First, there was the legend of the Doctor. And then, there was the man that revived him. Russell T Davies put a shiny new spin on one of Britain's most hallowed institutions. Gone were the Time Lords, the cardboard-cutout creatures, and in swaggered Christopher Eccleston, fresh from war and donned an awful lot more sensibly than Tom Baker was, with his infinite scarf. But when Davies left, his successor was a fans' favourite, critically acclaimed for every one of his episodes thus far. Moffat brought a younger Doctor, bigger twists and a much more complicated story arc with him; gone were the days of David Tennant sprinting through the streets of London, replaced by Matt Smith bouncing from one space station to the next. We are forever in Davies's debt for him bringing back the show. Does that play a part in the criticism of Moffat though? We certainly don't owe him as much. Who is the better writer anyway? Well, they're both entirely different. I don't expect us to find a unanimous outcome from this debate, but let's study Moffat and Davies on twelve points to decide who we prefer. Which side do you favour? Comment below, but remember this is a friendly discussion; I'm focussing on the strengths of the writers, not putting anyone down.
Opening Episodes
Both Davies and Moffat gave action-packed opening episodes of their tenure ('Rose' and 'The Eleventh Hour' respectively), but Moffat focussed more on the Doctor saving the day, with Davies centring his episode on the companion. Davies's technique recalled 'An Unearthly Child', making Rose the lead in to the show for new fans. He used a classic enemy in the Autons, and set the tale in modern-day London, which set a familiarity for viewers, old and new, which allowed the Doctor to be more enigmatic. Moffat's Doctor however began much more as a charismatic, funny and energetic character; he allowed for Matt Smith to find his feet in the role with a light-hearted opening few scenes before introducing the drama. Another difference was in the TARDIS: Davies went for the classic introduction of Rose walking around the outside in disbelief, while Moffat played more with the idea of a world in a box... Moffat thought inside the box and Davies outside.
Main Themes
Another huge contrast between Moffat and Davies is in their main themes; Moffat's a staunch believer of "Everybody lives", while Davies believes that loss shapes his Doctor as much as his victories. And Davies focussed his series on a more Biblical figure; lonely and powerful, and seeking redemption for ending a war. Moffat's Doctor buries that side of his personality; what's scary about Eleven is how far he could go if you anger him, not what he's done in the past. Another key difference is that the Moff plays with timelines an awful lot more; Davies seems more keen on the spatial aspects - visiting parallel worlds, introducing familiar settings - which draws another nice difference between the two.
Story Arcs
It was a fantastic payoff in Series 1 when the Bad Wolf puzzle fell together in 'The Parting of the Ways'. And throughout his tenure, Davies imbedded code words and subliminal messages that would lead us to finales. Moffat's an awful lot more complex though; his arcs aren't just longer, he overtly introduces mysteries that are needed to be solved, like River and the Doctor's death. There isn't necessarily a mention every episode either, but Moffat's Doctor is always travelling somewhere, to solve something. It's as if Moffat's arcs are more for the Doctor, and Davies's arcs are more for the audience. Nine and Ten have never noticed the arc or knew where they were heading; Eleven is more of a mystery-solving Doctor. You might say that there's a Sherlock Holmes influence in that...
Characterisation
New Who was famously labelled as more character-driven when it returned in 2005. Moffat claims they had to be to make the show "a bit Hollyoaks" to fit in, and thus, a lot of more detail went into character relationships, with the plots of stories staying thin, and easily manageable. That's not to say Davies couldn't handle a plot, he just allowed for more characterisation in his era. The first couple of series focussed a lot on Rose's relationship with the Doctor, which was given time to grow and breathe; Moffat chose however to whisk Amy around all of time and space without paying too much attention to how her and the Doctor reacted to one another. Moffat's Who is an awful lot more in line with the Classic Series in terms of plot-driven story. The Tenth Doctor was given plenty of screen-time for brooding, reminiscing and coming to terms with events; the Eleventh just sort of deals with life on the spot.
Resolutions And Finales
In each of Davies's series finales, a character became god-like to save the day. In Series 1, it was Rose becoming Bad Wolf, in Series 2 the Doctor sent the Daleks to hell, in Series 3 Martha resurrected the Doctor and watched him rise to forgive the Master, and in Series 4, Donna became half-Time Lord. This not only continued the main themes of RTD's Who, it allowed for ordinary people to become amazing and save the day. Moffat allows for his companions however to save the day by seeing things that the Doctor doesn't; Clara was the one who wouldn't let the Doctor use the moment ('The Day of the Doctor'), and Amy realised the Star Whale was helping humanity ('The Beast Below'). And this shows the difference between humanity and alien life. Moffat plants devices and ideas midway through a story that become crucial to saving the day later on, often altering timelines along the way. Davies alternately paints his characters into seemingly impossible positions before digging them out with the big themes of his work.
