Doctor Who is legendary, but Doctor Who is also sci-fi. Even modern day writing marvels such as Russell T Davies, Mark Gatiss and (yes) Steven Moffat can appreciate that sci-fi often involves some sort of surrealism that really has no practical solution. Sometimes they manage to impress us with incredible feats of writing, like the masterful way Moffat managed to write himself out of a massive corner in the resolution of "The Pandorica Opens/Big Bang" or the epic, yet somewhat confusing grand finale of David Tennant that RTD delivered in his mutual sendoff. Then there are other times when it seems the writers go out of their way to make us all turn into Mr. Grumpy Face. Most seasons have one or two outliers in quality (and everyone needs bad TV some Friday nights after a rough week at the office), but then there are those episodes that just make us wonder how in the name of God these episodes (and at one point during the first season, even the entire revival) ever got off the ground to begin with. Matt Smith once famously said to "never apply logic to Who," but here are the 10 moments of true stupidity and fault in writing that no one has ever quite gotten over.
10. Amy & Rory In New York City, 1937 (The Angels Take Manhattan)
Probably the most infamous Moffat plot hole was the exit of Amy and Rory, which could have been solved with just one little steering adjustment to the TARDIS. Amy and Rory jumped off the roof of Winter Quay in New York City in one of the most heartbreaking moments of the reboot's history (together... or not at all), thus cancelling out a paradox which erases the Winter Quay and thus all the Weeping Angels in New York City, including a freakish Statue of Liberty. All seems well, until they end up next to a grave with Rory's name on it; one last Angel touches Rory from behind and sends him back to 1937. Amy then allows herself to be touched by the same Angel when River tells her mother that the same Angel will send her back to the exact same instance in time as her father. They live out the rest of their lives in the past, and Amy's name is revealed on the same gravestone as they both lived to very old ages. So what's wrong with this? That's a pretty merciful ending by Steven Moffat's standards. Well... the last thing the Doctor tells them both is that he can never go back to 1937 New York or else the city would be ripped apart from the ensuing paradox. The Angel sends Rory back to around the same era, and the Doctor says that their leaving is now a fixed point in time. Who's to say the Doctor can't go back to 1938 New York? Or even a few years afterwards? They traveled over a period of ten years over the course of two and a half linear years. Amy is 21 in 2010 and 31 in 2013; would the costuming and makeup for older Amy and Rory have cost too much? And who's to say they can't go elsewhere in the country? By the 1930s railroads were the primary means of interstate transportation in the U.S., and Amy becomes a world famous author, so why couldn't the Doctor have given River a message on where to meet him rather than just to write an afterword on the last page of his book? Or why couldn't River have just brought Amy and Rory back with her vortex manipulator? The Ponds' exit was a poignant one, but the plot holes were about as massive as a time paradox in NYC.
9. Matt Smith's Weeping Angels (Time Of Angels / Flesh & Stone)
It was thought Blink was undoubtedly Doctor Who's finest hour in 50 years. It introduced probably the most frightening villain in science fiction history while the Doctor himself was only present for about 5 minutes of the episode, having to save the day from 40 years in the past... well, 38. The idea that a creature who could literally consume you in the time it takes for a single blink was the product of someone's worst nightmare, passed along to every single Whovian. Have you blinked since you hit this page? Probably not, and that's the best part of Blink. That's why the two parter Time of Angels/Flesh and Stone, in some regards, was absolute rubbish. It reintroduced River, which was great, and it established that any likeness of a Weeping Angel can harness the same power as a stone Weeping Angel, which was even better. Keep your eyes on the screen... However, just the very concept of the Angels talking, even through the consciousness of Bob, and actually seeing Angels move completely robbed us of what were once terrifying enigmatic villains and were now no more threatening than Daleks or Cybermen. It's somewhat forgivable just because all Angel outings were written by Steven Moffat and he made it up to fans with the fantastic, albeit plot hole ridden The Angels Take Manhattan. The idea of the Statue of Liberty being their queen was completely genius.
