Game Of Thrones: 5 Winners And 5 Losers In 'The Mountain And The Viper'

With only two episodes of the season remaining, we’re delving into the business end of things this week.

By Emile Lewis /

This article contains some big SPOILERS, mostly related to the latest episode, but also a little something related to the adaptation from the books on which the series is based (nothing beyond the latest episode). After the long and arduous ordeal of Tyrion€™s arrest and subsequent trial for the murder of King Joffrey (which seems like a long time ago), we now have a conclusion and know what the fates have decided for the imp with nine lives. It seems Tyrion€™s luck has finally run its course, as his voluntary champion, Prince Oberyn, failed spectacularly to prevent the bookkeepers favoured outcome of defeat in the much hyped trial-by-combat. Prince Oberyn fought with great skill and flair, but in the end, he was unable to deliver the fatal blow to the Mountain, Ser Gregor Clegane, whose brute strength proved more than a match for the human skull. All of this means that Tyrion will now face the dire prospect of a summary execution, and there€™s no way he€™s going to talk his way out of it. In other developments, Arya and the Hound finally arrive at the Eyrie to unexpected news, whilst Sansa comes into her own in defence of a cornered Littlefinger. In the north, Ygritte and the Wildling raiding party edge ever closer to the Wall and the desperately vulnerable Castle Black, whilst in the east, Ser Jorah€™s espionage comes back to haunt him. With only two episodes of the season remaining, we€™re delving into the business end of things with this week€™s winners and losers.

The Winners:

5. Sorry, Not Sorry (Grey Worm & Missandei)

There€™s a budding romance developing between two of the secondary characters in Daenerys€™ storyline, and considering the lives they€™ve led as slaves up until this point, a little human connection is certainly no more than they deserve. Daenerys was gifted Missandei as part of her deal with the masters of Astapor for the Unsullied. Daenerys saw her value as a translator, and also for her knowledge of the cities in Slaver€™s Bay. Grey Worm is one of the Unsullied, and they chose him as their captain with Daenerys blessing after she had declared them free men. In his new role on the queen€™s council, Grey Worm needs to learn the common tongue, and Missandei was perfectly equipped to teach him. Through their lessons, they€™ve begun to develop an emotional connection. It was hinted at before, but only properly addressed in this latest episode. When everyone is bathing naked in the river (as you do), Grey Worm sees Missandei nude, and perhaps for the first time in his life, becomes aware of the allure of a woman€™s form. Later, when Missandei recalls the encounter to Daenerys, her queen reassures that the Unsullied do not see women in this way, however Missandei is certain that he did. They also wonder how much of his parts were removed by the masters when he was a boy. Grey Worm approaches Missandei in the throne room to apologise for his lingering stare, but it is obvious that they both want this relationship to develop further. With not much else going on in Meereen at the moment, it€™s likely that we€™ll get to see just that.

4. Gilly

It's difficult to see Gilly as anything more than a career loser, given the hard lot she€™s had to endure her entire life, living under the thumb of her despicable father€“husband, Craster, but another side to Gilly is brought to our attention this week. We€™re talking of course, about her uncanny knack for continuing to survive in the most treacherous of circumstances and encounters. She regularly finds her self in peril; peril that would consistently claim the lives of many others, even the hardened warriors of the Wildling camp, or the experienced rangers of the Night€™s Watch, and yet Gilly remains alive (though surely traumatised). We are made to consider her adaptability when Sam€™s Night€™s Watch brothers are attempting to console him after they receive the news that Tormund Giantsbane€™s raiding party has overrun Mole€™s Town. Sam fears that Gilly is surely dead, and blames himself for having deposited her there in an effort to protect her from the exclusively male occupancy of Castle Black. Eddison Tollett (the sarcastic one) reminds him (and us) that so far Gilly has survived Craster, the long march to the Wall, and even a White Walker: an impressive list of notches on anyone€™s belt. We know that Gilly has now added surviving the attack on Mole€™s Town to that list, which only further serves to demonstrate her impressive track record of making it through fatal trials. Is it simply blind luck, or are the Gods saving her for some as-yet unclear purpose? Either way, Gilly is our most underrated winner this week.

