Emmys 2017: Who Should Win Every Major Award (And Who Actually Will)

Who will take Game of Thrones' crown?

By James Hunt /

Netflix/HBO/ATAS

Awards season is well underway. The big festivals are in full swing, the 'worthy' movies set to be released, and chatter about the Oscars is ramping up - but it goes as much for TV as it does cinema.

Advertisement

With the new fall season kicking off, the 69th Primetime Emmy Awards take place this Sunday to honour the best of the small screen over the last year (and a bit), from the network sitcoms to the prestige dramas of HBO, Netflix, and FX.

There's added intrigue this year because there will definitely be a new winner in the biggest award of the evening, Outstanding Drama Series. Game of Thrones has taken the prize the last two years, but its delayed start means Season 7 isn't eligible until next year, and Downton Abbey ending too means there's a real influx of fresh names and faces.

Advertisement

The nominees are led by HBO's big hitters Westworld and Veep, Netflix's The Crown, and perennial Emmy favourite SNL, with all the other buzzy new shows, limited series, and TV movies - from Atlanta to Wizard of Lies - in the mix as well. A lot of the races are wide open, and there's plenty of room for shocks and surprises come Sunday night in the Microsoft Theatre.

18. Supporting Actress In A Limited Series Or Movie

HBO

Nominees

Advertisement

Judy Davis - Feud: Bette and Joan

Laura Dern - Big Little Lies

Advertisement

Jackie Hoffman - Feud: Bette and Joan

Regina King - American Crime

Advertisement

Michelle Pfeiffer - The Wizard of Lies

Shailene Woodley - Big Little Lies

Advertisement

Who Should Win

Laura Dern

Advertisement

Dern is having a hell of a year on the small screen, with a great supporting turn in Twin Peaks (which could see her back in this race next year) and an entertaining guest spot in Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt. But some of her best work came in Big Little Lies where, in a drama full of excellent performances, she so frequently managed to steal every scene she was in and show off her full (and considerable) range of acting chops.

Who Will Win

Advertisement

Laura Dern

This is Dern's sixth Emmy nomination, and despite that she's yet to actually win anything. There's a good chance the voters will look to correct that now, especially when she's delivered such a strong body of work and an excellent performance in this, while Big Little Lies is the buzziest of the shows/movies in contention here. It won Best Casting at the Creative Arts Emmys, so it's a popular choice too. There is the outside chance Dern and Woodley split the BLL vote though, in which case Regina King could make it three-in-a-row.

Advertisement

17. Supporting Actor In A Limited Series Or Movie

FX

Nominees

Advertisement

Bill Camp - The Night Of

Alfred Molina - Feud: Bette and Joan

Advertisement

Alexander Skarsgård - Big Little Lies

David Thewlis - Fargo

Advertisement

Stanley Tucci - Feud: Bette and Joan

Michael K. Williams - The Night Of

Advertisement

Who Should Win

David Thewlis

Advertisement

The strongest part of Fargo's third season isn't actually nominated (see: Mary Elizabeth Winstead), but Thewlis was still pretty great himself as the latest iteration's antagonist. Looking creepy as heck, Thewlis' performance was more than just a disconcerting smile, affecting his whole performance with an odd, sinister nature that shone even when the rest of the season didn't.

Who Will Win

Advertisement

Alexander Skarsgård

It's a bit of an open field, this, but the former True Blood star should just about shade it. As mentioned, Big Little Lies is a buzzy series and its cast are set to reap the benefits of that. Skarsgård's role is a difficult one as he plays such a monster, which might turn some voters off, but he does it so well - and in a way that really stands out - that the statue will probably head his way anyway.

Advertisement

16. Lead Actress In A Limited Series Or Movie

FX

Nominees

Advertisement

Carrie Coon - Fargo

Felicity Huffman American Crime

Advertisement

Nicole Kidman - Big Little Lies

Jessica Lange - Feud

Advertisement

Susan Sarandon - Feud

Reese Witherspoon - Big Little Lies

Advertisement

Who Should Win

Carrie Coon

Advertisement

There's a fair argument to be made for pretty much any of these contenders, but I'd say Coon's performance in Fargo just about edges it (and not just because it'd make up for the lack of nomination for The Leftovers, where she truly deserves it). Her Gloria Bugle was an absolute standout of Fargo's third season, with her being one of the crutches the series increasingly leant on as it moved forward (the other being the aforementioned Winstead).

