Locke & Key Review: 5 Ups & 5 Downs
A wildly mixed bag for Netflix's latest fantasy series.
Netflix's long-awaited adaptation of Joe Hill's award-winning comic book series Locke & Key is now available to stream worldwide.
The supernatural horror comic has had an incredibly arduous journey to the screen, with numerous failed attempts to get both a TV series and a movie made, before Netflix stepped in and finally stumped up the cash.
In case you're unaware, the series revolves around three children who, shortly after their father's murder, move into their rustic family home in Massachusetts, where they discover a number of keys which grant them supernatural abilities. Naturally, there are also malevolent forces who want to get their hands on those keys.
It's painfully clear throughout Locke & Key that Netflix forced some disappointing creative concessions upon Hill and co., by taking a significant departure from the tone of the source material and instead creating a more family-friendly, teen-skewing fantasy show rife with iffy melodrama and questionable plotting.
Is Locke & Key a bad show? Certainly not, but an underwhelming one? Absolutely. Though it might fill the void for those craving some creative-yet-flawed supernatural fare, it doesn't nearly begin to realise the potential of its premise, nor of Hill's original work.
It's certainly worth checking out an episode or two to decide for yourself, though it's also smart to go in with appropriately middling expectations...
Downs...
5. The Sanitised & Inconsistent Tone
Though the Locke & Key comic was often incredibly disturbing and brutally violent, much of the "mature" content has been scaled back significantly in this TV adaptation, opting instead for a more easily digestible dark fantasy series.
As a result, the tone feels like a jumbled mish-mash of The Haunting of Hill House, A Series of Unfortunate Events, Stranger Things, and most frustratingly of all, Riverdale.
There is a total disconnect between the show's aspirations to be both a frothy high school melodrama and something more tantalisingly macabre.
On one hand, the show features the bloodless-yet-savage murder of children and a poor soul being strangled to death during sex, and on the other, it's full of all the typical high school drama tropes, like awkward parties, love triangles and, yes, the excessive overuse of pop music.
Clearly, Netflix should've just committed to one tone and stuck with it, and given that the source material clings firmly to grim horror, that's obviously what the show needed.
Instead, Locke & Key is a frustrating, often jarring combination of two styles and moods that just don't fit together.
4. All The Stupid Character Decisions
Arguably an even larger dramatic roadblock than the tonal issues is the simple fact that the vast majority of the show's characters frequently act like absolute idiots.
Whether it's the Locke children recklessly spreading word about their ability-granting keys to anyone in the vicinity, or a spectacularly stupid excursion into an extremely dangerous cave at the season's mid-point, the characters routinely act without the faintest scrap of common sense.
Yes, the focal trio are youngsters, for sure, but even so, their lack of self-preservation instinct, and their bizarre inability to actually use the most powerful and effective keys to help fend off the villainous Dodge (Laysla De Oliveira) quickly becomes infuriating.
But it's not just the kids who are affected: even the adults constantly act counter to their own interests, being purposefully vague and refusing to simply say what they mean, only for the sake of keeping the show's conflict going.
As a result even the most likeable characters in the series have their trying moments, because there's just not much psychological plausibility to their actions.
3. The Inconsistent Production Values
Like most of Netflix's original content, Locke & Key's base visuals are mostly rock solid: the sweeping cinematography looks frequently gorgeous in 4K, and the production design of the Locke house itself is indeed quite remarkable.
But other aspects of the show's visual style sadly aren't quite up to par: the editing feels especially choppy, with an excess amount of unnecessary cutting around in the first half of the season in particular.
Rather than hold on gorgeous shots, there's this constant, anxious movement, and it's especially irritating during basic dialogue scenes that we're being so needlessly shuttled around visually.
Though the show is surprisingly sparing in its use of elaborate CGI, the effects are nevertheless a rather mixed bag overall, culminating in a throw-everything-at-the-screen CGI-fest in the season's final episode, which reveals just how limited the VFX budget truly was.
Given the money Netflix is known to pour into their prestige shows, it does feel like they perhaps cut a few corners too many here, and the sloppy editing does it no favours either.
2. Scot Is Insanely Cringe-Worthy
This may be a divisive opinion, but there's one character in Locke & Key who is absolutely insufferable, and that's Kinsey Locke's (Emilia Jones) love interest Scot Cavendish (Petrice Jones).
Though Petrice Jones does about as well with the role as any actor could, the twitchy nerd is more an irritating attempt at comic relief than an actually engaging character in his own right.
A solid 70% of his dialogue is either a forced pop-culture reference, a bad joke, or him mentioning that he's English, most of which proves wince-inducingly awkward rather than charming as clearly intended.
