Doctor Who: Once, Upon Time Review - 5 Ups & 6 Downs
Does anyone else feel like they need a lay down?
What the Flux was that?
Never has an episode of Doctor Who left us so baffled. Once, Upon Time had so much plot stuffed into its forty-five minute runtime that it makes the infamously convoluted series 6 look like an episode of the Tweenies by comparison. It seems like Chibs has quit cribbing from the RTD era and gone full Moffat on this one.
Was that a masterpiece or a misfire? We aren’t sure yet. Let’s unravel this web of timey-wimey exposition and attempt to find some sense.
11. DOWN - A Confusing Mess
First things first, we have to praise this episode for its structure, which sets it apart from the crowd. The episode attempts to tell five simultaneous stories, one for each of our five protagonists: The Doctor, Yaz, Dan, Vinder and the newly introduced Bel. It tends to be the episodes that change up the ‘monster of the week’ format that really stick with you, for better or worse.
Unfortunately, this time, it’s a case of great concept, poor execution. The jumps between these stories, especially in the first twenty minutes, are frantic at best and downright disorientating at worst. So much is dumped on the viewer in quick succession, with little context, that it’s difficult to follow exactly what’s going on. As the episode continues, this pacing becomes less of an issue, but by that point the damage has been done.
We can’t help but feel that this episode could have been Chibnall’s best yet if we watched each story unfold one at a time like an anthology - now that really would have been an interesting format change. In fact, when ‘Bel’s Story’ appeared, this is what we expected to happen, which begs the question: what exactly was the point of the title slates at the start of her scenes?
So close to greatness, and yet so far.
10. UP - Inside The Doctor’s Head
The episode starts with something we really don’t see often enough: a glimpse into The Doctor’s thought process.
We’re taken straight back to last week’s cliffhanger, which saw Swarm about to subject Yaz and Vinder to the full force of unadulterated time. The Doctor walks us through what she’s thinking - every consideration that is running through her mind every time she’s in danger, and how she formulates a plan, before springing into action.
This sort of fourth-wall breaking narration was very characteristic of the Capaldi era, and it always served to deepen his character, providing a rare level of insight into the head of our mysterious protagonist. More of this please!
We’re also pleased to report that this was a much better cliffhanger resolution than the previous botch-job, though they do take their time to explain it fully…
9. UP - Familiar Faces
One absolute master stroke of this episode was the decision to have our protagonists appear in each other’s stories - it all felt very inspired by Cloud Atlas. This really helps to sell the idea that time is falling apart, and prompts the characters to question the reality they are experiencing. It gives the episode an eerie vibe, with a surreal, unnerving edge of something not being quite right.
It also gives some fun opportunities for the lead actors to play outside of their usual roles, with Yaz taking the role of Vinder’s stoic commander, The Doctor’s amusing turn as Yaz’s complaining stake-out buddy, and Dan playing the role of his soul-brother, Karvanista. We half expected Yaz and Vinder to be revealed as Gat and Lee in The Doctor’s story, and we’re still not entirely convinced they aren’t.
If we had one criticism, we maybe would have had the characters take on their original forms just a little more than they did.
8. DOWN - Over-Explaining (Whilst Also Not Really Explaining)
Another week, another opportunity for The Doctor to narrate her every action. Is this an intentional character trait for Thirteen? Because it’s starting to feel like it…
The scenes of The Doctor and The Mouri in the middle of the CGI disaster that is the ‘time storm’ are a jumbled, incohesive mess. The Doctor tells the audience what they’ve just seen in case they missed it, then claims credit for hiding her companions within their own memories to keep them safe. The thing is, she doesn’t seem to have actually planned this, because she was confused and scared by her friends disappearing into the time storm just five minutes earlier, exclaiming that ‘time was pulling them back’ and she had to ‘rescue them’ - which is it, Doc? And more to the point, how does The Doctor have the power to control this, anyway?
The Doctor then pops up in Yaz, Dan and Vinder’s stories to explain what’s happening to each of them. This is reasonable enough, as the plot relies on them understanding what’s going on, but does this mean the audience needs to see a copy of the same scene three times? It wastes valuable time that could be spent giving these stories some much needed breathing room.
