Every Arrowverse Crossover Ranked From Worst To Best
They've fought aliens, shadow demons and even each other, but which crossover stands tall?
It's hard to believe that there was once a time when the Arrowverse simply consisted of one show, but that was the way things were between 2012 and 2014, as Arrow flew the flag for superhero television. But with its success, spin-offs soon followed and before we knew it, the Emerald Archer had spawned a universe full of shows that were headlined by other iconic DC heroes.
The CW's Arrowverse crossover has become an annual tradition now, as the originator yearly crosses paths with some of his peers in a bid to take down the biggest baddies they've ever faced. Once little more than a fun team-up with The Flash, it has evolved into main event-level television featuring almost all of the Arrowverse's characters, with heroes from Supergirl, DC's Legends of Tomorrow and now Batwoman joining the original duo.
With the long-awaited Crisis On Infinite Earths spanning across five TV episodes, it's safe to say the-powers-that-be at The CW saved the biggest crossover for last - well, last for Arrow at least - but was it the best? With that in mind, let's take a look back at all the super-powered team-ups and, while we're at it, rank them.
Note: While characters from multiple shows have crossed over countless times through cameos and references, this list will be looking at every official crossover episode in the Arrowverse.
8. Heroes Join Forces
The second-annual Arrowverse crossover only consisted of its two flagship shows (Arrow and The Flash), but it may as well have been a backdoor pilot for soon-to-arrive spin-off DC's Legends of Tomorrow as it introduced heroes Hawkman and Hawkgirl, villain Vandal Savage and a large portion of the first season's plot.
It once again felt like cutting-edge television seeing both Teams Arrow and Flash unite to take on an unstoppable threat and this one was pivotal in changing the crossover format so that both episodes covered the same adventure - as opposed to two standalone offerings like the first. It also contained some great character work, particularly in regards to Barry and Oliver's relationship, and even introduced the latter's son William into the fray.
In spite of this, and that truly jaw-dropping sequence in which The Flash runs back in time, this crossover struggled to match the heights of the others. It didn't have that notoriously light-hearted sheen that we'd come to expect from superhero team-ups, as it was bogged down with a lot of plot threads that took themselves far too seriously. Moreover, important characters like Laurel Lance, Thea Queen and Iris West were given very little to do while the contrived Oliver and Felicity conflict was nothing short of mind-numbing - a particular reminder of why Arrow's fourth season was, by far, its worst.
7. Elseworlds
We didn't know at the time that Elseworlds would essentially serve as a backdoor pilot for Crisis On Infinite Earths, but in a way that's exactly what it was, introducing us to The Monitor while dropping the breadcrumbs of battles yet to come. That said, it was certainly its own unique (emphasis on unique) entity too.
With the Book of Destiny having swapped Oliver Queen and Barry Allen's lives, they turned to Kara for help because Earth-38 wasn't affected by the rewritten reality. A wise decision no doubt, because they ended up taking on John Deegan's reality-writing book with the support of the Girl of Steel, Superman and, for a moment, new arrival Batwoman.
Elseworlds unexpectedly thrived on its humour, gifting us with plenty of great light-hearted moments as Oliver and Barry attempted to convince their loved ones of their true identities. That didn't, however, prevent it from telling an edge-of-seat tale that was capable of taking its plot seriously when it needed to and it ultimately excelled because of its ability to do so.
As it went on, the stakes increased and that made the final battle, and Oliver's mysterious promise, all the more engaging. The cinematography was particularly impressive too, as Gotham City's introduction was beautifully twisted, while the sight of John Wesley Shipp back in his legendary Flash suit from the '90s TV series was enough to make any DC fan's heart happy.
It would have been nice to see the Legends involved, and it could have done without all of the predictably melodramatic Oliver/Felicity drama, but other than that, Elseworlds was a bizarre, oddly hilarious and goosebump-inducing adventure that absolutely lived up to its name.
6. Duet
Grant Gustin and Melissa Benoist's Glee backgrounds had fans calling for musical episodes of The Flash and Supergirl for nearly two years, and it finally came to fruition in the form of a special crossover episode of the former show's third season.
Not part of the annual Arrowverse crossover, it took place in the spring and tied directly into the Savitar-heavy storyline, as Music Meister utilised a musical dream to make Barry see everything he was doing wrong in his personal life. It might be a little on-the-nose to say that he made a big song and dance of it, but oh he did.
Trapped in a never-ending musical, Barry and Kara (who was also having relationship problems with Mon-El) had to help fictionalized versions of their own love interests live happily ever after in order to realize the importance of love. And, it was honestly as wonderfully ridiculous as it sounds.
From the golden tint of the dream sequence to the fact that both Gustin and Benoist were in their absolute element showcasing the full of extent of their talents, 'Duet' was worth its weight in gold - and, perhaps more importantly, worth the wait in general. And if you weren't clicking your fingers to 'Super Friend' or reaching for the tissues for "Runnin' Home To You", who even are you?
Heart, humour and harmonies - a perfect example of the Arrowverse at its gleeful best.
5. Flash Vs. Arrow
Back when the Arrowverse crossover was a huge novelty, Flash Vs. Arrow was little more than two standalone episodes of The Flash and Arrow that were only vaguely related to each other.
Team Arrow found themselves in need of Team Flash's help analyzing Captain Boomerang's boomerang and their trip to Central City led to a fun little team-up that quickly went sideways when Barry was infected by Rainbow Raider. One battle between heroes later and all was good between the pair - and Team Flash was so grateful, they decided to return to the favour by travelling to Starling City (in the Arrow episode 'The Brave and The Bold') to help the Emerald Archer stop Boomerang.
