The Simpsons had a very different feel in its first ten seasons than in its last fifteen. Though the show we see today can provide a quick laugh or Family Guy-esque antics, the shows earlier run contained episodes that had heart as well as comedy. It was far from preachy (particularly if you ask a certain First Lady of America during the late 80s) but The Simpsons contained many truly heartfelt moments that would make you think, reconsider your priorities, or even shed a tear. Comedy inevitably has the potential be just as emotionally fulfilling as drama, because what makes us laugh can reveal just as much about ourselves as what makes us cry. These moments in Simpsons history are what make the series not just a comedy show, but a work of art.
10. Lisa On Ice (6x08) - A Hug Between Rivals
When Bart and Lisa are pitted against each other in separate hockey teams, a rivalry is quickly formed between the two. Lisa finds that she has the hidden talents of a goalie, and Bart can't help but feel jealous that she has both academic and athletic skill. Homer encourages their sibling rivalry, becoming one of "those parents" who puts too much emphasis on their children's competitiveness. Before the pivotal match between the two teams Homer proclaims, "Don't go easy on each other just because you're brother and sister. I want to see you both fighting for your parents' love!" This spurs both siblings to play rough against each other, up until Bart is faced with a penalty shot towards Lisa's goal that could win the game. But as they stare at each other, they each remember times when they bonded as brother and sister. The two abandon their hockey gear and skate towards each other into a hug. Though Homer and the seats full of parents don't react well to the gesture, the moment is a sweet one and is a notable part of Simpsons history.
9. Eeny Teeny Maya Moe (20x16) - Moe Smiles
The only episode on this list from a later series, Eeny Teeny Maya Moe shows that sometimes the newer episodes of The Simpsons can show an emotional side. Moe Szyslak isn't the most fortunate character of The Simpsons, a tragic and openly ridiculed fool considered to be a grotesque by his fellow Springfield residents, who barely tolerate him. But all that changes when he meets Maya, a woman he met over the internet who also has dwarfism. Though he wonders at first what his friends will think, he introduces her to Homer and Marge and everything goes well. Eventually he asks her to marry him, and she seems inclined to say yes until some insensitive words from Moe change her mind. Moe tries to win her back, but it's too late. Mourning Maya's departure while cleaning his bar, Homer gives him some sound advice: "Sometime, when you least expect it, you'll realize that someone loved you. And that means that someone can love you again! And that'll make you smile." Moe hears his words, staring at a picture of Maya with a sad smile. "Who'd have thought that such a little woman could make me feel so big?" he asks, showing that even for Moe there is hope to find love in the future.
8. Bart Gets An F (2x01) - Bart's Struggle
Bart Simpson may be the infamous El Barto, purveyor of rude humour and advocate of shorts-eating, but deep inside his spiky-haired exterior is a little boy with weaknesses and feelings that he would never openly acknowledge. In Bart Gets An F, Bart is finally forced to care about his grades when the school psychiatrist suggests he repeat the fourth grade. He makes an honest effort, leaving behind the answers-stealing, procrastinating ways of the past. He does well for a while but soon finds himself becoming distracted. The day before the test, Bart sits down and prays for a miracle, and he gets it in the shape of a snow day. Frustrated that he cannot join the rest of the town in their fun, he forces himself to study for the test after Lisa guilt trips him. But despite his best efforts, he fails the test by one point. Mrs. Krabappel turns away having expected the result, but looks back at Bart in surprise when he starts crying. He vents about how much he really tried, comparing his efforts to George Washington at Fort Necessity, earning an extra credit point from his amazed teacher. Bart Gets An F shows us perhaps the most human side of Bart Simpson, and helps us to understand that human beings are never one-dimensional if you look close enough. The scene where Bart breaks down in front of Mrs. Krabappel gives children who struggle in school an honest image to relate with, and as a viewer you can't help but feel sorry for him.
7. Bart Sells His Soul (7x04) - Bart's Existential Crisis
On paper it seems like a strange formula for an episode, but it is written so brilliantly that you find yourself considering the nature of your own soul while laughing along with the gags. After Bart declares that the soul does not exist, he sells his own soul (symbolized with a piece of paper with 'Bart's Soul' written on it) to his friend Milhouse for a measly five dollars. He continues on with his life happily until strange things start occurring: automatic doors no longer work for him, he is unable to find things funny, and the cat and dog reject him. After a nightmare where he is the only child in Springfield without a soul, Bart decides he needs to get it back. A poignant and emotional episode (while still being filled with classic comedy moments), Bart Sells His Soul is a favourite of the show's creator Matt Groening and has even been discussed by scholars of philosophy and religion. The episode's climax contains a nice evaluation by Lisa of the nature of the soul, and the dream at the episode's conclusion where Bart is reunited with his soul has a childlike sweetness to it that will leave you smiling.
6. The Simpsons Movie (2007) - Our Wedding Video
The Simpsons Movie was a delightful mixture of the emotional balance in the show's early run as well as the more mature comedy of its later years. The most heartbreaking part of the film comes when Homer stubbornly disagrees to help save Springfield from destruction, instead choosing to stay in the safety of Alaska. Homer leaves their cabin in a rage but returns to find the family gone, a videotape lying on his bed. The tape shows Marge telling Homer that she is taking the kids to save the town and will never see him again. The real kicker is Marge's final line of the scene: "to prove to myself that this is the end... I taped this over our wedding video." The video then cuts to young Marge and Homer's first wedding dance, the song "Close to You" (a theme of the couple's since season 2) playing in the background. Throughout the series Marge and Homer have had their share of fights, but this moment shows an all-time low point for the couple, and it hurts to watch.
