The Simpsons is the greatest TV show ever made. Its inimitable mix of the smart, silly, subversive and satirical has earned the show countless awards, millions of fans and billions of dollars. Given the hundreds of jokes packed into a typical episode, the show not only withstands repeat viewing; it practically demands it. And yet, as America's longest-running sitcom heads into its twenty- fifth year, the show's 'golden age', a period wherein every episode could rightly be considered a classic, increasingly becomes but a distant memory. Although it would be impossible for any show- let alone a sitcom- to keep hold of its crown over a quarter of a century, there can be no denying that the call to cancel The Simpsons grows ever louder with each new season. Here are ten moments that fuel the fire of critics who insist that the show is merely a shell of its former self. The thankfully rare examples of the show's writers dropping the ball, overstepping the mark and jumping the shark. Here are the absurd storylines, the jokes that fell flat, the moments that made even the most ardent fan swear loudly/switch off/scrawl their disgust across every message board they could find. Or, y' know, channel their frustration into writing a passive-aggressive article.
10. The Diving Bell And The Butterball
Episode: Treehouse of Horror XXII The Treehouse of Horror episodes are usually an annual treat of movie pastiches, gratuitous violence and non-canon deaths. But then along came a spider...which bites Homer, leaving him paralyzed. Lisa then discovers that her father can only communicate through farting, and so sets about decoding his er, messages, by having him fart his way through the alphabet. Remember, this is The Simpsons - not South Park. We've come to expect a little more than this over the last twenty five years. Having apparently run out of horror films to feast their fangs upon, the show has instead turned its attention to a puzzlingly lowbrow parody of acclaimed French film The Diving Bell and the Butterfly (in which a man suffers a stroke and can only express himself by blinking his left eyelid), a feature that doesn't exactly scream 'comic potential'. And especially not when the punchline sees another spider bite transform Homer into a still-paralyzed Spider-Man, shooting webs from his rear end. All of this wouldn't be so bad had it been only a passing reference; instead the show decides to devote a quarter of its running time to what is essentially a fart joke - easily becoming the worst part of the worst Treehouse of Horror episode yet.
9. Cop Out Endings
Sitcom lore dictates that no matter how many twists and turns are packed into the third act, everything shall be miraculously returned to normal for the final frame. But of course, The Simpsons is no ordinary sitcom. And so, while the abrupt ending of 'Pygmoelian', say, serves as a self-aware gag (just as Moe begins to question the episode's deus ex machina, the closing credits come down and cut him off mid-sentence), other episodes latch on an ending that had absolutely nothing to do with the preceding twenty minutes. For example, in 'Missionary: Impossible', Homer and Lisa Jr. appear to fall to their death - only for the scene to suddenly cut to a Fox network telethon. Or in 'The Frying Game', in which Homer faces the electric chair only to discover at the last minute that it is in fact simply a stunt for a reality TV show. Or perhaps the most ridiculous of all; the conclusion to 'The Great Money Caper', which sees Groundskeeper Willie wrongly sentenced for stealing the Simpsons' car. Upon hearing the guilty verdict, he snatches Chief Wiggum's gun and shoots up the courtroom. Homer and Bart finally give in and admit to losing the car in a scam- at which point Marge declares the trial a hoax, much to Homer's confusion. Just as Lisa is about to explain, Otto bursts through the courtroom doors and yells ''Hey, everybody! Surf's up!'' The court empties, everyone grabs a surfboard and up go the credits. It doesn't quite justify building up an entire third act only to throw it away with a deliberately evasive non-sequitur. In each example, why bother to invest in the episode if it's only going to throw the ending away?
8. Skinner Kisses A Corpse
Episode: On A Clear Day I Can't See My Sister The Simpsons has always had an undercurrent of dark, uncomfortable humour- and it's all the funnier for it. Yet here's a moment that, for some fans, was a step too far. On a field trip to Springfield Glacier, Skinner puts an uncomfortably long bus journey to good use by attempting to rekindle his relationship with Mrs. Krabappel (''So, Edna, I, uh, wrote up some possible discussion topics for this trip. Oh, here's one. I'm still in love with you. Discuss?"), only to be rebuffed. ''See that man?'' asks Edna, pointing to a Park Ranger,''Take note of how he's not you''. She then throws herself into the Ranger's arms and begins to make out with him. Clearly enraged- but not to be outdone - Skinner resorts to desperate measures. He takes a mummified Ice Age corpse from her display stand, cradles her, kisses her and whispers, ''Just play along''. Not only were fans taken aback by this bizarre attempt at gross-out humour, but the concept of Skinner making out with a corpse was ridiculously out of character. However, if it had been Kirk van Houten or Hans Moleman puckering up to those perfectly preserved lips....
