Doctor Who has always been a show of missed opportunities and what ifs, both within episodes and the grand history of the show. What if the Doctor got mixed up with Madame du Pompadour? What if he had an opposite-sex clone? What if he accidentally got engaged to an ancient Aztec woman? Sometimes the episodes have played out wonderfully and other times theyve left the fans wanting more, or less, or something completely different. Dozens of one-shot or secondary characters that should have been companions or treated differently. Why would you hire John Simm to reprise his role as the Master after a fantastic first turn, and then waste two episodes on him running round screaming and fixating on food? Why hire the daughter of the Fifth Doctor, to be the daughter of the Tenth Doctor, just to have her fly off into the sunset and never heard of again? And then, sometimes they do get it right the first time and we simply want to see the characters again. But what other one shot or recurring characters have a plausible chance of returning to the show? We're not going to see Carey Mulligan or Kylie Minogue filming in Cardiff for a year any time soon, so what other characters should return to the show, even just for a one off episode? Here are five characters that should no, must have another shot on the series and their return is plausible too.
5. The Rani
I will kick and scream if we never see the Time Lords or Gallifrey in the show again, even though were pretty much guaranteed to see them again one day. The Master came back twice, so why shouldnt they? But if not the Time Lords, Id definitely settle for the Rani, originally played by Kate OMara during the run of the Sixth Doctor. Basically a female counterpart to the Master, the Rani was a fellow ex-classmate of the Doctor, a scientist who enjoys experimenting on people and other species, if the Master and the Doctor would just stay out of her damn way. Her mindset is not the usual one we see in Doctor Who shes not evil for kicks or for power, but a consequence of her research. Everything comes second to her search for knowledge, even morality. At one point she even teams up with Anthony Ainleys Master (under duress) and at another has the good sense to kick him in the crotch. The Ranis a likely candidate for a comeback, as an exile from Gallifrey its easy to justify her not having taken part in the Time War. Shes fiery, evil and a lot of fun a good campy changeup from the increasingly dark villains of the new series. Who knows if wed see her played by Kate OMara again (whose face has barely changed since the 1980s) or, in the grand tradition of Moffat, a new sassy, sexier regeneration, but the possibilities are infinite..
4. Billy Shipton
Forget Carey Mulligans Sally Sparrow, shes long gone and in Hollywood, hooking up with Jay Gatsby. What about the other fan favourite character from the amazing Blink? Despite having ten minutes of screentime on the outside, Billy Shipton, the flirty young detective who became the elderly, dying DVD salesman with a beloved wife, is remembered and adored by the fandom for his charisma and charm. He arguably had better chemistry with Sally than the forced romance between her and Lawrence Nightingale. The implications of his story are endless from a successful career in the modern day, sent back to an era where race was even more of a hurdle to moving anywhere in life, he managed to succeed and find happiness, a wife and family. The 1960s and 1970s are an era we need to see on New Who again, as the success of the 1969-set Impossible Astronaut proves. Billy would make the perfect one-shot companion to the Doctor, perhaps as he rushes around 1970s London in a story perhaps calling back to the Third Doctors era. And the choice Billy might have to make at the end return to the 2000s with the Doctor and find a different way around the loop in Blink (after all, Eleven has a lot less respect for timey-wimey paradoxes than Ten) or stick with his new girlfriend and the friends he made in the 1970s?
3. Canton
Busy as he must be ruling over hell in Supernatural, Mark Sheppards two-episode turn as an ex-Secret Service agent circa 1969 made his character a fan favourite and lead to demands for his return for the show. He was a breath of fresh air in a series that was increasingly being made up of two breeds of character sassy heroic dudes who were awkward yet successful with women and sassy sexy ladies whose ability to give birth or have been born were important. We liked that he was an older guy from a separate time, with a mysterious backstory that was hinted at through his two episodes, then made yet more intriguing and tragic with one final, funny at first, line Yes. He is. Canton felt fleshed out and was an instant fit to the TARDIS crew in the short time we knew him. Canton was a staunch soldier, a self-aware parody of the way Americans are often portrayed in the media (that is, trigger happy) something I think we can all get behind. With a serious need for the representation of LGBTQ people in the media, its high time we saw a character so comfortable and confident in his sexuality, despite existing in an era at odds with this behaviour.
2. Romana
Im really betraying my affection for the Time Lords here, but Romana was literally the one who got away, for both the Doctor and the Time War. She is the only other Time Lord in the series that has a plausible excuse for surviving the destruction of all Time Lords in the universe namely, she wasnt there at the time. Though RTD claimed Romana made her way back through the gate and became President of Gallifrey but hey, it aint canon until weve seen it onscreen. In the new series, the only thing weve seen of Time Lords outside of the Doctor is the bad ones the Master and Rassilon, to be specific. The contrast of the tough, intelligent and moral Romana to the murderous insanity of other Time Lords would be refreshing, and her youthfulness and poise a changeup compared to the saucy flirting and innuendos of River Song. Not to say Romana cant be sexy and funny when she wants to, but the restrictions placed on the Classic Series meant that the subtext between her and the Fourth Doctor remained just that, subtext. I reckon wed see a more serious Romana, traumatized by the loss of Gallifrey but willing to smack the Doctor in the head when he steps out of line and do whats right by the laws of time an aspect of Mary Tamms Romana I, rather than the usual fan-favourite of Lalla Wards Romana II. Instead of being a reminder of the Time War and awful times for the Doctor, she would be a reminder of Gallifrey and his family and childhood, something we need to see in the increasingly alien character. And maybe we could finally get a canon answer to all that sexual tension between her and the Fourth Doctor. Preferably one that doesnt end with their divorce, like Ward and Bakers actually did, after two years of marriage.
1. The Eighth Doctor
Though Eight has received a thorough fleshing out in the audios and novels of the expanded universe, after the middling 1996 attempt at a revival of the series, his only on-screen turn as the Doctor was far too short. Paul McGann has been a wonderful attendee of cons all over the world and unlike his successor, is happy to return to the series isnt it time we saw him on our screens again? Imagine an episode where he goes toe-to-toe with the Eleventh Doctor, perhaps a full-length time crash where they switch companions and TARDISes and have to get back to each other and find out who switched them around. Wed see the hope and naivety of an Eight before the Time War coupled with the cynicism and darkening of the Eleventh after that unspeakable trauma. Or what about the Eighth Doctor bursting onto the scene directly after the destruction of Gallifrey, bringing the devastation of the Time War back to our screens in a very literal way no more vaguely grand references to the Could Have Been King and the Nightmare Child, but the most hopeful, childlike Doctor of them all appearing as a war-weary, burnt-out veteran. It would also shed some more light on when and where he regenerated into the Ninth Doctor. Paul McGann has already expressed an interest in hopping into the TARDIS again, and he unfortunately missed his chance with the upcoming 50th Anniversary special. So come on, give Eight a chance. What characters would you like to see return even just for a couple of lines?