5. 'Round Springfield (6x22) - A Tribute To Bleeding Gums
It is often difficult for Lisa Simpson to find people to relate with, but she was able to find a kindred soul in musician Bleeding Gums Murphy. When he dies suddenly and she finds herself the only attendant of his funeral, she makes it her goal to tell all of Springfield of her great Jazz mentor. The remainder of the episode chronicles Lisa's journey to attain a rare Bleeding Gums album so that it can be played on the local Jazz station. With the help of a surprise favor from Bart and a divinely-placed bolt of lightning, soon Bleeding Gum's music is played on every radio in Springfield. In the end clouds gather and Bleeding Gums appears before Lisa, thanking her and asking her to play Jazz with him one last time. The subject of a loved one's death can difficult to write, especially for a cartoon sitcom, and as the story moves forward all the elements fall into place, providing a tissue-worthy ending. It's nigh impossible to listen to Lisa's rendition of Jazz Man without a lump forming in your throat.
4. Lisa's First Word (4x10) - Not Homer, Daddy
Like several other episodes before it, "Lisa's First Word" starts with Homer and Marge telling the kids a story in flashback. We see Bart on his first day of Kindergarten and Lisa as a baby. Bart has a hard time fitting in at school, made all the worse by the attention drawn away from him by Lisa. He becomes resentful towards her and unleashes his anger on her, but soon she spits out her first word: "Bart". Elated, Bart shows Homer and Marge Lisa's new talent, and she begins to pick up other words as well, but just like her older brother, she is unable to say "Daddy", instead referring to him as "Homer". Oddly enough the most emotional moment of the episode is not the titular first words of Lisa, but instead the first word of Maggie. At the end of the episode Homer puts the youngest Simpson to bed, telling her "You know, Maggie. The sooner kids learn to talk, the sooner they talk back. I hope you never say a word." Just after he leaves Maggie removes her pacifier and says her first word: "Daddy". It's the final punchline to an episode-long running gag, and yet it's more likely to make you shed a tear than to inspire a laugh.
3. One Fish, Two Fish, Blowfish, Blue Fish (2x11) - Homer's Promise
The Simpsons has had several episodes about death, but none quite like this. When Homer ingests an improperly-prepared blowfish, he is informed that the poison is in his system and that he has 24 hours left to live. The episode chronicles Homer's last day and how he spends it with each of his loved ones. But when he accidentally sleeps in, he finds he has to use the rest of his time wisely, and though each scene has a somber feel to it, the episode is not without comedy. In the end Homer wishes he had more time to spend with everyone, and ends up crossing people off his list as he takes time rekindling his relationship with his father. When he returns home he says goodbye to his sleeping family and dozes off. The next morning Marge wakes up in a panic, but finds Homer unconscious downstairs with warm drool hanging from his mouth. They are both equally excited by the fact that Homer is still alive. That's when Homer delivers his last line, "I am alive! Woo hoo! This is great Marge! From now on, I vow to live life to the fullest." The scene immediately cuts to Homer sitting on the couch lazily, watching TV with a bag of pork rinds. There is no more dialogue or music, just the sound of Homer's TV as the episode ends. It's a moving and chilling ending that has stuck with me since my first viewing.
2. Mother Simpson (7x08) - Gazing At The Stars
This episode marked the first major appearance of Homer's mother Mona. After believing she was dead for many years, Homer is finally reunited with his estranged mother. He is thrilled to see her and invites her into his home, happily making up for lost time and looking back on cherished memories together. But in the end Mona is forced to leave again when a figure from her past comes back to haunt her. After sending her off with a tearful goodbye, Homer continues to stand on the side of the road, still waving long after the bus has crossed the horizon. The image fades and we see that night has fallen, but Homer still sits atop his car, staring into the distance. He continues to stare during the length of the credits as a sombre melody plays in place of the show's theme. It is an usually quiet moment for Homer's character, and a lovely ending to an episode with so much heart.
1. And Maggie Makes Three (6x13) - Do It For Her
Now we come to what is perhaps my favorite Simpsons episode in the show's 25-year history. Bart and Lisa ask why there are no pictures of Maggie in the photo albums. The episode is then told in flashback as we see what life was like for the family before Maggie was born. After paying off all their debts, Homer is able to quit the power plant and get his dream job working at a bowling alley. It is a perfect life for him, and he even claims out loud that he never wants anything to change. It is at this point that Marge finds out she is pregnant for the third time. Not wanting to tell Homer, she tries to keep it a secret for as long as possible (in a series of hilarious moments where Homer should have obviously figured out what was happening). But soon he finds out and sadly quits his dream job in order to make more money at the plant to take care of his family. Gloating that Homer was forced to return literally on his hands and knees, Mr. Burns posts a plaque in Homer's office that reads: "Don't forget: you're here forever." In the final moments of the episode, Bart and Lisa ask what all this had to do with Maggie's missing photos. Homer responds that he put them all where he needs it most. Then the plaque is shown once again, Maggie's photos covering up the letters so that it instead reads: "Do it for her". It is a beautiful last image that shows so much about the intricacy of Homer's character, and it simply cannot be watched without shedding a tear. Want to share some of your favourite Simpsons memories? Have a Simpsons moment you think should be on this list? Let us know in the comments!