Star Trek: 10 Episodes That Could Have Happened

By Brian Chapman /

There are nearly seven hundred live-action episodes of the Star Trek franchise. If you watched them all back to back, it'd take you more than twenty one days before you get to the end. Although if I were you, I'd skip the last episode of Enterprise. So with that many episodes of the series developed, it is unsurprising that a significant number of episodes went undeveloped. During various periods of the shows, the producers allowed unsolicited scripts to be sent in for consideration and a handful of those were made. At least one online reviewer was flown out to pitch story ideas for Star Trek: Voyager (incidentally - hey, new series producers, I'm over here!). But seriously, Star Trek has had some famous episodes and storylines go unproduced. Some end up being reworked and reworked until they become something different (Deep Space Nine's Time's Orphan episode originated as a Next Generation episode about Alexander), whilst others get completely canned (ever hear about the episode where Tom Paris gets his arm ripped off? Nope? Didn't think so). In some cases, they even become elements of other shows - I know at least one Farscape episode originated from a Star Trek concept. A number of science fiction writers worked for different shows at the same time they must have reworked failed Star Trek pitches and re-used them elsewhere. Plus of course you have Star Trek: Phase II - that had a full half season of stories planned out and only two were re-used for Star Trek: The Next Generation. So here are my 10 favourite undeveloped stories and ideas for episodes in the Star Trek franchise...

10. The Origin And Return Of Thomas Riker (Star Trek: The Next Generation & Deep Space Nine)

Poor Thomas Riker. Such big plans, and yet only appeared in two episodes. Two pretty good episodes mind you. For those of you that aren't in the know, Thomas Riker was essentially a transporter duplicate of Commander William Riker. Yes, they wheeled out that old Original Series plot. Except this version was permanent, and a Lieutenant, and had spent several years trapped on a planet as no one knew he was there. In his mind, he never broke up with Deanna Troi. I always thought he was a very interesting version, and the season long duplicate version of John Crichton in Farscape always reminded me of Tom Riker. The reason why I include the origin here is because interestingly enough at one stage the plan was to kill off William Riker in the first episode to feature Thomas and have the new version of Riker become the main character ongoing. A very soap-opera-esque idea, I know. It would have made Data the second in command of the Enterprise, although I can't remember if the plan was to have Riker as the Operations Officer to replace Data or the Security/Tactical Officer to replace Worf (who would have become Ops Officer). Anyway, they never went through with it. So Thomas Riker missed out on a bunch of episodes there. In my mind, they made the better choice. Thomas Riker returned in Deep Space Nine, having joined the Maquis and stole the Defiant. He ended up being captured by the Cardassians and that was the last we saw of him. But at a few points that wasn't the plan either €“ it seemed that the producers of Deep Space Nine aimed to bring him back but for whatever reason it just never happened. At one point the writer's pack for one of the seasons actually stated that they weren't looking at Thomas Riker return stories presumably because they already had something in mind. Jonathan Frakes, who played both William and Thomas, wanted Riker to suddenly pop up in Damar's rebellion towards the end of the series. I personally think that by then it would have been too late. I know exactly the right time to re-introduce Riker and I think that the producers had the same idea. I'm convinced he was originally intended to appear in the episode In Purgatory's Shadow €“ the one where Garek and Worf travel to the Dominion prison where they meet Enabran Tain, General Martok and the real Julian Bashir (who we didn't know had been replaced by a shapeshifter). I'm sure that Bashir was probably Thomas Riker in one of the early drafts and then someone came up with the shapeshifter replace which wouldn't work with the character and they subsequently chose Bashir instead. After that, Thomas Riker just didn't fit anywhere and so was never used again.

9. I.Q. Test (Star Trek: The Next Generation)

Every season of Star Trek: The Next Generation has episodes starring John De Lancie as Q. Every season. Except season five that is. Because both the stories for season five had some serious problems were shelved. This is the story of one of those episodes, I.Q. Test. Otherwise known as the Q Olympics episode. I wish I was kidding. Thankful Michael Piller can be thanked for canning this idea which was made by Herb Wright and an unnamed co-writer (who has probably kept their name under wraps due to the shame of it). Basically Q and another member of the Q-continuum decide to have an Olympic type duel using two teams of athletes. You guessed it, the Enterprise crew was our Q's choice, while the other Q chose a new race called the Zaa-Naar. Ronald D. Moore later described the idea as "ludicrous" and said that Piller was right to dump it. And if to make matters worse, a rumour got around that none other than Arnold Schwarzenegger was due to appear in the episode. In the same AOL Chat as before, Ron Moore said that "There was never €“ ever €“ any chance that Arnold was going to appear on the show." Phew. We'll have to wait for till Voyager's Tsunkatse before we get scenes like that.

