Riverdale: Ranking Every Character From Worst To Best
Which Riverdale characters 'ascended' their way into our hearts, and which ones to failed to do so?
Riverdale has been a fixture of TV for nearly three years now. During that time, it has bewitched, baffled and bewildered its fans with its apparently endless supply of wacky storylines and off-the-wall concepts (many of which really do beggar belief). Aside from all of that, it's also a unique twist on the Archie Comics series and it is undoubtedly one of the most aesthetically-pleasing shows on television.
Of course, no show is complete without memorable characters and it goes without saying that Riverdale's abundance of truly unique personalities sets it apart from anything else on our screens.
A unique (there's that word again) spin on some of Archie Comics' most famous characters, the show is led by its core four teenagers Archie Andrews, Jughead Jones, Betty Cooper and Veronica Lodge - all of whom embark on secret missions to discover whatever mysteries lie in Riverdale's grim history (and, you know, unmask serial killers and Gargoyle Kings along the way). Though not every character has gone down as well as these four, they're all memorable in their own way.
From Gryphon Queens to Gargoyle Kings and corrupt business dealers to demented cult leaders, Riverdale has been incredibly ambitious when it comes to characters. With that in mind, let's take a look back at every major one of them and, while we're at it, rank them.
27. Hiram Lodge
Hiram Lodge was more convincing as the ghastly presence that hung over Season 1 than he ever was as an actual character. The reason for that is down to the fact that he never changes and ultimately never learns. And this isn't the same as the likes of Archie Andrews who just repeats the same mistakes over and over again, it's much worse than that as the writers seem to think that Hiramis only capable of playing one role: Villain.
He was never great, but at least in Season 2 he had purpose. However, when he was finally defeated by our core four, he wasn't changed or written out; he was instead relegated to secondary villain status and has been irrelevant ever since.
Better yet, he constantly attempts to pull the same old one-dimensional evil villain rubbish that he's been pulling since his arrival and it's just not interesting anymore. Hiram is a caricature and the longer this goes on for, the more screen time he wastes.
Mark Consuelos is both brilliant and convincing in the role and it's a joy to see him bring some of the other aspects of Hiram's personality to life. Unfortunately, the writers just aren't interested in exploring that as, every time he has an intriguing moment (making amends with Archie, showing genuine emotion after Hermione's attempts to kill him), he instantly reverts back to his boring old villainous ways. And now, we have to endure yet another season of one-dimensional daddy goes dark. Yay.
26. Charles Smith
Considering that Betty's and Jughead's long-lost half-brother was long-considered to be, well, dead (due to Chic's impersonation of him), it was rather disappointing when he just quietly turned up to assist the pair with their investigation into The Farm in the Season 3 finale - robbing us all of family reunions and dynamics we were waiting on.
Though Wyatt Nash does a great job with what he's given (it also helps that Charles looks like he inherited all the dreamy genes from both Alice and FP), the character has yet to interact with his mother on-screen and rarely interacts with half-brother Jughead.
There's more to Charles than meets the eye, so there's definitely room for growth here but as his existence was such a long-running storyline, we kind of expected more from his arrival.
25. Edgar Evernever
The third season's never-ending Farm storyline had run its course long before the cult's leader Edgar Evernever made his first on-screen appearance, but when he finally did, we sat up and paid attention. Now, that could have had something to do with the fact that he looked like Chad Michael Murray, but it was certainly somewhat intriguing getting to know this enigmatic leader.
While he was conveniently one step ahead a little too many times, Murray's performance brought the character to life and ensured that all eyes were on him whenever he was on-screen. Though Riverdale's constant knack for thinking too big undercut much of his storyline, Edgar wasn't the worst part about it... and that in itself is a huge victory.
24. Polly Cooper
Betty's sister, Polly was at the center of the show's debut mystery as it was her relationship with Jason Blossom that ultimately resulted in the latter's father killing him - robbing her of a life with her one true love and her unborn babies of their father. Naturally, she found herself stuck in the middle of the aftermath, as the involved families wrestled for control of her and the twins.
Betty's intervention resulted in her clawing her way out of that hell, and it would have been better if the show had just written her out then and there because, in all honesty, what came next for the character is both insignificant and infuriating.
Called upon by the writers to show up and turn Betty's life upside down whenever they want her to, Polly became less like herself with each passing scene, spouting mindless rubbish about The Farm and then even turning on her sister because she spoke ill of Edgar Evernever. Though it could have seemed plausible with character development, it wasn't to be and, as a result, Polly has been reduced to nothing more than a plot device that just doesn't make sense anymore.