Essentially two mini crossovers in one - tied by the overarching Boomerang narrative - this one was a highly entertaining offering that reminded us how effective these shows can be when they keep it simple. But it also managed to make both offerings feel extra special because of the magnitude of this whole crossover, and it's worth it alone for the epic fight between Oliver and Barry.
What a way to kick off what would quickly become an annual tradition..
4. World's Finest
When Supergirl made its debut on CBS, it wasn't long before fans started calling for a crossover between it and The Flash. They did so for a number of reasons - yes, Melissa Benoist and Grant Gustin's shared Glee history obviously played a large part in that, but it was also down to the fact that they were convinced the light-hearted tones of both shows would blend together really well. They were right.
Worlds Finest arrived just before the conclusion of Supergirl's debut season and it was huge deal given that it was on CBS at the time and The Flash was on The CW, but the cross-network crossover was nothing short of super.
Utilising the concept of the multiverse that had been introduced in The Flash's second season, the episode saw Barry accidentally travel to Earth-38 and get stranded there in the process. And when he crossed paths with the Girl of Steel, it wasn't long until a super adventure kicked off - as the pair ended up facing off against the villainous duo of LiveWire and Silver Banshee.
A light-hearted, joyous and utterly refreshing superhero smackdown, Worlds Finest was corny in all the right ways, as it highlighted the best of both shows while also using it to further Supergirl's ongoing narrative. It never took itself too seriously and yet still inspired a hopeful message - all while kicking off one of the most important relationships in the Arrowverse.
You really couldn't want any more from superheroes. This was glorious.
3. Invasion!
The biggest Arrowverse crossover of them all at the time, Invasion! marked the first ever time that Arrow and The Flash crossed over with DC's Legends of Tomorrow and Supergirl on this scale. Naturally, there was only one threat big enough to make it all happen: Aliens.
Based on the legendary DC limited series from the late '80s, it focused heavily on the arrival of The Dominators and their apparent plans for humanity while also attempting to juggle the titular heroes from four different shows - an example of just how much the Arrowverse had grown in a few years. However, it also managed to mix in the fallout of The Flash's Flashpoint arc incredibly well while shifting gears in order to use its plot to give Arrow the 100th episode it deserved.
Though there were some issues - the time-travel jargon in the final installment was a little confusing, Cisco's behaviour was exhausting at this point and it was a little annoying that Supergirl never got her own episode - but none of them could take away from the truly larger-than-life feel that Invasion! possessed. Not only was it an experience that would have been every bit at home on the big screen, it exceeded expectations by ensuring that the first time Supergirl met all of her Arrowverse counterparts was a unforgettable one.
To this day, it remains perhaps the most underrated crossover of them all, but it was an example of how bigger can indeed be better. And, for the record, the Arrow installment is one of the best episodes the show ever produced.
2. Crisis On Earth-X
The fourth annual crossover saw the gang of heroes unite on a more positive occasion, as they all showed up for the wedding of the Arrowverse's primary couple Barry Allen and Iris West. Unfortunately, that occasion also sparked a visit from a ton of Nazi doppelgangers from the near-dead Earth-X.
With the largest cast of heroes to grace the Arrowverse yet, Crisis On Earth-X did a swell job juggling its countless characters as the writers ensured that all of the major storylines had the stakes that they needed, while also crafting villains that were far from one-note. From the unexpected pairing of Earth-X Oliver and Kara to the return of the vile Reverse-Flash, the villainy was undoubtedly delicious, but it was also multi-faceted - and that made it compelling.
Moreover, there was a seriousness to this one that made it all the more poignant. Sure, some of our favourite faces return and there are plenty of Easter Eggs in there, but the overarching feeling of dread that came with Earth-X and its barbaric outlook felt incredibly authentic - something that was heightened by a fan-favourite's shocking death - and it was that grit, that maturity, that played a big part in making this one feel even more cinematic than its predecessor.
There were some major drawbacks - like Felicity's insensitive hijacking of Barry and Iris' wedding - but overall, Crisis On Earth-X saw the-powers-that-be successfully raise the stakes once again to produce a gripping tale full of power and emotion. And, all said and done, that final battle is one of the best in Arrowverse history.
1. Crisis On Infinite Earths
The endgame of the Arrowverse, Crisis On Infinite Earths was originally envisioned as a point in time in which The Flash would end up vanishing, changing the Arrowverse forever. From there, it grew into something else entirely until it finally became the basis for the most ambitious crossover in TV history.
The Arrowverse has done bigger and better many times in the past, but nothing that came before (or probably after) reached the magnitude of this one. Based on one of the most iconic comic book stories ever told, the five-part crossover saw Arrow, The Flash, Supergirl, Legends of Tomorrow and Batwoman intersect as the heroes of each show attempted to save the multiverse from extinction. And being the heavily-anticipated spectacle that it was, there was an abundance of cameos and references to some of the most famous DC films and TV shows of all time.
In spite of its occasional flaws (and certain character absences), Crisis On Infinite Earths was a cinematic-level smackdown that will undoubtedly go down in history as one of the greatest TV events of all time - changing the face of the Arrowverse with five episodes that left viewers in awe of some of the feats they pulled off.
For a shared universe that tends to struggle with stakes, Crisis had plenty of them and it ultimately succeeded in its attempts to ensure that nothing would ever be the same. This was, by and large, a piece of art.
-
Which Arrowverse crossover was your favourite? Tell us in the comment section below.