Anyone even remotely familiar with George R. R. Martin's 'A Song of Ice and Fire' novels and the epic TV show based on them is aware of the astonishing mortality rate of many of the central characters. As an avid lover of both the books and the show, I find this to be one of the most emotional and brilliant aspects of Martin's world, having spent hours getting attached to these rich, interesting characters only to have my allegiance unexpectedly broken by their sudden, shocking and often gruesome demise. I also found it incredibly difficult to write this piece without major spoilers for forthcoming episodes. But even for those who haven't read the books, there's a virtual gold mine of devastating and shocking kill-offs, with these being my top ten from the show so far.
10. Renly Baratheon
I'll admit I feel as though I've only really included Renly for the sake of rounding out the list to an even ten. I never really felt as attached to him as several of the other characters in this list, therefore it was less of a crushing blow to me when he died. That being the case though, there's no denying his death was certainly one of the more sudden and shocking of the second season. Despite having fairly little screen time, Renly was a charismatic, charming character who played a fairly important role in the war until his shocking death at the hands of Stannis, Melisandre and their supernatural shadow assassin (that may very well have a proper title that I've missed in the books). While Renly's death therefore wasn't terribly upsetting to me, it was certainly a shocking kill-off that set Stannis up as a true contender for the Iron Throne, as well as hinting at the supernatural elements of Martin's world that are often overlooked.
9. Rodrik Cassel
With the old castellan of Winterfell, I'm venturing more into deaths that had more of an emotional impact on me as a viewer. Rodrik in particular was a sad death after several episodes of becoming a more prominent character, looking after Bran and Rickon, becoming a protective, almost father-like figure to the boys. This made it even more devastating when Theon hacked his head off, with the emphasis on hacking. Poor Rodrik deserved better than a botched execution from the turn cloak, a scene made even worse by the anguish it causes to Bran and Rickon. And who could forget his final words to the boys, 'Don't worry child, I'm off to see your father.' This was definitely one of the series' more emotional deaths, especially after Theon made such a mess of it.
8. Lord Commander Mormont
Lord Commander Jeor Mormont, The Old Bear, was another death from the series that had a huge impact on me. Having spent two and a half seasons getting to know the gruff, grizzled old commander of the Night's Watch and after everything he did for Jon Snow and his brothers, it was devastating to watch his shocking end at the hands of his traitorous recruits. The character was always a good and respectable man who tried to do his duty for the Watch and for the realm, but sadly he couldn't please everyone which made his death even more tragic. Though for all of the shock I felt at his death, I was pleased that he died fighting Rast and the rest of the traitors, not giving up until he literally couldn't fight anymore and finally keeled over. A great character that I was truly sad to see go. And now his watch is ended.
7. Maester Luwin
Like poor old Ser Rodrik, Maester Luwin's death was sad on its own, but was made even worse by the devastation it caused to Bran and Rickon. The kind, sad old man never faltered in his duty to the Starks or to Winterfell, looking after the boys and the castle after Robb went to war, even trying to assist Theon when he styled himself the lord following his invasion. He was inherently good right up to the moment he was murdered in cold blood by Dagmer Cleftjaw and the rest of the ironmen. Perhaps this is what made his death even more heart-breaking and tragic, he was a harmless old man that actually tried to help Theon, but the ironmen saw him as a loose end that needed tying off. Luwin's death was definitely an emotional end to the second season and certainly one of the more emotional kill-offs of the series for me.
6. Syrio Forel
Arya's 'dancing master' was another character that I quickly became fond of and was sad to see go. He was likeable, inspiring and definitely one of the more interesting characters that Arya meets throughout the series. He also proved to be a hell of a swordsman, quickly and effectively dispatching Lannister guards with a wooden sword. Syrio was an awesome character who I definitely miss now he's not in the show however his place on my list of deaths is a bit of a grey area for me. Other GoT conspiracy theorists and I have noticed that following his awesome display of wooden swordsmanship against the Lannister guards, there follows a scene with a disembodied scream. Naturally this hints that Syrio might have finally met his match, but what if he didn't? What if he's still alive and waiting to make an amazing reappearance? Possibly a far-out theory but assuming he's dead for the purposes of this piece he definitely deserves a place on this list for being a fantastic character who I definitely wish I'd seen more of.