7. Panda Love
Episode: Homer vs Dignity In an episode wherein Homer becomes Mr Burns' prank monkey, undertaking increasingly embarrassing acts for money, it takes something truly awful to stand out. And if there's one adjective that springs to mind while watching Homer being sexually assaulted by a giant panda, it's 'awful'. Burns' most humiliating prank sees Homer sneaking into Springfield Zoo and wearing a costume that will fool the tourists into thinking he is the resident female panda, Sim Sim. But after being zapped by two handlers, he is too weak to retreat from male panda Ping-Ping's amorous advances. As Ping-Ping drags 'Sim Sim' into his cave, and a curtain emblazoned with 'Shhh, Pandas Need Their Sleep! ' falls over the entrance, Homer's screams are drowned out by the audience's applause. Admittedly, the offending scene occurs offscreen - but nevertheless the implication is more than enough. A ' morning after' scene shows Homer escape from the cave only to be sprayed while crossing the skunk exhibit before, at his worst moment, he is spotted by Lisa. For both the man and the show, this is certainly a new low. ''Yes, I may be naked and reeking of panda love,'' says Homer, ''but I've got to stop this before it goes too far.'' Too late. For many Simpsons fans, this episode marked a turning point. Outlandish storylines are one thing but crude, unfunny shock tactics such as this are quite another.
6. Jakob
Episode: The Greatest Story Ever D'ohed You'd think that a guest spot from Sacha Baron Cohen would be a good thing. After all, Borat was pretty funny, right? Jakob, however, the eccentric (read: incredibly annoying) tour guide who shows the Simpsons and Flanders around Jerusalem, is anything but. In fact, he sounds like he's doing a mangled impression of Borat- only faster, louder and for far longer than anyone would ever want. Seriously, he never shuts up. Which wouldn't be so bad if anything he said was remotely amusing, or indeed memorable. Instead, the entire episode (which, due to an overemphasis on Jakob and a particularly uninspired storyline, ranks among the worst) becomes a twenty-minute one-note joke. And that joke, basically a reiteration of his line ''What? Israel people are pushy? How about you experience a few genocides and see how laid back you are?'', screams at you until you're reaching for the aspirin. It's almost as if Baron Cohen was trying new material for another outrageous national caricature and the Simpsons writers were simply too polite to rein him in. But of course, the blame should be shared equally. And just in case you were wondering how Jakob could become even more frustrating, he jabbers on through the closing credits- outstaying his welcome for just a few more minutes.
5. The Rise Of Jerkass Homer
Episode: A Tale of Two Springfields Angry, clumsy and impulsive he may be, but Homer has always reminded us (usually while wrapping up an episode that has seen him yell at Lisa or strangle Bart) that despite his temper, he remains a loyal and loving husband and father.Yet, as The Simpsons progresses, his transition from bumbling but good natured to impatient and outright malicious has caused concern amongst fans, who have labelled the latter incarnation 'Jerkass Homer'. Put simply, the traits that had initially made Homer so endearing have suddenly become quite disturbing. Remember how he revelled in his neighbour's misery in 'When Flanders Failed'? Remember when he shot a tranquilizer dart into Marge's neck to get out of doing chores in 'It's A Mad, Mad, Mad, Mad, Marge'? Remember when, although we wouldn't always agree with Homer lashing out in anger/frustration, we could at least understand why he'd react in such a way? And then came 'A Tale of Two Springfields', showing Jerkass Homer at his irritable, irrational best. Here, we see Homer threatening to blow up a town council meeting with explosives strapped to his belt, and all because of his reluctance to accept a new area code. Somehow, we're less empathetic...
