Sherlock Season 4: 20 Easter Eggs & References In 'The Final Problem'

Sherrinford, Skyfall and Sea Devils.

By Christian Bone /

BBC

Sherlock's season four finale went all out to blow the socks off its audience, as it delivered an action-packed 90 minute climax that threatened the lives of just about all of our favourite characters at one point or another. It is an episode that has proved controversial with fans, even though pretty much all are praying it won't turn out to be the final ever episode of the show, as showrunners Steven Moffat and Mark Gatiss have threatened.

Advertisement

With Sherlock, John and Mycroft trapped in an underground facility at the whim of a psychotic inmate, it was more like a horror or action movie than Sherlock has ever been. And, whatever you thought about it, it was certainly very far removed from the traditional armchair detective stories written by Arthur Conan Doyle.

While it might have been of a very different spirit to Doyle's work, however, The Final Problem was still stuffed to the rafters with nods and references to the original Sherlock Holmes stories - along with a few callbacks to some other bastions of pop culture.

Read on for 20 easter eggs you might have missed in the season - series? - finale of Sherlock.

20. Mycroft's Portrait

During Sherlock and John's elaborate prank on Mycroft at the start of the episode, he becomes spooked after the portraits on the walls weep blood.

Advertisement

One of these portraits looks a lot like Mark Gatiss in Elizabethan dress, presumably intended to be an ancestor of the Holmes family. This recalls a plot point in The Hound of the Baskervilles. Holmes realises that Jack Stapleton is in fact a member of the Baskerville family due to his uncanny resemblance to one of the portraits hanging in Baskerville Hall.

If you were wondering who the man in the clown suit and the dwarf woman dressed as a child in this scene are, Sherlock tells them to collect their money from Wiggins and "don't spend it all in one drug den." Presumably, then, they are members of his Homeless Network.

For more on Wiggins, read our easter eggs list for The Lying Detective.

19. Sherrinford

We finally learn here what Mycroft's recurring references to something called Sherrinford have been about. It's actually the top secret facility where Eurus is kept, along with other highly-dangerous criminals labelled "uncontainables".

Advertisement

Sherrinford is taken from the name given to the third Holmes brother in William Baring-Gould's biography of Sherlock Holmes. Baring-Gould chose it as it was Doyle's original name for Sherlock in early drafts of debut novel A Study in Scarlet. For more on Sherrinford, visit our The Six Thatchers easter eggs list.

In the many non-canonical Holmes stories that feature Sherrinford, he is usually depicted as the most intelligent member of the Holmes clan. This distinction is likewise given to Eurus here.

18. Oscar Wilde

Mycroft quotes Oscar Wilde's The Importance of Being Earnest when he says that "truth is rarely pure and never simple."

Advertisement

A reference to Wilde is an apt one for Sherlock to make, seeing as the Victorian writer should be thanked for indirectly inspiring Arthur Conan Doyle to continue writing Sherlock Holmes stories.

Wilde and Doyle attended a dinner party together one night in 1889 and had a discussion about the depictions of evil in fiction that got the creative juices flowing. This led Wilde to write The Picture of Dorian Gray and Doyle to resurrect Holmes for his second novel The Sign of the Four.

17. Sherlock's Hidden Trauma

It turns out that Sherlock did not remember his sister because of the trauma surrounding the death of Redbeard (more on him later). This is said to have resulted in him becoming the removed, calculating machine he is today.

Advertisement

This recalls Nicholas Meyer's novel The Seven Per-Cent Solution (and also the movie adaptation). In that, Holmes visits Dr Freud and uncovers the fact that he invented Professor Moriarty the master criminal. The man he sees as his nemesis was actually his mother's adulterous lover who contributed to her death when Sherlock was a child.

The idea of Sherlock losing a loved one as a child is also lifted from Young Sherlock Holmes. In that movie, Sherlock loses the love of his young life, Elizabeth Hardy, which causes him to forego romantic attachment for the rest of his life.

16. The Musgrave Ritual

Here's another revelation. After killing Redbeard, Eurus repeated a strange song that apparently held the key to finding him. Mycroft calls this her "ritual." She then set the Holmes' family house alight - a house called Musgrave Hall.

Advertisement

This is a loose reinterpretation of Doyle's The Adventure of the Musgrave Ritual. In that story, a college friend of Holmes', Reginald Musgrave, asks the detective to investigate an incident involving the family's traditional riddle.

Eurus's song and Doyle's riddle are different but they have several lines in common. Eurus sings of "16 by 6 and under we go", for example, while Doyle wrote "North by ten and by ten, east by five and by five, south by two and by two, west by one and by one, and so under.”