3. Cersei

After a slight road-bump in her attempt to have Tyrion killed by means of a blatantly rigged trial for murdering her son, Joffrey, Cersei affects some much-needed course-correction and comes out on top as the true winner of the highly anticipated trial-by-combat. We discussed in last week€™s list how Cersei might have made a losing choice in her selection of champion for the trial, and as it turns out, opponent Prince Oberyn proved more than a martial match for her man, Ser Gregor Clegane. In the end though, it wasn€™t skill in the field that earned the Mountain his victory, but rather the hubris of Prince Oberyn, who threw it all away.

Advertisement

The manner of victory will not concern Cersei however, only the knock-on effect of it€™s outcome. With the trial concluded, Tryion has been judged guilty of regicide in the eyes of the Gods, and is subsequently sentenced to death, a result that was the entire purpose of the whole charade. Cersei will at long last be able to rip out the oldest weed in her garden of enemies, before no doubt turning her malice upon the next target, most likely Lady Margaery. At the end of the day, Cersei always gets what she wants.

Advertisement

2. Sansa

Sansa Stark isn€™t an innocent child any longer; she put on her game face and grew some serious balls this week. Summoned to give her witness€™ statement regarding the manner of her aunt€™s alleged suicide, Sansa puts on the waterworks and delivers an impressive show to not only confirm Littlefinger€™s lie, but put him in the unusual position of not knowing where he stands with her. For the first time in their relationship, Sansa knows Littlefinger€™s game, but Littlefinger doesn€™t know hers. Also consider that with Lady Lysa out the frame and Littlefinger back-tracking (in relation to her), Sansa is suddenly holding all the cards at the Eyrie. She should now have untold influence over little Lord Robin, and for the moment it will be her chance to insert influence over the lesser lords and ladies of the Vale. Never count out Littlefinger though, because it may only take him a short while to regain the upper hand over her, but for the immediate future, Sansa has the opportunity (and now the guile) to really become a force of power behind-the-scenes in the Vale. This could be the beginning of a sharp transition in Sansa€™s character. For much of her arc so far, Sansa has been the victim; a day-dreaming child who€™s romantic ideas about the politics of the world was ground and crushed over a long period of torture and torment at the hands of the Lannisters. Now she is free of them, she can grow stronger from the harsh lessons that she learned during her captivity, and so use them as a means of playing the game to her own advantage. You could say this transition is signified by her wardrobe change in her final scene of the episode. The dress she wears then is strikingly more regal than anything we have seen her in previously. It suggests that its wearer is someone of great power and influence, and this is hopefully something we can expect to see of Sansa in the future.

1. Ramsay Bolton

If there€™s one way for any bastard-born character in the world of Game of Thrones to achieve a gain in political capital, it€™s by having your birth legitimised as a natural-born heir. Such is the case with young Ramsay, the Bastard of Bolton this week, and you can clearly see how much it means to him. For successfully delivering the strategically vital northern fortress of Moat Cailin, Roose Bolton awards his bastard son with the honour of their family name. This obviously has greater significance than the minor amendments to a few name-day cards however, as the real benefit will be Ramsay€™s legal claim to his father€™s inheritance. As Roose Bolton€™s only living son, Ramsay is now in line to inherit his father€™s title of Warden of the North, along with a seat as the lord of Winterfell, and all the lands of the North that the Bolton€™s now hold dominion over. As Roose is keen to point out, this is a significant amount of real estate. The northern kingdom of Westeros is as large, if not larger geographically than all of the other six combined. For a bastard-born to suddenly have a legal claim to the largest of the Seven Kingdoms is no small deal, but there is also one more additional benefit to Ramsay€™s new name. As a naturalised Bolton, Ramsay is eligible to father heirs of his own, continuing the line of the Bolton family and implementing a lasting legacy as the ruling family of the north. Ramsay has demonstrated that he has high level of pride for the Bolton name and its history, so this will definitely be an aspect of his newfound status that he will want to fulfill. Gods help the unfortunate bride, whomever she might be. Hit next to find out this week€™s biggest losers.