23. Hal Cooper
The very definition of a useless father, Hal Cooper moaned and groaned his way through the first season as he collided with Alice and his children over just about everything. From "Listen to your mother Betty" to his refusal to listen to his own children, he was very much a caricature of an indifferent father from decades-gone-by.
However, he then received a bit of an origin-rewrite when the show decided to have him become the murderous Black Hood. While it certainly made Hal a more interesting character, the problem here was that he wasn't all that interesting to begin with, so if the show hoped that he would suddenly become more enticing just because he was a serial killer, it isn't hard to see why the played-out narrative flopped in the end. Throw in the fact that he became even more one-dimensional in Season 3 and, well, you get the point.
From cardboard cutout to caricature (and back again), Hal Cooper should have been more of a well-rounded character to begin with, but the lack of solid foundations made him the show's least interesting villain so far.
22. Sheriff Keller
Even though Tom Keller is no longer sheriff of Riverdale, he will forever be known as Sheriff Keller. Now that could be down to the fact that he hasn't been given that much to do outside of his officer of the law duties, but it's also due to his unflinching heroism and kind heart.
His relationship with Sierra McCoy may have been a little underdeveloped but at least it resulted in some decent character development. But his greatest asset is undoubtedly the loving relationship he has with his son Kevin - something that hasn't been significantly explored in far too long.
Like many of Riverdale's secondary characters, there is potential here for more. Let's just hope that we actually see that more take place (and aren't just told about it).
21. Ethel Muggs
When Ethel made her debut on Riverdale, most of us were glad to see 'Barb from Stranger Things' get some justice (which was portrayed in the show's on-the-nose but ingenious 'Justice For Ethel' storyline). Though she isn't a regular part of the show, she does pop up from time to time and every time she's on-screen, Shannon Purser's endearing performance allows her to shine.
Unfortunately, like with so many others, the character's somewhat increased role in the third season resulted in her becoming one of the show's most infuriating, as she led the Gryphons & Gargoyles brigade, spouting endless babble about ascending and the Gargoyle King.
Had this list been written before Season 3, then Ethel Muggs may have been quite a bit higher as she was actually involved in a number of meaningful storylines. But alas, the year of the Gargoyle King and/or The Farm struck again.
20. Chic
Betty's search for her long-lost brother eventually resulted in her crossing paths with the person who convinced her that he was Charles. A tortured soul with demons that he refused to reveal, Chic had the entire Cooper family fooled (with the exception of Hal who never believed him to be Charles) but it didn't take long for Betty to deduce that something was off about him.
It's hard to sum up Chic's time on the show because so much of it was filled with ambiguity. Yes, parts of his attempts to get one over on Betty got incredibly repetitive (as did Alice's refusal to see him for who he was) but we'll chalk that all that up to the writers intentionally portraying him like that.
Why Riverdale's two most intrepid reporters weren't asking more questions about him is baffling, but for the most part, Chic succeeded as an unnerving red herring in the search for Charles. Though the fact that the culmination of the year-long "is he dead or not?" question merely resulted in him being revealed as a pawn Gargoyle King in Penelope Blossom's scheme was a disappointment, Chic had his moments over the course of his time on the show and remained one of the only remotely consistent things about Season 2.
More than anything though, Hart Denton did a fantastic job bringing this chilling character to life.
19. Evelyn Evernever
Originally introduced as Edgar Evernever's devoted daughter, Farm recruiter Evelyn was obsessed with, well, recruiting people to The Farm. An in-your-face character of the highest degree, she was the kind of person that would be nice to your face only to stab you in the back - which makes sense considering she was masquerading as Edgar's daughter when she was actually his wife.
Evelyn's sole purpose was devotion to The Farm so, unlike some of the other characters on this list, she completely got away with being infuriating. Her behaviour was indeed off-the-wall but it was consistently off-the-wall and, as a result, it felt totally believable. She was the kind of character you just wanted Betty to punch in the face - and not because she was behaving out of character, because she was behaving totally in character.
ZoƩ de Grand'Maison did a fantastic job as Evelyn, making sure that she came across every bit as invasive and unnerving as the writers wanted her to. Was Evelyn an annoying character? Absolutely. But she was supposed to be - and, believe it or not, that's what made her one of The Farm's only bearable characters.