How I Met Your Mother: Ted's Relationships Ranked
Who should Ted have really ended up with?
As the world welcomes its spinoff, How I Met Your Dad, it's worthwhile to revisit the original series off of which HIMYD spun, How I Met Your Mother.
The series ran for nine seasons on CBS and follows Ted Mosby as he recounts to his children the titular story of how he met their mother. The story takes place starting in 2005, and sees Ted and his friends, Marshall, Lily, Barney, and Robin, as they face the challenges of being in their late twenties in New York City, looking for love.
Since the show reveals from the start that Ted does find love, the writers have fun playing with the audiences' expectations. They introduce so many love interests for Ted, knowing that the audience knows any one of them could have been the mother. Across nine seasons, Ted has fallen in love countless times, performed more grand romantic gestures than anyone can count, and even proposed to three different girlfriends. Ted has more serious relationships than anyone who regularly complains about his love life as often as he does should.
Here is every one of Ted's serious relationships ranked.
7. Jeanette
Upon meeting Jeanette, The late Bob Saget's future Ted warns the audience that this is the final girl he dates before settling down and going out with the Mother. After Ted's experience with Jeanette though, it's surprising he'd ever consider dating ever again.
Jeanette and Ted first meet when they happen to be reading the same book on the subway, but Jeanette leaves before Ted can get to know her. Coincidentally, Jeanette then shows up at Ted's school as the fire alarm goes off, and they just happen to bump into each other. However, this meet cute isn't all that cute once we learn that Jeantette started a fire in order to meet Ted, and she had been stalking him for some time, which is how they had the same book.
This would not be the only fire Jeanette causes in her brief tenure on HIMYM. Throughout their relationship, she accuses Ted of being in love with Lily (then proceeds to describe a woman who is nothing like Lily), steals his dead grandmother's ring (with which she was buried), and trashes his apartment, culminating in the destruction of Barney's playbook by means of fireworks.
Both the fans and the characters in HIMYM weren't too upset to learn that Jeanette would not be the mother.
6. Karen
Karen was Ted's on and off again college girlfriend who re-enters his life in Season 4. As the episodes with Karen aired long before the name "Karen" gained a negative connotation, this Karen was technically ahead of her time.
Karen comes across as a pretentious jerk to Ted's friends. She would often berate them for their interests, such as Wrestlemania, and struggled with their boundaries, like when she and Ted crashed Marshall's trip to Paris to see Lily, and she broke up with Ted on the flight and stayed in Lily's room. What's worse is that Karen brings out many of these qualities in Ted, turning him into her snobby yes-man.
Karon would also relentlessly cheat on Ted. Each time, unfortunately, he forgave her, and her new paramour would simply give Ted a "sorry, bro." Despite how poorly she treated him and those around him, Ted could never see what was wrong with Karen. Until their final breakup in Season 4.
For any Karen fans hoping she'd place higher on this list, Sorry, bro.
5. Zoey
Ted and Zoey's relationship goes through a few more steps than most enemies to lovers couples. The duo start as potential friends, then sworn enemies, then actual friends, then, finally, lovers.
Ted and Zoey meet when Ted scouts out the Arcadian, an old, disgusting building he was set to destroy in order to design a new building for Goliath National Bank. Zoey, a beautiful woman, wants to keep the Arcadian from being destroyed, so naturally Ted himself now wants to preserve it. When he discovers that Zoey is married, he switches back to GNB's side and advocates for the building's destruction.
Zoey then spends some time antagonizing Ted in an attempt to sabotage the project, and the two start to loathe each other. However, when Zoey accidentally befriends the gang, Ted reluctantly becomes a friend as well, and the two start a relationship once Zoey gets divorced.
Even for those who did not watch the first half of HIMYM Season 6, it's obvious from their relationship that Ted and Zoey started out as enemies. They constantly antagonize each other, never agreeing on anything, including how often healthier couples like Marshall and Lily agree with each other. Future Ted even admits that a supportive relationship, one in which your girlfriend does not record you behind your back in order to sabotage your lifelong dream, is a better fit for him.
