The Simpsons: 10 Real Unaired Pitches (And What They Could Have Been About)

At 545 episodes in, it's crazy to think that some ideas are still on the cutting room floor to this day.

By Glen Naylor /

The Simpsons is widely considered to be one of the greatest TV shows of all time. The American animated sitcom has been running for 25 seasons, making it the longest running American prime time television show, and all the members of The Simpson family are worldwide icons. While the quality has understandably waned somewhat from when the show was at its peak, it still maintains a viewership of millions across the world. The show has aired 545 episodes at the time of writing and with it being renewed by Fox for a 26th season, it is hard to believe that there are many ideas that the show haven't done. In honour of the show's 500th episode back in 2012, show runner and writer Bill Oakley tweeted about real-life pitches that were made for The Simpsons that ultimately didn't make it to air. This list intrigued me and many other Simpsons fans at what could have been. Some of these ideas were merged into other episodes, some got no further than a title or theme for an episode, while some were fully fleshed out but were abandoned prior to animation and voice work. This list chronicles the ten ideas in the order that Oakley tweeted them and discusses the history of these plotline/episode ideas, alongside how these could have gone - ultimately deciding whether or not they would have worked.

10. Homer's Sexual Fantasy

Originally pitched by writer Dan Greaney, little can be found about this episode idea, suggesting that Homer's Sexual Fantasy never got past the ideas stage. It would be too full-on a title for Fox to handle - this is more in keeping with its other major and more risque animated hit Family Guy. With the show airing before what would be classed as the watershed here in the UK, blatant references would be too much. It also doesn't fit with the show's tone, which is more implicit and implied than this idea would suggest. The fact that Homer and Marge talk about "snuggles" while in bed demonstrates this point. The issue of sexual attraction has been the theme of other Simpsons episodes. Homer and Marge have both contemplated affairs and leaving each other, most memorably with Homer and Mindy in "The Last Temptation of Homer." Marge and Homer have also tried sex outside too, finding that the fear of being caught turns them on in "Natural Born Kissers." These two episodes, combined with other episodes during The Simpsons, suggest that this idea may have been slightly watered down and merged into other episodes. The writers have mined this theme for some very funny moments and it could be done again in the future.

9. Homer Privately Tells Bart He Loves Him Best

This idea was initially pitched by writer Ken Keeley. Homer and Bart, despite regularly choking one another throughout the years, have had many stories where the duo have worked together, as well as many incidents of causing mischief and some tender moments. "Saturdays Of Thunder", where Bart and Homer build a soapbox derby racer together springs to mind as an example of this. Despite all the choking and arguments (and the fact that Bart nearly always refers to his dad as Homer), they still love each other and as the only men in the Simpsons house, you would expect a closer bond between the two. Not much can be found about this episode idea but it doesn't take much to imagine how an episode around this concept would go. Despite Lisa being by far the most successful Simpson, any moment of success for Bart is always heralded by the family - witness Bart's D- test go on the fridge next to Lisa's A+++ in "Bart Gets an F." Bart could go on to achieve a dream that Homer has always wanted to do (quite what this would be I don't know, as Homer as achieved so much) and receives the focus of the family's attention, much to the chagrin of Lisa. He would ultimately go on to fail in a way only the Simpson men could do (previously discussed in "Lisa The Simpson"). The episode could end with a tender moment, conducted either on the Simpsons doorstep or when Bart is in bed, as Homer tells Bart that despite loving all his family and all their arguments, he loves Bart the most and kisses him on the head. The idea of who Homer loves the most has always been an interchangeable idea, for instance Homer has all of Maggie's baby photos covering his workstation in "And Maggie Makes Three." Threads of similar stories have been in other episodes but it's such a simple, organic idea that you have to wonder why it didn't get produced and made into an episode.

