When writing a season finale, writers generally choose one of two options: either make it a definitive end to this leg of the story, or close with a cliffhanger that will leave fans desperately yearning for when the show returns the following year with the solution. The merits of the open-ending remains a point of contention amongst television critics and audience members: Are they an example of lazy writing, or a clever use of the medium to maximise the impact of specific story beats? For a long time during the run of Hannibal's second season, it seemed as if the producers were aiming for the former - from the cold open we were lead to believe we were approaching the prologue of Red Dragon, wherein Hannibal is apprehended by Will Graham & Jack Crawford and subsequently confined to the Baltimore State Home for the Criminally Insane. However, Bryan Fuller and company have other plans for their version of this story. The finale they gave us, entitled Mizumono, was one right out of a Grand Guignol fever dream - bloody, violent, and uncompromising, with a thoroughly ambiguous ending. For an episode packed to the brim with last-minute gut punches, surprises, and twists, it was relatively lacking in any sense of closure. That fact has become hit or miss with many fans, some praising the cliffhanger, and others condemning the lack of resolution. So while hungering for the third season, we have put together a list of some questions that will continue to bother us until the inevitable return of Hannibal next year. Have any of your own? What did you think of Friday's blood-soaked finale? Let us know in the comments section below!
7. Will They Ever Catch Hannibal?
For many of this series' fans who also have read Thomas Harris' novels, the driving question going into season 2 was "How will the FBI apprehend Doctor Lecter?" The cold open at the outset of season 2, which showcased Jack Crawford and Hannibal brawling in the kitchen, seemed to hint toward Hannibal becoming a caged animal toward the end of the season, trapped with nowhere to run. Bryan Fuller & Steve Lightfoot's script, however, deprives Crawford of the comfort of FBI backup - completely contradicting the viewers' assumptions about the fight's context. By the time Hannibal walks out of his house, not only is he the victor, he has essentially gotten away clean. This poses some problems for Fuller and Company, should they continue their somewhat strict adherence to Thomas Harris' canon of psychological thrillers. Hannibal cannot remain at large forever. At a certain point in any TV series, it becomes clear that they are just spinning their wheels in order to churn out more seasons without regard for narrative progress (see Dexter seasons 5 - 8 for a textbook example). And while Hannibal has not yet reached that level yet, if they put off his capture for too much longer, the show will start to run the risk of becoming repetitive.
6. Where Is Hannibal Going?
This we know for certain: Hannibal is on a plane. Every incarnation of the Hannibal Lecter character from the page to the screen has shared a distinctly European sensibility, but that is a relatively vague clue at best. The world is a large place, and Hannibal Lecter has proven quite a slippery figure when taken out of his home town of Baltimore, Maryland. Lecter is a man of fine tastes - his artwork, wines, and even his "memory palace" suggest that he would be most comfortable in a place thick with refined culture. In Hannibal (the novel and film), Dr. Lecter found himself quite at home in Florence, Italy, but that was set after his extended incarceration with Doctor Chilton, while this show remains definitively a prequel to that series of events. There is one tantalising detail that may offer a clue as to where he's headed: The stewardess on the plane offered Hannibal champagne in French. While this may just be another leg on a longer journey Hannibal and Bedelia are taking, perhaps going to the culinary capitol of the world is not such a far fetched idea for this master chef.
5. What Will Be The Legal Repercussions Of Jack Crawford's Actions?
A very popular cliche in television shows and movies features a passionate Federal Agent (in this instance, Jack Crawford) pursuing a case he knows is worth pursuing in direct defiance of his superiors. Mizumono adhered quite strictly to this cliche (Jack even had to hand in his badge in the middle act), until a key moment. That key moment was in the literal apprehension of Hannibal Lecter. If this series stuck closely by the cliche route, Jack would have captured, or assisted in capturing, Hannibal, and then received validation from the Bureau for sticking to his guns and capturing an infamous serial killer. But people make mistakes. By defying the FBI, assaulting Hannibal Lecter in his own home, and subsequently failing to capture Hannibal, Jack Crawford has started an avalanche of legal consequences tumbling down onto the heads of whoever ends up surviving Hannibal Lecter's knife. And let us not forget how many risks Crawford took in establishing Hannibal's trust in Will - approving him to murder a man (another killer, but still a victim in the eyes of the law), brutalise the body, and set up a crime scene. The carnage at Doctor Lecter's is certainly going to prove a dense legal maze for all the survivors, especially if one of them was the man who sanctioned murder and mutilation for the sake of capturing a mastermind, however inadvertently.
