MCU What If...? - Every Episode Ranked From Worst To Best

The MCU's most inconsistent series so far...

By Scott Banner /

Phase Four has been something of a new beginning for the Marvel Cinematic Universe. With the Infinity Saga now in the rear view mirror, and many of the biggest heroes of the previous three phases now out of action, the franchise can be taken in a much different direction than ever before.

Advertisement

One of the biggest changes is that the MCU has branched out into the world of limited series on Disney+, and in the case of the fourth outing on the streaming platform, animation.

Bringing back an impressive cast from the MCU past, What If…? boasts the kind of talent most projects can only dream of, and with a new animation style, paired with The Watcher chronicling the very different versions of events that happen across the multiverse, there was a lot to be excited about for this completely unique series.

Now that the dust has settled, and Marvel Studios has put out all nine episodes, each different outing can be compared to those around it. There was some truly spectacular Marvel Cinematic Universe content within this series, but there were also those rarest of times when the franchise missed the mark.

9. What If... Killmonger Rescued Tony Stark?

In theory, this episode could have, and should have been great. It was the only one to feature Tony Stark for more than a cameo, it brought back one of the franchise’s greatest ever antagonists in Erik Killmonger, and had the chance to explore Wakanda once more. However, this episode was far from what it could have been.

Advertisement

The story itself felt rushed, and made little sense at times. After Killmonger saved Tony he decided to hire him as his head of security. This was fine, but when he uncovered that Obadiah was the one who tried to have him killed, why did he automatically offer him Stane’s old COO job, despite having zero business acumen or experience? It seemed that this episode didn’t actually care about the story so much as getting to the end where Killmonger became the Black Panther. This was the endgame, and it almost didn’t matter how we arrived there.

It may have previously been unthought of in the MCU, but Tony Stark actually detracted from this episode. Without his life changing attack, he was incredibly entitled and annoying, and too much of this was definitely a bad thing. Not to mention that, although Mick Wingert didn’t do an terrible job as Tony Stark, he certainly wasn’t Robert Downey Jr.

All this paired with poor action sequences, particularly compared to what the show achieved in other episodes, and a final battle between Wakanda and America that didn’t feel earned, made for an episode that was, for lack of a better word, boring.

8. What If... Thor Were An Only Child?

It’s not too unreasonable to suggest that the first two Thor movies made it the most boring franchise within the MCU. Thankfully, Taika Waititi came in and turned it completely around with Ragnarok, injecting more than a little humour into a character that had lacked it for the previous six years.

Advertisement

In the What If…? episode based around Thor, however, Marvel leaned into this humour far too much. It was almost as if they were trying too hard to make it as funny as possible, and the episode suffered for it. Thor just came off as a spoiled brat in an episode that had little to no actual substance.

Like the Killmonger episode the week before, episode seven seemed to be more focused on introducing the new version of Thor rather than actually telling a compelling or strong story. The God of Thunder’s fight with Captain Marvel took up a big chunk of the episode, which was something MCU fans had wanted to see for a while, but this wasn’t enough to excuse a lack of any real narrative.

While it was too silly at times, and never particularly deep, it was at least a lot of big dumb fun. Though not what fans of the series had necessarily come to expect at this point, this at least was something. That and seeing Loki in his true Jotun form.

7. What If... Captain Carter Were The First Avenger?

With the first episode of What If…?, the MCU brought to Disney+ yet another series unique and unlike anything seen in the franchise previously. This chapter detailed Peggy Carter taking the super soldier serum instead of Steve Rogers, and though the Captain Carter character herself was fantastic, the episode around her felt somewhat underwhelming.

Advertisement

Hayley Atwell gave another strong performance in the MCU as per usual, and the animation style was excellent. However, for a ‘what if’ story, the narrative felt rather basic. The episode was essentially a retelling of The First Avenger, with a few details altered.

Much of the story had been seen before, and with the series’ first outing for all intents and purposes trying to fit an entire movie’s worth of events into half an hour, the pacing felt incredibly rushed, like it was simply a race to the finish line.

There were also several disappointing performances in the voice acting department from MCU alums that you wouldn’t tend to expect it from. Sebastian Stan has been a joy to watch every time he has appeared on screen in the franchise, however for this episode of What If…? it felt like he was at completely at the other end of the spectrum.

6. What If... The World Lost Its Mightiest Heroes?

Throughout What If…?, there were some incredibly dark moments and episodes that would only be possible outside of the main MCU continuity. The first of these was episode three, as Tony Stark, Thor, Clint Barton, Bruce Banner, and Natasha Romanoff were all murdered in cold blood.

Advertisement

Revisiting the events of The Incredible Hulk, Iron Man 2, and Thor, the spotlight was put on Nick Fury’s big week and the story that came out of it was compelling from start to finish, if not as spectacular as some of the other episodes. Seeing some of the MCU’s greatest heroes fall, and the mystery behind who could do such a thing kept audiences guessing until the very end.

The episode itself of course wasn’t perfect. In a similar complaint to many of these episodes, the pacing felt very rushed. There was a lot to get through and unpack in this chapter, and to fit it all into half an hour meant going at a hundred miles an hour.

Scarlett Johansson was also definitely missed in the Natasha Romanoff role, but all things considered, this was a strong, above average outing in the series.

