Doctor Who: Every Title Sequence Ranked From Worst To Best

From the Howlround effect to full CGI vortexes, let's see how far the Doctor Who titles have come.

By Rich Hutson /

Alongside the casting of the Doctor themselves, what they wear, and the design of their TARDIS, the opening of (almost) every episode of their respective series plays a big part in the overall feel of a Doctor's era. Over the last 57 years of Doctor Who, we've seen title sequences that have pushed the boundaries of television special effects, made the hairs on the back of our necks stand on end, and look at the telly and think, 'wow, that was rubbish.'

Advertisement

So we're going to take a look through the history of one of, if not the most iconic opening sequence in television history, and rank them from worst to best. Whilst the arrangement of the iconic Ron Grainer theme music will play a part in this ranking, we're not ranking the themes themselves (though if you'd like to see that, let me know in the comments!) Instead, we're looking predominantly at the visuals, and how they help or hinder a given era of the show.

Grab your sonic, and hang on tight, we're going to be hurtling through quite a few time vortexes from here...

12. The Eleventh Doctor (2012-2013)

As the Matt Smith era of Doctor Who drew to a close, his final two specials, The Snowmen and The Time of the Doctor, and the second half of the overall mediocre Series 7 in-between, introduced an entirely re-imagined title sequence for the show. Ditching the majority of the tried-and-tested time vortex until the very end, this new opening pitted the TARDIS against more low-resolution special effects and PNG files of nebulas than you could shake a stick at.

Advertisement

This title sequence lacked any kind of direction, and was difficult to really track where the TARDIS or 'camera' was throughout this bewildering 30 second trip. As the cherry on top of a mediocre cake, the sequence wraps up with the TARDIS spinning toward the audience, with the doors opening to reveal the first shot of the episode. In theory, this ending sounds exciting, and the smoothest transition between titles and episode we'd ever seen, but the sheer lack of any lighting on the TARDIS model itself (look at it compared to the one you see at the beginning of the sequence) wrapped up an entirely cheap-looking opening. Even a VFX YouTuber did a better job of it.

One thing this opening did get right however, was bringing back The Doctor's face to the title sequence. A glint of hope in an otherwise murky pond.

11. The Seventh Doctor (1987-1989)

The cheeky, yet charming Seventh Doctor had an era born from controversy and shunning of Sci-Fi from the BBC. Though his time in the TARDIS wasn't a complete tire fire, there were a few questionable moments during Sylvester McCoy's run. The title sequence, though not completely horrific, was unfortunately nothing more than a glorified tech demo. Though the technology at play was some of the most advanced used for television at the time, the opening sequence felt like one of the most drawn-out of the lot.

Advertisement

For the late eighties, the visuals are stunning. From the thousands of stars, to the TARDIS encapsulated in a force field, and motif of flying rocks and 3D 'WHO' lettering, this was quite a spectacle. But 'spectacle' was unfortunately all this was. As the years have progressed, this opening sequence has sunk into relative obscurity in comparison with the other titles on this list. However, McCoy's portrait winking at the camera gave the viewers of Time and the Rani back in 1987 a perfect first impression of the Doctor to come.

10. The Third Doctor (1970-1973)

When Doctor Who exploded onto our screens in vibrant colour back in 1970, the title sequence was more of the same, but was viewed from what felt like an almost different dimension. Eventually seeing the blue of the iconic blue box was one thing, but seeing just how many colours could be crammed into the opening of Spearhead from Space was another. Whilst the visuals were still very reminiscent of the first two opening sequences for the first two Doctors, the splash of colour, and almost trippy feel set this apart from what came before.

Advertisement

The Doctor's portrait emerging from within the 'vortex' was something we had seen in Patrick Troughton's opening, but seeing the pink and peach tones blend into Jon Pertwee's full-colour portrait was as equally mind-blowing as the first time viewers saw the original title sequence back 1963. Also, the Pertwee era logo has to be the best of the bunch. I just wish it became the logo for the series going forward after its heavy use during the 50th Anniversary. That's not to say that the incumbent logo is bad, it's still gorgeous all the same. Anyone for a logo ranking?

9. The Eighth Doctor (1996)

The Pertwee era logo is back, so the 1996 TV Movie already has a few brownie points in my book. Paul McGann's Eighth Doctor's feature length outing began with an extremely rare (for the time) cold open, and proceeded into arguably the first 'modern' title sequence. These visuals almost perfectly bridge the gap between Classic and 'Nu' Who, featuring a vortex with discernible depth, and text flying throughout (similar to what we saw from 2005 onwards), to rocks hurtling through space, and a large, three-dimensional logo (similar to Sylvester McCoy's opening).