8. Bart Gets 144 Jeeps

This was an episode idea that was pitched by Bill Oakley and Josh Weinstein and featured in a list of "leftover storylines and ideas" discussed by Oakley on the internet back in 2010. The idea for the episode comes from a World War Two era myth, where advertisements in the back of magazines like Boy's Life and Popular Mechanics said you could buy surplus Army jeeps that had been packed in crates for only fifty dollars or cheaper when bought in bulk. You can imagine that Bart finds the advert in a magazine at the Springfield Retirement Castle and either cons Grandpa Simpson into buying the jeeps or steals Homer's credit card and buys them over the phone. A young man (similar to Squeaky Voiced Teen) ends up sending the crated up jeeps to Evergreen Terrace and, upon opening up the crates, Bart and his school friends drive around Springfield, causing chaos wherever they go. Homer inevitably gets involved and they cause thousands of dollars worth of damage. The jeeps end up with Mr Burns, who uses them to set up a racing league, earning the elderly billionaire a few more million. The Simpsons are left regretting not doing something useful with them as they watch it unfurling on TV. Bart buying stuff he shouldn't do with Homer's money or getting a lot of something has been done in previous episodes (see "Rome-Old and Juli-Eh" where Bart and Lisa get a load of cardboard boxes) but this could work as a fresh twist on the theme. If anyone has played The Simpsons games Road Rage or Hit And Run, you know that you can cause chaos driving round Springfield and this episode could easily replicate that sort of behaviour. The episode could easily have been made, using the episode to parody the manic driving styles often employed in real life and in the Grand Theft Auto games.

7. Homer The Narcoleptic

This idea was originally pitched by David X. Cohen and is one of the ideas that has been discussed by the writers in public. The concept is easy to grasp and you can understand the logic in pitching this idea: Homer is often seen wanting to stay in bed longer or to have a nap in the middle of the day, so why couldn't he develop the disorder where he suddenly falls asleep in the middle of performing activities? This gives potential to many funny moments, seeing Homer falling asleep in the middle of jobs and the effects of this. The first symptom of Narcolepsy is excessive and overwhelming daytime sleepiness, which leads into falling asleep in the middle of tasks, leading to things like causing an incident at the nuclear power plant, crashing the car when driving or falling asleep during "snuggles" with Marge. You suspect that Bart and Lisa would use his disorder to their advantage and their amusement. The disorder can be reduced with less stress and more exercise - both things Homer doesn't do very well - and this could be a nice end to the episode, watching Homer trying to become fitter and more relaxed (and most probably failing.) While The Simpsons, and other TV shows, manipulate real life issues to best fit their stories, Narcolepsy is a disorder with no cure. It would have to be something the show carried on, although it does stay true to character traits - Lisa's vegetarianism and Barney's spell of sobriety from seasons 11 to 14 are good examples. Cohen and Bill Oakley discussed this episode idea at the end of the "Much Apu About Nothing" episode commentary, with them explaining that the title summed up the entire story and they couldn't take it any further, resulting in why the episode was never made.While the idea got shot down as a main episode, it is more of a B-story that would sit alongside a main thread in an episode, with the slapstick nature of the potential scenarios definitely worth seeing.

6. Thirtysimpsons

This idea was originally pitched by David M. Stern and is one of the ideas on this list that reached the draft script stage. The episode was a "thirtysomething" look at Homer and Marge's marriage and contrasting it with the lives of some yuppies who moved in next door and become friends with The Simpsons. It was initially pitched early in the show's life and would have been part of season three had the episode gone ahead into production. Former show runner Mike Reiss discussed the episode idea in the DVD commentary for "Stark Raving Dad" and said that Homer gets a taste for their lifestyle and tries to adopt it, but ultimately realises that his life with Marge and the kids is more than enough for him. Many writers loved the idea and, according to Reiss, Stern developed four or five different draft scripts but it just didn't click and in the end the idea got abandoned. It is hard to speculate further on what the episode could have been about, as it seems the sprouts of this pitch merged into another episode. The episode "The Day The Earth Stood Cool" from season 24, featuring The Simpsons getting new cool neighbours from Portland, seems eerily similar to the Thirtysimpsons pitch. Terrence and Emily live the modern, hipster lifestyle which Homer desperately tries to replicate so he can seem cool, but altercations between the other Simpson family members and the new family cause Homer to be ostracised, leading to a war between him and the new neighbours. All very similar to fans' thoughts about how Thirtysimpsons might have played out.

