Every HBO Comedy Ranked From Worst To Best

32. Run

The high octane comedy thriller is a much maligned genre. At its worst it can be an excuse for the lazy dregs of both formats, but at its best it can be a vehicle for great characters, a propulsive plot, and some laughs to sweeten the deal.

Advertisement

Run wouldn’t necessarily be an example of the comedy thriller at its very best, but this engaging series starring Merritt Wever and Domhnall Gleeson was a surprising treat that could potentially have had life beyond its single season order. The premise is immediately engaging: Ruby and Billy, college sweethearts, made a pact that, if they ever both texted the word “run” to one another, they’d drop everything in their lives and hit the road.

Obviously that’s our inciting incident, and the show works hard to maintain that initial bolt of energy while subverting what we’d expect from our characters from there on out. For the most part, it really works. This is in no small part down to the quality of the leads, who are given flawed and interesting characters to work with.

It perhaps suffers from a few thrilling twists too many, but Run is interesting, distinctive, and engaging throughout.

31. Betty

While HBO’s raison d’etre, simplistically, is to make the kind of programming that couldn’t be seen on the more cautious networks, one of their best comedy efforts of the past few years is this gentle, heartwarming series about female friendship in the New York skateboarding community.

Advertisement

Based on Crystal Moselle's 2018 film Skate Kitchen, the 2020 series assembles much of the same cast, whose freewheeling, easy chemistry is key to the show’s success. It’s a coming of age story as well as a search for acceptance, as this ragtag group of girls from all different backgrounds attempts to penetrate the male dominated world of skateboarding.

Naturalism is key to Betty’s success - the whole show is shot on the streets of New York, and the decision to choose skateboarders to act rather than attempting to teach actors to skate pays dividends. The stakes can be low or high, but even when the episodes deal with something simple as crushes or fear of the future, it’s dealt with honestly and in a manner anyone can relate to.

30. Crashing

The “stand up comedian plays himself in a loosely autobiographical series” genre of TV is a long established one with mixed results, but few have done so with such bold vulnerability as Pete Holmes in Crashing. The good natured, lanky comic has made a career of spilling his guts on stage and on his successful podcast, but his mostly successful series is his highest profile work to date.

Advertisement

Holmes fills the show with his real backstory: growing up devoutly Christian, he married young then had to rebuild his life after his wife had an affair. The show simultaneously depicts the devastation of serious heartbreak and the exciting notion of starting over as a rising comedian in L.A.

Holmes gambles on the notion that we’re interested in the inner workings of the comedy scene, and while he’s a little reliant on chucking in familiar faces (Bill Burr, Sarah Silverman) as guest stars, he pulls it together in his likeable lead role. The genuine sweetness of Crashing sets it apart from the trend of spikier sitcoms - it’s a show about the healing power of laughter, rather than its ability to be used as a weapon.

29. Los Espookys

One of the most distinct shows on HBO’s current comedy roster, Los Espookys was co-created by Saturday Night Live alum Fred Armisen. If you’re familiar with his work in front of and behind the camera, you’ll know he’s a fan of wonderfully observed genre spoofs, and all round kookiness.

Advertisement

Los Espookys follows a group of friends who, under the eponymous banner, attempt to break into the horror filmmaking market. The remaining cast are made up of Armisen’s co-creators, a collection of mostly unknown performers from across North and Latin America. The show is primarily in Spanish, set in a dream-like mystery land that allows the show to genre hop from fantasy to horror to comedy.

It’s a gentle and warm watch; it’s not always laugh out loud funny, but the surrealism and invention on show here is beyond what most modern comedies would dare to dream up.

The interplay of the core cast is what keeps you coming back - this is the most heartwarming show you could hope to watch that centres around a bunch of misfits dressing up like ghouls for bizarre purposes.

28. A Black Lady Sketch Show

For fans of literal titles, this is the show for you; for fans of high quality sketch comedy from performers often underrepresented in the industry, A Black Lady Sketch Show is also a safe bet. Devised by Robin Thede and written by an evolving cast of great talent, this is one of the finest sketch comedies on TV today, providing something totally different.

Advertisement

The two seasons released thus far have produced hilarious and surprising skits on all manner of subjects, taking on segregated baseball of the 1930s, Motown, modern life and dating, TV spoofs, and more. It’s a timely show in many ways - alongside racial commentary, the pandemic-delayed second season allowed them to take on COVID before most TV shows had the chance.

The show is stuffed with appearances from pop cultural legends like Angella Bassett and Patti LeBelle, all of whom are more than game.

Like any sketch show, not everything hits the mark, and between the more incendiary material the Ladies hit on some pretty rote stuff, but when the show hits, its unique perspective and quality writing tips it over the edge.