5. What If... T'Challa Became A Star-Lord?

If the first episode of the series was disappointing because it didn’t really live up to the expectation or potential of a ‘what if’ story, episode two more than made up for it. T’Challa becoming Star Lord had a huge effect on the entire universe, and it resulted in a story that was brand new and completely unseen.

Advertisement

Spinning off from the titular question, the episode also asked and answered what would happen if Thanos gave up his infinity quest, and introduced some fun new takes on classic MCU characters that wouldn’t have even been dreamed of before.

The entire episode, in fact, was just a lot of fun. The tone was unmistakably reminiscent of the Guardians of the Galaxy franchise, with the same humour, vibrant colours, and outer space adventures that made James Gunn’s movies so popular. It struck a great balance between classic Marvel humour, fantastic action sequences, and a surprising storyline.

The greatest part of this episode however, was without question the performance of the late Chadwick Boseman. This posthumous appearance of the great actor was incredibly bittersweet, as he gave as good a performance as ever as T’Challa, with the same eloquence and grace as in live action.

4. What If... Zombies!?

The majority of the first season of What If…? on Disney+ looked at past MCU events, and tweaked them ever so slightly, showing the colossal ripple effect they could have throughout the multiverse. Though this episode did the same, as Hank Pym brought back a zombie virus from the Quantum Realm, this was very much inspired by a fan favourite story from the comics.

Advertisement

Like some of the best episodes of this series, this was an incredibly dark story. Almost every Avenger was turned into a zombie, with the exception of Vision, who Marvel still managed to kill in a different way, Scott, who was just a head in a jar, T’Challa, who had part of himself fed to zombie Wanda, and Peter Parker.

Against that however, it could be argued that there was a touch too much comedy, mainly coming from the likes of Scott Lang and Happy Hogan, and that less would have been more in this particular department. Despite this being the overwhelming criticism to come from the episode, it delivered everything that was promised, with an interesting story, genuine horror moments, and some stunning visuals.

Once again, though he was only in it for a relatively short time, the standout of the episode was Chadwick Boseman. His words about death not being the end were not only a comfort to Peter and Scott on board the Quadjet, but were poignant for the entire world watching and missing the actor himself.

3. What If... Doctor Strange Lost His Heart Instead Of His Hands?

Hank Pym murdering the Avengers was dark, and seeing the Earth covered with flesh eating zombies was possibly darker, but there was no episode quite so dark as episode four. Seeing Doctor Strange lose his heart instead of his hands was the potentially the darkest the MCU has ever gone.

Advertisement

Such a change of pace from the jovial norm of the franchise was more than welcome, as Stephen Strange spiraled down into a descent of madness and heart ache. This was yet another showing from Marvel Studios exactly what lengths grief can drive people to.

The story itself was compelling, heartbreaking, and like any good ‘what if’ scenario, completely unique and different from anything seen previously in the MCU. Doctor Strange is an incredibly powerful sorcerer, and seeing what he could achieve should he ever turn his talents to darker magic was truly eye opening.

What made this chapter of the series even stronger was the completely unexpected ending. The original Doctor Strange was pitted against his now evil counterpart, but instead of the good guy prevailing as we are trained to believe will happen in every superhero story, he was simply absorbed too. Even this couldn’t stop the universe from ending, as everything around Strange, including Christine, melted into a black goo in the most shocking ending of all.

2. What If... The Watcher Broke His Oath?

Episode nine of What If…? was the big season finale that brought together the stories from all the previously separate episodes to give the MCU’s first foray into animation an explosive, satisfying ending. There can be few who could doubt that this was achieved, and then some.

Advertisement

The Watcher selected his recruits from across the multiverse, bringing together some of the best characters from throughout the series to fight Ultron. Coming off the back of the previous eight episodes, there was little need for any exposition or introduction, allowing the episode to dive almost immediately into the action.

The Guardians of the Multiverse gave some incredible new team dynamics with the likes of Captain Carter and Natasha Romanoff, and Doctor Strange and the Watcher, and with the entire episode effectively being the final act of the story, there was plenty of room for some incredible action pieces, and stunning visuals.

One or two of the Guardians themselves did feel surplus to requirements, and without her own episode coming before her, Gamora was afforded almost zero development. However, it was a fantastic ending to the series, the action was awe inspiring as any final battle should be, and it brought everything to a satisfying conclusion. It just wasn’t quite as good as the episode that set it up…

1. What If... Ultron Won?

After the success of The Avengers in 2012, Age of Ultron three years later failed to live up to the expectations set for it. What If…? however, took the concept, tweaked the tiniest detail of Ultron succeeding in occupying his new vibranium body, and it turned into something truly incredible.

Advertisement

This was another dark episode in a dystopian future created by Ultron, something far more similar to the story arc of the comics. Natasha and Clint’s journey to trying to save the world was great to watch, and the latter's sacrifice was nothing short of stunning, but it was Jeffrey Wright’s Watcher that stole the show.

After seven weeks of standing by, resisting the urge to intervene, the Watcher was forced into action by the Infinity Stone powered Ultron. The battle the two had throughout the multiverse was one of the greatest action pieces of the entire series, with two insanely powered gods kicking the hell out of each other, and the series finally properly utilizing the talents of Jeffrey Wright.

The episode was essentially part one of the incredible What If…? finale, and set up the Guardians of the Multiverse’s battle with Ultron in episode nine. However, even as a standalone episode, this was stunning.

Advertisement