Red Dwarf: Every Series Ranked From Worst To Best

It's cold outside, there's no kind of atmosphere. I'm all alone, more or less.

By Mik Furie /

BBC

You'll never hear such melancholy lyrics sung as cheerfully as in the Red Dwarf theme song. Like so much about the programme, it's something quite sad and lonely yet produced in such a way that it comes across as almost joyous.

Advertisement

And that's the thing about Red Dwarf; for all the jokes, the smegs, and the silliness, the story it tells is as dark as it comes. A normal man is flung into the far future where loneliness and desperation are as much his companions as a humanoid cat and a hologram of his superior officer. Much of the sometimes very silly, often very clever, humour comes from playing in this dark space, exploring the things the Boys From The Dwarf do to stay sane, and how their enforced camaraderie has somehow grown stronger than true friendship.

Still holding the record for the longest-running and highest-rated comedy on BBC2, 21 years after the last new episode aired on that channel, and recently having a revival on Dave, Red Dwarf has barely a weak episode amongst its thirteen seasons. That's going to make ranking them difficult but Space Core Directive 451 says we have to smeggin' try.

14. Back To Earth

The concept of Back To Earth is interesting - a female version of (clue is in the title) Back To Reality's despair squid has captured them and is inducing hallucinations filled with joyous events that keep them occupied while it prepares to feed on them. The execution of the story is another matter entirely.

Advertisement

Dave, a UK channel that mostly airs reruns, had commissioned more Red Dwarf after ten years of the show being off the air. Finding them having to work around the actors' other commitments (notably Craig Charles was filming Coronation Street at the time, and several actors from that appear as themselves in Back To Earth), the story brought the boys from the Dwarf to our Earth. Faced with the idea that they were fictional characters here, they came across their own actors as well as fan club oddities such as the Starbug car.

There's a lot to like about Back To Earth, and some of the clever continuity and science fiction that Red Dwarf is known for. It's just a shame that it never really feels like the show until the third episode.

13. Red Dwarf USA

Described by Craig Charles as White Dwarf for its overwhelmingly caucasian cast, the two pilots for Red Dwarf USA are amongst the most sought after and maligned episodes in the history of the show.

Advertisement

Casting Craig Bierko as Lister changed the character considerably and was emblematic of the problems for most fans. Far from the hamster-faced, slobby, loveable loser, we now had a traditional American hero archetype fronting the show. "I've still got that library book!" the British Lister exclaims when he finds out he's been in stasis for three million years, showing that he's got some serious fines coming his way if the library somehow still exists. In the American version, Lister says that his baseball cards will be worth a fortune, chalking one up in the win column for him.

This fundamental misunderstanding of what the show should be for American audiences and a lack of faith from the network meant that, when Grant and Naylor finally had their shot to break into the USA, the funding was mostly wasted on a version that didn't work and needed heavy rewrites just to make it even feel like Red Dwarf.

12. Series 11 & Series 12

Series 11 and 12 very much belong together on this list. Not only were they filmed back to back, making them effectively one long series, but they have the same level of overall quality to them. This includes some frustrating shortcomings that fans had hoped the show would grow out of by now.

Advertisement

Episodes like Samsara and Can Of Worms continue series 10's worrying trend of relying on rehashes of old ideas in slightly new ways, and one of the funniest scenes in both series is a remake of the "Everybody's dead, Dave" scene from the first episode.

While the humour is as spot-on for its demographic as it ever was, some of the stories suffer from a problem that plagued the early series of the show. These seem to finish without a proper resolution or a rushed ending that has yet to conclude the tale, sometimes with a hail of bazookoid fire cutting down a creature they'd been running from for the meat of the episode.

Still funny, and the boys still shine as their characters (even Robert's Kryten make-up looks a lot less creepy than in series 10), but this is Dwarf by the numbers and it shows.

11. Smeg Ups

There was a trend in the 90s of American shows putting some of their bloopers at the end of episodes to show how much fun the cast had filming the episode. Red Dwarf took that one step further by releasing a video (later, DVD) of their bloopers called Smeg Ups.

Advertisement

By this time, the group was so tightly knit that they knew how to blow off steam and relieve tension in scenes. They knew how to play to the live studio audience and get them riled up for scenes in the show by joking around with each other and playing with the odd circumstances they were currently in.

Every one of the main characters was played by someone with a natural flair for comedy who had learned to play off each other so well that something as simple as make-up leaving a stain could be turned into something hilarious as they worked it into a scene, sometimes breaking the fourth wall and sometimes staying in character.

The full collection of Smeg Ups may not be a series of the show, but any ranking would be remiss if it didn't include them.

