Sherlock: 10 Biggest Plot Twists

Every episode of Sherlock had a number of great twists, but which one will make it to the top?

By Jacob Wilkins /

Sherlock was one of the best television shows of the last decade. Thanks to a terrific premise and two phenomenal leads, this modern rendition of Arthur Conan Doyle’s classic detective stories gripped audiences across the globe.

Advertisement

Given the ambition of Steven Moffat, Mark Gatiss, and Stephen Thompson, Sherlock was always a show that kept viewers on their toes. Whilst these three screenwriters may have overstepped the mark from time to time, their scripts were generally accessible as well as complex. Indeed, the respect Sherlock had for its audience’s intelligence was one of its greatest strengths.

Though the show was based on the novels and short stories of Conan Doyle, the series took huge liberties with the source material, and as such, even those familiar with the classic tales of Sherlock Holmes and Dr John Watson were unable to second guess what would happen next.

Consequently, the various plot twists scattered throughout the show were always impactful. Sure, a few of them were a little far-fetched (particularly in the final series), but for the most part, these plot twists were both satisfying and unexpected…

10. It’s All In Sherlock’s Head – The Abominable Bride

Unlike the other twelve episodes of Sherlock, ‘The Abominable Bride’ did not belong to a particular series. However, despite the Victorian setting, it eventually became clear that this one-off special was in fact relevant to the rest of the show.

Advertisement

After almost an hour in Victorian London, ‘The Abominable Bride’ returns sharply to the present day. It is then explained that the case of Emelia Ricoletti is an unsolved mystery stored inside Sherlock’s mind, and that he is aiming to solve said mystery in the hope it will reveal the truth about Moriarty’s death in the present day.

As odd as this plot twist is, there’s no denying it caught audiences off guard. What’s more, it doesn’t go totally beyond the realms of the show. Sherlock’s mind palace had been used in a number of previous episodes, and given he had also taken several substances beforehand, the mental exploration of the case of Emelia Ricoletti isn’t totally ludicrous.

9. Redbeard Is A Human Not A Dog – The Final Problem

‘The Final Problem’ was a strange way for the show to finish. Though it was a non-stop thriller from start to finish, it also felt rather ridiculous at times. Nevertheless, this patchy episode also contained a well-executed plot twist.

Advertisement

At the beginning of the episode, Mycroft reveals that Eurus (his younger sister) was taken to a mental institution after burning the family house down and killing a dog named Redbeard.

However, at the end of the episode it is revealed that Redbeard was in fact a boy named Victor Trevor who had been Sherlock’s best friend as a child. Eurus – angry at the lack of attention from her older sibling – had thrown Victor into a well.

As with the overall tone of the episode, such a revelation is rather far-fetched. Yet part of the reason it works so well is due to how it is revealed. Indeed, Watson discovering the bones of a child at the bottom of the well is a creepy and effective way for such a twist to be unveiled.

8. Watson Is Captured By Moriarty – The Great Game

The finale of Series 1 was a fast-paced adventure in which our favourite detective was able to cut through a number of baffling cases with his superior intellect. However, even Sherlock did not foresee Watson getting captured by Moriarty.

Advertisement

As with all of Moriarty's victims in this episode, Watson meets Sherlock with a multitude of explosives attached to him.

In addition to being unexpected, this scene also shines light on Sherlock’s character arc during the first series. Far from being the emotionless sociopath he claims to be, his reaction to Moriarty’s trap demonstrates how he genuinely cares for his companion.

As such, the ending of Series 1 is both thrilling and emotionally satisfying thanks to a character-driven plot twist no one saw coming.

7. Appledore's Vaults Are Inside Magnussen’s Head – His Last Vow

After the amusing but slightly patchy episode that was ‘The Sign of Three’, ‘His Last Vow’ amped up the quality considerably, and much of this was due to the terrific villain.

Advertisement

Given his occupation as a professional blackmailer, Charles Augustus Magnussen possessed an archive of pressure points – a library of secrets and scandals he used to influence certain people. However, the big twist with said archive was that it did not physically exist.

Upon arriving at Appledore to confront Magnussen, Sherlock and Watson soon learn that the archives are in fact a giant mind palace inside Magnussen’s head. Though some found this revelation a little far-fetched, it still made for a great twist thanks to some brilliant performances.

Moreover, given the capacity of the brain is essentially limitless, said twist – though highly improbable – is certainly not beyond the realms of possibility.

6. The Taxi Driver Is The Murderer – A Study In Pink

‘A Study in Pink’ was the perfect start to the show. As well as introducing us to the modern incarnations of Holmes and Watson, this episode also contained a thrilling mystery.

Advertisement

The central enigma of ‘A Study in Pink’ revolves around a series of unexplained deaths in which several people appear to have taken suicide pills in places they had no reason to be.

After tricking the murderer into returning to the location of his last crime, Sherlock and Watson are forced to chase a taxi across London in pursuit of their suspect. Yet when they eventually catch up to the taxi, Sherlock soon deduces that the passenger is definitely not a murderer. However, it is later revealed the murderer is in fact the cab driver.

