After nine long years, How I Met Your Mother is coming to an end in just four weeks, finally concluding Ted's hilarious and sometimes frustrating long story of how he met his wife. It is exciting to be in the home stretch after so long. It is also strange, despite how much viewers already know regarding the ending of the story, such as who The Mother is and where and when they actually meet, how many questions there are still left to answer. One question which has grown significantly in the last few years has regarded the fate of The Mother. Several theories have been floating around about why exactly Ted is telling this story to his children, pointing to various supposed clues as to what happens in the future. The latest episode, 'Vesuvius', dropped a potentially major hint about where The Mother is while Ted is telling this story to his kids. Could it be a legitimate hint or, as Carter Bays and Craig Thomas love to do, a red herring to draw viewers away from what will really happen? Here are four possible outcomes to How I Met Your Mother's grand finale in just a few short weeks.
4. The Mother Is Dead
The most obvious theory fans have discussed for years is the possibility that The Mother has passed away by 2030. Speculation around this theory grew significantly with last season's 'The Time Traveller's' where Ted gives an impassioned, imaginary speech to The Mother in the video above. What aroused suspicion of this monologue was Ted's plea of wanting an extra 45 days with The Mother and his pledge to love her "to the end of my days and beyond." This could imply something has happened to her in the future, making Ted want those extra days with her. 'Vesuvius' seemingly reinforced this theory with a moment where The Mother says to Ted in 2024 "What mother wouldn't be at her daughter's wedding?", a remark Ted had a strong emotional reaction to, hinting she will not be around for their daughter's wedding. If The Mother has passed away, it would certainly explain why Ted is telling his kids the story of how they met, especially in such a long drawn out manner. He wants them to understand their mother was one of a kind and they were meant to be together despite the short amount of time they shared. It would also explain why Ted has only referred to The Mother in the past tense. One problem with this theory, though, is how exasperated the kids are when Ted begins the story, sarcastically asking if they're being punished. If their mother passed away, wouldn't they want to know more about her and how their parents met?
3. They Live Happily Ever After
Since the kids are exasperated only by the slow pace and seeming random story threads Ted is telling, the more obvious conclusion is The Mother is alive and well in 2030. Fans have pointed out how Ted only speaks of her in the past tense, but this is not entirely uncommon when people talk about a person who is out of the room in real life. The kids wouldn't be so callous if The Mother was either dead or dying. Perhaps, as some fans theorize, she passed away several years before, healing some of the wounds the children would have, but this is also a very uncharacteristic trait for children to have about a parental loss. The Mother could very well be alive in 2030, simply out for groceries or saving the world from poverty. A possible reason for Ted's brief emotional breakdown might be because his own mother passed before his wedding and didn't get to know The Mother and their grandchildren really well. Granted, the evidence seems to be tipping the other way at the moment, but much of that is pure speculation. Perhaps The Mother was even sick at one point, but lived through it and got better? Maybe they only had a health scare and Ted is simply happy to have her in his life still? Or perhaps an entirely different fate awaits them.
2. Ted Has/Is Developing Alzheimer's
A noteworthy theme throughout 'Vesuvius' was about stories. Ted and The Mother have apparently shared every story about their lives with each other, becoming an old married couple who repeat them over and over again. After beginning a story they think she doesn't know, The Mother admits to Ted that she worries about him becoming the guy who lives in his old stories, reliving the glory days rather than moving forward and making new ones. Ted seems shocked that she knows all his stories, finishing them long before he gets to the punchline, but could this have a deeper clue? Maybe Ted is going through early stages of Alzheimer's and has simply kept repeating his stories to The Mother enough times that she knows them off by heart. Her comment about living in his stories might act as foreshadowing as he's bound to confuse when and where he is. Interestingly, after they realize she knows the story of Lily and Robin's fight, he asks her to finish it. Could this be a lovey-dovey moment or maybe he can't remember how it ends? Perhaps the reason Ted is telling the kids such a prolonged version of how he met their mother is because he wants them to remember every detail before he completely forgets. Let's remember Ted has already forgotten many details or mixed up stories throughout the series as well. At the moment this is a far-fetched theory, but one which holds a certain thematic quality to it as Ted has always loved telling stories. If he has or develops Alzheimer's, his wife's warning will become a very stark reality where he literally relives his old stories in a very Notebook fashion. It may seem morbid, but certainly not as morbid as the final theory.
1. Ted Is Dying
Though the story leads up to Ted meeting The Mother, it has largely been about Ted's life and his quest to find success in both his romantic and professional life. He's making absolutely sure his children know everything about him because Ted is the one who is ill, not The Mother. A possible clue to this is the same 45 day speech he gives to The Mother. At the end he says "I will always love you. To the end of my days and beyond," putting a very interesting emphasis on the last sentence. If Ted is dying, it also gives a very valid reason for his emotional breakdown in 'Vesuvius' because he and The Mother know he may very well not live long enough to his daughter's wedding. His need to live in his old stories could partially be explained in this episode as The Mother tells him life only moves forward, but he's afraid of the future and leaving his family behind. Another telling scene is Ted commenting on how the feeling of being with the gang for the last time was too intense to deal with, that it was best, as The Mother put it, to "leave it unspoken and just enjoy each others company", clearly hinting at a deeper understanding between the pair. A problem with this theory is if Ted was ill in 2024, wouldn't the kids know before 2030? Perhaps he briefly recovered from whatever illness he had only for it to come back a few years later and plans on telling the kids once the story is done. Either way, it seems Ted or The Mother may not live past 2030, giving their tale a bittersweet ending. Knowing Carter Bays and Craig Thomas' love for red herrings though, this could be an elaborate trick to get the audience guessing only to surprise them with something completely different and unexpected. How I Met has thrived on these plot twists before so it would be no surprise to see Bays and Thomas with one last ace up their sleeves.