10. The Promised Land

The latest fixing of Red Dwarf was only broadcast on April 9th 2020, and it's honestly a really fun ride. The jokes are on point though perhaps grown a little bit since the early days (the past few seasons felt worryingly left behind), and the characterizations were as tight as ever, showing the loneliness these guys feel without ever dropping into melancholy and taking us away from the comedy of a situation.

Advertisement

Taking us back to the Cat species arks that departed Red Dwarf before Lister awoke in The End, we see how the Cat culture surrounding their religious beliefs in Lister as their god have led them to yet another war. Some serious thoughts about theology are hidden amongst the jokes here, and the action scenes are beyond anything Red Dwarf has had a chance to do since it began.

So, why is it so low on this list? Well, first a quick SPOILER WARNING for the rest of this paragraph. The main antagonist is revealed to be Cat's brother despite the Cat Arks leaving Red Dwarf hundreds of years earlier. It's a little thing, but this snub to the established continuity will be a major bugbear to most longterm fans.

9. Series 8

Where Series 8 places on this list depends on how you watch it. Watch the series episode to episode and you can have it right here. However, if you go into the DVD settings you'll find the option to watch two of the storylines as movies. Watch the series in this way and you can swap it with the series just ahead of this.

Advertisement

Back In The Red plays a lot better in this mode, as all three episodes are chained together and slightly recut. No longer needing to make sense as single episodes, they fit together a lot better as a single feature-length story. While Pete doesn't go through quite as many improvements when the two-parter is watched this way, simply removing the credits between the episodes allows for the comedy behind the boys constant visits to long-suffering Captain Hollister's office to ramp up as planned.

Gambles were taken in reintroducing the crew and putting the boys in a new situation in series 8, and not all of them paid off. While far from the best of Red Dwarf, this is still miles ahead of most other comedy of the time.

8. Series 10

After the travesty that was Back To Earth, fans didn't know what to expect when Dave announced series 10, but we needn't have worried. What we got were effects that could finally realize the vision of the show, alongside a mish-mash of episodes that, while not quite a return to form, were still better than anyone expected.

Advertisement

So many of the jokes, and even episode concepts, seemed to be rehashed from earlier seasons but with a more modern spin on them. It almost seemed like the original plan was for a movie that recreates some of the classic Red Dwarf stories and jokes, and that was changed to a new season at the last moment.

This is especially true of the last episode that seems almost like a movie finale. Here we see Rimmer finding out more about his past, and finally coming to terms with himself as a person. The episode showcases not just how far the characters have come on their journey, but how much the show itself has evolved from its original concept. It's no surprise that many fans consider The Beginning as the perfect send-off for the boys.

"The slime's coming home."

7. Series 7

Series 7 is when Dwarf went through its most drastic changes. Co-creator Rob Grant moved on to other projects and Doug Naylor, wanting to continue working towards an eventual movie, made moves to improve the series throughout. Film quality and visual effects were drastically improved, and the episode count increased. However, not all the changes were welcomed by fans.

Advertisement

Chris Barrie, fatigued by the shooting schedule and offered other shows, left this season and his character was written out as the next incarnation of the multiversal hero Ace Rimmer. In his place we got an alternate dimensional version of Lister's long-term love, Kochanski.

Originally played by Claire Grogan, the casting of Chloe Annett in the role seemed another step too far for fans at the time, and Chloe started the role having to prove herself as a very different Kochanski.

But the most jarring change came from the way the series was filmed. The cast were used to playing much of the episodes in front of fans, playing off them in almost an audience-participation effort. The lack of that audience shows in series 7, and it diminishes the episodes throughout the series.

6. Series 1

"Lister, D, third technician. Offence: obstructing a superior technician by humming, clicking, and being quiet."

Originally conceived as The Odd Couple in space, and playing off some very real animosity between Chris Barrie and Craig Charles at the time, Red Dwarf started as a slower-paced show experimenting to see what worked and what didn't. A very different show from what followed, this laid the foundations that future seasons built upon so magnificently.

Advertisement

Future episodes of Red Dwarf would show that the comedy series has as strong a grasp of the science fiction elements as any serious sci-fi of the time, but it was well-named Future Echoes that first showed this off. Confidence & Paranoia is one of the first to show off Red Dwarf's interest in personified psychological aspects; a concept that would be revisited multiple times throughout the different series.

Waiting For God takes us to visit one of the last surviving Felis Sapiens on board and dips its toe into theology on the way. And the episodes Balance Of Power and Me² show us just how insecure Rimmer actually is, to the point that he literally cannot live with himself.

"Look out Earth, the slime's coming home!"

5. Series 2

Finding themselves limited with stories solely set on the mining ship, the writers introduced ways to get the boys to different planets, realities and time periods. A stasis leak took them back in time, and the Holly Hop Drive took them to a parallel universe where they met a female Holly of all things.

