Futurama: 12 Plot-Holes That Almost Ruin The Show

Time travel, exploding planets and nonsensical technology... not everything holds up.

By Stacey Henley /

Much debate rages between Futurama fans with too much time on their hands as to whether Nibbler actually appeared in the first episode of Futurama or not. Some argue he was added in later for the DVD releases and re-runs, while others are adamant he was there from the premiere.

Advertisement

If he was, it’s one of the best set ups in television history, with the payoff and explanation coming years later. Despite this - potential - attention to detail though, there are still a fair few Futurama plot holes.

Though some have come into existence via the passage of time - we didn’t actually get suicide booths in 2008, for example - this list is more concerned with internal plot holes. Things which happen in the show which either contradict earlier episodes, go against established events or just straight up don’t make sense.

Futurama was a wonderful show and nothing here can take away from that; it’s just a bit of fun, after all. They might have you scratching your head a little on a rewatch though. Futurama has bags of rewatchability after all, even if it didn’t always make sense.

12. The Wheel

Pretty easy one to start things off.

Advertisement

Part of Futurama's core mythology is that they have evolved beyond the use of the wheel, something which gets specific focus in Mother's Day, where no one beyond Fry even knows what one is.

In Mother's Day, Mom begins a robotic uprising, causing all technology to rebel and leaving the incredibly dependent humans to fend for themselves. Fry then 'invents' the wheel (albeit a rather ineffective oval shaped one) to help cart the Planet Express crew around.

The Professor is even astounded, asking Fry to "'show us this 'the wheel'", confirming that not only are wheels not in use, they're completely unheard of.

However, wheels very plainly do exist within Futurama's world. While yes, cars have been replaced by hover cars, other wheels are extremely common in New New York.

We see office chairs, Bender's friend Fender (the one who gets him hooked on jacking on), and the Professor has several wheeled gadgets. When Bender bends him backwards, he uses a mini unicycle to support his head, and he has a wheel chair, one he specifically refers to as 'the one with the wheels'.

11. Robosexual Marriage

This is a plot hole which spans three distantly spaced episodes, so could be dismissed as understandable. Considering how big a plot point each incident is in their respective episodes though, it's worth noting.

Advertisement

The plot hole concerns Robosexual Marriage, the driving force in the episode Proposition Infinity. Amy and Bender campaign for the right to marry in a Proposition Eight/gay marriage parody, and while the mechanics might be difficult to imagine, that's not where the plot holes lie.

Instead, they're in I Dated A Robot and the original finale, The Devil's Hands Are Idle Playthings.

I Dated A Robot sees Fry dating a Lucy Lui bot in a now quite dated Napster reference. Though the ethical issues with involuntary cloning are mentioned, what gets more focus is how unnatural Fry dating a robot actually is; something not mentioned by most of the crew in Proposition Infinity. Perhaps, like the public perception of gay marriage, the crew are just more open minded in the later episode.

In The Devil's Hands Are Idle Playthings, it's not the perception but the legality which raises issues. The Robot Devil contractually ties Leela into a marriage, something which should be illegal in the state of New York.

Maybe the Robot Devil just breaks the rules?

10. Heads In Jars

Just their whole deal.

Advertisement

We know the technology was invented by celebrity inventor Ron Popeil, the man most famous for the chop-o-matic, electric pasta maker and spray on toupee. But wait, there’s more! He doesn’t seem the prime candidate to invent such a life changing technology, though even side stepping that, there are some issues.

Presumably, the heads in jars are clones of the actual person rather than their actual head, seeing as the likes of George Washington and Abraham Lincoln have heads in jars. There’s also the fact that no one probably wants to have a funeral for their loved one with their head cut off. While this all kinda, sorta tracks, there’s still a few question marks over it.

First off, if this is true, it doesn’t explain how Hermes is kept alive in Bender’s Big Score (more on that later) when his head is sliced off. There’s also some notable gaps in the roster.

Nobody could have expected Futurama to do a Simpsons and predict Trump would be President, but the Presidents we see in jars do seem to be exclusively pre Obama. Then there’s the fact Yancy doesn’t have one, despite his greatness. Doesn’t make much sense.

9. Bender's 40%

There's a running joke with Bender where he declares he's 40% of whatever metal or substance is being discussed, and after two times, the joke clearly no longer makes sense as a third time tips him up to 120%. Is this particularly a big deal? Not really.

