Sherlock: Every Episode Ranked Worst To Best

They're all fantastic, but if you were to watch one - any one - right now for the next hour and a half, which one would it be?

By Mark White /

Almost ten million viewers tuned in to watch how Sherlock Holmes cheated death, in 'The Empty Hearse', broadcast on New Year's Day at 9pm. Not bad, considering the number of modern-day distractions we have to good old-fashioned storytelling. And it's a testament to Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, to Steven Moffat and Mark Gatiss, and to Benedict Cumberbatch's fantastic portrayal that the style of Sherlock has been such a hit. It's a programme of shocking contrasts; the warmth of humanity and the coldness of a sociopath, the greyness of mystery and the colour of morality. It's a show that tells simple stories and relationships, via the long way round, and it's one that's gripped us for four years now. But with all the blockbuster episode figures, the twists, the speculation, the theories and Cumberbatch himself, inevitably, being talked about all over the internet at the moment... which is the best episode? There are nine to choose from, and they're all fantastic, but if you were to watch one - any one - right now for the next hour and a half, which one would it be? Let's count down the contenders, romanticise the living daylights out of them, and remember to tell us your favourite in the comments.

9. The Blind Banker

By no means a bad episode of television, 'The Blind Banker' has only one real flaw; it's not as good as the other episodes. It has a hard task from the outset, having to squeeze in between the thrilling 'A Study In Pink' and the incendiary 'The Great Game'. 'The Blind Banker' provides us with some funny moments though, introduces John Watson's first girlfriend in the series, and sees Sherlock in much more of an action hero role, fighting assassins and chasing them around London. It's a fun ride, but ultimately it's not quite as clever, intriguing or unique as the first episode suggested this series would be; it's a great bit of telly, just not good enough for this show. Sorry Steve Thompson: it's not a reflection on you. It's more a reflection on how good Sherlock is.

8. The Hound Of The Baskervilles

One of the scariest episodes of the show, 'The Hound of the Baskervilles' is brilliant, with the horror of the hound stalking John across the lab - and Russell Tovey's character Henry Knight at home - being by far the most captivating scenes. It's also a fascinating look into the mind of a frightened Holmes, as he starts questioning everything around him, pushing John away. As is the standard of the show, the direction is excellent, with the chilling white laboratories contrasting nicely against the murky woods. The twist of what the beast is, is typically Gatiss, and likewise, the small threads that tie up throughout the episode, such as the owner of the luminous rabbit are wonderfully handled. But more than anything 'The Hound of the Baskervilles' is a rattling episode for the show; it shakes up its lead characters and their relationship, takes Sherlock out of his London comfort zone, and throws an enemy into the thick of the action that's almost unseeable; it's really a test of how great this show can be, and though it's not the best episode, the cast and the writing surpasses that test with flying colours. It's an intriguing mystery tale, perhaps capsized, some might say, by an anti-climactic bombshell of a ending. But nevertheless, it's a fantastic plot, and a bone-chilling piece of television.

7. The Empty Hearse

Sherlock Holmes's big return didn't disappoint, with a tongue-in-cheek action opening, fan-service aplenty, and an injection of hilarity into the show. The plot to blow up parliament is certainly one that you could see Sherlock getting embroiled in, but fittingly, it takes a backseat in favour of developing the relationship between Holmes and Watson: if this man doesn't even know who our monarch is, why should gunpowder, treason and plot get in the way of TV's finest bromance? Sherlock is typically cold and calculating, as he can't see why it's such a big deal, but it's really touching that despite the sociopathic tendencies, he really does want to be forgiven by his best friend. The scene on the tube is a particular highlight, as Martin Freeman breaks viewers' hearts with a wonderfully emotive performance. In the end, it's just not worth staying angry at the people you love the most. That's the lovely message of this episode, brilliantly shown by Mark Gatiss, and it's a message that many fans are still telling themselves over the "how he did it" confusion. We'll never know, unfortunately. But maybe it's better we get over it, for our love of the show's sake.

6. A Study In Pink

The first episode of the show, 'A Study in Pink' introduces a war hero hungry for adventure and couples him with the world's first consulting detective. It would be understandable if the pair needed a bit of time to gel, but Steven Moffat does no such thing, as Holmes and Watson hit the ground running, investigating serial suicides. The scenes where Sherlock analyses the crime scenes are fantastically novel and brilliantly directed; the bullet-train monologues also glitter in the script, and the dry, eccentric performance from Benedict Cumberbatch is a lovely opposition to Martin Freeman's everyman Watson. We see this world through John's eyes, through his meetings with the mysterious Mycroft, to his confusion over this otherworldly detective; it's a recipe that's perfectly judged with some brilliant lines - "You're right about thing: the police do not consult amateurs" - and topped off with the chemistry that the leading pair have. But perhaps most astoundingly, it really pushes the boundaries for what a lead character should be; it's not enough for him to find the murderer, the plan and be the only man to walk away from him. Sherlock Holmes still has to outwit him. He will outlive God having the last laugh, and he will prove himself cleverer than a dying man, and darker than your average detective. Only the somewhat unbelievable cabbie villain lets the episode down, but it's still a thrilling ride; I don't know about you, I still want to know which pill Sherlock would've gone for.