15. Young Mycroft

In the flashbacks we see of the Holmes children's childhood, we see that Mycroft was a somewhat heavily-built child. This is both a nod to the original stories and the culmination of lots of references in the show itself.

Advertisement

When Mycroft first appears in Doyle's The Greek Interpreter, he is described as "massive." In Sherlock, the detective has previously needled Mycroft on his weight loss and we have seen Mycroft maintaining an exercise regime to battle his bulging belly. In The Abominable Bride, Sherlock's Victorian vision of Mycroft was an enormous man constantly surrounded by food.

Though it has not been seen clearly on screen, part of the set decoration in Sherlock's bedroom since the beginning of the show is a photo of young Sherlock and a young heavily-built Mycroft. That image has now been brought to life.

14. Baker Street On Fire

In a tense scene, Sherlock, John and Mycroft are caught in a blast from a drone carrying a "patience grenade" that destroys 221B Baker Street. This is a dramatized version of an incident mentioned in passing in Doyle's The Final Problem.

Advertisement

When on the run from Professor Moriarty, Holmes explains to Watson that the criminal "set fire to our rooms last night." This incident was also referenced in The Great Game, when Moriarty sets off a bomb across the street from 221B.

13. Disguised As A Sailor

To break into Sherrinford, both Mycroft and Sherlock disguise themselves as sailors. Mycroft goes for a full make-up job as a swarthy old sea dog while Sherlock just wears a hat and puts on a Scottish accent.

Advertisement

This scene is a reference to the two occasions in the canon when Holmes went incognito as sailors. He briefly donned the guise of a seafaring man in The Sign of the Four and then masqueraded as Captain Basil in Black Peter.

12. James Bond Connections

Sherlock has been accused of becoming more James Bond and less Sherlock Holmes in recent episodes, but The Final Problem was perhaps the most Bondian yet. Two plot points, in particular, heavily recalled the two most recent films to star 007.

Advertisement

Firstly, the image of Sherlock's mansion of a childhood home burning down is heavily reminiscent of a similar scene in 2013 James Bond film Skyfall. Just like in The Final Problem, we the audience finally discover the hero's secret past when the action returns to his destroyed house.

Sherlock having a secret evil sibling also brings to mind the revelation in 2015's Spectre that - spoilers - Christoph Waltz' Blofeld is really Bond's bitter half-brother. Both Eurus and Blofeld were also consorting with their brother's enemies behind the scenes.

At least Eurus never said "It's me, Sherlock, the author of all your pain!"

11. Doctor Who: The Sea Devils

A much more overt reference to another British institution can be found in the notion that Eurus appears to be an inmate in her secure island prison but is actually in charge of the governor.

Advertisement

This is exactly what the Master does in a Doctor Who story from 1973 titled The Sea Devils. In that, the Third Doctor visits his old enemy in jail and it appears that everything is in order. It only transpires later that the Master has used his hypnotic control to put the governor under his thumb.

As well as borrowing from the Master, Eurus is also partly inspired by Hannibal Lecter, Anthony Hopkins' infamous cannibal. This is referenced in the episode itself when a guard explains to Sherlock: "It's basically The Silence of the Lambs."

10. Vatican Cameos

When John realises something is wrong at Sherrinford, he tries to let Sherlock know by sending him the message "Vatican cameos."

Advertisement

In The Hound of the Baskervilles, Holmes says at one point: “I was exceedingly preoccupied by that little affair of the Vatican cameos, and in my anxiety to oblige the Pope I lost touch with several interesting English cases."

In Sherlock, the phrase has been reattributed as John and Sherlock's codeword for when things are getting serious. Sherlock previously said the warning to John in A Scandal in Belgravia and The Sign of Three.

9. Moriarty's Brother

Moriarty returns in this episode in the form of a series of amusing/threatening videos that he apparently recorded before his death. Eurus explains that Jim enjoyed doing them as he was jealous of his brother, who was a stationmaster.

Advertisement

This is a reference to The Valley of Fear, in which it is said that Professor Moriarty has a brother who works as a stationmaster.

In Doyle's The Final Problem, Moriarty is also mentioned as having another brother called Colonel James Moriarty - who weirdly posseses the same first name as his criminal brother.

8. Stradivarius

In this episode, Eurus gives her violin to Sherlock as a gift. He correctly identifies it as a Stradivarius.

Advertisement

As any violin virtuoso knows, a Stradivarius is the very finest type of the instrument. In The Adventure of the Cardboard Box, Holmes is said to have bought one from a pawnbrokers for just fifty five shillings, when he estimates that it is actually worth five hundred guineas. Bargain!