5. Amusement Park

Little information can be found surrounding this quite generic sounding pitch by Matt Groening. It sounds more like the starting point for the writers to come up with ideas. The fact this idea was pitched by Groening would indicate that it was early on in The Simpsons' life, back when he was more actively involved in the writing of the show, but although he still has input through his role as creative consultant and as the creator of the show, he is less involved in the writing these days. Amusement parks, alongside fun fairs, have certainly supplied The Simpsons with a great source of comedy and episode content. Mount Splashmore, Duff Gardens, Itchy & Scratchy Land, Storytown Village and Krustyland have all featured in episodes and you suspect they have provided enough opportunity for amusement park jokes for one lifetime. The episodes these amusement parks feature in are some of the series' best ever and little more can be added to what the writers have already provided.

4. Homer Vs. Dr. Hibbert On The Issue of Race

For all the satirical takes on American culture and modern society the show has done, The Simpsons have never really tackled race - not the greatest source of comedy - in a big way. Writer Greg Daniels reportedly pitched a story exploring the concept of race in Springfield several times. If you exclude minor recurring characters such as Cookie Kwan, Bleeding Gums Murphy, Apu's wife Manjula and his cousin Sanjay, there aren't many main black or Asian characters. Of the multi-national characters in the show, it could be argued that they fit into racial stereotypes: Groundskeeper Willie (angry Scot), Fat Tony (Italian mobster) and Krusty The Clown (self-loathing Jewish comedian) are all examples that spring to mind. Homer deals with Apu, Carl and Dr Hibbert more than any other character so it seems apt that he would feature strongly in this pitch. A new black family, possibly from another country, could move to Evergreen Terrace and Homer would disagree with their lifestyle and how they have come here. Dr Hibbert could challenge Homer's views on race and multi-cultural beliefs, pointing out how all the characters in the town have contributed to the ever changing culture of America and how his black friends are more intelligent than he thinks (Nahasapeemapetilon, Hibbert and Carlson all have PHDs from university.) Before long, the two are clashing in a variety of ways over the pros and cons of each culture. At the end of the episode, with the help of the town, Homer comes to realise how wrong his views have been and he embraces all of his friends like never before. The episode could work but it needs sharp writing and on point jokes that makes it feel balanced. It would be a difficult topic to broach, particularly this far into The Simpsons' run - the episode was mooted for featuring in season seven during the show's peak for writing, jokes and great episodes. In the audio commentary for "Bart Sells His Soul", Oakley mentions that the idea was nixed because it was decided "The Simpsons may not be the right forum to deal with racism." Daniels doesn't seem to remember the story at all when Oakley brings it up. This suggests that the idea never got further than the initial pitch and it might be for the best.

3. Homer's $1000 Dollar Suit

The idea of Homer having a thousand dollar suit was pitched by Sam Simon, one of the co-developers of The Simpsons. Little is known about the pitch, other than it was left on an index card on the bulletin boards in the offices of the show. It is more of an idea that requires fleshing out as part of an episode but you could see what might happen with it. Homer is known for extravagant purchases bought on a whim - the astrolabe is a prime example. Homer could find a bunch of money on the sidewalk (dropped by Snake after robbing the Kwik-E-Mart) and while meaning well and going to pay off some bills, ends up buying a ridiculously expensive, yet sharp-looking suit. After being mistaken for someone important, he catches Mayor Quimby's attention, who likes his style and employs him at the Mayor's office to help him run the town. When things go wrong, Quimby places the blame on Homer to help him keep his job and Homer returns to his normal life, vowing to never buy anything so stupid again...well, for a while anyway. Simon, like Matt Groening, helped form the style of this series during the show's early few seasons. This idea would probably be around season two or three. This pitch, while not the strongest, has threads that have possibly fed into other episodes - "Simpson and Delilah", where Homer buys Demoxinil and becomes a high powered executive at the Nuclear Plant, is a prime example of this. The Simpsons living in a world beyond their means has brought some good moments and episodes but this pitch on its own wouldn't have provided a classic part of the series' history.