Advertisement

Is it worth talking about, if only to revisit all of Bender's great one liners? Absolutely.

Bender claims to be 40% zinc, titanium, dolomite, lead and 30% iron, as well as having a 0.04% nickel impurity, and being 40% empty, though that final one wouldn't quite contradict the others. Added to all this, he claims to be 40% scrap metal, 40% wires and 40% horseshoes, though again none of these would necessarily contradict the first list.

When he's broken up and must be reassembled, he also claims to be 40% back, baby.

The metals all add up to 190% though, with 0.04% of that being the nickel impurity. However, we know the dolomite one is true, because he survives the lava pit, and we know he's iron, because he's magnetic. He's able to pawn himself when titanium prices skyrocket, though that would put him at 110%. Maybe he lied to the pawn guy, or he's just bad at maths.

8. Why Not Just Kill Santa?

A bit of a dark suggestion, perhaps, but Futurama’s version of Santa is actually a killer robot. Though he does occasionally dispense toys - Zoidberg received a pogo stick - he puts people on the naughty list far more often for spurious reasons, and wreaks havoc around the world.

Advertisement

Planet Express has even installed a top of the range security system to keep them safe on Christmas Eve. Wouldn’t it just be so much simpler to just kill him though?

The Earth is shown to have an impressive military, even if it is poorly led by Zapp Brannigan and often defeated by the Omincronians. Futurama’s Earth government is clearly just an extension of the USA’s too, so you wouldn’t think they’d have any qualms in quashing a hostile invader.

Though Santa causes a lot of damage, he’s just one person. His elves don’t even work for him now with such low demand for toys, and even if they did, they’re not much of an army.

The Planet Express ship made it to his Neptune base, so it’s not like he’s in some impossible to reach lair. Surely killing him is the easiest option.

7. Fry Never Really Left Home

Fasten your seatbelts, because there's three time travel related plot holes in a row. They all connect to the first movie, Bender's Big Score, which uses time travel to propel its plot forward.

Advertisement

One of the main elements of the story sees Fry returning home to the year 2000, living there for 12 years until Bender goes back in time to kill him. This turns Fry into Lars, setting up the events which actually kickstarted Bender's Big Score, and fast fossilises Seymour; something which stacks up with Seymour's back story.

What doesn't stack up though is anything else about this back story. Fry went home, which as far as his family are concerned, means he never left. This means all the flashbacks we see of his family missing him can't have happened.

Yancy naming his son after Fry, Fry visiting his mother's dreams, Seymour's loneliness outside the pizza shop... none of it really happened if Fry was there all along.

Time travel does throw up things like this, and to Bender's Big Score's credit, it does balance its internal plot holes fairly well. There is one other thing though that it doesn't explain...

6. Fry's Tattoo

Another time travel plot hole here, this time concerning the actual catalyst for the time travel itself. The time travel is only possible due to the tattoo of Bender on Fry's ass, which contains a timecode hidden in Bender's eye.

Advertisement

There's a minor plot hole that Fry is somehow able to read this code with a mirror while running when the Professor's powerful microscope is needed the first time, but that's not the big one here. Instead, it's where the tattoo comes from at all.

Bender takes it off Lars (really Fry) at the end, but then how did it get on Lars, who was really Fry? And why did nobody ever see it before?

Various strange and overly complicated wormhole theories exist, as does the theory that it was planted there at some point by the cosmic, God like being Bender meets in Godfellas or by the Nibblonians somehow. Both seem rather pie in the sky, though.

Some have tried to explain that taking the tattoo from Lars and putting it on Fry completes the loop, but without an ultimate origin, this doesn't quite wash.

5. Nibbler Disappears From The Universe

This is the third time travel related one, but unlike the previous two it does not contain time travel directly. It does, however, come at the end of Bender's Big Score after Bender's paradoxical time travel adventures.

Advertisement

The universe splits open, tearing a hole in the sky, causing Nibbler to panic. He jumps up into the air and eats himself, snake eats tail style. Leaving the logic of this aside, this just makes no sense. Nibbler reappears in the next movie The Beast With A Billion Backs, with no explanation for where he went.

Obviously, this is just supposed to be a weird sight gag with no explanation needed, but it does raise an interesting questions. Futurama often explores strange areas of sci fi, and even though there was absolutely no chance of them ever doing anything more with it, you can't help but feel if they really wanted to, they could have.

