Every HBO Comedy Ranked From Worst To Best

12. The Comeback

Give or take a Morning Show, this Lisa Kudrow-led smash is the best post-Friends project any of the stars produced. The show, co-created with Sex And The City producer Michael Patrick King, is the most self aware and self lacerating piece of work to come from the phenomenon, and is as good a vehicle for the versatile and hilarious actress as you could imagine.

Advertisement

Kudrow plays ​​Valerie Cherish, a former sitcom star who has subsequently failed to maintain career relevance. There are major differences between Cherish and the star - the character is a decade or more removed from her career-defining show rather than a couple of years - but Kudrow’s decision making is nonetheless bold.

The curse of Friends is a much-debated matter, as many of the stars have struggled to find much decent work since. Kudrow gets on the front foot and owns the matter, playing Cherish - here hired to chronicle her attempts at a comeback - as bitter and lacking self awareness.

The show disappeared in the ratings in 2005, but somehow came back again even better in 2014. Kudrow’s had one of the best post-Friends careers with parts in a lot of great TV and movies, but this is her crowning achievement.

11. Insecure

Co-created by Larry Wilmore and lead actress Issa Rae, Insecure is a frank, often explicit, sometimes painfully funny show about the modern struggles of two young black women in L.A. A show with a unique perspective and angle, this is a coming of age story with a difference, in turn hopeful, hilarious, angry, and despairing.

Advertisement

Rae co-stars alongside Yvonne Orji as a charity worker and a corporate lawyer respectively. Two best friends at different stages of their careers, they nonetheless lean on each other as they navigate the rocky world of love and dating, as well as the specific difficulties that come from being black women in contemporary America.

Insecure tells many stories specific to this community, tackling racism on the smallest and largest scales, and Rae weaves narratives with this audience in mind, but many of its stories and characters are universal. It has some of the most realistic depictions of sex and relationships ever seen on TV, with some shocking moments thrown in there.

Its fifth season, currently airing, is to be its last - since its 2016 debut, Insecure hasn’t put a foot wrong, and has provided a vital voice and unforgettable characters.

10. The Kids In The Hall

An all time great in the sketch comedy genre, The Kids In The Hall provided some of the best work from the Great White North for five seasons and a whopping 102 episodes between the late ‘80s and mid ’90s.

Advertisement

The troupe comprised Dave Foley (A Bug’s Life), Scott Thompson (Hannibal), Bruce McCulloch, Kevin McDonald, and Mark McKinney. Each member had his own particular strengths - Foley the everyman, Thompson the sensitive soul, McCulloch’s righteous fury, McDonald’s wild card, McKinney’s wry turn.

Together, they were unstoppable. Indebted to Monty Python, this was often deeply surreal, like a sketch which saw 30 women named Helen in a field concurring on some or other matter, or McKinney’s head crusher. They took wild swipes at celebrity - McDonald’s bravura turn as Buddy Holly in his final moments - and helped elevate the inherently nerdy practise of sketch comedy into something genuinely cool.

They went their separate ways but have reunited several times over the years, with their dark masterpiece feature Brain Candy a must watch. It’s nearly - but not quite - as good as sketch comedy gets.

9. Enlightened

Mike White (still just about best known for his portrayal of Ned Schneebly in School Of Rock) is one of the best writers of socially aware, subtly provocative comedies working today. In tandem with star Laura Dern, they produced two seasons of Enlightened, a wide ranging and confrontational series that asked big questions and created a unique vibe.

Advertisement

Dern is incredible as Amy Jellicoe, a former executive at a major, and majorly shady, California conglomerate firm. After a nervous breakdown, she returns to work having learned mindfulness and calming techniques, but finds that she’s taken less seriously than ever, and as she uncovers some of her firm’s dodgy dealings, plots her next explosive move.

Enlightened is capable of being very funny, be it via Amy’s hair trigger temper or the sappiness of her colleague Tyler (Mike White, so funny), but it aims far higher than simple laughs. It has plenty to say about mental health as well as the rigours of the working world and the uncaring, often downright malevolent mindsets of corporations.

Its cancellation after two runs was a great shame, but Enlightened managed to say a hell of a lot in just 20 episodes without ever losing momentum. It’s unique, intelligent, and with a perspective all its own.

8. Barry

This show’s premise - hitman moves to Hollywood and dreams of becoming an actor - could come off the back of a sub-Tarantino crime caper DVD. In the hands of creators Alec Berg and Bill Hader, though, this has quietly become one of the must multifaceted shows on TV, part satire, part knockabout comedy, part engrossing crime drama.

Advertisement

Its great strength is Hader, who stars as the titular contract killer. Barry is a lost soul, a former marine brought into the underworld by his handler turned enemy Fuches (the always delightful Stephen Root). Hader has never had a role so textured as this, and he can brilliantly flip Barry’s switch between desperation for a better life and the ability to dispassionately murder dozens of foes.

The rest of the cast is terrific, including Sarah Goldberg as aspiring actress Sally, Henry Winkler as tutor Gene Cousineau, and the show’s finest discovery, Anthony Corrigan as Chechen mafioso Hank. No character is an archetype; they’re all given layers and subtleties.