Sherlock being given one as a gift recalls a humorous scene from 1969 movie The Private Life of Sherlock Holmes, in which Robert Stephen's detective is given one by an aging Russian ballerina who wishes to sleep with him.

7. The Three Garridebs

One of the cases that Eurus forces the Baker Street Boys to solve is the mystery of who killed a man named Evans. She has narrowed it down to the three Garrideb brothers - Howard, Alex and Nathan - but they have to guess which is the murderer.

Advertisement

The names of the key figures in this mystery are taken from Doyle's The Three Garridebs, though the facts of the case are completely different. The villain in the original story, for instance, is "Killer" Evans - a serial killer escaped from the States.

It is fitting that this story is referenced in this episode as it contains the one moment in the canon when Holmes openly admits how much he cares for Watson, when the good doctor gets shot. Though this exact moment isn't recreated, Sherlock's love for John is definitely made plain here.

6. Victor Trevor

Things take a dark turn in The Final Problem when it's revealed that Redbeard was not Sherlock's dog at all. Eurus' real victim was Victor Trevor, Sherlock's redheaded childhood best friend. Eurus was jealous of the bond the pair shared when playing pirate games and trapped poor Victor in a well.

Advertisement

This is a tragic revising of a character from the canon. In Doyle's The Adventure of the Gloria Scott, Holmes reveals to Watson that he had one significant friend before him: Victor Trevor, his best pal at university.

Trevor is also indirectly responsible for starting Sherlock on the detective game, as he brought him his first case. This is much like how Eurus describes the hunt for Victor as young Sherlock's first case.

5. He's A Good Man

There's a lovely callback to the show's first ever episode when Lestrade makes a small appearance at the end of The Final Problem.

Advertisement

When he catches one of his officers staring at Sherlock, Lestrade asks him why. "Well, he's a great man," the PC replies. "No, he's better than that," says Greg. "He's a good one."

Back in A Study in Pink, John asked Lestrade about Sherlock. At the time he said: "Sherlock Holmes is a great man. And one day, if we're very, very lucky, he might even be a good one."

The clear implication is that this day has finally come, and that Sherlock's journey from high-functioning sociopath to hero is now complete.

4. The Best And Wisest Men

John's late wife Mary has one more trick up her sleeve when she posthumously sends Sherlock and John a second DVD message. This one tells them to rebuild their lives and to be the defenders of the desperate forever. She calls them "the best and wisest men she has ever known."

Advertisement

This is a callback to what John called Sherlock in The Empty Hearse when they were trapped in a train carriage that was apparently rigged to explode. That instance was itself also a callback to what Dr Watson says of Holmes in Doyle's The Final Problem, when he thought his friend had fallen into the Reichenbach Falls.

3. The Dancing Men

In the episode's final moments, there is one last blink-and-you'll-miss-it reference to the stories of Arthur Conan Doyle.

Advertisement

As Mary gives her speech, we see John and Sherlock attending to a bevy of cases. One sees them studying a blackboard upon which some stick men in various positions have been drawn.

These stick figures are lifted from The Adventure of the Dancing Men, in which they form a code that Holmes must deduce the meaning of. That same code is replicated here. If you're interested, it reads: "Am here Abe Slaney."

2. Paul Weller As A Viking

In this same scene, there is a very unlikely - and very easily-missed - cameo from a British rock star.

Advertisement

At one point, we see John inspecting the body of a man dressed as a Viking lying on the floor at Baker Street. Eagle-eyed music fans will note that this is Paul Weller of The Jam.

As for what he is in doing in Sherlock, Weller is a friend of self-confessed rock afficionado Martin Freeman. Freeman previously appeared in the video for Weller's Pick It Up, so it seems like this is Weller returning the favour.

1. Rathbone Place

The final shot of The Final Problem is a striking image - Sherlock and John racing off into their next adventure. If this is the last ever time we see these heroes, it's a good reminder that these characters will never really die and will be solving crimes for as long as people keep on writing about them.

Advertisement

The building they are running out of in this scene has a plaque reading 'Rathbone Place'. This is an obvious reference to Basil Rathbone, the actor who played Holmes in 14 movies during World War Two. These were notable for bringing the character up to date and plonking him into the 1940s, a move that directly inspired Sherlock's similarly modern-day setting.

Mark Gatiss has explained the decision behind this final easter egg:

“The reason we [ended with] Rathbone Place is that, actually, if we do come back – and we would love to come back – we could absolutely very easily start with a knock at the door and Sherlock saying to John ‘Do you want to come out and play?’. They have become the two heroes that we always knew them to be.”
Advertisement