Comedy
Both Russell T Davies and Steven Moffat are brilliantly hilarious writers, let's make no mistake about that. They often employ really silly humour into their work, and let their actors bring colour to the scripts. Davies's Doctors were knowingly brilliant, and so Davies used this as a point of fun. He also used subtle sarcasm in places ("Donna, you don't know how to change a plug"), as well as using pop culture and dry wit. Moffat's humour though is definitely more zany and often a bit ruder, but fairly similar to the template Davies laid out. Both employ a lot of comedy too; no episode is too sad or serious to slip in the odd joke, and both often include gags to contrast against the darker themes in Who. They're easily the two funniest writers of New Who, aren't they?
Tragedy
Both Moffat and Davies are well-known for the darker, sadder themes in their writing. Neither writer is afraid to write a heartbreakingly sad episode, and both have written tense, eerily dark stories for Doctor Who. Steven Moffat doesn't so much build an episode with sadness, but he does shock his audience with the final reveal that everyone won't live happily ever after ('The Angels Take Manhattan', 'A Good Man Goes to War'). Davies alternately sets up the tragedy to come a lot clearer by foreshadowing it, like when Ten knows he's going to die, and Rose narrates the opening scene of 'Doomsday'. Whilst both writers have delivered tragedy though, Moffat is more of a "happy ending" writer. RTD isn't afraid to end a series in complete despair for the Doctor, and is willing to make him lose everything. Moffat alternately, always ends on something sweet.
Fear Factor
Whilst Steven Moffat is more famous than Davies in terms of scariness, RTD did produce one of the more frightening Tenth Doctor monsters, in the 'Midnight' entity. What was so scary about it was that it was totally unknown, and that it brought the true side out of the entire carriage. Moffat has of course given us the Silence, the Weeping Angels and the Whispermen, as well as the Vashta Nerada - who surely have to return one day - and he wrote one of the series's most frightening episodes in 'The Empty Child'. He's tried to upgrade the Cybermen and show the Daleks in more evil lights too, building Davies's stories, and both writers have done well to show brutal savagery from the Daleks; it's a shame in a way that they're so universally loved, as they'll never be as scary as they once were. Both writers are unafraid of showing the Doctor terrified by his foes too; the scene in 'Asylum of the Daleks' when the intensive unit corner Eleven mirrors Nine's reaction to the last Dalek in 'Dalek'.
Christmas Episodes
A festive tradition of Doctor Who, both Davies and Moffat have mixed reviews from their Christmas episodes. Both however do have a hugely acclaimed one in 'The Christmas Invasion' and 'A Christmas Carol' respectively. 'The Christmas Invasion' not only featured killer santas - that would appear again the following year - but it was overtly Christmassy. Davies seemed to take this approach of centring his stories specifically at Christmas, whereas Moffat's just happen to be set at Christmas; even 'A Christmas Carol' borrows elements from a Seventh Doctor novel that Moffat wrote. Both Davies and Moffat bring out a guest star in their Christmas specials; the former having written a part specifically for Kylie Minogue, and the latter casting Michael Gambon as Kazran Sardick. Again though, Davies uses his stars more to play off David Tennant, and Moffat focusses more on a plot; Christmas episodes are usually good ones to spot tropes from writers, as they're standalone and used to introduce new viewers as well as cater for fans.
Monsters
Whilst Moffat has famously added to the roster of classic Who monsters in the form of the Weeping Angels and the Silence, Russell T Davies hasn't been as prolific. Whilst Davies has introduced creatures like the Slitheen and the Sycorax, he prefers to use known monsters, such as the Daleks, the Master and even the Ood for the familiarity of his audience. This means that when writes a big episode, there's a big, known threat attacking the Doctor, and plenty of interplay between known enemies. Moffat on the other hand plays with the discovery of alien life, and lets the Doctor find out about his enemy as the episode progresses ('The Impossible Astronaut', 'The Time of Angels'). When Moffat uses the Daleks, the Cybermen, and even when he reuses his own creations, he adds to the mythology each time.
Low-Budget
Both Davies and Moffat have written low-budget episodes of Who; Davies has written 'Love & Monsters' and 'Midnight' and Moffat has written 'Blink'. Two of these episodes are Doctor-lite and all three pay less attention to depicting a monster, and more to the threat of evil itself; it's the same in 'The Lodger', an episode produced by Moffat and written by Gareth Roberts. Again, Davies focusses more on the myth of the Doctor when he's not around, and Moffat chooses to convey him as a mystery. Where both writers are similar is that they take the Doctor out of comfort zone, or completely sometimes, meaning that the lack of special effects or flashy location doesn't detract from the enjoyment of the episode.
Regeneration Episode
Discounting 'The Parting of the Ways', - as it wasn't originally a regeneration episode - 'The End of Time' and 'The Time of the Doctor' are actually strikingly different stories in tone and pace. Davies chooses to make his episode the biggest one of Tennant's tenure, whereas Moffat chooses to just tie up all the threads. And where Davies plays the sadness and tragedy of the Doctor dying to epic proportions, Moffat sees it as a triumph that the Doctor can regenerate, and makes 'The Time of the Doctor', in many ways, his biggest victory. Both choose to let their Doctors regenerate in the TARDIS, and both convey the fear of changing; both also show icons from each Doctor's past, but Davies chooses to elongate the goodbye for effect. Which writer do you prefer though? What do you think the strengths of each writer are? Did you click on the link by mistake? Comment below!