, Sky Silvestry, who begins to take the voices of those around her, leading to a horrific state of paranoia and eventual mob mentality from the passengers.

Lesley Sharp is incredible as the possessed Sky, giving unnatural body movements when she first awakens after being taken over and her demonic repetition of everybody’s lines is eerily creepy. Equally as brilliant as always is David Tennant, whose Doctor faces one of the biggest challenges in his life, villainised by the group of humans who do not trust him and eventually turn against him.

Midnight is hands down one of the best NuWho episodes for its psychological horror and admirable craft from all involved to result in a very chilling watch.

1. Human Nature/The Family Of Blood

Adapted from Paul Cornell’s novel Human Nature, this two-part story sees The Doctor change his biology to that of a human’s to hide in 1913 from the Family of Blood, but will he sacrifice innocent lives in exchange for his own or make the ultimate decision to become the Time Lord once again?

Advertisement

The very best story of NuWho, these episodes highlight Tenant in top form, playing the human school teacher, John Smith, as well as The Doctor in all of his dark glory. Dark being the operative word once he delivers on the harshest punishments to each member of the family, condemning them to endless suffering for eternity.

Harry Lloyd as Baines has to be up there as one of the greatest villains in a singular Who story, with each member of the family giving wonderfully well realised and sinister performances all around.

This story is rich in mature thematic presentation, questioning the very nature of The Doctor as an isolated figure who comes and goes, making connections and losing them as he leads a dangerous life.

The very essence of the character is stripped down and examined to provocative effect, with Jessica Hynes’ character, Joan Redfern, acting as the literal beating heart of the story. The school nurse becomes John Smith’s romantic interest and the montage of what their lives could have been if he chose to remain human is one of the most dramatically profound pieces of television put to Doctor Who.

Not only do we have an exemplary exploration of The Doctor’s character, but the setting of the months preceding World War 1 make for equally as powerful viewing. The episodes are simply brimming with so much interesting content to unpack, making for an emotionally resonant story with some of the best performances and direction NuWho has ever seen.

It is going to be a huge challenge to top this fantastic two part story.

Advertisement