Smallville: 10 Episodes Which Got Superman Right

Often regarded as the red-headed step-child of the Superman canon, Smallville could still occasionally throw out something awesome.

By Grace Murray /

Declaring you're both a fan of Superman comics and like Smallville is equivalent to admitting that you're a Star Wars fan and you kind of like The Phantom Menace. It's just not done. The difference is that while The Phantom Menace is consistently mediocre, Smallville just gets a really bad press. It's terrible sometimes, sure, but just as often, it's pretty great. It ended over two years ago now, so here's a quick recap for those of you who never watched the show or have decided to pretend it didn't exist. Smallville (2001-2011) ran for 218 episodes and was about Clark Kent's journey to become Superman. Its unpopularity stems from its stubborn adherence to the 'no flights, no tights' rule, which most memorably led to Clark taking the name of The Red-Blue Blur so the series could save the birth of Superman for the final episode. Smallville is silly, soapy, full of angst, and unintentionally hilarious, and that is why, on occasion, it works. It's not consistent, and it's not the same Superman fans were seeing in comics at that time, nor is it the grittier interpretation of Man of Steel; Smallville does what it says on the tin, which is explore a juvenile Superman's efforts to become a hero, with Silver Age body-swapping, melodrama and morals thrown in. The show proves that there's more than one way to get Superman right, and here are ten episodes in which Smallville does just that.

10. Heat (Season 2, Episode 2)

Episode Summary: Clark develops heat vision when he's turned on by a sexy substitute teacher. Yes, you read that correctly. How is this getting Superman right, you ask? Well, this is the first episode of Smallville which finally acknowledges that although it might be silly, it doesn't mean you have to pretend it doesn't exist. Heat vision looks odd on film, even in Man of Steel, so Smallville decides to play it for laughs and it works. Tom Welling absolutely sells the excruciatingly embarrassing scene in which Jonathan Kent (John Schneider) tries to teach him to control his urges by getting him to aim at a haystack and think of Lana Lang. It's ridiculous, but then, comics have ridiculous elements too. After all, we are talking about a character who, prior to the reboot, spent his childhood travelling to the far future with a teen superhero team and grew up to wear his underwear over his tights and deceive everyone with a pair of glasses. It's possible to do Superman right without these things, but Smallville stakes its claim to the silliest of concepts in this episode and somehow produces an entertaining hour. It's the first episode in which Smallville acknowledges that emo pop music playing over angsty staring will only get you so far.

9. Red (Season 2, Episode 4)

Episode Summary: Red kryptonite makes Clark lose his inhibitions. Watching Clark revel in his power is a thrill for Superman fans, because it highlights how much of his time is spent holding back. There's a moment when he shoots himself in the hand to demonstrate his invulnerability which is so out of character that it's almost laughable, particularly as Tom Welling is clearly having so much fun letting go of Clark's usual mildness. Case in point: the symbol of Clark's rebellion is his newfound love of leather jackets and motorbikes. The episode plot is inconsequential, but again, it's a first: the realisation that a young Superman must make mistakes. For the most part, Smallville manages this admirably as Clark grows into the hero we know and love.

8. Rosetta (Season 2, Episode 17)

Episode Summary: Christopher Reeve appears as Dr Virgil Swann, who tells Clark about his Kryptonian heritage. Forget Doctor Who's anniversary specials: this is the definitive example of passing the torch from actor to actor. Reeve's appearance in the series not only gave it a seal of quality for some sceptics, but also showed Smallville's willingness to embrace both its cinematic heritage and its comic book origins. Smallville was very slow off the mark with all things Krypton, probably to avoid alienating audiences who were actually interested in the romantic drama of the first season, so Rosetta was a landmark moment when Clark's home world was finally named. It's the moment when Smallville finally begins to slot into place in DC's history, and it was a huge relief for everyone who thought the show might never get to the most famous part of Superman's origin story.

7. Phoenix (Season 3, Episode 2)

Episode Summary: A double bill in which Clark, again under the influence of red kryptonite, turns to a life of crime. He's saved by Jonathan, imbued with Clark's powers by Jor-El. What is a comic book show without the ability to do a good action scene, with superpowers thrown in? Exile and its second part Phoenix throw probably the season's whole budget away on one big fight, but it's worth it. It's the grandest one yet, with the two Kents falling through the window of a skyscraper. Evil Superman is difficult to do, because it would be devastating for the character to do irreparable damage. There's an intense moment between father and son when Jonathan dares Clark to kill him if that's how he's been raised, and Clark hesitates, but punches the wall instead. Clichéd, maybe, but that's how to do a conflicted Superman, and Smallville shows it can keep the character's integrity and deliver a good old punch-up.

6. Crusade (Season 4, Episode 1)

Episode Summary: Clark is brainwashed by Jor-El into his Kryptonian persona. Smallville rigidly kept to its 'no flights' vow until the finale €“ except when it didn't, usually due to brainwashing or dreams. A Superman adaptation would be nothing without a thrilling first flight sequence, and Smallville doesn't disappoint. In the first episode of season 4, Kal-El declares to Martha that Clark Kent is dead, and that he must fulfil his destiny, and he shoots up into the sky. It's hard to overstate how huge this moment is after three years of earthbound action. Clark is momentarily incapacitated by a piercing ringing in his ears, then stands and glances up to the heavens. With Martha Kent in slow-motion next to him, Clark gathers the air around him, the music swells, and he takes off. We even get a cheesy version (is there any other kind?) of the bird/plane line. Smallville revels in grand gestures to Superman fans, and the first flight is notable for taking place in an episode which also introduces Erica Durance's Lois Lane, who confronts a naked and confused Clark in a corn field and remains totally unfazed. More on her later.