5. The Sign Of Three

'The Sign of Three' is not only the most divisive and, on first watch, confusing episodes of Sherlock, but it's also one of the most ambitious. More importantly though, it's a lesson that you should never judge an episode until it's finished. The mysteries all tie themselves together at the end, but for much of this episode, it's like a sitcom, as Sherlock and John get drunk, dance to Rihanna and make serviettes. The speech from Sherlock is genuinely moving; he feels both more human in this episode, and totally detached from society, but it's the final third, when Irene Adler appears, Mycroft shouts at him in his mind palace, and he has to solve a case quickly - and stop being a "drama queen" - that this episode really excels. 'The Sign of Three', like 'The Empty Hearse', is more about the characters that Moffat and co have built, rather than the plot. Mary ascends to someone we can all love, the John/Sherlock relationship develops into an unstoppable bond and we see further into the character of Sherlock than ever before. Why should that be divisive?

4. The Great Game

'The Great Game' may be the most typical episode of Sherlock that there is; there's a case every ten minutes for him to sink his teeth into, comedy, brilliance and plot-twists galore, and a cliffhanger face-off against a supervillain. The deduction skills really step up a notch, as Sherlock, chillingly, quite enjoys the challenges constantly being thrown at him; Cumberbatch is masterful in the role, quicker and sharper than everyone else, noticing why the Vermeer is a fake with only seconds remaining and crying in front of a suspect to try and prize clues and answers from her. This is the episode that he really does feel like a Hollywood star in the making, and he's an absolute pleasure to watch. It's like several episodes packed into one, with a killer pace and intriguing crimes, but quite brilliantly, there's always a threat bubbling under the surface; Sherlock can sense it, the way his eyes dart around in the cafe when John asks, "Is it Moriarty?". We know it is, and we know that he can't rest until he finds him. With every case, he drifts closer and closer to the villain, and it really does feel like he's not sleeping in between. And that final scene: sure, the rooftop might've eclipsed it in the cliffhanger department, but Andrew Scott provides such an unhinged and charismatic performance, that he nearly steals the entire episode. Did anyone else watch 'The Great Game' first time around and assume that when John steps out to meet Sherlock, he's revealing himself to be Moriarty?

3. His Last Vow

For all the comedic brilliance of 'The Empty Hearse' and the lovely sentiment of 'The Sign of Three', it was time to bring Series 3 crashing down with the cold 'His Last Vow'. A sentiment we all know, is a chemical defect found in the losing side. Because just when we think Sherlock Holmes is lightening up a bit, we discover he's on heroin. Again, the character relationships are far more expanded on, as the Watsons' marriage is shone under a microscope; Martin Freeman gives (another) heart-tearing performance ("Why is everything my fault? She wasn't supposed to be like that."), and Amanda Abbington is stoic and moving. Cumberbatch is much more capricious and exciting, and the scenes set in his mind palace are incredible; we really delve deep into the psyche of this character, and it's a fascinating insight for that. And perhaps it's perfect that it should end with a final gunshot; because that gunshot signifies that you can never estimate Sherlock Holmes. His mind is labyrinthine, this show is, at times, too multi-layered for its own good, and often, someone just needs to get shot for Sherlock to get out of bed in the morning. Sherlock Holmes is the mystery of 'His Last Vow', and again, the mystery goes unsolved.

2. A Scandal In Belgravia

While 'His Last Vow' is a study of the mind that is Sherlock Holmes, 'A Scandal in Belgravia' is study of his heart. From the hugely funny - "Are you wearing any pants?" - to the strangely deep - "All hearts are broken; caring is not an advantage" - 'A Scandal in Belgravia' isn't just an episode of television, it's a journey; it tracks a relationship, from the spiky beginnings of her appalling him with her attention-grabbing nudity, to the silent affection he has for her by the end. Lara Pulver is masterful as Adler, Cumberbatch delivers a very different side to Sherlock, and the mystery, the big mystery of the episode, is what could possibly unlock Irene's heart. The reveal that it is in fact "I Am Sherlocked" might seem obvious now, but the ingenuity of building this invisible love affair, before exposing it with a pin code, is deftly judged and wonderfully paced. Pulver and Cumberbatch have a friction early on that melts into sumptuous chemistry: the couple are two sides of the same complex coin, and the fact that you can never second-guess either of them - and they can't second-guess each other - only makes for more interesting watching. Because they're, effectively, a pair of people who don't understand each other. Sherlock doesn't feel love like she does, and she longs to see inside his head. It's fitting really that she lives in his mind palace.

1. The Reichenbach Fall

Could it be anything else? People will tell you that 'The Reichenbach Fall' is so good because it's so complex; there's a twist around every turn, signposted by the "IOU"s and the gradual downfall of Sherlock Holmes. But 'The Reichenbach Fall' is really quite simple. It's a rivalry between two people; one of whom wants to tear down the entire world to destroy his nemesis, and the other one has so much to lose. This episode plays off everything that Sherlock is up to this point; it's about the darkness in your heroes, about the trust you place in your friends, and about two super-geniuses going face to face in the most unnerving battle of wits on television. Sherlock Holmes is famously always one step ahead of anyone else. And the twists work so well in 'The Reichenbach Fall', because we see that he's not perfect. He's beaten, over and over again, and we love to see that. We love multi-faceted characters and morally grey heroes. But as John Watson stands at that grave, and his voice breaks, it's obvious that Sherlock is a show that will only ever be about human emotion. It's about the relationship that John has with his best friend, and it's about how Sherlock tried his best not to hurt him; if it wasn't, he'd have put a bullet in Moriarty's head himself. And that's a fairly alright note for me to end on too: Sherlock is a detective show, but it's only ever about the relationship that a man has with his best friend. Maybe that's we love it so much...