Advertisement

The theme music itself was arranged by American composer John Debney, who gave the usually electronically produced theme a fully orchestral flair - something we would become very used to for the majority of NuWho. The Eighth Doctor's titles were beautifully simple, yet produced with stunning detail. For a hopeful reboot (which of course didn't happen), they went all-out on this opening sequence. Though the movie itself didn't stick the landing, this opening sure did.

8. The Twelfth Doctor (2014-2017)

YouTube is rife with fanmade title sequences. Every time a new Doctor is announced, or we're in the no man's land between series, budding VFX artists begin to fill the void with potential opening visuals for the next series. While the incredible work of John Smith VFX was recognised by the BBC, and they went on to produce an advertisement for Series 10, the real winner of the YouTube to real Doctor Who race was won by Billy Hanshaw (billydakiduk). His concept title sequence for the Twelfth Doctor was noticed by the BBC, and he was subsequently hired to produce the actual title sequence for Peter Capaldi's run as The Doctor.

Advertisement

This was a fresh take on the tried-and-tested vortex sequence seen throughout Doctor Who since 1996, hence why it caught Steven Moffat's eye. The dark, mechanical opening, instantly juxtaposed by the more whimsical, on-the-nose numerics of an infinite, roman numeral clock face, set Capaldi's title sequence apart from its disastrous Matt Smith predecessor. Keeping the actor credits and brief look at Capaldi's attack eyebrows, this title sequence felt much more refined than what came before.

However, this opening was done a heavy disservice throughout its use across three series and the Twelfth Doctor specials, as this iteration of Murray Gold's theme was a different amount out of sync each and every time the sequence played. It's unsure as to why, but it's one of the most irritating things about what would have otherwise been a perfect opening sequence.

7. The Thirteenth Doctor (2018-Present)

When Jodie Whittaker and Chris Chibnall stepped into the TARDIS in 2018, everything was about to change. Not only was it a new showrunner taking the reigns, a new actor tackling the iconic Time Lord, and almost an entire change in production, it also brought about a new title sequence and composer. Segun Akinola took the reigns from Murray Gold, who had composed for Doctor Who since 2005. This sequence was much more reminiscent of the original titles, dropping the TARDIS for the first time since the 1984-1986 openings, and removing the much-loved portrait of the Doctor.

Advertisement

If the technology were available at the time, this is how Jon Pertwee's title sequence probably would have looked. Though the time vortex used in Series 11 onward is reminiscent of these visuals, this is a much more abstract approach to the usual opening seen in Doctor Who. This stunning creation represents the much higher-quality production values seen throughout the Chibnall era, and an accelerated push through this nebula-laden star field, into a hard cut to the episode title wrapped things up in a gorgeous fashion.

Segun Akinola's more minimal approach to the original theme also hails back to the days of the original Delia Derbyshire theme, cementing the Thirteenth Doctor's title sequence as something that would have been produced back in the sixties if the technology was there.

6. The Second Doctor (1967-1969)

Patrick Troughton's run as The Doctor had a lot to live up to. Not only was recasting The Doctor in the first place a risky (yet genius) move, the production had to remain stellar to keep avid viewers on-board. So, they ramped up the black and white bling on the title sequence. The more complex, symmetrical howlround effect complimented the more layered arrangement of the original theme, and the introduction of Patrick Troughton's visage to the title sequence not only added a new dimension to these stunning effects, it solidified that this was something outright new.

Advertisement

However, the base DNA of the Doctor Who title sequence viewers had come to know and love of the previous four years was still here. It was Doctor Who '2' in many respects. New Doctor, new music, new visuals, but still Doctor Who through and through.

5. The Fourth, Fifth, And Sixth Doctors (1980-1986)

In 1980, the Doctor Who title sequence changed drastically, all thanks to the command of infamous producer John Nathan-Turner. Not only was the theme replaced, the overall visual style changed also. Gone were the bright colours, trippy visuals, the original time vortex, and the TARDIS itself, and in were simple starfields, unflattering portraits of The Doctors (poor Tom Baker), and a re-designed, neon tube logo. As much as the changes might sound bad, it wasn't all terrible.

Advertisement

This new, high contrast title sequence was heavily influenced by the success of Star Wars. As the viewer traversed space, stars began to align, forming both the portraits of Doctors Four, Five, and Six, and the new logo. Unfortunately, the legendary Delia Derbyshire arrangement of the theme was dropped, and Peter Howell produced the new one.