Who Will Win

Advertisement

Nicole Kidman

Although this category is stacked, with four Oscar winners in the mix, it's Kidman who has been getting the most attention (and claimed the win earlier in the year at the Gold Derby awards). Kidman gives a powerful performance in Big Little Lies, and a showier one than castmate Witherspoon, which combined with the love for the BLL cast as a whole should be enough to see her win.

Advertisement

15. Lead Actor In A Limited Series Or Movie

HBO

Nominees

Advertisement

Riz Ahmed - The Night Of

Benedict Cumberbatch - Sherlock: The Lying Detective

Advertisement

Robert De Niro - The Wizard of Lies

Ewan McGregor - Fargo

Advertisement

Geoffrey Rush - Genius

John Turturro - The Night Of

Advertisement

Who Should Win

Riz Ahmed

Advertisement

The Night Of was never quite as great as its brilliant first episode suggested it would be, but Riz Ahmed was consistently excellent. He starts off incredibly naive, using those saucer-plate eyes to convince us of his innocence. Then, over the next seven episodes, begins a remarkable physical, mental, and emotional transformation, making us think that maybe he really did do it after all.

Who Will Win

Advertisement

Robert De Niro

Another close race, but Robert De Niro is a massive name making a rare TV appearance, something they like to recognise - and it's also an increasingly infrequent chance to heap awards and acclaim on the actor's more recent output, of which this is one of his far stronger efforts. Cumberbatch has been a spoiler before though, while Rush has form in the category too.

Advertisement

14. Outstanding TV Movie

Netflix

Nominees

Advertisement

Black Mirror: San Junipero

Dolly Parton’s Christmas Of Many Colors: Circle Of Love

Advertisement

The Immortal Life Of Henrietta Lacks

Sherlock: The Lying Detective

Advertisement

The Wizard Of Lies

What Should Win

Advertisement

Black Mirror: San Junipero

It shouldn't really be in this category, since it's an episode, but since it is then it's the best choice for a winner. San Junipero was one of the very best episodes - or 'TV Movies' - of 2017, a beautiful futuristic love story that upended all expectations of how a Black Mirror instalment would go.

Advertisement

What Will Win

Black Mirror: San Junipero

Advertisement

Although it aired a while ago now, San Junipero received a huge amount of critical acclaim and a lot of audience attention too, so there's a good chance voters are very familiar with it. With the opportunity to recognise Wizard of Lies in the acting categories, there's more room to then give this one to Black Mirror, although Sherlock did (undeservedly) win here last year so can't be counted out.

13. Outstanding Limited Series

Nat Geo

Nominees

Advertisement

Big Little Lies

Fargo

Advertisement

Feud: Bette and Joan

The Night Of

Advertisement

Genius

What Should Win

Advertisement

Big Little Lies

While Fargo has some excellent individual performances, it's not as cohesive a whole as some of the other contenders here. The same can't be said of Big Little Lies, which blends its prestige talent with a satisfying mystery, strong direction, and entertaining melodrama along with its handling of some tougher subject matter as well.

Advertisement

What Will Win

Big Little Lies

Advertisement

The series is shaping up to be a real winner for HBO this year, and looks set to take the top prize for which it's eligible alongside a number of acting awards. As is so often the cast it's down to HBO vs FX, and more likely BLL vs Feud, and it's the latter that appears to have more love among voters going into the awards, especially as it's the biggest cultural hit of the bunch this year.

12. Outstanding Variety Talk Series

HBO

Nominees

Advertisement

Full Frontal With Samantha Bee

Jimmy Kimmel Live!

Advertisement

Last Week Tonight With John Oliver

The Late Late Show With James Corden

Advertisement

Real Time With Bill Maher

The Late Show with Stephen Colbert

Advertisement

What Should Win

Last Week Tonight With John Oliver / Full Frontal With Samantha Bee

Advertisement

A tough call this, because Oliver, Samantha Bee, and Stephen Colbert have all been doing some brilliant work, while Jimmy Kimmel knocked it out of the park with his very personal healthcare monologue. Any of them would be deserving winners really, but Oliver and Bee have been slightly ahead of the pack in terms of how sharp, well-researched, and simply hilarious they've been week in, week out.

