While it's hard to argue that King Joffrey or Ramsay Snow are anything other than pure evil, most Game of Thrones characters are made up of shades of grey. There is a utilitarian undercurrent to how the characters behave, and even the best characters on the show are capable of the most awful deeds under the right circumstances. Take Ned Stark for example: in Season 1 he was the moral heart of the show, yet we are first introduced to him when he seemingly harshly beheads a Nightswatchman for desertion. In reality, that's a monstrous thing to do, but in the context of the show - where honour rules - it's understandable. Because each character is complex, and not easily defined as good or evil, it is probably more accurate to say any transformation they undergo usually happens in the mind of the viewer. Often when we are introduced to a character we are confident of their motivations, and what sort of person they're supposed to be, only for that to get flipped on its head later in the show. This list considers the characters we thought we had figured out, only for them to surprise us later down the line by transforming into something completely different.
Advertisement
9. The Hound
How He First Appears With a nickname like The Hound, you'd be forgiven for making a snap decision regarding the values and defining characteristics of Sandor Clegane. It doesn't help that his brother is The Mountain either; surely no man related to such a murderous giant could have any redeeming qualities. Listen to The Hound talk and your preconceptions are reconfirmed - this is a man who expresses regret for not raping enough women before he killed them. And yet, bubbling underneath all this is the suspicion of a better person. In Season 1 he saves Ser Loras from his brother, then reveals how he was tortured by his brother as a child - explaining some of his behaviour patterns. What He Becomes It is Arya Stark who brings about the biggest change in The Hound. At first, his reasons appear self-serving; he intends to take her to her mother and earn ransom money for his efforts, but as the two spend more time together, he responds to her single-mindedness. He is grumpy, yet accommodating, and it seems that he actually likes her more than she likes him. And by placing the two together, we see it is Arya who is truly ruthless and vengeful, not Sandor.
8. Samwell Tarly
How He First Appears Given that Sam was at first a lovable, hapless coward, if you stopped watching halfway through Season 1, you're in for a shock the next time you return to the show. He was the archetypical shoddy sidekick: vulnerable, loveable but useless in a fight. Unfailingly dependable and loyal, but with no self confidence. What He Becomes For a start, he's no longer afraid of the harsh realities played out beyond the wall. He still abhors violence but he's no longer reluctant to take a punch to the gut, or even risk his own life, if it means saving one of his friends. Not that he's now some brute who favours brawn over brains, just that he's far more comfortable in his own skin. What brought on this change? Well it probably had something to do with meeting Gilly. No longer is Sam just looking after himself. The additional responsibility of having a woman and a child to look after means he is more willing to take a beating and to stand up for his principles - even if he knows he's fighting a losing battle. At no time was this clearer than at the end of last season, when he stands up to the Night's Watch members who are attacking Gilly. It's impossible to imagine the Sam of previous seasons doing that. He's no longer a wimp, that's for certain.
7. Daenerys
How She First Appears It's hard to believe the position Daenerys found herself in at the start of the show. Essentially chattel, she was sold into marriage to Khal Drogo where it looked like she had a life of misery mapped out for her. She was passive, helpless as she was abused by her brother as well as her new husband. It was difficult to imagine her making the change necessary to escape the life ahead of her. What She Becomes Piece by piece, though, the world seemed to fall apart in her favour. Her resilience and intelligence earned the respect of her husband, who murdered her brother. It seemed she was finally among her people in the Dothraki. The wild and tribal aspects of their society brought the same features out of her character. Before long she was eating a horse's internal organs and bathing in dragon fire. From shrinking violet to total bad-ass in a few short episodes.
6. Olly
How He First Appears No-one could have guessed that this fresh faced young boy would go on to become the show's purest symbol of total evil. It's hard to believe a farm boy who witnesses the death of his entire family at the hands of a wildling horde could be anything but sympathetic... but here we are. We first come across Olly in Season 4, fleeing the wildlings, and eventually making his way to Castle Black. Jon saves him and even makes him steward, only to have this good deed thrown emphatically back in his face. What He Becomes The thing is, Olly gradually changes from being unquestionably loyal to his master, to resenting and ultimately murdering him. His inability to understand forgiveness or the complexity of his hero's position within the Night's Watch results in Jon's untimely demise. What's more, he even kills Ygritte at the Battle of Castle Black. A character who at first inspires pity and sympathy in the viewer, has at this point become a universal hate sponge. Who knows if there's a chance of redemption next season!