Advertisement

Then there was the total immersion video game Better Than Life that provides the perfect world for users (which may not be that good for someone like Rimmer who hates himself). Finally, Blue Midget was introduced as a shuttle in this series to allow the boys some more freedom.

The first episode is notable for introducing Kryten (here played by David Ross) to the show, although he'd leave at the end of his episode and only return from series 3 onwards. And the brilliant but underrated Queeg ("We are talking jape of the decade") is always fun.

But it's Thanks For The Memory that really hits it out of the park. Starting with a party, we follow a mystery and see our characters becoming a lot more well-rounded throughout. Oddly moving and just as funny as the others, this is the standout episode of the series.

4. Series 6

The series arc introduced in series 6 saw the boys having lost Red Dwarf and Holly along with it. Trapped in Starbug, the four main cast members went through monster of the week episodes with some surprising continuity to them.

Advertisement

When Starbug was upgraded with weapons and armour or Rimmer was given a physical form through a hard light bee, those changes stayed with the show through the end of the season and beyond.

The series is a bit of a mixed bag, between those that are good but seem to be leftover ideas from older episodes (Psirens, Emohawk, Rimmerworld) to the great (Legion and Out Of Time), but it's the outstanding Gunmen Of The Apocalypse that brought the show an Emmy, and with good reason.

The BBC, believing the script to be too costly and time-consuming to film, sent a memo to shut down the episode's production. By the time the crew got that memo, they'd wrapped and preproduction had already begun. It's genuinely amazing what they pulled off with the BBC's shoestring budget. While the western town isn't fully realized, it feels it and Gunmen expertly plays off both video game and western film tropes throughout.

3. Series 3

Series 3 was when the BBC first realised they'd got a hit on their hands and started shoveling more money into the show. The bland sets were replaced and expanded upon, Blue Midget was replaced with the more iconic Starbug, the basic costumes were upgraded, Robert Llewellyn was introduced as a returning Kryten, and Hattie Hayridge took over from Norman Lovett as Holly.

Advertisement

The new budget brought with it the opportunity to add creatures, though Grant & Naylor's belief that alien life would derail the show caused them to introduce Genetically Engineered Life Forms. Supposedly created by mankind as a labour force, the first of these GELFs we meet is a Polymorph in the episode of the same name that riffs off the film Alien.

Fantastic moments fill series 3, from everything about Backwards to Body Swap's characterisations, but there's one episode that stands above all the others. Ironically something that could have been included in the simpler early series, Marooned traps Lister with Rimmer in a crashed Starbug, and is basically a half-hour conversation between the two. Filled with great stories, charming wit, gross food, and a lot of heart, this is what Red Dwarf does best.

2. Series 4

It's hard to find fault with 1991's series 4 as every episode is amongst the best that Red Dwarf had to offer, and the world of the Dwarf is built up in ways that put some more serious sci-fi shows to shame.

Advertisement

Simulants were introduced for the first time as an antithesis of androids like Kryten, while at the other end of the insane droid spectrum we saw something terrible happening to Winnie The Pooh. Another parallel universe was shown with the unlikeliest of heroes ("Smoke me a kipper, I'll be back for breakfast") and the guys all met their perfect partners in a riff on Casablanca. We even watched causality going mad in this writer's favourite episode of the entire show.

Every episode would be a standout in any other show, but it's DNA that has some of the most memorable scenes in the series. From Kryten's double polaroid moment to Robo-Lister fighting a curry monster with the help of the only thing that can kill a vindaloo, and his subsequent meal.

Series 4 is almost as good as Red Dwarf gets, and it'd take something smegging great to top it.

1. Series 5

Relying heavily on Chris Barrie's comic skills and some truly classic storylines, series 5 is as perfect as it ever got for Red Dwarf and anyone who argues is going to make Mr Flibble very cross.

Advertisement

Early on Red Dwarf had displayed an interest in psychology, sometimes personifying different emotions and lack of emotions in interesting and always funny ways, but series 5 was the one to take that idea and really run with it. While all the cast had a chance to show different sides to their characters in the wonderful Demons & Angels, it's Rimmer who the series seems focused on. Holoship and Terrorform both give us a look at a character far more rounded than he first appeared, and his admission in The Inquisitor is nothing short of heartbreaking.

But it's Back To Reality that's the standout episode here. A concept so good it could have been saved for a Red Dwarf movie, this painted the boys as a bunch of smegheads who've been bumbling around a video game for four years. While everyone remembers Dwayne Dibbley, it's Timothy Spall who shines brightest in this episode despite having a real hard time filming it.

"What a bunch of twonks!"
Advertisement