*As this is an article discussing changes from the book, it will be crammed full of spoilers. Please do not read it if you don't want the books spoiled for you. This has been a rough season for all of us. Not just for those off in Westeros, but right here at home too. We laughed, we cheered, and we cried...a lot. White walkers were killed, chains were broken, guest right was forsaken, an oathbreaker became an oathkeeper, and the Starks were so close and yet so far apart. To help with the Game of Thrones withdrawal that many of us are going through as we wait another year for the next season and mourn the loss of many dearly beloved characters, I have made a list of the top 5 changes between the show and the book, A Storm of Swords, which this season was based on. Keep in mind that the producers of the show said they were splitting this book in two, so that the second half of the book is what the fourth season will be based on. Some of the events in the books have happened earlier than they did in the book, but Im not counting those as changes because the basic chronology is the same. Now then, lets just dive right in.
5. Bringing Jaime Lannister Back Before The Purple Wedding
In the books, Jaime doesn't arrive back in Kings Landing until the Purple Wedding, during which King Joffrey Baratheon finally dies at his wedding feast. ( Not gonna lie...one of the very few things I was sad about when I read they were splitting the third book into two seasons was that I would most likely have to wait an extra season to watch Joffrey die.) Arriving back at the city right at the heels of the death of the son whom he was never allowed to claim as his own certainly sours his arrival, as he is forced to contend with a bitter Cersei, and angry Tywin who demands he leave the Kingsguard, and a little brother who has just been accused of killing the king before a thousand witnesses. Having him arrive much earlier than that is certainly going to change the dynamic and will no doubt lead to some great scenes with his, Cersei, Tyrion, and Tywin in the next season. Nikolaj Coster-Waldau certainly proved his acting chops this season, turning the despised sister-screwing, child-crippling Jaime Lannister into one of the most beloved characters in the show and is sure to guarantee some powerful scenes next season as the consequences of the loss of his hand and his change of heart because of his time with Brienne play out.
4. The Fates of Gendry Waters and Ser Barristan Selmy
One of the advantages of being in novel format rather than on TV is that the there is a greater ability to have a large cast of characters and one character can be a mystery to another and the audience, and all they need to do is change their name. The same cannot be said of television, where budgets limit cast size and once a character is introduced in one setting, it is much harder to give him an air of mystery in another, since the audience has already seen his face. Producers David Benioff and D.B. Weiss handle the issue well, managing to cut the cast of thousands down to a still great, but much smaller number. In the books, it is Edric Storm, another of King Robert Baratheon's b**tard sons that Melisandre intends to sacrifice to the Lord of Light and Gendry Waters stays with the Brotherhood Without Banners. It is Edric who Ser Davos Seaworth saves from a death in the flames. In the show, they do away with Edric all together and instead have Gendry as the intended sacrifice, a much more farmiliar face by now. Not only does this make the whole sacrifice much more personal, but it also cuts down the cast and gives more significance to the characters that are already there, something that Game of Thrones is particularly good at. In this same vein, you can't hide the identity of Ser Barristan Selmy because the audience has already seen him. In the books, he disguises himself under the name Ser Arstan Whitebeard before eventually being forced to reveal himself to Dany. Cutting this out not only saved time, but also what would have ultimately been a lackluster reveal since the audience knew his identity the whole time. It gets the ball rolling faster and though it may lead to some complications down the road, it is certainly nothing that Benioff and Weiss won't be able to find a way around.
3. Bringing A Pregnant Talisa To The Red Wedding
Some people might disagree with me in this regard, as Talisa was not a very popular character when she was introduced. In the books, she doesn't even exist. Instead, Robb marries Jeyne Westerling, a sweet girl who is in no way a major part of the story and really only matters insofar as how their marriage affects Robb's war effort. I can't say that I like every change they made with making Talisa such an important character when she wasn't one in the books, but I certainly did like this one. In the books, Jeyne Westerling wasn't at the Red Wedding and she certainly wasn't pregnant. (It's implied in the books that her mother has been giving her herbs to prevent pregnancy.) These two changes only heightened the tension, and the dread that book reading fans of the show had only got worse when they saw her walk in to the wedding with her husband and mother-in-law. The raw brutality of killing a pregnant woman by stabbing her in the belly pierced the heart of even the most cynical of fans and had many staring in shock by the end. (The friend with whom I was watching the show, who hadn't read the books, told me that she refused to even watch another episode ever, ever, again. She still came over again next weekend, though.) And it really did show the finality of the war between the Starks and the Lannisters. That stab in the belly was what it took to show that there really was no hope left and demonstrated in broad strokes, even before the arrows came down on Robb and Catelyn, that this was the end. As much as it hurt to watch, it was one of the telling moments in the show and showed what essentially amounted to the fall of House Stark...at least for now.
2. All The Extra Margaery Tyrell
I was really excited when I heard they were casting Natalie Dormer as Margaery Tyrell, who I remembered from the very popular Showtime costume drama, The Tudors. Dormers portrayal of Anne Boleyn has me sure that she would knock Margaery Tyrell out of the water. She did that and more, as the many extra scenes written for her that were not in the books demonstrate. In the books, she is mostly a part of Sansas story, at least during A Storm of Swords, but this season gave us a lot of extra time with her and let us see her for the masterful player of the Game of Thrones that she is. Managing to control Joffrey Baratheon is no small feat and the skill at which she manages him, pulling away what little influence Cersei still had over him, adds a lot to her character. The scene between her and Cersei is particularly good at showcasing this, and letting us know that Cersei may have a powerful enemy in the future, one who knows better than to play the petty games that she does. Giving her all this time really also developed her motives as to why she would want the crown, whereas the books are much more ambiguous. She doesnt want to be a queen, she wants to be the queen. And if she continues to play the Game as good as she is now, who knows what the future might hold in store.
1. All The Extra Tywin Lannister
Charles Dance is an amazing actor and every scene that he is in is a joy to watch. Luckily, they gave us a lot to watch this season, with scenes with pretty much every much every important person in Kings Landing. Joffrey may wear the crown, but it's clear that Tywin has the power. A lot of his material this season wasn't in the books, like the conversation with Cersei, the dialogue with Joffrey in the throne room, the marriage talks between him and Olenna Tyrell, and parts of the conversation between him and Tyrion after the Red Wedding. And yet, Charles Dance killed every single one. Tywin Lannister is pragmatic and he is always use to being smarter than everyone else around him, always playing them to get what he wants. As Olenna Tyrell says, he is a man who lives up to his reputation. Watching him march right into Kings Landings and knock all the former players in this Game of Thrones right out of the way was spectacular to watch. Watching him talk Joffrey down, even as Joffrey sits on the throne, was great to watch and every single conversation he had this season didnt miss a beat in showing the force that is Tywin Lannister. And yet, Dance even managed to make the character oddly sympathetic. The bit of conversation in the finale where he tells Tyrion he wanted to drown him when he was born, but didnt, had me genuinely feeling for him. Because, as sad as that is for this dysfunctional family, saying that is as close to loving as Tywin will ever get. Still, Dance turns what is one of the most hard-hearted characters in the story into someone the audience can actually empathize with. I cant wait to see what he does next season, in what will most likely be his last. (If youve read this far into the list, then you shouldve known that.) Thats my list and if youre as hungry for the next season as I am, hopefully this helped a little bit with your withdrawal. But just remember that, as the Bastard of the Lord of the Dreadfort says, If you think this has a happy ending, then you havent been paying attention.