What Will Win

Advertisement

Last Week Tonight With John Oliver

While either Oliver or Bee would be most deserving, and sticking with the same kind of love the Emmys have shown to the John Stewart-era The Daily Show over the years, the voters are often creatures of habit. They gave this award to Oliver last year, and he's been just as good again, so should be getting the nod once more.

Advertisement

11. Outstanding Variety Sketch Series

truTV

Nominees

Advertisement

Billy On The Street

Documentary Now!

Advertisement

Drunk History

Portlandia

Advertisement

Saturday Night Live

Tracey Ullman’s Show

Advertisement

What Should Win

Saturday Night Live

Advertisement

Thanks to the 45th President of the United States, SNL writers were given a wealth of material to work with in their 42nd season. But it's to their credit that they mostly nailed-it, with some pitch perfect political sketches, extremely memorable guest stars, and David S. Pumpkins. Not everything about Season 42 worked, but it nonetheless felt like a really momentous one in the show's history.

What Will Win

Advertisement

Saturday Night Live

The Emmys absolutely love SNL, giving it 50 awards over the course of its lengthy run, and with the show coming off the back of one of its most watched and talked about seasons in years there's no reason to suspect that's going to change.

Advertisement

10. Supporting Actor In A Comedy

NBC

Nominees

Advertisement

Alec Baldwin - Saturday Night Live

Louie Anderson - Baskets

Advertisement

Ty Burrell - Modern Family

Tituss Burgess - Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt

Advertisement

Tony Hale - Veep

Matt Walsh - Veep

Advertisement

Who Should Win

Tituss Burgess

Advertisement

Burgess has been runner-up in this category a couple of times now, and he really deserves his moment in the spotlight (his character on Unbreakable... would certainly agree). He was better than ever in the show's third season, giving a gloriously, hilariously over-the-top performance and stealing scenes all over the place, whether it was Lemonading or being a cannibal.

Who Will Win

Advertisement

Alec Baldwin

As mentioned, Emmy voters love SNL, and Baldwin's Trump has been the face of the show this past year. Even people who don't watch it have seen his performance, and it's been so widely acknowledged that he's going to be the easy choice for everyone with a ballot paper.

Advertisement

9. Supporting Actress In A Comedy

Amazon

Nominees

Advertisement

Kate McKinnon - Saturday Night Live

Vanessa Bayer - Saturday Night Live

Advertisement

Leslie Jones - Saturday Night Live

Anna Chlumsky - Veep

Advertisement

Judith Light - Transparent

Kathryn Hahn - Transparent

Advertisement

Who Should Win

Kate McKinnon

Advertisement

Both Transparent actresses would be worthy winners too, but McKinnon is SNL's real shining light at the moment. Her Hilary Clinton was superb (and a little underappreciated, due to the plaudits and attention heaped on Baldwin), and any chance to see McKinnon put her humour and weirdness on display was more than welcome. Her movie output hasn't hit yet, but she deserves to be a star after this year.

Who Will Win

Advertisement

Kate McKinnon

Like with Baldwin, McKinnon's performance is the one they're really going to remember, as it was the showiest of the bunch, and she won last year so it's another easy vote. The only risk to that is the SNL vote potentially being split three ways, which could open the door for one of the others.

Advertisement

8. Supporting Actress In A Drama Series

HBO

Nominees

Advertisement

Ann Dowd - The Handmaid’s Tale

Samira Wiley - The Handmaid’s Tale

Advertisement

Uzo Aduba - Orange Is the New Black

Millie Bobby Brown - Stranger Things

Advertisement

Chrissy Metz - This Is Us

Thandie Newton - Westworld

Advertisement

Who Should Win

Millie Bobby Brown

Advertisement

Brown earned a lot of acclaim for her breakout performance, and justifiably so. Eleven was a total badass thanks to Brown, but so much more besides, as she in equal turns imbued her performance with childlike wonder and glee, but also a real sense of vulnerability and pain. Put all those alongside how powerful you believed she was, and her sheer presence, and it's a great performance for any age, let alone an adolescent.