5. Reckoning (Season 5, Episode 12)

Episode Summary: After Lana dies, Clark turns back time to prevent it, with tragic consequences. Smallville can play Superman for laughs and it does with varying degrees of success, but it also likes its drama, and the most dramatic event of the young Clark Kent's life is the death of his father. In an episode which features time travel, the Fortress of Solitude, and a car wreck, it's poignant that Jonathan Kent dies of a heart attack. What's more, it's possibly because of all he endures in Exile/Phoenix, leaving Clark with guilt which will play on his mind for years. Smallville spent far less time on the father/son relationship than it did on that of Clark and Lana, but it felt genuine, and Reckoning sees the show using its soapiest tactics for an emotional gut-punch. Jonathan Kent's death marks the show's transition from teen fare to a more confident series with dramatic as well as comedic beats €“ as well it should.

4. Descent (Season 7, Episode 16)

Episode Summary: Lex kills Lionel and confronts his conscience. Villains are vital to Superman, because otherwise, we end up with him walking across America for some reason (see Superman: Grounded for proof that this happened). Descent sees Lex Luthor complete his transition from sympathetic loner to big bad. In the first five minutes, he murders his father, the magnificent Lionel Luthor €“ who was played positively gleefully by John Glover €“ with the chilling words, "No one will even remember your name." Lionel had been a moustache-twirling villain worthy of Bond prior to his semi-redemption, but we watched Lex almost as closely as Clark. The final moments of this episode, in which he and Clark exchange stares but no words over Lionel's grave, are equivalent to a declaration of war. Rosenbaum carries the episode and gets the best out of Welling too, leaving the audience with no doubt that Smallville had a handle on its legendary villain.

3. Infamous (Season 8, Episode 15)

Episode Summary: Clark goes public with his abilities. It ends badly. Time travel fixes it once again. Lois Lane is one of the most important parts of the Superman mythos. She grounds Superman but also encourages him, and Erica Durance plays Smallville's Lois in the feisty tradition of Margot Kidder, Teri Hatcher and Dana Delany. This episode gives us Clark telling Lois his secret ("Guess I should stop calling you Smallville...") then catching her in his arms, in an homage to an iconic moment in film and on the page. Infamous is a busy episode which justifies Clark's decision to keep his powers secret and moves him one step closer to the big glasses, but it's on the list because of Lois. Everything about her scenes, from her assumption that she is the first one Clark told to her correct observation that Clark will not tell her a second time, is pitch perfect. While Crusade gave us a Lois Lane who would be more than a match for Clark's crazy life, Infamous actually confronts her with it and she reacts as brilliantly as we hoped she would.

2. Absolute Justice (Season 9, Episode 11)

Episode Summary: Superhero team-up! The JSA and the Justice League join forces. By season 9, Smallville had well and truly immersed itself in DC mythology, introducing a rudimentary Justice League with the spotlight on Green Arrow; here it adds the JSA, and throws recurring character Martian Manhunter in there too. The tenuous premise of a killer after the Justice Society is little more than an excuse for a two hour team-up between the youngsters and the old guard. Superman works best in a team, because his usually unshakeable convictions are challenged by heroes with more cynical and abrasive attitudes. While Smallville never had the rights to the best foil of all, Batman, we get a whole lot here to make up for it. Michael Shanks is suitably gruff and irritable as Carter Hall/Hawkman €“ he made a welcome return in season 10 €“ particularly when paired with an equally sulky Oliver Queen, who dubs him 'Conan'. We also get a cryptic hint at Clark's future courtesy of Doctor Fate, for whom cryptic is actually a redundant adjective. Absolute Justice is the culmination of Smallville's investment in DC's history.

1. Homecoming (Season 10, Episode 4)

Episode Summary: Clark, despondent about his heroism, is taken on a journey through his past and future by the benevolent Brainiac 5. Critics of Smallville argue that it was never really about Superman, and in some ways, they're right. The show stuck so closely to its original premise of Clark becoming Superman that it slowed the journey to that endpoint to a crawl. If you're waiting impatiently for Clark to don the cape, this is the wrong show for you, but as this list shows, if you accept that Smallville is only ever going to be about the road to get there, you'll see that Superman's character shines through. In Homecoming, Clark needs some encouragement at his high school reunion and it comes in the suitably silly form of Buffy alumni James Marsters as Brainiac 5. He's whisked to the future, where he is initially repelled by his uptight future self in his Clark Kent guise before he realises that Lois knows his secret here and helps him to keep it. Then he catches a glimpse of a red and blue blur flying past the window. They're conventional moments in the comics, but in Smallville they take on added meaning because we've waited so damn long to get there. At this point in the present Lois does actually know Clark's identity, and she tries to tell him at the episode's conclusion, but he shushes her and neither one notices that they float up into the air as they dance. Yes, Lois is the key to Clark's ability to fly, which is a spot-on dramatisation of the importance of their relationship. It's the crown on top of a series which was always caught between promising the inevitable ending and preventing it from occurring, and Homecoming finally lets us know that Clark's almost there.