The Losers:

5. The Hound

The Hound simply cannot believe his luck when he finally arrives at the Eyrie with his prize hostage in tow, only to learn that he€™s once again missed the deadline for delivery. Arya€™s relatives keep dying just as he€™s about to hand her over to them in exchange for a cash reward. In this instance, Arya€™s last living relative (of age) has died just three days past. Lady Lysa of the Vale took a tumble through the moon door with an encouraging shove from her deceptive new husband, Littlefinger. With Lysa out of the picture, the Hound has run out of people who would be interested in trading his hostage for gold. Unfortunately, everyone in this scene is totally ignorant of the fact that there is someone at the Eyrie who would be overjoyed to pay Arya€™s ransom. Arya and the Hound have no idea that Sansa Stark currently resides there, and the guards are none the wiser either. As far as they know, the auburn haired girl that arrived with Littlefinger is his bastard niece, Alayne. So when the Hound declares Arya€™s true name before them, the connection goes right over their ignorant heads. Poor old Sandor Clegane has got to be the unluckiest person in the world. He€™s just one of those characters who was born to lose, destined for a life of people using him and then finding no help from the universe when he finally strikes out on his own. So what next for the Hound? Perhaps the only people left who may find potential value in Ayra Stark would be the Lannisters. They would definitely take her as a hostage, however they would be unlikely to pay the Hound with anything but a spear to the belly, after all, he did abandon his king during the Battle of Blackwater Bay. Alternatively, he could take her home to Winterfell, where Roose Bolton could marry her to his now legitimate son Ramsay, thereby solidifying his family€™s claim to the North. Such a scenario would be a terrible prospect for Ayra, but it represents the best option for the Hound. Of course, all of this is dependant on how much longer he can keep Ayra under his own control. Now believing that all of her family is lost to her, Ayra is essentially free of any commitments to anyone, and can begin to define her own path.

4. Illogical Adaptation Decisions

There are many cases where the television adaptation differs from the source material. This is only natural, and doesn't really concern us for the purpose of this series of articles. However, it sometimes happens that a difference in the adaptation doesn't even make sense within the context of the show, and therefore has relevance to merit discussion. This case in point concerns the revelation to Daenerys that Ser Jorah was once employed as spy for the Seven Kingdoms, and has been selling information about her to the crown. It sort of came out of the blue, as it has been a long time since we were addressed with Ser Jorah€™s role as a spy for King Robert. It€™s been so long in fact that the letter of pardon Ser Barristan receives is actually signed by the late king, meaning we are dealing with something that happened all the way back in Season 1, when both Robert and Ned were still alive.

Advertisement

The letter is only now reaching its intended across the Narrow Sea, more than two seasons after the fact. Not only is this an abrupt and unlikely scenario, it is also unnecessary. Ser Barristan himself should already be aware of Ser Jorah€™s treachery. As Lord Commander of King Robert€™s Kingsguard, he held a seat on the small council, and though he may not have attended many meetings, he should still be privy to their dealings (he knew about Daenerys and where to find her after he left the capital, so why not Ser Jorah?). With such knowledge, it makes no sense that Ser Barristan did not expose Ser Jorah earlier, when the plotline was still a little fresher in our memories. Instead, Ser Barristan seems to have no knowledge of Ser Jorah€™s deal with the crown, and as consequence, the writers needed to create an arbitrary excuse (the letter from out the blue) in order to reintroduce the conflict.

The drama also occurs at a time when not much else is going on in Daenerys€™ storyline, and this makes it seem all the more forced. It would have had more impact if it had occurred during a vital moment for Daenerys, say, during her conquest of Meereen, as indeed this is the case in the source material. Ser Jorah€™s treachery is revealed in the books at a time when Daenerys needs her advisors most, and this gives more punch to the drama. There doesn€™t seem to be any logical reason why the show runners felt the need to change this aspect of the plot in their adaptation. We can€™t accept that it was because they needed something interesting to happen to Daenerys at this stage of the season. They could have easily left her storyline alone for one episode and shown us something else. It€™s not as if they are stretched for other material to adapt.