2. Lisa The Scientopteran

Lisa The Scientopteran was pitched by legendary Simpsons writer and producer George Meyer. This episode was originally meant for season eight but ran into issues. Bill Oakley discussed in a 2005 Q & A about "a hilarious and fully worked out story by George Meyer. I can't reveal the subject matter here but we never went forward with it because of 1) legal ramifications and 2) the fact that at least a couple of people on the staff/cast would've felt personally attacked by the episode and we just didn't want to deal with the fallout." It is a sensible deduction that this was the episode he was talking about. Lisa, the most enlightened of the Simpson family, could become fed up of what Reverend Lovejoy and the church are preaching and she decides to find a new religion. She meets a young girl and her family, who are part of the Scientopteran movement, and decides to try this one. When the family notice she has become brainwashed and is spending the family's money on literature to move up to the next level, they try to intervene and stop the obsession. Lisa eventually breaks the hold the group have on her and realises that the religion is a profit making business and that alien intervention in Earthly matters doesn't make sense. She returns to The First Church Of Springfield for now but is still searching for something more. This pitch is clearly targeted at Scientology. Mark I. Pinsky, author of "The Gospel According to The Simpsons", mentions that the producers had "vetoed an episode-length swat at Scientology in fear of the group's reputation for suing and harassing opponents." Nancy Cartwright, the voice of Bart, is a big Scientologist and would have felt the episode was attacking her and her beliefs. Unlike Isaac Hayes in the controversial South Park episode mocking the religion, Cartwright is integral to the show and the producers wouldn't want to risk losing her. This episode had huge potential and it is possible that some elements of Meyer's story may have been watered down and used in Season nine's "The Joy of Sect," which focuses on a fictional cult, The Movementarians.

1. Prince Comes To Springfield

Mike Reiss talked about a never produced sequel to the Michael Jackson episode "Stark Raving Dad" on the episode's commentary for the DVD. James L. Brooks wanted the character of Leon Kompowsky to return - this time believing he was Prince. The idea was developed by Conan O'Brien and the writers and after some confusion over the scripts (Prince's chauffeur reportedly did a version of a script and gave it to the singer, whose people sent it back with notes), Prince hated the actual script in the end and the episode fell through. The use of Kompowsky to do this is fatally flawed. The people of Springfield may be stupid, but they aren't stupid enough to fall for the same thing twice. The clever thing to do would be to flip the premise of "Stark Raving Dad": the real Prince comes and gets the whole town of Springfield to loosen up, become more flamboyant and sexually open. The only person who doesn't believe it is him is Homer, who's been fooled by a crazy singer before. Prince tries to win Homer round and is ultimately unsuccessful, so he leaves Springfield to go to Shelbyville - somewhere he will be universally loved. The townsfolk, not for the first time, are mad at Homer for making the singer leave. The idea has huge potential and some of the episodes featuring celebrities have gone on to huge acclaim. "Stark Raving Dad" was a huge success and is widely accepted as one of the best episodes. It is understandable that the writers and producers would want to do an episode of a similar ilk, but ultimately the draft scripts and Prince's opinion of it made the episode an no-go. What do you think to these episode pitches: do you think they could have been successful episodes? What could have been done with them? Leave your thoughts and ideas below. If you like this article, please follow me on Twitter €“ @glen_naylor.