8. The Lake Silencio Resolution (The Wedding Of River Song)
There's a certain degree of bias here when it is said that this is a HUGE facepalm moment, because this episode is the one that first got many Americans into Doctor Who. It was bizarre beyond all reason, it was twisted, and it was perfect. A future Doctor interacting with his own past to meet his own death by an astronaut in a Utah lake alone was a facepalm moment for most newbies, and even some of the more zealous diehards, but the word facepalm is used in the nicest way possible because it was a huge moment for Matt Smith's Doctor. So naturally, with an exponentially increased audience this season alone, expectations of a tense ending were huge. Of course there was no way the Doctor was really going to die, and the overall story arc was actually great, but the season's finale which wrapped up said arc was extremely confusing and didn't wrap up until the very last few seconds. You waited months for that... Okay so after Let's Kill Hitler and the Teselecta were introduced, the resolution should have been seen from a mile away, but the season still left viewers with more questions than answers. River says that Madame Kovarian died in the alternate reality and is probably still alive, but she's still never seen again (thank God). By that logic, are the Doctor and River actually married, especially considering it was only done to get close enough to her to start time back up again? How could the Doctor still be destined to die on the fields of Trenzalore if his death at Lake Silencio was a fixed point to begin with? If it really was a fixed point, then the Silence would seem to have succeeded, yes? Exactly why one should never apply logic to Who. The Wedding of River Song was a decent, albeit confusing finale, but it didn't neatly wrap things up while making us anticipate the new season even more the same way Big Bang did.
7. Finding Melody (Let's Kill Hitler)
After the somewhat disappointing "twist" that River Song was in fact the lost daughter of Amy and Rory (seriously, Moffat said he DOESN'T go on Tumblr), the overarching story during the sixth season's midseason hiatus was the Doctor traveling all over the universe trying to recover Melody Pond. Obviously, you all know who she grows up to be so the Doctor does eventually save her, but everyone was curious as to what other great battles he would have to fight to save the child of his two best friends. So when those seven infamous words were uttered by the Doctor, "you named your daughter after your daughter," the entire Whoniverse gave one worldwide facepalm to the one line that arguably makes Doctor Who what it's best known for. In their defense though, time travel, you can't keep it straight in your head. Amy and Rory got to raise Melody after all, just as their childhood best friend instead of as their daughter. It definitely made up for the "big reveal" of River's identity (which was actually pretty predictable) but after the glorious "A Good Man Goes To War," fans were probably hoping for something a bit more exciting and less twisted than what they actually got. You understand why it was done though; so Amy and Rory never really lost River and got to raise her after all, which was nice after the heartbreaking real twist of the last episode where the baby was taken earlier on by Madame Kovarian and turned out to be a Flesh. A great return, a disappointing conclusion, but with the best Doctor Who line of all time...
6. Matt Smith Returns (Deep Breath)
"Please tell me I didn't get old... anything but old..." It's taking some time to get used to an older Doctor again, but Peter Capaldi is absolutely fantastic. That being said, Deep Breath showed us what a great Doctor Peter would be, but it wasn't the best premiere mainly because it brought out the absolute worst in Clara. The companion who was built up to us as the one who understood the Doctor's regeneration cycle better than any other companion (seriously, she met at least three of them herself alone) is basically a weeping mess of denial over losing Eleven for pretty much the entire episode. It isn't until the very end when Clara gets a phone call from Eleven himself right before his regeneration at Trenzalore, begging her to stay with his new self. Even after that, she still doesn't much accept the fact that he's really the Doctor; that moment where she accused him of eavesdropping on a call he made himself made us want to throw things at her on our TV screen. This whole episode was a facepalm moment, just mainly the ending. The phone call seemed like a hokey torch passing moment, one that was overly unnecessary. It seemed like an effort to win back the fangirls who only watched the show to begin with because they had a crush on David and Matt, whom quite frankly Doctor Who can live on without. That's not to say Clara hasn't had her moments with Peter's Doctor, because honestly after Deep Breath she's been fantastic and the dynamic between Peter and Clara this past season has been nothing short of superior to the chemistry with Matt, but as the Doctor himself said "times change," and so must he. Let the man do his thing.
5. The Matt Smith Era Resolution (The Time Of The Doctor)
This finale was riddled with facepalms but there was one huge one that was just plain head scratching, and that was Handles. That was a big one that made absolutely no sense and served practically no purpose other than giving Peter Capaldi one of his opening lines, "Handles??? Wow, you've let yourself go." The true nature of this hour long facepalm (okay, maybe like 45 minutes or so because the two pronged regeneration itself was fantastic) was this episode's attempt to wrap up every single loose plot thread over the past three years into one hour, and there were a lot of them. Matt Smith was the first Doctor in the revival to have an overarching story arc throughout his entire tenure, as opposed to Christopher Eccleston and David Tennant who mainly had one off stories. Some of them had more gravitas than others; the resolution as to what was behind the Doctor's door in The God Complex was pretty great, while the Doctor telling Clara that the Silents are actually priests who make you forget you ever confessed, like he knew who they were the entire time, wasn't so great. Then you have the entire story line of seasons 5 and 6 completely explained by Tasha Lem in basically one sentence like they were in a hurry, which was incredibly disappointing. Basically, Matt Smith's final outing was plagued with the same problems as The Wedding of River Song: too much climax, leaving little room for resolution.
