The Simpsons: 10 Times Homer Really Should Have Died

How has one man been damaged to such an extent and still lasted more than 500 episodes? That's the power of television, we guess.

By Simon Spowart /

We're still waiting to find out which of The Simpsons' characters is to be killed off in season 25. Fans and critics have practically fallen over themselves to predict who will bite the bullet after the teasing reveal, even if Family Guy's similar stunt might have dulled the impact since.

Advertisement
Following the sad passing of Marcia Wallace, Mrs. Krabappel will no longer appear in the show, but if there's one character that shouldn't be in the show anymore, it's bumbling, stumbling father-of-no-year Homer. Make no mistake: Homer J. Simpson should be dead. Think about it: how many crazy schemes and unlikely adventures has this guy been on? Over the show's quarter century run, he has been beaten, drowned, stabbed, shot, crushed, and trampled on, and yet lives to tell the tale, reappearing the following week without so much as a scratch. Take a look at some of the moments Homer has endured, where lesser man would have surely perished...

10. Head Crushed In Drawbridge

Of all of his body parts, it's Homer's head that has probably taken the most punishment throughout the show's history. Of course, suffering from Homer Simpson Syndrome (which we'll examine more closely later), this hasn't posed much of a problem for him. In "Lost Our Lisa," Homer incurs further damage (which should really be fatal damage) to his dome when he loses Lisa after his parenting skills sink to a spectacular new low. After insisting his young daughter rides the bus alone, he dashes across town to rescue her, eventually finding her thanks to a borrowed cherry picker. Naturally, Homer loses control of the cherry picker and rolls downhill, smashing his head on a traffic light and scraping it on a bridge, before plunging into a river. Lisa has a drawbridge closed for Homer to grab onto, but in typical Homer style it closes right on his head. To compound the injury sustained from what must be an incredible amount of force crushing his head, several cars drive over his scalp as he is dangling below. Despite all of this, he requires no hospital treatment and is healthy enough to encourage Lisa to take even more risks in order to break into the Springsonian Museum. Most other men would have needed a lie down first.

9. Eating Poison Fish

With Homer being such a greedy guy, it was inevitable that one day his enormous appetite would be his undoing. A victim of his own hunger, he almost pays the price when visiting a local sushi restaurant for a change of scenery in "One Fish, Two Fish, Blowfish, Bluefish." After being reluctant to try the new cuisine, he is won over and begins gorging himself, working his way through the entire menu before reaching the fugu. Despite repeated warnings not to eat it, he demands to be fed and so the apprentice chef prepares the dish, apparently in a way which suggests he has eaten the poisonous parts. Homer spends the next day crossing things off his bucket list, doing all the things he always wanted to (until Grampa hogs most of his time and he winds up in jail), and then prepares himself for death by listening to Larry King reading The Bible. The neurotoxins should have paralysed his muscles and stopped him from breathing, but somehow, Homer manages to survive through a stroke of pure luck: you might say he "pulls a Homer."

8. Hyper-Obesity And Exposure To Radioactive Gas

There's a running theme here: a unique combination of hunger and stupidity seems to land Homer in the worst possible danger. Working in a nuclear power plant for years should really have seen him off by now, but he's still going strong in season seven in "King Size Homer." After finding out a colleague is allowed to work from home on disability grounds, Homer makes it his mission to become disabled by injuring himself. After this doesn't work, he reads up on disabilities to see if he already has any - being disappointed when he doesn't. He then realises if he gains even more weight, he will be classed as hyper-obese, and achieve his dream of working from home. He sets out on his mission, eating everything in sight (including a play-doh donut). After gaining the weight and having a safety terminal installed at home, his sheer laziness endangers the whole town and he is forced to rush to the plant to shut down the core manually. Climbing a ladder, he reaches the manual override switch just as the ladder breaks under his enormous weight, sending him plummeting down into a tank of radioactive gas. Luckily, his ample ass plugs the hatch tight. Not only should Homer have developed severe health issues associated with being incredibly overweight, falling into radioactive gas really should have finished him off. But again, Homer's unbelievable luck meant that he was too big to fall completely into the gas, and his life was saved.