For every silly moment there’s some incredible action (an entire episode based on a game of cat and mouse with a lethal kung fu master and his similarly aggressive young daughter) and real pathos. The second season ended with a great cliffhanger, and it feels as though there’s plenty of life left in the tale.

7. Veep

While most US adaptations of British comedies are met with trepidation, comedy fans knew they were onto a winner with Veep. Not only was Armando Iannucci dealing directly with the remake of his own The Thick Of It, but the excellent cast and personnel meant we could rest assured this would be quality.

Advertisement

What we didn’t expect was a show that in many respects outstripped its forebearer. It’s not a fair fight as there’s so much more content in Veep, but its seven seasons barely put a foot wrong. Intelligent and articulate but ever-accessible comedy, Veep was some of the most polished and acerbic satirical work in years.

Beyond the fat free scripts was an incredible cast. Julia Louis-Dreyfus, Anna Chlumsky, Reid Scott, and the incomparable Timothy Simmons as overgrown buffoon Jonah are just scratching the surface of the riches on show here. Veep was a spiky and acidic show in the Seinfeld mould, but never hateful or cruel - the characters were at constant verbal war with one another, but seemed to relish the combat.

Seven seasons of quality is no mean feat, and Veep managed to keep up the pace incredibly well. A show that exceeded all expectations.

6. Sex And The City

One of HBO’s very earliest megahits, the profane, hilarious, super relatable series first took to our screens over two decades ago, and despite the odd moment that hasn’t aged too well, it retains its status as one of the most beloved comedies of all time to this day.

Advertisement

Its key strength is its four central characters: romantic Carrie, straight laced Charlotte, careerist Miranda, and wildcard Samantha. In having four protagonists of such differing temperaments, SATC could all but guarantee to have at least one lead that any given viewer could relate to and associate with.

The women of this version of New York live in, admittedly, a fantasy land, where even a high powered lawyer has abundant free time for leisure, but the matters the show tackled were real and accessible even if you didn’t live a life of luxury in the Upper East Side.

A sensation at the time, SATC has been emulated and downright ripped off many times over, but by virtue of its snappy dialogue, perfect cast, and originality, nothing else has come close to equaling it.

5. The White Lotus

Mike White’s latest may be his masterpiece. A timely tale of haves and have-nots, The White Lotus is one of the best new shows of 2021. It’s a dark and bitter tale of privilege run amok, but White’s masterstroke is in spinning a story about such difficult people without ever becoming downright nasty.

Advertisement

Set in the titular Hawaiian resort, we’re introduced in quick succession to the guests soaking up the sun and the staffers tasked with running around after their every last whim. The recognisable cast is full of great performances, but special mention must go to Connie Britton, a frequent White collaborator. She has a magical way of portraying a character who can so innocently say and do the worst things while still being likeable.

Among the class tension is a dark mystery of sorts which unfolds across the season. It’s compelling stuff through the characters and humour alone, but its ability to carry on a great narrative amidst this makes it all the more impressive.

4. Mr Show With Bob And David

One of the most influential programmes HBO has ever produced, Mr Show affected the comedy landscape as much as any show since The Simpsons. Written by and starring Bob Odenkirk and David Cross (among others), Mr Show introduced many alternate comedians to the big time and reimagined what’s possible for a sketch show.

Advertisement

Gone were the catchphrases, repetitive characters, and safe punchlines. Mr Show seldom reused an idea, instead giving each episode a throughline, with skits running into each other, picking up where the previous one left off, and constantly switching formats and styles.

In sketches like “The Audition” and “The Story Of Everest”, they pushed the medium to its limits; the latter sees gangly performer Jay Johnston as a mountaineer fresh from an expedition but unable to recount the tale to his parents as he keeps knocking over shelves full of thimbles.

So many comics got their big break via Bob and David; so many more had their eyes opened by the sheer possibility on display here. Bob and David were given a blank canvas by HBO, and for four years, they painted it with sheer joyous nonsense.

3. Eastbound And Down

Danny McBridge’s masterpiece (co-created with Ben Best and Jody Hill) is best remembered for its brash, bawdy humour and McBride’s signature creation Kenny Powers. The baseball sensation turned laughing stock, he’s a force of nature played with gusto and just the right amount of vulnerability, and is truly a character for the ages.

Advertisement

Beyond that, though, Eastbound’s true strength lies in its structure. With the exception of the slightly shaggy third, each season tells an immaculate self-contained story, all part of the Kenny Powers saga but entirely its own thing. Kenny seeks redemption in season one; runs away from his troubles in two; attempts maturity in three; and finally rises back to the top in four.

The storytelling on show here is hugely underrated. It’s perfect binge TV, not just for the jokes but for the airtight plotting and pacing, an antihero’s journey Joseph Cambell would be in awe of.

It’s also properly laugh out loud funny, with McBride ably supported by Steve Little as sidekick Stevie Janowski, one of the most pathetic and deviant characters in TV history. It ended on a high with one of the all time great finales. Abrasive but genius TV.

Advertisement