Who Will Win

Advertisement

Thandie Newton (Or Chrissy Metz)

Westworld performed well in the technical categories at the Creative Arts Emmys, which indicates some love among voters, and Newton's performance was an extremely popular one. Standing an equally strong chance, though, is Chrissy Metz. This Is Us is the biggest network drama contender in years, and it's likely to get a lot of love.

Advertisement

7. Supporting Actor In A Drama Series

Netflix

Nominees

Advertisement

John Lithgow - The Crown

Jonathan Banks - Better Call Saul

Advertisement

Mandy Patinkin - Homeland

Michael Kelly - House of Cards

Advertisement

David Harbour - Stranger Things

Ron Cephas Jones - This Is Us

Advertisement

Jeffrey Wright - Westworld

Who Should Win

Advertisement

David Harbour (But really, Michael McKean)

If they'd nominated the real deserving actor in Better Call Saul's third season then this would be a different story, because McKean was head and shoulders above the competition, but without his presence it's a much closer bunch. They're all good, but Harbour's performance anchored Stranger Things and brought it a lot of humanity and emotional resonance.

Advertisement

Who Will Win

John Lithgow

Advertisement

Ron Cephas Jones has a great chance here, playing a very emotional role on (the very emotional) This Is Us. But Lithgow has been a winner already this year and has far more hype behind him, and he's a big Emmys favourite, so they'll likely relish the opportunity to recognise him for the first time since 2010 (Dexter).

6. Lead Actress In A Comedy

HBO

Nominees

Advertisement

Pamela Adlon - Better Things

Tracee Ellis-Ross - Black-ish

Advertisement

Jane Fonda - Grace and Frankie

Lily Tomlin - Grace and Frankie

Advertisement

Allison Janney - Mom

Ellie Kemper - Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt

Advertisement

Julia Louis-Dreyfus - Veep

Who Should Win

Advertisement

Ellie Kemper

Kemper feels like she's constantly overlooked for Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt, both in her own show (Burgess gives the flashier performance) and in this category, and her role deserves something. She's the sugary sweet centre of the show, and it wouldn't work without her. She's infectious to watch, sells every ounce of the oddball nature and tragedy of the character, and hits every required emotional beat too.

Advertisement

Who Will Win

Julia Louis-Dreyfus. Obviously. (Though if the voters do finally decide they want to mix it up, Ellis-Ross - who won the Golden Globe - is a good shout).

Advertisement

5. Lead Actor In A Comedy

FX

Nominees

Advertisement

Anthony Anderson - Black-ish

Aziz Ansari - Master of None

Advertisement

Zach Galifianakis - Baskets

Donald Glover - Atlanta

Advertisement

William H. Macy - Shameless

Jeffrey Tambor - Transparent

Advertisement

Who Should Win

Donald Glover

Advertisement

It's a crowded field, but Glover is ridiculously good in every department he handles for Atlanta, and that certainly extends to starring in it. His slightly offbeat brand of humour fits brilliantly, but more than that is the sense you're really getting to know Earn, who feels more like a real person than he does a character. That's partly down to the writing (which also comes from Glover), but it's also thanks to his performance, and Glover makes you root for him and expertly shows what it's like to be a black man in America right now.

Who Will Win

Advertisement

Donald Glover

Atlanta probably won't win the top prize, but it's such a well-received series that they'll want to give it some recognition on the night, and this is a great chance of doing that (and, y'know, he's earned it).

Advertisement

4. Lead Actor In A Drama Series

NBC

Nominees

Advertisement

Sterling K. Brown - This Is Us

Anthony Hopkins - Westworld

Advertisement

Bob Odenkirk - Better Call Saul

Matthew Rhys - The Americans

Advertisement

Liev Schreiber - Ray Donovan

Kevin Spacey - House of Cards

Advertisement

Milo Ventimiglia - This Is Us

Who Should Win

Advertisement

Bob Odenkirk

This marks Odenkirk's third consecutive nomination, and it feels like it should be his time. Better Call Saul has gradually turned into one of the very best dramas on TV, and Odenkirk is its heart. We knew from Breaking Bad he could do funny with this character, but what's more surprising is how he conveys the tragic helplessness of Jimmy McGill, delivering a fall on a much smaller, but also far more devastating, scale than that of Walter White.