While Tom Baker and Peter Davison's variants of this title sequence are nigh-on the same, Colin Baker's opening was given much more flair. Not only was the star field much busier and brighter, it also featured multi-coloured stars, a portrait of the Sixth Doctor that transitions from a slight grin to a big smile, and a more colourful, slightly curved version of the existing Doctor Who logo. Season 23 also saw a new theme, arranged by Dominic Glynn, which was only used for this final Sixth Doctor season with the same titles.

4. The Eleventh Doctor (2010-2012)

After a title sequence spanning the first two Doctors of the rebooted era, it was time for new branding, and subsequently a new opening to take the stage. First appearing in 2010's The Eleventh Hour and remaining unchanged through Series 6 (apart from Arthur Darvill being added to the opening credits). It was the first time many viewers new to Doctor Who experienced a change this significant. As much as the theme tune and visuals have their own distinct style, it wasn't so removed from the Ninth and Tenth Doctor's openings that came before.

Advertisement

Come the first half of Series 7 however, this title sequence had a few tweaks. Gone were the metallic, stone-like credits at the beginning of the sequence, and in were simple 2D text titles with a wavy transition. The Doctor Who logo removed the 'DW' TARDIS from within it, electing to transition to it after the main 'Doctor Who' title (which itself had a different, ugly texture based on the episode about to be shown), and the entire thing was put beneath what looks like an Instagram filter. With Doctor Who being huge on social media at this point, it was as if the production team had decided to pre-filter the GIF potential before it ended up on Tumblr.

Though it started incredibly strong in Series 5 and 6, the Eleventh Doctor's title sequences would take a downward turn, especially come the second half of Series 7.

3. The First Doctor (1963-1967)

The original, you might say.

Advertisement

When Doctor Who was pitched to the BBC back in the early sixties, the concept was borderline outrageous. Though it did get past Sydney Newman, the production needed to remain equally outrageous. The TARDIS set was like nothing seen before, the duo of Ron Grainer and Delia Derbyshire brought one of the most iconic and influential pieces of electronic music to life, and the production team of this then-unknown show produced an eerily beautiful title sequence to boot.

By simply pointing a camera at a display that is showing that camera's feed, you get an unusual effect of pulsing blobs. This, combined with the legendary theme was like nothing else on television at the time. Originally, the idea of having someone's face appear in the vortex was tested, but then-producer Verity Lambert deemed it too scary. Of course, this idea was eventually used in the Second Doctor's titles. This sequence is so iconic within Doctor Who history, it was used once again 46 years after it was replaced to open the 50th Anniversary episode, The Day of the Doctor.

2. The Third & Fourth Doctors (1973-1980)

Come 1973, Doctor Who was just as popular as it was when it launched ten years earlier. Jon Pertwee was producing his final season, and Bernard Lodge (creator of all the openings up to this point) was commissioned to produce an all-new title sequence for the show. This was the first radical change to the established style of the opening. Gone were the howlround effects, and in came the more recognisable time vortex. Jon Pertwee's image was promoted to a full-height shot of the actor, and the iconic diamond logo was introduced. The theme tune however, remained the same.

Advertisement

When Tom Baker took on the role in 1974, the rough concept of the previous title sequence remained. However, the TARDIS was used for the first time in the opening sequence, and unlike his next titles, Tom Baker's Doctor portrait is much more flattering. The vortex effect used after the image of the TARDIS has become iconic in its own right, appearing in the likes of Family Guy of all things. Whilst the explicit vortex was dropped between 1980 and 1996, this was the first big step up in the visual effects used in the title sequence, and it still holds up incredibly well today.

1. The Ninth & Tenth Doctors (2005-2010)

There is nothing quite like the energy behind the Ninth and Tenth Doctor's title sequences. The time vortex was back in full-force, the TARDIS was given a starring role, and the BBC threw everything at 3D graphics, from the new logo to the actor credits. Murray Gold's perfect blend of orchestral and electronic pays homage to both the original version of the theme, and to that of the 1996 movie, all while moving it forward into the 21st century. The version heard from Voyage of the Damned onwards is by far the most adrenaline-pumping arrangement.

Advertisement

There were a few minor tweaks over the five years this opening was incumbent, from a better logo model and the aforementioned theme tweaks. But, the title sequence remained pretty much unchanged throughout its tenure, as it was pretty much perfect in the first place. Nothing in the modern era has matched these visuals or this Murray Gold arranged theme, and it's not entirely certain anything ever will.

Which Doctor Who title sequence was your favourite? Let me know in the comments!

Advertisement