Development of Nibbler has happened in fits and starts, and the movies are no exception. Though a major player in Bender's Big Score until he disappears himself at the end, he appears without incident in Billion Backs, and the whole thing is quickly forgotten.

4. Where Did The Popplers Cash Go?

Moving on from more complex, science fiction questions to something far more rational. In the episode The Problem With Popplers, we see Fry, Bender and Leela discover an unknown delicious food: Popplers.

Advertisement

These turn out to actually be baby Omicronians, eating them raises ethical questions and almost starts a war and yadda yadda yadda. The rights and wrongs of Popplers isn’t where the plot home lies, but in the financials.

Bender and Fry initially sell them for a dollar a dozen, before Fishy Joe’s Joseph Gilman goes into business with them, selling the Popplers at two dollars a dozen. In this deal, Fry & Bender (presumably Leela and the rest of Planet Express once they start harvesting in commercial quantities) get paid their regular dollar a dozen.

Prior to the Omicronion involvement, these are a huge success. They’re basically the Big Mac meets the Whopper with the Colonel’s secret recipe. They sell in astronomical figures, which surely would mean massive profit for Planet Express. Where exactly did that money go?

It might be that the Professor simply wasted it, or with his senility just never signed a contract. Most likely though is that it’s just a cartoon and not worth thinking about.

3. Mars Wasn't Really Destroyed

The Comedy Central seasons of Futurama were more topical than the timeless feel of the original series, and while that wasn't for everyone, it did throw up some interesting plotlines.

Advertisement

One of these was the riff on the 2012 Mayan calendar prediction with the 3012 Martian calendar again predicting that the Earth would be destroyed. There's a whole storyline with Fry jinxing Leela every time she takes his hand and the calendar actually being about Mars rather than Earth, but that's besides the point.

The plot hole here is that the solar flare actually does occur, unlike in 2012. Mars explodes and is shunted out of orbit, coming so close to Earth people can literally jump from the red planet's dusty service into the streets of New New York. Scientific issues aside, the story basically makes sense.

However, a few episodes later, we're back to Mars for Viva Mars Vegas, where we see Amy's family business of casinos. How exactly are these things still going after the planet was exploded and thrown out of orbit? Assuming these sites even survived the blast, the planet would be out of orbit, the buildings would have been crushed by the close proximity to Earth and casinos are unlikely to be thriving.

2. Did The Common Cold Leave New York?

Some of these have gone across various different episodes of the show, and sometimes you might be willing to forgive those sorts of gaps across a long running series. Considering Futurama is already juggling being set 1000 years in the future and the complexities of the sci-fi genre, that goes doubly so.

Advertisement

In Cold Warriors though, there’s a rather large plot hole which never gets explained. Fry gets the common cold, which due to the disease having been wiped out, turns out to be incredibly dangerous to everyone else. Initially the crew are quarantined to the Planet Express building, before Bender breaks it and the disease spreads through Manhattan.

The island is then wrapped in massive shrink wrap then launched into space. Leaving aside how similar the containment is to The Simpsons Movie, there is a glaring flaw in Cold Warriors. Once the disease starts to spread, Linda and Morbo the News Monster are shown to be suffering from it too.

However, despite seeming to report on New New York goings on more than you’d think, it’s been firmly established that the news is filmed in an LA studio. Quite a big oversight.

1. Leela Is 'The Other'

One defence for Futurama’s few plot holes over the years could be that they’re very good at setting up the plots which actually matter, and generally have pretty good continuity. This one though went absolutely nowhere, and feels like a wasted opportunity.

Advertisement

Fry and Nibbler's storyline gets revisited throughout the series, linking together the core mythology and the Nibblonian's battle with the Brainspawn. Because Fry is his own grandfather (surprisingly not really a plot hole), his unique brainwaves make him immune to the Brainspawn attacks, and so he's key to the Nibblonian fight.

This means that whenever Nibbler's main storyline is explored, before we all know he can speak, Fry is usually with him. He vents to Nibbler that he wishes he was with Leela, to which Nibbler mutters 'perhaps she is "The Other"...' and telling Fry he'll help set them up, then wipes Fry's memory.

While Fry and Leela do end up getting together, Nibbler's role seems muted and they don't particularly help the Nibblonian war; at least not as a couple.

Either this was a vague reference to Star Wars, with Yoda's 'there is another' about Leia, or was a plot thread they just snipped off with no explanation.

Advertisement