The clever aspect of this twist is how it ties in with Sherlock’s earlier comments that the murderer was likely to be someone we trust even though we don’t know them, which is why he was able to obtain his victims so easily.

5. Sherlock Fakes His Death – The Reichenbach Fall

‘The Reichenbach Fall’ is a strong contender for the best Sherlock episode. From beginning to end it hooked in viewers with its fast pace and unpredictable storyline.

Advertisement

The final stages of the episode see our favourite detective fall from a great height in order to save his friends from Moriarty’s snipers. Crucially, the audience sees such a fall from Watson’s perspective, and as a result, Sherlock’s death is both tragic and authentic.

Whilst it seemed unlikely the writers would kill off their titular character, it was hard not to believe Sherlock was genuinely dead given he had also died in one of the original short stories by Conan Doyle. Thankfully, the final shot of the episode reveals Sherlock to be alive and well.

Though other twists were certainly more shocking, the best aspect of this closing scene was that it sparked years of conversations and fan theories about how the great detective managed to fake his death.

4. Watson’s Therapist Is Eurus – The Lying Detective

‘The Lying Detective’ was the best episode in the fourth series, and though the whole adventure was well done, it was the final scene that really hit home.

Advertisement

Following his wife’s death in 'The Six Thatchers', Watson invests in some therapy sessions with a woman he believes to be a legitimate therapist. It is later revealed that said therapist is in fact Eurus Holmes – the younger sister of Mycroft and Sherlock.

Owing to her unparalleled intelligence and her gift for manipulation, Eurus is able to go in and out of Sherrinford (her high-security prison) as she pleases.

Moreover, during her time in the outside world, Eurus disguises herself as two other people in addition to Watson’s therapist. Indeed, she masquerades as the daughter of Culverton Smith in order to have a conversation with Sherlock, and she also takes on the persona of an attractive young woman in an attempt to seduce Watson in the opening episode of Series 4.

As such, the twist at the end of ‘The Lying Detective’ has several layers to it given Watson’s therapist is actually one of several personas undertaken by Eurus.

3. Moriarty Is Richard Brook – The Reichenbach Fall

Due to the public’s increasing interest in Sherlock and Watson, Kitty Riley (an ambitious young journalist) sought out the famous detective for an interview. Unsurprisingly, Sherlock turned her down, but Kitty still managed to garner plenty of information about Sherlock owing to a source by the name of Richard Brook.

Advertisement

It is later revealed that Richard Brook is a fake identity created by Moriarty. With such an identity, Moriarty aimed to discredit his nemesis by claiming Sherlock’s career was one big lie, and that he was simply an actor being paid to perform the role of a consulting criminal.

Using the information he had previously obtained about Sherlock’s past when under Mycroft's interrogation, Moriarty was able to sell such a lie by wrapping it up in a true account of Sherlock’s life.

Such a twist is a little complex when watching this episode for the first time, but with repeated viewings, this plot point shines light on how terrifyingly clever Moriarty was.

2. Mary Is An Assassin – His Last Vow

Mary Watson – though certainly an intelligent lady – was never a cause for suspicion in the first two episodes of Series 3.

Advertisement

After breaking into Magnussen’s office, Sherlock finds him kneeling on the ground with a gun pointed at his head. Recognising the smell of Claire de la Lune, Sherlock presumes the assassin is Lady Smallwood, a British MP who had previously been blackmailed by Magnussen.

However, when the assassin turns around, Sherlock is met by the face of Mary Watson. Such a reveal takes both Sherlock and the audience completely off guard, and the surprises only continue as the famous detective is then shot by Mary.

Whereas most twists are only relevant to the episode they occur in, the revelation that Mary is an assassin challenges everything the audience thought they knew about her from the previous two episodes.

Such a twist also creates a great deal of sympathy for Watson. After the grieve he had to endure for two years following Sherlock’s fake suicide, the unveiling of his wife’s true identity is yet another emotional blow for him to take.

1. Moriarty Shoots Himself – The Reichenbach Fall

Andrew Scott’s Moriarty was always a madman, but few could have predicted he would take his own life just to oust his rival.

Advertisement

In order to complete his false story about Sherlock’s manufactured career, Moriarty threatens to kill three of his closest friends unless he commits suicide. Nevertheless, Sherlock realises that whilst Moriarty is alive, there’s still a possibility he can force his nemesis – by any means necessary – to call off the killers.

In order to guarantee his plan will work, therefore, Moriarty draws a gun from his pocket, sticks it is his mouth, and fires a bullet threw the back of his head.

The look of utter madness and determination on Moriarty’s face as he reaches for the gun and takes his own life is a brilliant piece of acting from Scott, and as such, Moriarty’s last act makes for an unforgettable moment in the show.

Such a twist also puts our hero in great jeopardy, for Sherlock now has no choice but to jump. Of course, in reality he had prepared in advance for such an eventuality, but when watching this scene for the first time, Moriarty’s suicide was a death sentence for our hero.

What do you think is the best plot twist in Sherlock? Share your thoughts below in the comments thread.

Advertisement