Doctor Who: 10 Dropped Plot Threads We'll Never Get The Answer To

Doctor Who... knows how these plots were supposed to end.

By Christian Bone /

We're right on the cusp of a brand new age for Doctor Who. The upcoming season 11 will see Jodie Whittaker steer the TARDIS in a fresh direction as the Thirteenth Doctor, alongside her squad of companions Ryan, Yaz and Graham (Tosin Cole, Mandip Gill and Bradley Walsh, respectively). New showrunner Chris Chibnall has been keen to emphasise that this is basically the 2005 reboot all over again and is hoping to wipe the slate clean. Even the Daleks supposedly won't appear.

Advertisement

While this is good news, it does mean that many of those questions we had by the end of Steven Moffat's lengthy era on the show, as well as those leftover from the Russell T. Davies years, will never be answered. Both previous showrunners introduced some major concepts during their tenures on the series - but they both can also be accused of dropping the ball sometimes when it came to wrapping the narrative up.

So, just before we venture into the era of the Thirteenth Doctor, let's first spend a moment looking behind us as we remember some of those perplexing Doctor Who plots that apparently got lost in time.

10. What Happened To Those Dalek/Time Lord Hybrids?

2015's season 9 opened with a bang with thrilling two-parter 'The Magician's Apprentice/The Witch's Familiar.' It featured the return of Missy, Skaro and Davros himself - exploring his childhood and adding new layers to the Dalek-creating tyrant.

Advertisement

The climax still left us scratching our heads, however. It's ultimately revealed that Davros' dying act was a ruse to get the Doctor to share some regeneration energy with him. The evil scientist siphons this off to his babies and so creates Dalek/Time Lord hybrids: basically Daleks with the power to regenerate.

There's a fatal flaw, though, as Davros' scheme also awoke the abandoned Dalek mutants in Skaro's sewers who rose up and attacked those with shells. The Doctor seems to treat this as the end of it but he couldn't have been paying close enough attention.

In shots of the exterior of the city, we can clearly see many Daleks patrolling the skies. Surely these weren't affected by the sewer mutants on the ground, which means they must still be out there somewhere.

9. So The Universe Remembers The Doctor Again?

After apparently dying at the end of season 6, the Doctor decided to keep a low profile and, starting with the season 7 premiere Asylum of the Daleks, he began removing himself from every database in the universe.

Advertisement

This was an intriguing idea that Moffat perhaps introduced to combat the criticism that the Time Lord was increasingly getting by on his reputation alone. When it came to the finale of the Eleventh Doctor's era The Time of the Doctor, however, this building subplot never really came to anything and the gathered enemies of the Doctor all remembered who he was again.

With the Twelfth Doctor's era, Moffat clearly decided to abandon this and create some new plots for Peter Capaldi. Which means we're left forever wondering if he had originally planned to do more with this concept before Matt Smith opted to leave.

8. Why Did The TARDIS Hate Clara?

In the early episodes of season 7, there is a running gag that the TARDIS has a dislike for the Eleventh Doctor's latest companion, Clara Oswald. In 'Hide', the time machine even refuses to let Clara in to help the Doctor until after she pleads with the blue box. So what was the cause of the TARDIS' attitude problem?

Advertisement

Well, we've no clue. After a short while, these references dried up and the reason was never explained on screen. We can infer that the TARDIS perhaps didn't like that Clara was a complicated space/time event - as she was splintered throughout the Doctor's time stream in season 7 finale 'The Name of the Doctor.' The ship previously had a similar reaction to Captain Jack Harkness back in season 3, after all.

If that's the case, though, why does the TARDIS eventually shelve its hatred of Clara and treat her much the same way it does every companion?

7. What Happened To Nardole?

Nardole was an unexpected addition to the TARDIS for season 10. Going by Matt Lucas' broad turn in 2015 Christmas special 'The Husbands of River Song', fans weren't expecting much, but the character actually turned out to be an entertaining companion for the Doctor and Bill.

Advertisement

Which is why it's still annoying that he never got a proper ending, as finale 'The Doctor Falls' last catches up with Nardole as he escorts a load of orphans away from the Cybermen. It's a neat end to his character arc as it shows that he's grown braver, but it also leaves his fate open-ended. There's a real chance he could have died in the battle with the metalheads.

The Christmas special 'Twice Upon a Time' confuses things by featuring a glass replica of Nardole, courtesy of the Testimony. It's established that these are effectively A.I.s of the dead. So does that mean he didn't make it out alive?

6. Who Is The Woman In The End Of Time?

Let's cast our minds back to David Tennant's 2010 swansong 'The End of Time' for this mystery. Throughout the two-parter, Wilf was visited by a ghostly woman who seemed to know a lot about the Doctor and coming events. At the end of the adventure, the Doctor himself glimpsed her among the returning Time Lords and they seemed to share a meaningful gaze.

Advertisement

So who was this character, only credited as the Woman? Clearly, she's a Time Lady with a special connection to the Doctor - but who? Well, Russell T. Davies has admitted that, while he wanted to keep the Woman's identity secret on screen, he personally believes she is the Doctor's mother.