7. Falling Down Springfield Gorge (Twice)

There aren't many men that could survive falling down a gorge. There are even fewer men that could survive falling down a gorge twice. But Homer manage to despite tumbling down the jagged canyon twice in a row. Homer accidentally winds up jumping Springfield Gorge whilst trying to stop Bart in "Bart the Daredevil". After almost making the jump, he plummets to the bottom, smashing his body over and over again on the unforgiving rocks. After falling for what seems like forever, he hits the ground. Lying there gasping for breath, the skateboard smacks him in the head, adding insult to injury. After being airlifted out on a stretcher, he is rushed into an ambulance which crashes into a tree, flinging the doors open and sending Homer falling down the gorge again. This time, he is strapped into a stretcher and has no way to even put his arms in front of his face - yet he still manages to survive. There's simply no way any human being could survive this kind of punishment, especially twice in a row, so unsurprisingly this is perhaps the most famous of all Homer's brushes with death. An early favourite, it's been referenced in a number of later episodes, and even in the Simpsons Movie, where you can see the ambulance that crashed still wedged against the tree that it hit.

6. Fighting The Heavyweight Champion Of The World

For fans of Homer head trauma, we're coming back to good old brain injuries. As mentioned, Homer is the sole sufferer of a unique genetic condition called Homer Simpson Syndrome, where his brain is cushioned by a layer of protective fluid. His skull is also thicker than average, acting almost like a football helmet under his skin (no wonder he can take such punishment). This is all explained (and exploited) in "The Homer They Fall." After seeing Homer take a beating from three guys in his tavern, Moe signs Homer up to box in the amateur leagues. Realising his shocking fitness levels mean he couldn't hurt a fly (literally), Moe's tactic changes to the old rope-a-dope: allowing opponents to tire themselves out punching Homer before he lands a single knockout punch. This works fine, until Moe is tempted by a lucrative offer to pit Homer against the world heavyweight champion Drederick Tatum. After just six seconds of the first round, Homer is in serious trouble, enduring intense shots to the head and body. Homer is nothing more than a human punch bag, standing there taking incredible punishment until Moe flies him to safety. It's a wonder that Homer made it as far as the Tatum fight. Even the amateur fighters he faced must have dealt out a fair bit of punishment before tiring themselves out, and you'd think it would have taken its toll eventually. The Tatum fight should have been enough to see Homer take his final fall, but luckily Moe remembered how important their friendship was and stepped in to do the right thing.

5. Attacked By Santa's Reindeer

Homer's ignorance is to blame for another major assault on his person, after his narrow-minded opinions of a new family friend lead him to take Bart deer hunting. Homer sustains serious internal injuries and is lucky to survive a run-in with a herd of reindeer. After meeting John, a charming shop owner, the Simpsons are welcoming of him until Homer finds out he's gay. After this, he becomes obsessed with making sure Bart grows up straight for once, and takes the boy hunting. After not finding any wild deer, Homer takes Bart to Santa's Village where a herd of reindeer are kept in a pen. The reindeer don't take too kindly to their intrusion, and end up surrounding Homer and Bart. Homer does manage to do something honourable for once, and lifts Bart up above his head to shield him from the imminent danger. Homer is then butted and gored by antlers from all sides, as the reindeer exact a brutal revenge. Just as it looks like the end for Homer, John saves him with a creepy robot Santa that scares the reindeer away. There's no doubt that Homer should have died in "Homer's Phobia," with deer antlers capable of inflicting pretty serious damage to a human. As well as internal rupturing and haemorrhaging, they'd have cut him up pretty bad too. Once he went down he'd have been trampled to death by the herd for sure.

4. Locked In A Sensory Deprivation Tank

Now and then, Homer really does try to make up for his lack of parenting skills - it's just a shame they usually result in him being severely injured in some way. His relationship with Lisa often sees him subject himself to major punishment, especially when he agrees to seal himself inside a sensory deprivation tank. "Make Room For Lisa" sees Homer take his prodigious daughter to a new age healer to make up for letting a cellphone mast be built in her bedroom. The pair enter sensory deprivation tanks where Lisa is enjoying her out-of-body experiences, but Homer's journey is a little less spiritual. His tanks is repossessed, but falls off the truck and mistaken for a coffin by the Flanders', who bury it deep in the ground - too close to a pipe, which collapses and Homer is washed out to sea before returning to shore on the tide (where Ralph Wiggum thinks it's a whale egg). Unable to protect himself, this really ought to have been the end of Homer. Falling off the truck may have seen him run over by a passing car, whilst being buried should surely have ended with him suffocating inside the tank. He was incredibly fortunate not to drown, as the tide could easily have swept him out to sea rather than back to land.