Advertisement

Who Will Win

Sterling K. Brown

Advertisement

Brown won an Emmy last year for The People vs O.J. Simpson, so he's someone the voters definitely know and like, and he just so happens to give a stirring performance in the year's biggest network show. There is a risk of vote splitting, with Ventimiglia also in the running, which could benefit Odenkirk, but the material Brown's working with and his recent love suggests this is his.

3. Lead Actress In A Drama Series

Hulu

Nominees

Advertisement

Viola Davis - How to Get Away with Murder

Claire Foy - The Crown

Advertisement

Elisabeth Moss - The Handmaid’s Tale

Keri Russell - The Americans

Advertisement

Evan Rachel Wood - Westworld

Robin Wright - House of Cards

Advertisement

Who Should Win

Elisabeth Moss

Advertisement

The Handmaid's Tale is well acted across the board, but Elisabeth Moss gives an absolutely stunning performance that stands as one of the year's best (and, as far as this category goes, the best). It's simultaneously powerful and restrained, leading to a shattering portrayal of Offred, and one done largely through Moss' facial expressions, which are able to convey every thought and emotion to both devastating and triumphant ends.

Who Will Win

Advertisement

Elisabeth Moss

She may have been constantly overlooked for Mad Men, but this should make up for it. Moss gives a performance that's been incredibly well-received in a series that's already garnered plenty of Emmy love, and Alexis Bledel taking home the Guest Actress award is a good sign. Still, this is an extremely strong group, with Foy perhaps the best poised to threaten Moss' chances of being crowned.

Advertisement

2. Outstanding Comedy Series

Netflix

Nominees

Advertisement

Atlanta

Black-ish

Advertisement

Master of None

Modern Family

Advertisement

Silicon Valley

Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt

Advertisement

Veep

What Should Win

Advertisement

Atlanta

Most of these are great (Modern Family stands out as the one getting a lazy nomination), and Master Of None's second season is quite deserving, but Atlanta's debut was something really special. It was funny, surreal, and imbued with a dreamlike feel; the performances were all stellar; the writing razor sharp, offering a close study of its characters, city, and black lives in general, along with examining gender and class issues. It took a lot of risks, and they all paid off.

Advertisement

What Will Win

Veep

Advertisement

Veep has won the category two years in a row, and that's the kind of streak that often leads to more wins at the Emmys (see: Modern Family winning five years straight). With a fairly consistent quality and its biggest challengers being the newcomers, Veep looks well set to make it a threepeat.

1. Outstanding Drama Series

Netflix

Nominees

Advertisement

Better Call Saul

The Crown

Advertisement

The Handmaid’s Tale

House of Cards

Advertisement

Stranger Things

This Is Us

Advertisement

Westworld

What Should Win

Advertisement

Better Call Saul

Overlooked the last two years, this should be Better Call Saul's time ((but then, Breaking Bad didn't win this award until Season 5). It's the best of those eligible, an incredible slow-burn drama that takes a world we know and love and turns it into something very different, but almost equally brilliant. The performances are all stunning, the direction and cinematography some of the most inventive and beautiful on TV, and the writing gradually crafting TV's best tragedy without losing a sense of humour.

Advertisement

What Will Win

This Is Us / The Handmaid's Tale

Advertisement

The Handmaid's Tale is one of the buzziest new series of the year, and along with that has rave reviews, a great lead performance, and it's incredibly relevant in 2017. That gives it a strong chance of winning in this admittedly stacked field (and the odds obviously favour a newcomer), though This Is Us might have an even better one. It seems well-poised to get a lot of love, it's massively hyped, pulls at the heartstrings, and most of all is a real chance to award this prize to one of the 'big 4' networks, which hasn't happened since 24 back in 2006.

Who do you think will win at the Emmys? Who should? Share your thoughts down in the comments.

Advertisement