Although Ted and Zoey do care for each other, their relationship could not last. Like the Arcadian, it had to fall apart to make way for something better.
4. Stella
Stella and Ted's relationship proved to be one of his best. Unfortunately, their breakup proved to be one of his worst.
Ted and Stella meet when he goes to visit her dermatology office in order to remove his butterfly tramp stamp. Since doctors can't date their patients, Ted waits until all ten sessions are over before asking her out. Stella declines since she is too busy for a relationship, but she changes her mind after Ted takes her out for a "two minute date."
They two date for a while, but after an accidental breakup, Ted wins Stella back and proposes to her. She says yes, and despite the fact that Stella has to pretend that she likes Star Wars when she actually hates it, the two make for a very happy couple. However, when the day of their wedding arrives, Ted makes the mistake of inviting Tony, the father of Stella's daughter Lucy, when Stella explicitly told him no exes at the wedding. When Stella and Tony reunite, they run off together, leaving Ted at the altar and breaking his heart.
Though their breakup was devastating, it was ultimately for the best. Even after their engagement, Ted struggled to name a single one of Stella's hobbies or interests. Still, Stella would probably rank higher on this list had she not ended things with Ted the way she did.
3. Victoria
Technically, Ted's relationship with Victoria can count as two different relationships. The pair dated twice, once in Season 1 and once in Season 8. Though they proved to be a great couple, two break ups probably isn't a great sign for any fan who really wanted Victoria to be the mother.
The pair first meet at Ted's friends' Stuart and Claudia's wedding, for which Victoria baked the cake. The two date for a time, despite the fact that Ted does not tell her about his recent crush on Robin. Although their relationship went well, they transitioned to long distance after Victoria moved to Germany for a baking fellowship. This did not last long, as while they were struggling as a couple with Victoria away, Ted predicted they would break up, and jumped the gun, cheating on her with Robin.
The pair get together once more after Victoria pulls a Stella and leaves her fiance at the altar for Ted. She expects Ted to propose to her shortly after, and although he takes his time, he eventually asks her to marry him. She says yes, on one condition: He has to cut out Robin. This is too much for Ted, and he breaks up with Victoria for good.
Ted did not deserve for Victoria to give him another chance. Cheating on her is unforgivable. However, Ted ultimately made the right decision, choosing to remain friends with Robin, given how important she is to him and given that he would eventually meet an even better match than Victoria.
2. Robin
Ted spends the entirety of Season 1, and arguably the remainder of the series, pining after Robin. The two date throughout Season 2. Though they are fundamentally wrong for each other, they still make for a fantastic couple.
Ted and Robin first meet in the pilot, and the two instantly click until Ted lets slip that he's falling in love with her. This weirds Robin out, but the two eventually become friends. After a season's worth of one being in a relationship while the other has a crush on them, the two finally officially get together at the end of Season 2.
Season 2 is probably the best Season of How I Met Your Mother in large part due to Ted and Robin's relationship. They are endlessly entertaining to watch, and are beneficial to each other in the long run. Being with Ted allowed for Robin to learn how to be in a relationship, while being with Robin helped Ted learn what he really wants in a partner. Though the two's split is ultimately for the best, they make a great couple, so long as they don't try to get back together every other season.
1. The Mother
How I Met Your Mother would not work if The Mother were not at the top of this list.
Though fans had to watch for nine seasons to really meet her, the Mother, aka Tracy McConnell, is well worth the wait. She is the absolute best part of Season 9, and it's endlessly entertaining watching her weave her way throughout the gang, meeting them one by one.
We also get brief flashes forward to her relationship with Ted throughout the season, and he's never happier than when he's with her. The two have incredible chemistry, and this eventual marriage proved to be well worth the wait for Ted and the audience.
Unfortunately, in a controversial final episode, the Mother dies quickly and off screen. However, in what little screen time she had, she made a huge mark on the show, satisfying the core mystery while also developing a wonderful new character in the home stretch.