Gotham: 10 Reasons Why It’s A Bust

It's Batman... but not.

By Daniel Schwartz /

For years, fans and writers have said that the city of Gotham is its own unique character in the Batman mythos. After all, it is the setting that created several masked vigilantes and even more costumed villains. From the overly corrupt police force to the seemingly endless supply of criminals, Gotham has always been a city in crisis. Having just come out of the amazing Dark Knight trilogy and with a new Batman debuting in the upcoming Batman V Superman film, the Caped Crusader has never been more popular. DC and Fox decided to cash in on this popularity by creating an new take on the origin story that was also about the city that gave birth to the legend. Done correctly, an origin story (i.e. Batman Begins in serial format) would be vastly entertaining and would draw millions of viewers each week. Instead, fans were given a show that revolved around an up-and-coming Jim Gordon, a sadly predictable sub-plot involving mob warfare, and a pre-teen Bruce Wayne who is nothing like the man that he is supposed to become. What was supposed to be the story of a young man becoming everyone's favorite vigilante has turned into a slow-paced drama where old, beloved characters are given unflattering makeovers and poor dialogue. Because it is linked to Batman, the show will be given at least 2 seasons to succeed. Can it be saved before it outlives this leeway? Only time will tell, but the signs aren't good.

10. Alfred Is Not Alfred

Since when does Alfred speak with a cockney accent? In the comics, movies, and cartoons, Alfred has usually spoken with an proper English accent (Michael Caine being an exception). He has almost always been a refined British butler to every other iteration of the Caped Crusader. One can understand the writers for the show wanting to make their versions of characters somewhat different in order to stand out. Given that, if they only changed his speech pattern, it would not be such a big deal, but they also gave him a completely different background and personality as well. He now has weapons and special forces combat training, which he uses to defend himself and Bruce quite effectively. One of the things that makes Alfred likeable in his previous incarnations is that he cannot do what Bruce can, but is still able to support him in his own way with a refreshingly dry wit. This Alfred is not only a better fighter than Bruce, but he is also a jerk. This is not the Alfred you know and love.

9. Young Bruce Wayne

What's worse than a Batman show that does not feature Batman? A Batman show that has an un-entertaining young version of the Caped Crusader before he knew how to do anything. It is understandable that the creators wanted to show how Bruce Wayne became Batman from Day 1, but instead of looking like a master fighter and tactician in training, he comes across as a modern day version of Young Indiana Jones, but not as exciting (and remember how long that show lasted). Fans know they won't see a fully grown and costumed Batman in this version of the story, but why must they instead get a whiny and angry pre-teen who appears more on the path to being Catwoman's Robin than becoming Batman.

8. Fish Mooney

Fish Mooney is a new character created for this series. The middle-aged and angry caricature is played by none other than Jada Pinkett Smith (aka Mrs. Will Smith). She was created to add some drama to the mob war taking place early in the season - a dangerous and merciless mid-level mobster who will stop at nothing to rise to the top of the Falcone Empire. At, least that is what the writers want you to believe. Fish does not come across as a vicious criminal. Instead, she comes across as a cartoonish version of a vicious criminal. Looking like she is trying too hard, Smith overacts every scene that she is in in an attempt to show her character's strength when she is doing the just the opposite. If the writers can tone down her character and show a vulnerability that makes her likeable, however, she may be redeemable.

7. Penguin's Plan Is Obvious

In the world of Gotham, Oswald Cobblepot has proved himself to be a ruthless and tactical killer. Despite his disability, he proves to be a threat to any person who gets in his way. That being said, his plan to take over all crime in the city is as transparent as shrink wrap. Within the narrative, he is working for Maroni while secretly working for Falcone. This only serves him in order to use Falcone to take out Maroni and vice-versa; he's attempting to use both parties to eliminate each other. And any fan watching the show can see this plot a mile away. Somehow Falcone and Maroni (who are supposedly very street smart) are not intelligent enough to figure it out? Will he succeed? He'll probably end up taking out one of the two crime lords and end up working under the other until he can figure a way to kill that one. Hopefully, the survivor will see it as clearly and predictably as everyone watching will.

6. Barbara The Girlfriend

In the comics, Barbara Gordon is Batgirl/Oracle. She serves as not only the eyes and ears of various superheroes, but also as a dangerous vigilante in her own right. One of the big differences between this Barbara and the Babs in the comics is that Batgirl is the daughter of James Gordon and not his lover/wife as in the series. This same error first appeared in The Dark Knight movies; they chose to make Barbara his wife (and did not even mention a daughter of that name). What's confusing in this show is that Barbara (played by Erin Richards) probably won't become the vigilante that her namesake suggests (although that would add a very interesting element). How this woman will shape Jim Gordon and Bruce Wayne has yet to be seen. She showed courage by approaching Falcone on behalf of Gordon, but it is hard to imagine that courage taking the form of a costumed crimefighter. Will she and James name their daughter Barbara Jr.? Not likely. This means that the Barbara Gordon that comic readers are all familiar with will be nowhere to be seen in this series.