5. Shae
How Shee First Appears The big thing about Shae is her commitment to monogamy. As her relationship with Tyrion develops, it is initially surprising and thrilling. For a prostitute and a promiscuous dwarf, that's really something! However, Shae quickly turns into another character who moves from being universally loved by viewers, to one who is universally loathed. What She Becomes In fairness, the pressures that cause her character to change are pretty unique. When Tyrion returns to King's Landing it is impossible that they remain together in public. Therefore she becomes a maid to his betrothed, Sansa - so far, so good. The trouble is, a jealousy beings to develop in her mind that Tyrion really loves Sansa after all. So committed is she to her lover that she fails to comprehend much of what Tyrion does is done to save her life. Ultimately she tries to have him killed and then sleeps with his father for good measure. Amazingly, this is all done out of crazy love. It's one of the most emotional moments of show (and certainly one of the most surprising) when Tyrion is forced to kill her.
4. Sansa Stark
How She First Appears If anyone deserves a break it's Sansa, but go back to the start of the show and audiences had a less sympathetic relationship with this character. Back then, it seemed she had very few redeeming qualities. She was a naive snob who bullied her sister and failed to appreciate her father. She somehow fell for Joffrey (though in her defence, she'd never actually had a conversation with him at this point) and inadvertently had a role to play in the death of the butcher's boy and her own direwolf. What She Becomes Still after several seasons of torture and abuse at the hands of Joffrey, and more recently Ramsay Snow, audiences are far more pro-Sansa than they were before. At the same time, there is a greater change at work here than the audiences' relationship with Sansa; she's got a whole new personality too. Over the years she's expertly negotiated the trickiest of political tightropes and somehow escaped with her life. No one could have imagined her political savvy at the outset of the show. It turns out she's not just a pretty face - though she'd have everyone believe that in order to stay alive.
3. Stannis Baratheon
How He First Appears On our first introduction to Stannis, he is the grumpy, middle-aged man who has suffered the injustice of having his rightful claim to the throne removed from him. He denies the legitimacy of his daughter, courts the witch Melisandre after the failure of his wife to produce a male heir, and essentially acts in order to further his own ambitions. The transformation of Stannis from a character of relentless ambition to total resignation is a stark one. Few characters, even within the world of Game of Thrones, have the opportunity to become as complex and contradictory as this. What He Becomes As Season 5 progresses however, his character is slowly rebuilt. His experiences at the wall, seeing real evidence of Wight Walkers, and an impending apocalypse, strengthen his convictions, but it is the growth of his daughter, and his ultimate acceptance of her which brings about the biggest change in how the audience perceives him. In his final days, he is pulled in an endless number of directions, as the two things which matter most to him - his daughter and his claim to the throne - come into direct conflict. When he comes out of this test, he is a different character altogether. He's filled with remorse, regret and resignation. The pity is, he doesn't get the chance to show it.
2. Theon Greyjoy
How He First Appears An obvious contender has to be Theon Greyjoy, since his character seems to have been transformed three or maybe even four times. Starting out as a bit of a prat who had legitimate grievances about his position after being captured by the Starks, his ultimate betrayal of Robb still appalled audiences. What He Becomes He turned from scorned captive to borderline psychotic killer - it's amazing what being rejected by two families can do to your personality. From that point on Theon's character development gets increasingly weird. Captured by Ramsay Snow and tortured to the point of a total mental breakdown, the Theon that emerges is no longer called Theon at all - he is named Reek instead. So complete is the transformation that he repeatedly betrays Sansa to Ramsay, even though he knows it could result in her death. When Theon finally steps in to save Sansa, and thereby redeem himself, his character has finally come full circle. It seems Theon's character is pulled from one mental state to another from episode to episode. It probably wouldn't be too far to say he'd make an interesting case study for a psychologist.
1. Jaime Lannister
How He First Appears While Theon is in many ways an auxiliary character, Jaime is a central part of Game of Thrones, and the Jaimes at the start of Season 1 and the end of Season 5 could not be starker in their differences. Jaime began as an impulsive, boyish musketeer, embroiled in an incestuous love affair with his sister. Upon the discovery of their relationship, he is almost gleeful in his attempted murder of Bran Stark. Most people are going to hate on anybody who laughs as they push a kid from a window, and audiences were no different here. The impression at this point was that Jaime was a clearly defined villain for viewers to sink their teeth into. However, as the show progressed, we realised Jaime was as complex as any other character, who was capable of good as well as evil. What He Becomes Ultimately the character that emerges is changed by Brienne of Tarth's loyalty, as well as the first misfortune he ever experiences, in losing his hand. For the first time, he is accepted for who he is, even along with the knowledge of his love for his own sister. Jaime has become more of a diplomat than a warrior, and he is slowly coming to terms with his own mistakes. After admitting that he is both uncle and father to Myrecella she, remarkably, forgives him. It seemed in that moment that his transformation was complete, but it will be interesting to see what direction his character takes after her death at the end of Season 5. Will he fall into despair or be transformed for the better once again by her forgiveness and subsequent death? Which other characters in Game Of Thrones have completed evolved? Share your thoughts below in the comments thread.