27. Lucky Louie

The sketchy personal life of star and creator Louis CK can make this (and superior FX series Louie) a difficult watch, but taken on its own merits, Lucky Louie was an experimental, often riotously funny sitcom that pushed boundaries and helped introduce the world to a man who was briefly the king of comedy.

Advertisement

Its beauty is its simplicity: Lucky Louie is a traditional sitcom, filmed in front of a live studio audience, but on HBO. The show examines marital strife as Everybody Loves Raymond might, but instead of mild disagreement, here we had plotlines about Louie calling his wife the C word.

The intention was never to mock beloved sitcoms, but to celebrate the format and formula. Louie had a sitcom wife (the great Pamela Aldon) and dumb best buddies from which great comedy was mined, and CK in the lead role is as likeable a bumbling sitcom husband as you could ask for.

The show gleefully pushed buttons, and complaints combined with low viewing figures made it an easy one to cancel. One season was probably plenty, but it doesn’t skimp on the laughs.

26. Camping

Julia Davis is one of the most distinctive voices in British comedy, which is to say that she peddles a style of outrageously grotesque and bleak sitcom writing that no other creative would dare to try. Camping may not be as downright depressing as her breakthrough hit Nighty Night, but as a six episode descent into madness, it doesn’t get much stranger, nor much funnier.

Advertisement

As the title suggests, this is a show set in the gentile world of tents and cookouts. A group of old friends gather in the countryside to celebrate Robin’s (Steve Pemberton, hilariously pathetic) 50th birthday. But the ostensibly happy and serene scene quickly turns ugly as old wounds are opened, scores are settled, and the whole scene whirls out of control.

Davis’ hallmarks are present and correct - there are spiteful, downright horrible characters, body humour, unrelenting cringe comedy. It’s not for everyone, but if you like your laughs with a side of unremitting darkness, Camping is a winner.

25. Vice Principals

The least accomplished of Danny McBride’s HBO triumvirate, Vice Principals is nonetheless a scream. It’s a double header, with McBride and Walton Goggins as the titular school personnel competing to get bumped up to the big job.

Advertisement

Before long, the two conspire against a common enemy (the new principal played by Kimberly Hébert Gregory) and from there things become truly chaotic. True to form for McBride, everything is played to the max - what should be a petty squabble over a promotion turns into all-out war, complete with arson, gun fire, and attempted murder.

The brash style is complemented by exquisite attention to detail, particularly in the characterisation. Goggins is particularly hilarious as Lee Russell, an effete southern dandy fond of $10 words and foppish mannerisms.

It lacks the honed plot or pathos of McBride’s other work, but for pure comedy, Vice Principals is a high energy treat, two seasons packed full of gags and hijinks, with sublime chemistry between the two leads.

24. Getting On

The British love to complain about US remakes of their content, and the success/failure rate is a little iffy, but when it works, it works well. Case in point: Getting On, a reimagining of Jo Brand’s poignant hospital sitcom that gave a great showcase for some comedic actresses for three seasons.

Advertisement

Its success comes from distancing itself significantly from the British original. The former is quiet, wry, and reserved; the US version leans a lot more heavily into the dark humour, though it retains the original version’s ability to take on heavy topics like family strife, deteriorating mental health, and obviously the lingering spectre of death.

The leads, including Laurie Metcalf and Alex Borstein, are all terrific, and walk an impressively thin line between the comedy, which can be broad or refined in turn, and the drama inherent in the show’s hospital setting.

It can be a tough watch, and for some viewers that juxtaposition between knockabout fun and genuine grief can be hard to engage with, but this is a commendable and worthwhile remake.

23. High Maintenance

A web series that was snaffled up by HBO for four seasons, High Maintenance is a smart and charming anthology of sorts based on a fantastic initial idea. The show follows The Guy, a bike riding weed dealer played by series co-creator Ben Sinclair. He cuts around New York on delivery jobs, with each episode built around the bizarre situation his business brings him to.

Advertisement

It’s a show that celebrates the diversity and innate weirdness of New York City - the guy delivers to agoraphobic weirdos, politically charged rabble rousers, bohemians and tech millionaires. He also drops off the goods for some celebrity clients, with cameos from Lena Dunham, Rebecca Hall, and Hannibal Buress (as themselves) among others mixing things up.

The show is funny, sweet, and often genuinely poignant, with its unlimited set of characters reflecting every aspect of modern humanity. They’re often lonely people seeking a connection, or dealing with regret in their lives, and they seize any opportunity to engage in honest conversation with another person, even if he’s ostensibly just there to drop off their weed.

It’s a simple concept used to maximum effect. It was great in its web series format, but with HBO resources behind it, it’s better still.

Advertisement