4. Jockey Elves
Episode: Saddlesore Galactica After the Simpsons rescue Duncan, a diving horse from a state fair, they quickly realise (or should that be remember?) just how expensive keeping a horse can be. And so Homer decides to train him as a racehorse under the name Furious D. Things go well at first, with Furious D's bad-ass attitude intimidating the other horses and winning every race. But it isn't long before the other jockeys conspire against Homer and, having dragged him into their underground lair, they reveal their true identity. For their diminutive stature and high-pitched voices hide a terrible secret: the jockeys are actually elves. Evil ones, at that. After a bizarre musical number, they issue Homer with an ultimatum: lose the next race or we'll eat your brains. Erm...what? Such an outlandish plotline might have worked as an 'anything goes' Treehouse of Horror segment but as an episode's main story it's just absurd. What's more, the show seems perfectly aware of this; with Comic Book Guy (seemingly representing a disgruntled audience) pointing out that not only have the Simpsons already owned a horse ('Lisa Gets a Pony') and Marge has shown signs of a gambling problem before ('$pringfield'), but he later appears wearing a T-shirt stating ''worst episode ever'', pushing the episode from self-referential to self-satisfied.
3. Moe's Rag
Episode: Moe Goes From Rags To Riches Remember that ''You'll Never Stop The Simpsons'' song from 'Gump Roast', in which the show assures us ''Have no fears/ We've got stories for years'', before revealing such gloriously mundane future plotlines as 'Bart gets a cell phone'? Oh, how we laughed, until the episode 'Lost Verizon' managed to spin an entire story out of Bart prank-calling Denis Leary - and then we realised that the song was sounding increasingly like less of a joke and more of a genuine threat. How else to explain this frankly baffling episode in which we follow the journey of Moe's bar rag (voiced by Jeremy Irons) throughout history; from Persia to Italy, Civil War to Great Depression, one achingly gag-free scene to another? If nothing else, it's original. But then there's probably a good reason why other shows haven't devoted the best part of half an hour to the woes and wisdom of a bartender's rag. Oh, and if you're wondering what the above picture is all about, it turns out that Moe is part yeti. Yeah.
2. Hardly Working?
Episode: Them, Robot Take a promising storyline (Mr Burns decides to replace his employees with robots), throw in an inspired choice of celebrity guest (Brent Spiner, lending his voice to all of the robots), add Homer (who is kept on as the plant's maintenance guy/scapegoat) and surely you have the recipe for comedy gold? Sadly, no. The episode barely raises a smile but its absolute nadir comes from Homer's attempt to ingratiate himself with his metallic workmates. Unsure how to act when in a roomful of robots, he decides to open with the age-old joke ''Working hard or hardly working?'' What with them being robots and all, they don't get the humour. And so he says it again. Once more, nothing. And so he tries a third time. Repeatedly, loudly and for a whole thirty seconds. Eventually, and as a punchline that has come all too easily over the years, one of the robots electrocutes him. For such a ridiculously long build-up, it's a shamefully weak pay-off. Homer yells, gets electrocuted. Remember when The Simpsons used to be better than this?
1. I Wasn't Asking
Episode: Strong Arms of the Ma After having her necklace snatched from her by a mugger, Marge becomes agoraphobic and so, to while away the days, she makes use of a weight-lifting set recently purchased at Rainier Wolfcastle's bankruptcy garage sale. Having bulked up and regained her confidence, she later bumps into her mugger and, in an almost shot-for-shot homage to The Godfather, proceeds to beat the hell out of him in broad daylight. Such aggression ultimately winds up in the bedroom, leading to this uncomfortable exchange : Marge: Let's do it! Homer: Listen, my bulky flower, I have an early day tomorrow... Marge (forcefully): I wasn't asking. The next morning we see Homer sitting alone at the kitchen table, his pained expression our apparent punchline. After telling Lisa and Bart that he has made their lunches, he then limps away. The 'joke' being that a night of rough (and, it's implied, non-consensual) sex has somehow emasculated Homer - after all, nothing robs a man of his masculinity quite like making lunch for his children, right? It's a tasteless, unfunny and horribly misjudged scene - and without a doubt one of The Simpsons' most controversial moments. Suddenly a secret society of jockey elves doesn't seem so bad... Like this article? Disagree with the choices? Are there any other Simpsons moments that you wish you hadn't seen? Let us know in the comments box below.