4. How Will The Supporting Characters React?
As this season wound toward its conclusion, the importance of the peripheral characters began to diminish. The FBI task force and Freddie Lounds get some limited screen time toward the end of the season, but are largely out of the picture for Mizumono. Upon the discovery of the violence that went down at Doctor Lecter's house, we can only imagine how the various side characters will react. Due to the show's willingness to keeping its central action within a central cast, we can reasonably expect to see the same Forensic team investigate Lecter's latest butchery that have investigated all the other crimes on this show - Namely Brian Zeller and Jimmy Price, the two wisecracking forensic analysts. They will most likely have to confront working with the survivors, who will have massive psychological issues after their confrontation with Hannibal the Cannibal. The most interesting to think about is Freddie Lounds. She has, after all, known and interviewed all of the victims - she was even planning on writing a book with Abigail about her experiences with her father. Will she be able to curb her shock value tendencies and actually respect the wishes of Doctor Lecter's victims? Only time will tell.
3. How Deeply Involved With Hannibal's Scheming Was Dr. Du Maurier?
Of all of Mizumono's last minute twists, the one that was the least explained was the sudden reappearance of Dr. Bedelia Du Maurier, Hannibal Lecter's psychiatrist, on a plane with him to parts unknown. The two of them have shared eerie similarities before - chilling unorthodoxy with their therapy and murder being the two biggest ones. This reveal casts a critical light on all her actions in the last season, making things more confusing than ever. Early on in the season, it seemed like Dr. Lecter and Dr. Du Maurier were very much at odds with each other - Bedelia was growing wary of her patient, and he appeared to be growing suspicious of her. She attempted to flee him, but not before revealing to the imprisoned Will Graham that she believed he was innocent. Much later she is found by the FBI and brought into witness protection, where she revealed herself to be a victim of Dr. Lecter's "persuasion", having killed a patient at his suggestion. She is very clearly painted as a victim at this point in the season. This is where things get murky - she gives critical advice on how to catch Hannibal, which ends up falling through for Jack, Will, and Alana. At what point did she start helping Hannibal as opposed to trying to get him caught? Or was she working with him the whole time? Given the background nature of her plot line throughout the course of the season, we must hope these are questions Fuller will answer in season three.
2. How Much More Post-Traumatic Stress Can Will Graham Endure?
Will Graham's mind is far from a safe place. The first season tracked his complete psychological breakdown, and the second was largely spent rebuilding his sanity while he tried to hide his true mental state through a mask of psychosis. Of all the characters left bloodied in this finale - excepting, of course, Hannibal - Will Graham is the most likely to survive, which leads us to the question: how will his psyche take this abuse? Will has been bombarded from the outset of this series with trauma after trauma, and this latest was by far the most cruel he has had to endure - the reveal of Abigail Hobbs. Returning Abigail to Will before cutting her throat was possibly the cruelest thing Hannibal could have done to Will short of going back to his house and murdering every single one of his dogs. The way Lecter brutalised Abigail is nearly identical to the way her own father partially cut her throat before getting gunned down by Graham in the first season. While the ambiguous ending leaves many open possibilities, we know this for sure: If Abigail Hobbs dies of her neck wound this time around, and Will is facing a compounded guilt complex that can only serve to worsen his emotional state - especially since he is still seeing visions of Garret Jacob Hobbs.
1. Which Of The Main Characters Will Die?
This is brutality that even Game of Thrones has difficulty aspiring to - by the end of Mizumono, the vast majority of this series' principal cast members are lying in pools of their own blood in or around Doctor Lecter's house, gasping for air. Are any of them going to make it? This is the question that is most pertinent to any fan discussion of this episode, hands down. All in all, this is an impossible question to definitively answer before the outset of season three (provided casting doesn't leak if Kacey Rohl has been promoted to the principal cast, or the rest have been demoted to guest stars). There are compelling reasons for each of them to stay alive - Will Graham bears the emotional core of the show, so he likely will survive, Jack Crawford is a key figure in both Thomas Harris' Red Dragon and Silence of the Lambs, so his chances are good. However, this is also a series that took Fredrick Chilton, one of the key figures from Silence of the Lambs, and shot him through the head. Bryan Fuller is not beyond changing the source material to suit his narrative purposes. Hell, even though Chilton was shot, Fuller's since given cryptic hints about Serpico surviving a face-shot. Despite the frustrating lack of closure, one cannot deny the effectiveness of the open ending. This question will continue to be discussed from now until next year, serving to build the anticipation for season three and excitement for what is to come.