7. UP - Bel’s Story
We’ve decided to take each of the five stories from this episode one at a time for this list, as organising this any other way is a headache waiting to happen. Let’s start with our newcomer, Bel.
Bel is introduced to us as a scavenger and survivor of the Flux, who is on the hunt for the man she loves. Straight off the bat, she’s shown to be an optimist and a fighter - an extremely capable one at that, successfully evading a pack of Daleks and taking down a platoon of Cybermen single-handedly. She’s sweet and likeable, and the decision to have her dialogue confined mostly to a voiceover saves the trouble of forcing her character to spout exposition out loud for no apparent reason - looking at you, Thirteen…
Bel carries with her a chirpy little datapad companion, which sends her encouraging emojis as moral support throughout her journey. It’s a cute if slightly odd element to her story that suddenly clicks into place at the climax of the episode. Bel’s connection to the rest of the story is unclear until we get the double whammy reveal that; firstly, the lover that Bel has been searching for is Vinder, and secondly, that her datapad is in fact a futuristic baby monitor of sorts, that allows her to communicate with the baby she is carrying - Vinder’s baby (or, as Bel refers to it, in one of the worst lines the show has seen in a long time: his ‘beautiful, as yet unborn child’…)
One complaint we have for this storyline is that everybody seems to know exactly what The Flux is: Bel, the unusually chatty dying Cybermen, even some random unnamed bloke Bel apparently met at a bar. Everyone understands the Flux, it seems, except the Doctor, and by extension, us. Getting some serious FOMO, here.
Regardless, these nitpicks aren’t enough to prevent us giving this spunky new star-crossed lover a big shiny UP.
6. DOWN - Dan’s Story
In his first episode, we saw Dan abducted from his beloved home city of Liverpool. Last week, we watched on as he valiantly took the fight to the Sontarans following their invasion of… Liverpool. We simply can’t wait to see where his third journey in a literal time and space machine takes him! Where will he end up? Yup, he’s in Liverpool…again. Great. Is anyone else starting to think that John Bishop can only sustain his mortal form so long as he stays within Merseyside?
Dan’s story is fairly inoffensive this episode - there’s nothing terribly bad about it, but there’s not much good either. Sure, we get a nice bit of backstory about his ex, and his chemistry with Diane is passable, but other than that this story meanders for much of the runtime, culminating in the reveal that Diane’s consciousness has been stored inside The Passenger, as many of us already suspected. We still aren’t quite sure why Azure chose to capture Diane, given that Dan had zero connection to The Doctor at the time, but we digress.
We also saw the third appearance of Joseph Williamson, who made just as much sense and impact as he did the last two times as he runs from some terribly CGI’d blue fireflies. We’re going to need an explanation for this guy real soon, because his presence is becoming annoying.
Dan hasn’t really had his moment to shine yet, and his main contribution to Flux has been the ‘Evil Dan’ memes, but we live in hope.
5. UP - The Doctor’s Story
Now this was interesting. The Doctor had the meatiest backstory this week, and it was about time. At last, we got to see The Division in action, with Thirteen reliving a memory of the Fugitive Doctor defeating Swarm and Azure the first time around. It was great to see the reappearance of Jo Martin, though she didn’t get a lot to do here sadly, but regardless, we dined well on story progression tonight.
There’s still clearly more story to come here, but we now have a much clearer idea of exactly what The Doctor’s time in The Division was like - she appears to be in command, though it’s hinted that she’s been forced into service, she’s got a new hoodie, and she even has a little gang that includes Karvanista. We wonder why he never revealed this to The Doctor.
Much in line with what we saw in Fugitive of the Judoon, this incarnation of The Doctor is edgier, and more willing to disregard life than her successors, and it’s very interesting to see this portrayal. We also understand now why The Ravagers seem to have it in for The Doctor, deepening the history between the Time Lord and her new nemesis. Thumbs up.
4. DOWN - Yaz’s Story
Chibs really doesn’t know what to do with Yaz, does he? With no backstory to tell, Yaz is dropped back into her mundane life, sitting in a police car on a stake-out, and playing video games with her sister (and yes, people do call them that, despite the script insisting people don’t). If you think this sounds boring, that’s because it is. That’s why the scriptwriters decided to drop in a Weeping Angel to spice things up. Here’s the thing, it’s still boring.