Steven Moffat didn't appear to share this view, however, as 2014 episode 'Listen' - which visits the Doctor's childhood - heavily hints that he is an orphan. Despite the authorial intention, then, the Woman could be anyone at all.

5. Is Jenny, The Doctor's Daughter, Still Alive?

Sticking with the Tenth Doctor's era for a moment, here's another enigma surrounding the Doctor's family. Season 4's 'The Doctor's Daughter' did what it says on the tin and introduced Jenny, the Doctor's female clone who is referred to as his daughter. After a strained beginning to their relationship, the pair bond and the Doctor is crushed when she is apparently shot dead.

Advertisement

Unbeknownst to him, however, Jenny is resurrected (via regeneration or the terraforming device, it's not clear) and flies off to see the stars, much like her dad. There was a lot of promise for the character and fans subsequently expected her to return every season... except she never did. Thankfully, Big Finish's recent audio spin-off Jenny, The Doctor's Daughter finally continued her adventures.

But where is Jenny in the current timeline of the show? If they are both rolling around the universe she is bound to bump into her dad - sorry, mum - again at some point. As it stands, though, the Doctor still doesn't know that she's alive - which is a bit tragic.

4. Was Orson Pink Clara's Grandson?

'Listen' was a deliberately ambiguous episode that raised but didn't answer several questions - was there really a monster? Was that actually the Doctor as a boy? The one that really feels like it needs to be explained, though, is the mystery of Orson Pink.

Advertisement

In the episode, the Doctor and Clara encounter humanity's first time-traveller, Orson Pink, at the end of the universe and help him get back to his own time. It's clear from his name, his appearance and his talk of having a time traveller in his family that he's the grandson of Clara and Danny Pink.

It's often theorised that Moffat intended to reveal or at least hint that Clara was pregnant in later episodes. For instance, 'Dark Water' sees her make an urgent call to Danny with post-it notes on her wall that read 'truth', 'just say it' and '3 months.' This would have explained Orson's lineage.

As fans may know, Jenna Coleman was initially planning to leave after this season but ultimately changed her mind. Therefore, we can infer that Moffat was forced to change his plans and remove Clara's pregnancy from the equation.

In the world of the show, though, perhaps Orson was written out of history after Danny died in 'Death in Heaven'?

3. Is Gallifrey Actually Back?

50th anniversary special 'The Day of the Doctor' changed history when the Doctor saved Gallifrey by transporting it into a different universe rather than destroy it, as previously established. The very next episode, 'The Time of the Doctor', then explained that the Time Lords were trying to return to our universe via the cracks in time.

Advertisement

In season 9's 'Hell Bent', however, it's revealed that the Time Lords wasn't actually moved into a different universe but could be found at the end of time. Though the Doctor had to get there "the long way round" via his confession dial, he was able to use a TARDIS to run away again. So it seems, unlike during the Time War, Gallifrey is no longer time-locked.

So does this mean that Gallfrey is returned and, just like the old days, the Time Lords are back for good? Well, that's hard to say as season 10 decided to ignore this question completely. And, going by Chibnall's description of season 11, it seems unlike that Thirteen will take a trip back home as it wouldn't be particularly casual viewer-friendly.

From the evidence, though, Gallifrey is back - but the Doctor is happy not visiting it. Very much like the old days.

2. Is The Doctor Half-Human?

Here's a sore point for many fans. 1996's UK/US co-production Doctor Who: The Movie attempted to kick off a new series with Paul McGann. There were lots of major concept changes planned but the only one that made it into the finished TV movie was the revelation that the Doctor is actually half-human!

Advertisement

As this has never been mentioned before or since, fans like to hand-wave it away as just something unique to this regeneration. However, the dialogue that establishes this fact is very clear that this has always been the case. The Doctor even says he's human "on [his] mother's side."

Russell T. Davies is one of those who's not a fan of this Spock-like backstory and almost wrote a joke in 2008's 'Journey's End' that would have explained the half-human thing as "a 24-hour bug", suggesting it wore away after the Eighth Doctor's first day. However, he ultimately cut it as he thought it was too fan-orientated.

As things stand, then, the only evidence on the matter says that the Doctor really is half-human. Unless the Thirteenth Doctor proves otherwise.

1. So What Is The Doctor's Name?

For season 7, Moffat decided to make the show's very title a major plot point as the answer to the 50 year old question "Doctor Who?" was teased to be coming. After all, River Song was revealed to know what his name was back in 2008's 'Silence in the Library.' Would she finally share it with the class?

Advertisement

This came to a head in 'The Time of the Doctor', when it was explained that the Doctor needed to say his real name to let the Time Lords return to the universe. However, Clara was able to convince the Gallifreyans to give up their quest and grant the Doctor some more regenerations without the need for his name.

And so the arc was no more, with the central question of the show slipping back into the background. This probably proves that we'll never find out the Doctor's real name - and maybe, just this once, that's for the best. In any case, the Twelfth Doctor probably summed it up best in his final speech:

"Oh, and you mustn't tell anyone your name. No one would understand it, anyway. Except children. Children can hear it sometimes. If their hearts are in the right place, and the stars are too, children can hear your name. But nobody else. Nobody else, ever."

What other major plot threads that were dropped from Doctor Who still bug you? Have your say in the comments.

Advertisement