Every Death In The Simpsons Ranked
12. Health Inspector Frankie (Mommie Beerest)
Have you ever wondered how Moe's famously "dank" tavern stayed open for years whilst clearly violating every health and safety law in the book? The answer is Frankie; a health inspector who just so happens to be Moe's childhood friend. Frankie continuously overlooked the many shortcomings of Moe's Tavern and gave his bar-tending buddy a free pass no matter how bad things were.
Years of bending the rules finally caught up to Frankie in the Season 16 episode "Mommie Beerest" when takes a fatal bite out of one of Moe's pickled eggs and dies instantly. This is obviously bad news for Frankie, but also for Moe who fails the subsequent (and far more legitimate) health inspection. This was probably due to the fact that Frankie's corpse was still in the bar when the new inspector arrived.
Not only does Frankie's death facilitate the storyline of this episode, his character also adds a nice wrinkle to Moe's backstory. His death isn't impactful as we barely know the character, but his relationship with Moe and his place in the history of one of Springfield's most iconic locations gives his death the edge over other similarly comedic demises.
11. Cornelius Chapman (The Mansion Family)
In perhaps the show's greatest comedy death, Cornelius Chapman enjoyed the accolade of being "Springfield's Oldest Man"... for about ten seconds.
In Season 11's "The Mansion Family", the town gathers for the annual "Springfield Pride Awards" (there was a lot of buzz around Lenny) and one of the statues goes to the 108-year-old Cornelius Chapman. In his time in the town, Chapman built the first log cabin in Springfield, introduced the toothbrush to the community, and once took a bullet for former senator, Huey Long.
He might have survived being shot, but Chapman finally fell to a kiss on the cheek from awards co-host Britney Spears. The "Kiss of Death" was enough to finish the old man off for good, ending his reign with the trophy shortly after it began.
Everything about this death is hilarious. From its sudden nature to Kent Brockman kicking Cornelius' corpse out of the way, the whole thing is masterfully done. It also serves a purpose too, as Mr. Burns goes for his check-up upon being named Cornelius' successor. It's safe to say that Cornelius' long life was leading up to this one moment and it was totally worth it.
10. Congressman Horace Wilcox (Mr. Spritz Goes To Washington)
In this episode from Season 14, The Simpson family seek help from their Congressman after a change in flight path directs deafening air traffic right over their house.
They take their case to Horace Wilcox, who has served in the House for seventy years. Upon hearing their plight, Wilcox becomes angry, then feels numb, and dies of a heart attack. Wilcox could survive the sinking of the Titanic, but not the Simpsons. That figures.
Wilcox's death triggers an election for his replacement, which is won by Krusty The Clown. Had Horace held on just a little bit longer, then this whole episode would never have happened and The Simpsons may still be hearing plane noises over their house to this day.
Whilst Krusty being a Congressman doesn't carry over into future episodes, it's still a pretty big deal in the world of this episode. Whilst Chapman's death is way funnier (the joke about Homer performing "CCR" instead of "CPR" is good, but not great), Wilcox's demise would have had much larger ramifications in the fictional world of The Simpsons, which is why the good Congressman scores a place in our top ten.
9. Alice Glick (Replaceable You)
The video above clearly shows Mrs. Alice Glick's death being reported by Kent Brockman. However, some eagle-eyed viewers have noticed someone who looks very much like Mrs. Glick cropping up in episodes after "Replaceable You". For the sake of our sanity, let's assume that she did perish in Season 23.
Her death came over 20 years after her first appearance in Season 2's "Three Men and a Comic Book". Not only did Mrs. Glick scrimp on Bart's chore payments, but she would appear in later episodes selling candy dishes ("Ninety Dollars!"), mistaking Lisa for a pineapple, and hanging out at the Retirement Castle.
It is at said Castle where Mrs. Glick meets her grizzly end when she and the other residents are given robotic seals by Bart and Martin in an effort to cheer them up. However, the seals are hacked by a group of local businesses who thrive on miserable elderly customers and get so aggressive that one of them ends up killing poor Mrs. Glick.
It's a gruesome death - perhaps overly so - but it was certainly shocking, especially because it happened to a character we had known for so long. Or did it... it did.
8. Fat Tony (Donnie Fatso)
In perhaps the most frustrating death on this list, Season 22's "Donnie Fatso" was a real opportunity for The Simpsons to change things up.
This episode revolves around Homer going undercover in Fat Tony's gang, eventually gaining his trust and friendship until his lies are uncovered when the FBI attempt to arrest the mob boss. Distraught by his new friend's betrayal, Fat Tony suffers a heart attack and dies in a conflicted Homer's arms.
Fat Tony had been a part of the show for almost 20 years at this point and had provided fans with a bounty of iconic lines and moments. As devastating as his death was, it was also exciting as a show famous for its status quo was changing it in a big way. At least, they did for about fifteen minutes...
By episode's end, Fat Tony's cousin "Fit Tony" is running the mob and the stress of the job causes him to put on weight, rendering him identical to his deceased cousin. He also assumes the moniker of "Fat Tony", basically making this whole episode pointless. Still, the original death was so surprising that it earns its place this high up the list.