Yaz, as the character with no story to tell, is tasked with setting up next week’s episode instead, but the whole plot just ends up feeling shoehorned and random. Yes, it was nice to see that Moffat’s ‘the image of an Angel becomes itself an Angel’ rule is still a thing, but the arrival of the Angel from the video game is just too out of nowhere to have an impact, and is dealt with immediately with zero tension. This is the least threatening Weeping Angel scene we’ve seen to date, which is a shame coming off the back of their extremely tense stand-off with Claire in The Halloween Apocalypse. Fingers crossed that next week’s episode takes cues from the latter and not the former.
3. UP - Vinder’s Story
Vinder remains the most intriguing and well acted character in this series so far, and now that we know more about who him, he’s only improved. The hints dotted through the previous two episodes come to fruition nicely as we watch Vinder’s fall from grace play out in flashback form.
It turns out Vinder is a military commander who is assigned on a security detail to The Grand Serpent, a shady and corrupt official who makes sure to let us know he’s definitely a baddie. Craig Parkinson, forever typecast as the slimy bastard type, does a decent job with his limited screen time here, and is genuinely quite menacing. Vinder, strongly opposing The Grand Serpent’s general approach to life, ill-advisedly attempts to become a whistleblower, and is sent to the edge of the universe by way of punishment, leaving him where we found him in episode one.
This whole plot felt more Star Wars than Doctor Who, but it was a welcome departure that managed to squeeze in some solid world-building and character development. If Vinder and Bel don’t both survive this series, we’ll be mad.
2. DOWN - Swarm’s Baffling Plans
Swarm, mate, what happened to you?
The most compelling villain of the Chibnall era had an off-week this time around, both in the past and present day. In The Doctor’s story, Swarm’s appearance resembles the state we found him in at the start of the series. This design is far less striking than his newer look, at the prosthetics seem to limit his expression and speech considerably - taking all the oomph out of his performance to the point where he almost feels like a different character. He goes off on a crazy tangent about time and space and how time is at war with space and time is totally better than space, in what can only be described as some sort of intergalactic ‘my dad could totally beat up your dad’ argument with himself. Script-wise, it’s meaningless drivel, frankly.
Back in the modern day, Swarm reveals that he always intended for the Doctor to throw herself into the Time Storm and save her friends, which seems like a super weird plan. Maybe he just wanted the audience to get some much needed exposition and really fancied an anthology episode. With his work done, he just taunts the Doctor and leaves, instead of, you know, killing everyone like he absolutely can.
Big, big down.
1. DOWN - The Closing Scenes
With the main plot resolved, the episode makes sure to position our characters for next week, leading to a rather iffy conclusion and a run of three arguably weak scenes.
The first sees The Doctor communicating with a judgy and hostile old woman that really seems to have a bone to pick with her, but frustratingly doesn’t bother to explain why, beyond telling The Doctor that the Flux is all her fault. At this point in the series, not understanding the Flux is starting to get a little frustrating, and now we have another mystery box to theorise over with the identity of this woman. Tecteun, maybe?
Secondly, we have a slight gripe with Vinder’s last scene of the episode. The scene itself is absolutely fine - Vinder has a new purpose and all that, but we can’t help but wonder why, if he’s hunting the universe for Bel, he doesn’t stick with the person who has a time-travelling spaceship. That sort of thing feels like it might be useful?
Last but not least, we found this week’s cliffhanger was lacking, with another surprise Angel jumping out of Yaz’s phone and taking control of the TARDIS. We’ve lost count of how many times the supposedly unbreachable TARDIS has been breached in the Chibnall era: The Kasaavin, Zellin, The Judoon, Swarm’s possession of the TARDIS last week, and now the Angels. It just feels like Thirteen has disabled the security or something.
The episode is capped off with The Doctor proclaiming that the Angel has the TARDIS - a very on-the-nose Blink reference that takes you out of the moment. This one just felt like a cliffhanger for the sake of a cliffhanger. Not every episode has to end on an action scene…