4. A Dalek Downloads The Internet (Dalek)
This episode is what can be referred to as the very first puppy kick episode of the series. The Doctor's been a lone traveler ever since Gallifrey was "destroyed", the Time Lords and Daleks both "obliterated." This is the first episode of the revival when the Doctor discovers a surviving Dalek in 2012 Utah. Chained down and weakened, Rose's touch of pity gives off time energy from traveling in the TARDIS and re-energizes the Dalek, which obviously wasn't such a good idea. The Dalek shuts down the entire U.S. west coast absorbing all of it's energy... all the while downloading the entire 2012 Internet... Not exactly one of those moments where you wonder how this revival got off the ground in the first place, but now that 2012 itself has come and gone in our time we ask ourselves the challenging question... how smart could that Dalek have really gotten by reading our entire Internet? Be mindful that includes Reddit, FunnyJunk, YouTube comments, and every LOLcat and general meme to have ever existed, you name it. Watch the video below to give yourself a little perspective.Although, even in 2005 before such things existed on the interwebs, this was still pretty worthy of a facepalm.
3. Biological Metacrisis (The Stolen Earth / Journey's End)
The first time in the show's history to fake out a regeneration, the Doctor was finally reunited with Rose when he was shot dead by a Dalek in arguably the biggest puppy kick moment since Doomsday. Okay sorry, nothing is worse than Doomsday. Nothing. When his regeneration cycle begins, you're left on a cliffhanger to next week. Then we open up in Journey's End with the Doctor siphoning his regeneration energy into Jack's little play thing that is the Doctor's severed hand from the Sycorax invasion of Christmas Day. The facepalm of having to wait a whole week only to find out that the whole thing was a fakeout was made up for by all the adorable moments between the Doctor and Rose that everyone missed so much. Then we were all treated to another facepalm when the debate on whether or not this counted as one of the Doctor's twelve regenerations, which we found out years later that it did. He had vanity issues at the time.
2. The Entire Existence Of The Abzorbaloff (Love & Monsters)
Alright, this was just plain silly. In what, if memory serves, was the first Doctor-lite episode of the revival, this fluff piece to follow The Impossible Planet/The Satan Pit two parter is told from the perspective of original Doctor fangirls Elton and Ursula via their own camera footage. The monster of the episode, the Abzorbaloff, quite literally looks like something a 9 year old would draw himself and send to Russell T Davies to write into an episode and, well, that's exactly what happened. A mediocre episode with a decent script, the idea of fat green monsters that kill by absorbing the faces of its victims and the faces then protruding from its bodies is oddly enough only the second most cringeworthy alien in the history of NuWho, which is most certainly coming up next. However, this so-called aside episode format would be used again about a year later in a little episode called Blink, so consider this episode the beta test for what would eventually become a masterpiece.
1. The Entire Existence Of The Slitheen (Aliens Of London / World War Three)
The idea of ugly green aliens with uncontrollable flatulence who disguise themselves as members of Parliament sounds so much more like something a 9 year old would submit to Russell T Davies, but alas this gem came from nowhere else other than the brain of good ol' Russell. The most upsetting aspect of this episode was that it started off like it could have been great. You saw a spaceship crashing into Big Ben, a crossover from what would eventually become Torchwood, Harriet Jones' debut, Rose returning home after she was believed abducted and murdered, and a missing Prime Minister. Equally as upsetting is the fact that the Slitheen could have actually been decent one off aliens for the two parter had the infamous and hilarious flatulence not come into play. If you have a childish mind this aspect is extremely entertaining, but not much else about this episode. Considering the Abzorbaloff rather than the Slitheen was created by a 9 year old, this one episode always begs the question as to how NuWho ever got off the ground in the first place, but still no complaints... Any other moments in Doctor Who (classic or NuWho) that made you want to emulate Captain Picard once or twice? Sound off below!