5. Revisiting The Wayne's Murder (Again)

You've seen the death of Thomas and Martha Wayne time and time again in the comics, TV shows, and movies, and you'll get yet another look at it in the upcoming Batman V Superman movie. When you see the same murder portrayed time and time again, it loses its impact (even though it is the most important thing to happen in Bruce Wayne's life). In the comics and most other versions, the murder of the Waynes is an unexpected act of violence that shows the diseased condition of the city that Batman will one day protect. The fact that it is a random act performed by an average criminal (Joe Chill) is what makes it so powerful to Bruce Wayne's narrative. The show attempts to give a different meaning to their murder, repurposing it as a tactical land grab for Maroni or Falcone, or both. This attempt to widen the scope of the Wayne's death, however, will backfire. If Bruce (or Gordon) can get to the bottom of the crime and punish the responsible parties, why will Bruce Wayne feel the need to cleanse the city when he already has justice before he ever suits up?

4. The Choice Of Villains

One thing that the series does not have a shortage of is bad guys. Unfortunately for viewers, the scariest villain to date has been a person who ties victims to balloons and lets them float away. Having various factions of the mafia at war with each other adds a layer of drama to the narrative, but you don't tune in to see who the next mob Don will be. You want to see action and powerful villains doing extraordinary things. While Victor Zsasz is a psychopath, he's not even on the B-List of Batman's foes (although he owns one of the coolest scenes in the show where he clears out the police station simply by commanding it). The plot seems to be developing Edward Nygma (slowly) along the path to becoming the Riddler. In the comics, he is one of the few people in the world who is actually smarter than Bruce Wayne. If the show can begin to show Nygma's fall to the dark side and move him in the direction that will see him as the Riddler within the series, they will go a long way towards regaining credibility.

3. No Superheroes

After Batman emerges as a tactful and effective vigilante, the city fills with costumed civilian crime-fighters. The reason that you read comics and watch films and shows associated with them is to see these heroes in action. So far, Gotham has shown no heroes outside of Jim Gordon (who will never wear a costume). Robin, Oracle, Nightwing, Azrael, and Huntress are just a few of the masked heroes that appear in Batman's world. It would be wise of the show to include at least one crime-fighter with a mask within the series. This criticism may be premature as the show is only half way through its first season, but there is not even a hint as to anyone other than Bruce Wayne fighting crime about 20 years from the current timeline of the show. Showing a fully costumed and capable Azrael would be a slight departure from the comics, but it would provide Bruce with inspiration for his journey and it would give you something to feel hopeful for in the future of the series.

2. The Pace

To say that the plot of Gotham is moving slowly would be an understatement. The show does a fine job of setting up certain plot threads to take place, but has not moved the story forward as much as you'd like. It feels that the show is building up to something that may never be reached. The treachery of gang warfare and the uphill battle that Gordon has to face as an honest cop are very interesting points, but, as of yet, they have not gone anywhere. Again, since the show only has half a season under its belt, the pace of things could change, but it is unlikely. If the writers and producers want people to keep tuning in each week, things need to start happening. There are several good developments so far, but they are contained within their own stories and do not drive the overall narrative forward. In one episode, Gordon was in direct warfare with the mob, then the writers easily cleaned up their differences and put everything back to normal by the end of the episode. There is an over-arching plot in the first season about the murder of the Waynes and the mob. If they can start to show more of how their murder ties into Gordon's battle against Falcone (rather than hinting), the show may be able to be saved (for now).

1. Who Is Harvey Bullock?

Everyone's asking themselves that very question every episode. He appears to be a corrupt cop with a schizophrenic personality. Is he a good guy or a bad guy? No one knows for sure. On one hand, he forced Gordon to "kill" Cobblebot in order to prove his loyalty to Falcone, which somehow gained trust between the two. When Penguin turns up alive, Bullock is livid and ready to kill Gordon. Yet within that same episode, he is ready to follow Gordon into battle and save the day. Sometimes he is against Gordon, other times, he is fully with him. He is so confused about what he is that he is causing confusion among viewers as well. This may be an intentional character quirk that is meant to keep you guessing as to his true allegiance, but all that it is really doing is making his character look ridiculous. If he is a fully corrupt cop, let him be a corrupt cop. If he is a good cop (doubtful), let him be a good cop. The spontaneous personality changing of this vital character only make you feel as though you're being taken on a ride with no sensible conclusion. What do you make of Gotham? Does it still have potential? Discuss the Batman prequel in the comments below.