3. Duel With A Southern Colonel

Homer's brash, headstrong attitude can land him in hot water at times, but combine this with a blatant disregard for his own safety and there's a recipe for disaster. Not only does he risk his own life, but he puts his family in harm's way too. After seeing a movie in "E-I-E-I (Annoyed Grunt)" Homer decides to solve all of life's problems by challenging people to duels: something which eventually gets him into serious trouble. He eventually challenges the wrong guy - a Southern gentleman that says "Suh" - leading Homer to flee town with his family in tow. They find shelter on Grampa's old farm, before being forced to return to Springfield after the animals develop a dangerous addiction to his tomacco plants. The colonel is still pitched outside the Simpson house, waiting to duel. Homer finally has to deal with the situation that he created, but just as they're about to duel, the colonel is distracted by Marge's mincemeat pies. Even though it looks like Homer has wriggled out of more deadly circumstances, he demands they continue with the duel. His pig-headed behaviour leads to him being shot, luckily only in the arm. It's a real wonder that he wasn't killed, as you'd generally expect a man who regularly carries firearms to be fairly proficient - and accurate - in their use.

2. Sucked Into Space

Most of Homer's brushes with death occur in Springfield, as it seems he can't go two minutes without placing himself in mortal danger. But there are a handful of times where he makes it beyond his front door, where his idiocy almost kills him in new and unknown locations. "Deep Space Homer" sees our beloved patriarch become the first civilian to go into space following NASA's concern that their Nielsen ratings are too low. Shortly after launch, Homer reveals a bag of chips he has smuggled aboard. Tearing open the bag, the chips begin to fly around the shuttle in zero gravity. He smashes open the ant farm, releasing hundreds of the insects into the shuttle which destroy the navigation system. Musician James Taylor suggests they blow the hatch to suck the ants out into space, but just before the hatch is closed, Homer's double dose of stupidity almost see him sucked out into space - not only does he not think to strap himself into his chair, but he lets go of whatever he's holding onto whilst the hatch is still open. He grabs the handle as a last resort, and is pulled back inside before snapping off the handle to attack a fellow astronaut in a fit of rage - meaning the door won't shut for re-entry. Luckily, a carbon rod is on hand to keep the door shut, saving their lives. It's amazing to see Homer managing to withstand the force created by the vacuum with just one arm, as he clings to the door handle. It's also remarkable that the rod held the door closed as the shuttle returned to Earth. There's a reason why average people don't go into space, and even more reasons why Homer Simpsons don't.

1. Eating Radioactive Waste, Surviving A Suicide Attempt & Being Swept Out To Sea

Homer has a great many character flaws - greed, laziness, selfishness and stupidity - and all of these combine mercilessly in "Hello Gutter, Hello Fadder" in order to finally bump Homer off. Of course, he manages to survive the entire episode thanks to sheer luck - and a little help from Maggie. After being forced to eat barrels of toxic waste as punishment for being 26 hours late for work (which he didn't even mind eating), Homer joins Lenny and Carl for a game of bowling - lying to Marge so he doesn't have to have a tea party with Maggie. He bowls a perfect 300 game, which turns him into a minor celebrity but leads to a suicide attempt when his fame wears off. He jumps off a building but grabs onto Otto who is bungee jumping at the same time, and survives the fall. Homer then realises what's important to him and focuses his attention on his children, but his efforts at parenthood are too little, too late for Bart and Lisa. He tries to bond with Maggie by taking her swimming but she doesn't trust him enough to enter the swimming pool. On the drive home, they stop off at the beach for a swim where Homer is swept out to sea. He tries holding his breath and running along the sea bed to shore, but his lack of fitness tells. Maggie summons the courage to swim out to Homer and save him: we later learn that babies can develop superhuman strength when a parent is in danger. If Homer should have died in any episode, this was it. There is just no way a man could eat radioactive waste, or survive a bungee jump with too much weight for the cord, or even have his infant daughter save him from drowning. But it's clear that no matter what Homer does, he's destined never to die just because the writers, and the fans, and - yes - the whole world, love him so much. Hooray! Like this article? Have we missed a notable near-death experience? Let us know in the comments section below.