Given that Scot forms a major aspect of Kinsey's arc throughout the season, it's a major dramatic ding for the series, and smacks of the writers trying a little too hard to pander to teen viewers.
1. The Totally Underwhelming Ending
No spoilers here, but the season's final episode sadly fails to resolve things in a particularly satisfactory fashion, nor provide a compelling setup for the expected second season.
Even ignoring the slapdash bombardment of wonky CGI during a frantic climactic set-piece, there's a final rug-pull waiting for fans that, while perhaps unexpected, doesn't land with quite the intended mind-blowing impact.
It's more of a shrug-worthy, "Oh, really?", moment than it is a genuinely jaw-dropping one, and suggests a relatively underwhelming direction for season two, if it happens of course.
Locke & Key has plenty of flaws for audiences to deal with, then, but there's also a lot that does make it worthwhile. Here's everything the show gets right...
Ups...
5. The Key Gimmick Is Fantastic
Easily the best and most distinctive aspect of the show is its central gimmick, whereby the Lockes come into possession of a series of keys allowing them to, for example, teleport to locations they've visited before, turn into a ghost, control other people, change their appearance, or best of all, enter their own mind.
Even with the show's many dramatic missteps - namely characters not using the keys when it'd make sense to - the keys themselves are compellingly weird enough to keep things on just the right side of interesting.
A good deal of thought and creativity has clearly gone into representing the keys on-screen, and though the rules of each key might not always be 100% clear to either the audience or the characters, they nevertheless give the Lockes (and their enemies) a dynamic array of powers to make use of.
4. It (Mostly) Avoids Netflix Bloat
By far the most common criticism of Netflix Original shows is the cursed "Netflix bloat," that in a desperate desire to fill the streaming platform with content, their seasons often feature a few episodes too many, and without the restrictions of traditional network TV, directors aren't ever asked to rein their more excessive tendencies in.
And while Netflix bloat has ruined many potentially great TV shows, it's actually not particularly apparent throughout Locke & Key, which chugs along relatively steadily throughout its 10-episode season.
It helps that the episodes are kept to a manageable length of around 40-50 minutes, and in addition to the keys constantly changing-up the established fantasy mechanics, the steady slew of narrative revelations make it a show that's bingeable without being totally exhausting.
3. The Ensemble Cast Elevates The Material
Even though the characters themselves make so many baffling and nonsensical decisions throughout Locke & Key, there's little arguing with the quality of the cast's performances.
The ensemble does an admirable job elevating the hit-and-miss material, best of all Darby Stanchfield as Locke matriarch Nina, and Thomas Mitchell Barnet, who is fantastic in his few episodes as Sam Lesser, the troubled high school student who murdered Nina's husband Rendell (Bill Heck) before they moved into their new abode.
Without such solid work across the board, it's possible the show would simply crumble apart dramatically, but even in its sillier and more head-scratching moments, the strong acting keeps it just afloat enough.
2. Its Darker Character Drama Really Works
Though Locke & Key is certainly filled to the brim with an excessive amount of dopey high schooler melodrama, it also does touch on some genuinely potent and powerful themes, again benefiting from the committed work of its cast.
Especially effective is the show's examination of grief, as the family continually struggles to cope with the murder of their patriarch.
We may have the show's co-developer Meredith Averill to thank for this, as she previously served as an executive producer on the brilliantly visceral The Haunting of Hill House.
Elsewhere, the show takes an interesting approach to examining anxiety through the character of Kinsey, with a startlingly believable depiction of paralysing fear, which eventually takes a compelling - if slightly silly - left-turn into supernatural shenanigans.
Then there's Nina's alcoholism, which manages to sidestep its soap opera-y potential and actually become a genuinely affecting subplot, largely thanks to Stanchfield's searing performance and how her disease ends up informing the main key narrative itself.
It's easy to see how a darker tone and stronger writing as a whole could've heightened the emotional impact of these subplots, but even so, they're not simply cliched dramatic padding: they really work for the most part.
1. All The Classic Horror References
What arguably transpires through from the source material to this TV show better than anything else is a clear love for the horror genre, as evidenced by the film's many amusing nods to both classic horror films and legends from the industry.
As irritating as Scot tends to be throughout the series, his team of nerdy pals is named the "Savini Squad" in honour of horror effects legend Tom Savini, who hilariously makes a cameo appearance himself in the second episode.
In the season finale, there are also cameos for Hill himself and the comic's illustrator Gabriel RodrÃguez, while the Massachusetts town in which the Lockes reside has been renamed from the rather on-the-nose "Lovecraft" to "Matheson," in honour of I Am Legend author Richard Matheson.
Fans of The Evil Dead should also keep an eye out for a rather unsubtle yet deeply amusing homage to the iconic "tree rape" sequence from Sam Raimi's horror classic.