5. Robb Stark
Perhaps the most devastating and shocking aspect of Robb's death was the brutality of it, showcased by the multitude of 'Red Wedding Reaction' videos plastered all over the internet. Even I, having read the books and knowing what was coming, was filled with anticipation and astonishment long before 'The Rains of Castamere' started ominously filling the hall as the doors were slowly barred. Not only was the scene itself shocking, but it was hugely emotional letting the character go. It's fair to say that most people (including myself) were rooting for the Starks throughout the story, particularly Robb as the good guy out to avenge his father and protect his remaining family. He may have made a few dubious judgement calls throughout his brief time as King in the North, but it was a hell of a way to go and a very emotional and shocking end to a great character.
4. Catelyn Stark
Another character that just couldn't get a break, poor Catelyn died in similarly tragic circumstances to her son at the infamous Red Wedding. Having lost everything, believing her other sons to be dead and with her daughters missing, the final insult to injury came watching her son, his wife and his men butchered before her very eyes before being finally put out of her misery herself. In a way it was almost a mercy that her pain was finally ending, but just like Robb she died in the most brutal and shocking way possible. For any viewers like me who were still rooting for the Starks as well, it was an excruciating scene to watch as they were viciously murdered, repeatedly. Catelyn therefore definitely deserves to be high up on this list, if not for her actual killing off then definitely for the pain she had to endure throughout the seasons, culminating in one final instance of pure suffering before her own murder.
3. Robert Baratheon
Robert Baratheon was many things, a bad king, a worse husband, but also a hilarious character in my opinion. It may well have been Mark Addy's performance but Robert was the perfect combination of seriousness balanced with occasional humour. Even his death was tinged with humour, bowing out with a grim sort of dignity and pride that he took down the boar that gutted him. This winning formula of stern yet funny made him a very likeable character and it was a shame to see him leave. Thankfully the show still doesn't go wanting for the occasional line of comedy gold thanks to Peter Dinklage, but there will always be a rather large hole left behind by Robert.
2. Ned Stark
What?! Ned Stark isn't number one?! I have to say I've never found it more difficult to decide anything than between my top two deaths and where to place them on this list and there is still virtually nothing between them. If I could award them both number one I would, but sadly Ned takes a very close second. The archetypal, clean-cut good guy, Ned was always the one I (and probably everyone else) was rooting for. Possibly the most shocking and upsetting thing about killing him off was that in a world with so many characters, Ned was the one that most identified as being the main one. To have him killed off in the first season therefore left me completely aghast and almost feeling lost after my allegiance was so quickly severed. It also created a consuming hatred for Joffrey within me that I didn't know was possible for a fictional character, but has only gotten worse as the seasons have progressed. Like many of the other characters on this list, Ned's only crime was trying to do the right thing and he sadly paid the ultimately price for it, leaving me horrified and crestfallen. Even with all the deaths since his, and there have been a lot of them, Ned's is still the death that shocks the most.
1. Khal Drogo
But this list is not just for shocking deaths, or clean-cut good guys that the show is now missing, but for the characters that I and many others miss the most, and the unadulterated badass that is Khal Drogo just about takes the top spot. It was very close between him and Ned but some of the moments from season one that I remember being the most awesome came from his scenes and they are difficult to top. Never again will we see him kill a guy by pouring molten gold all over his head, or rip another guy's gullet out with his bare hands. That kind of raw power is difficult to match and it may be a long time before another character has the same kind of awesome on screen presence that the Dothraki Khal had before his untimely death. The devastation it caused Daenaerys only made this death seem even worse, but it set her on the path to becoming a powerful conqueror herself, so perhaps it was not in vain. Khal Drogo therefore takes the top spot as the character I miss the most, by virtue of being a total badass with an awesome on screen presence that will be difficult to top for a very long time. But I think that with a show of this scale, with this many awesome characters, I'm bound to have missed someone or had a controversial opinion somewhere. Should Ned have taken the top spot? Is my theory about Syrio completely insane or could it happen? Let me know in the comments!