7. Green Day (The Simpsons Movie)
In Simpsons cannon, multi-Grammy award winning rock band Green Day are dead. They got sucked into Lake Springfield and died by drowning or pollution-based poisoning or both. That is insane.
Billy Joe Armstrong, Mike Dirnt, and Tré Cool were playing their punked-out version of The Simpsons theme during the opening sequence of 2007's The Simpsons Movie whilst floating on a barge in the middle the town's lake. After finishing their song, the band attempt to talk to the crowd about the environment, which is about a good idea as trying to persuade hungry wolf not to eat your leg.
The townsfolk pelting their barge with garbage and rocks (including one shot from Moe that hit Tré Cool right in the St. Jimmys) until the polluted lake dissolved their platform and the trio plummeted into the water below. Their deaths were later confirmed when a funeral service for the group was held in Springfield church... I guess their friends and families weren't that interested in the ceremony.
For the magnitude of the people involved, its role in the plot of the film, and its sheer bizarreness, Green Day's death in The Simpsons Movie is as legendary as any of their songs.
6. Rabbi Hyman Krustofsky (Clown In The Dumps)
In the build up to the show's twenty-sixth season, showrunner Al Jean revealed that a character would die in its premiere episode, "Clown In The Dumps". Now it doesn't take a genius to realise which Simpsons character was in danger with a title like that... Moe... oh wait, Krusty! I meant Krusty!
The thought of a major character death excited many in the Simpsons fandom as it presented a chance for the show to seriously shake itself up in a way it had failed to do with Fat Tony four years earlier. However, whilst fans correctly guessed the bloodline of the character being killed, they were out by one generation.
It was Krusty's father, Rabbi Hyman Krustofsky, who got the chop, dying mid-sentence when Krusty asked him if he was funny. The death was extremely sudden and didn't really play much into the episode's plot, but fans were very fond of the Rabbi since his introduction in Season 3 and to see him die was still a sad moment.
His death was made even more pertinent when comedian Jackie Mason - who provided the voice for Rabbi Krustofsky - passed away for real in 2021 at the age of 93.
5. Beatrice Simmons (Old Money)
The oldest death on this list, Beatrice "Bea" Simmons' passing in Season 2's "Old Money" still holds up as one of the most heart-breakingly beautiful story beats The Simpsons has ever presented.
Grampa Simpson's lonely days are seemingly over when he falls in love with Bea, a new resident at the Retirement Castle. The two are due to spend an evening together when Homer and his family forcibly take Grampa on safari, believing that the senile old man has imagined his new girlfriend. Tragically, Grampa returns to the home to find that Bea has passed away, robbing him of his last chance to see her.
Not only is it sad that Grampa lost Bea, but her passing also forces him to confront his own mortality and realise that he might have just missed his final opportunity at love. Bea's death also has consequences later on in the episode when Grampa inherits a large sum of money from her and refuses to spend any on Homer - the man he believes to be responsible for this tragedy.
A simple story told brilliantly, the tale of Abraham Simpson and Beatrice Simmons is as potent today as it was in 1991.
4. Mona Simpson (Moan Leaves-a)
Homer's mother, Mona Simpson, was first introduced to audiences in Season 7 and appeared just once more before her final living appearance in Season 19's "Mona Leaves-a". The outlaw arrives in Springfield to once again try and reconcile with her estranged son after faking her death to escape the police. However, Homer has been hurt one too many times and refuses his mother's apology.
After thinking about it, Homer decides that he was too harsh on Mona and attempts his own apology in the form of a card. When he goes to give it to her though, he finds her slumped in her chair having passed away from old age, or perhaps a broken heart.
Mona's death is an emotional gut punch for Homer and the audience alike. It serves as a brutal reminder that the ones we love will not be around forever and that sometimes we don't always get the chance to say a perfect goodbye. The fact that Mona was used so sparingly by the writers - just three times in just over a decade - made her appearances even more impactful and this one especially so.
Go hug your moms, they deserve it.
3. Maude Flanders (Alone Again, Natura-Diddily)
In terms of impact on the show, there is no bigger Simpsons death than Maude Flanders' in Season 11. An established character since the show's second season, Maude was an extremely familiar face to Simpsons viewers as the equally God-loving wife of the Simpsons' left-handed neighbour.
Her death not only marked the show's biggest status quo change to date (and maybe ever) but it severely impacted one of its biggest characters outside of the main family. It was a huge deal, so why is it not number one?
Firstly, part of the decision was made because of a pay dispute between Fox and actress Maggie Roswell, which is hardly the greatest reason to kill off a character. And secondly, her death is treated with so little care they may as well have flushed her down the toilet.
Not only is she killed in an embarrassing way - getting hit by a t-shirt canon is hardly Shakespearean - but Homer, the man responsible for Maude's untimely demise, goes right back to being a goofball after costing a woman her life.
If this episode wasn't so uncomfortable to watch, this death would absolutely take the top spot. But, as it is, Maude will have to settle for third.