Advertisement

Advertisement

3. Ser Jorah

Moving back to the character side of things, but staying in the same area, Ser Jorah has had the worst day of his life since Ned Stark exiled him from Westeros for selling men into slavery. As we€™ve already established, Ser Jorah was at one time selling information about Daenerys€™ movements and activities to the Seven Kingdoms, acting as their spy in her camp in a bid to earn himself a pardon for the crimes for which he was banished. Most of this occurs in Season 1, and indeed in early Season 2 Ser Jorah explicitly tells the mysterious masked woman at the garden party in Qarth that he is now fully devoted and loyal to Daenerys. The damage had already been done however, but it would take a further two seasons worth of episodes to undermine him. Unbeknownst to him, Ser Jorah€™s royal pardon had already left King€™s Landing in the time when King Robert was still drinking and bedding whores. Somehow, this letter must have gotten lost along the way, or at least severely delayed, or perhaps nobody could find Daenerys camp because she keeps moving around so much. Nevertheless, the letter arrived, exposing Ser Jorah€™s treachery, and honestly it couldn€™t have come at a worse time for him. Daenerys is settling into her new role as the ruler of the conquered Meereen, a task that brings with it a myriad of difficult challenges. Ser Jorah has never been more important to his queen as an advisor than at this point in the story. On top of that, his more than professional affections for her are being tortured by the rivalry of the dashingly roguish Daario Naharis. Daenerys has already taken Daario as a lover €“ which Ser Jorah openly disapproved of €“ and with this latest development, he will not be able to taper the sellsword€™s influence over their queen once Daario returns from his mission to Yunkai. You€™ve got to feel for Ser Jorah; despite his previous sins, he genuinely does love Daenerys, and only wants to do right by her. Now it€™s anybody€™s guess what will happen to him. It seems unlikely that he will return to the Seven Kingdoms. With Robert long dead, his pardon may not bare much weight anymore, and he could find himself on the way to the noose pretty soon. A sellsword in the free cities seems like the most viable option, and whilst it may not be the lofty post of advisor to a Targaryen queen, it would at least be preferable to death upon return from exile. That being said, Ser Jorah won€™t be in the best state of mind for making sensible decisions about his future; we fear that wandering drunk may be the most likely eventuality on his bleak horizon.

2. Prince Oberyn

Damn you George R. R. Martin, you unforgiving profiteer of the false dawn! Once again, fans across the realm are tearing the fabric from their sofa arms and pleading with their television sets as yet another well-loved, enjoyable character bites the dust in the ongoing, proverbial middle finger to the traditional hero story trope that is Game of Thrones. Defeat has been snatched from the jaws of victory, at the moment when all seemed won, and alas, the Red Viper of Dorne is no more. Unfortunately, Prince Oberyn only has himself (and Martin) to blame. His obsession with provoking a confession from the Mountain took things a step too far. He was not content to see his accused perish by his own blade, but instead wanted the whole world to hear to truth of the crime from the culprit€™s mouth. Prince Oberyn€™s hubris, perhaps his most attractive quality to viewers, ends up being the thing that gets him killed. But it isn't just his death, or the manner of it, that qualifies Prince Oberyn as a loser; he also fails in his attempt to exact vengeance on those responsible for the crime of raping and murdering his sister and killing her children. Whilst he does get his confession at the end, he doesn€™t live to see the Mountain perish, and also fails to uncover any conspiracy on Lord Tywin€™s part, for collusion in the vile act. In the end, his entire venture in the capital was a resounding failure. Farewell sweet prince.

1. Lord Tywin

What, no Tyrion? That€™s right, far too obvious, and also, not really applicable. Tyrion€™s fate has already been sealed for a while now; whether by death or by exile on the Wall, he hasn€™t got much political capital left to lose. Therefore, let€™s examine the man who lost the most (politically speaking) as a result of the trial-by-combat. As the Mountain crushed Prince Oberyn€™s skull like a ripe watermelon, Lord Tywin€™s precious Lannister legacy was also snuffed out. With Tyrion€™s impending execution, Tywin is set to lose his only legitimate heir, and with him, any chance of averting the end of the first-born Lannister line. When Tywin himself moves on from this world, his brother Kevan will become the head of the family, and Kevan€™s only surviving son is Lancel. Yes, Lancel Lannister will be the future of that once great and powerful house. No wonder Tywin always looks so irate. So what is the world€™s greatest dad to do? No doubt his first strategy will be to return to Jaime and somehow convince him to betray his Kingsguard vows and claim his inheritance, but we fear (for Tywin) that ship may have already sailed. It€™s going to take an extremely generous offer for Jaime to submit to his father€™s will now. With Tyrion€™s life thrown away, Jaime has no cause worthy of sacrificing what remains of his honour. One strategy nobody seems to have mentioned is that Tywin himself could re-marry and father as many children as he can before he expires. Of course this would be a desperate, last-gasp measure as there is no way to guarantee a son from such a union. Furthermore, Tywin would not be able to raise any potential heir in his image, as he would likely only live a few years beyond the child€™s birth. So whilst this approach may save his immediate line, there is very little chance he will get the heir he desires. Who knows, the hypothetical kid may be even more unsuited to the role than Lancel.