8. Deep Mudd (Star Trek: The Original Series)

Everyone loves Harry Mudd. To be honest, I expected in both of the J.J. Abrams films that Greg Grunberg would show up playing him. There is even a rumour that at one point that there was an intention to bring him back in Star Trek: The Next Generation as one of the cryogenically frozen survivors in the end of first season episode The Neutral Zone. This was certainly only a post-series rumour as Roger Carmel died the year before The Next Generation aired and so it couldn't ever have been possibly planned. In the end we only had two live-action episodes starring Carmel as Mudd, Mudd's Women and I, Mudd. They even considered airing Mudd's Women as the first episode of the entire series at one point but figured the subject matter wouldn't be a great first impression. There was actually a third Mudd based episode planned, called Deep Mudd. The plan was to have a direct sequel to I, Mudd with Mudd escaping the planet of androids and ending up with a bunch of powerful weapons and hijinks with space pirates. The Enterprise would have had to save Mudd's neck and dispose of the weapons. By all accounts it was going to be made - the only thing that stopped it was that Carmel was off filming a movie at the time and couldn't appear. I'm guessing that since they didn't shelve the episode and use it when Carmel was available, this must have been towards the end of the third season. It was a shame, as Carmel never appeared on screen as Mudd again - only voicing him once more in The Animated Series episode Mudd's Passion.

7. Kilkenny Cats (Star Trek: Enterprise)

This was actually an episode that was in the pipe-line for the fifth season of Star Trek: Enterprise under Manny Coto. As we saw in season four, he liked his references €“ and in some cases he referred not only to The Original Series, but also to elements of the Animated Series. Kilkenny Cats was to be another return to TAS and would make canon several elements of one of those episodes. The episode in question was The Slaver Weapon, written by famous science fiction writer Larry Niven. It was based on his short story The Soft Weapon, which was re-written into the Star Trek universe. If you've watched the episode, then you remember it as the one with cats (the Kzinti) in pink spacesuits. Alas, the spacesuits were meant to be grey, but the director (Hal Sutherland) was pink/grey colourblind and no one picked up on it. We're not entirely certain of the plot of Kilkenny Cats other than it was a very seriously taken episode idea - work had already begun on Kzinti starship designs for Enterprise as Josh Finney over at Glitchwork put some together. I would have loved to have seen them attempt a screen test for make up for a Kzinti, it would either have been fantastic or the worse make up we've ever seen. Sadly, not to be.

6. More Tribbles, More Troubles (Star Trek: The Original Series)

David Gerrold is a great writer. Literally, his first professional work was the script for The Trouble With Tribbles. Following the success of that earlier episode, Gene Roddenberry had promised to have a return episode once again featuring the furry little creatures. So Gerrold, who submitted (and subsequently documented) a fair number of other proposed episodes, set about writing the new episode. However, come the third season with it's reduced budgets and not exactly brilliant time slot, Roddenberry decided that he would no longer be attached to the project and left. Replacing him as executive producer was Fred Freiberger. Despite the fan reaction to the original Tribbles episode, Freiberger did not like the comedy elements of the episode and simply wasn't interested in making a further episode of that type €“ Tribbles or not. Fortunately for us, this isn't really an undeveloped episode €“ it was simply never developed in live-action. When Star Trek: The Animated Series began, Gerrold enquired about writing for it and executive producer D.C. Fontana immediately asked for the second Tribbles episode. Gerrold later said that pretty much everything that was in the live-action version ended up in the animated episode €“ just that the animation played faster and so it had a shorter running length. So next time you watch that episode, just imagine how much better it would have been in live-action (and as with the entire Animated Series, imagine everything that is pink is actually grey). Mind you, this isn't the last time David Gerrold is going to appear on this list...

5. Scorpion Replacement (Star Trek: Voyager)

We know Scorpion as the end of third season/fourth season opener for Star Trek: Voyager which introduced Seven of Nine. But that wasn't the original plan for the two parter. Instead, the first idea which was placed on the drawing board featured the return of the duplicate Voyager crew from the episode Demon. It would have seen "Voyager" return home to the Alpha Quadrant, either pulling past Deep Space Nine or arriving at Earth amid much celebration and fan fair. A number of ideas were put forward, which differed on whether the duplications knew who they were or thought they were the original versions. But the writers couldn't get their heads around it and it was shelved - but not entirely cancelled. It was later re-considered for the slots which ended up being used for both Year of Hell and The Killing Game. It was finally considers for the end of season four and start of season five. The idea ended up being ditched in the end because it was felt that it would undercut the series when the real crew managed to get home. In the end, the alternative crew did reappear, but no-where near Earth - instead they were completely wiped out when they returned in the episode Course: Oblivion.

4. Joanna McCoy

D.C. Fontana had an idea to expand the back story of Leonard McCoy by introducing his daughter Joanna as a character in the series. There were two attempts to bring her into the fold, first in the episode Joanna €“ which ended up being significantly rewritten until it became The Way to Eden. The original version would have seen a romantic interest between Joanna McCoy and Kirk (of course), which leads to a conformation between the Captain and the Doctor. Such was the expectation that Joanna McCoy was going to appear that she's mentioned in Gene Roddenberry and Stephen E. Whitfield's The Making of Star Trek as a character who was going to be appearing shortly €“ the book was written prior to season three of The Original Series. The second attempt, entitled The Stars of Sargasso, was intended for the fourth season of The Original Series but was cancelled along with the rest of that season. She's subsequently appeared in the novelisations, comic books and even a mention in an Animated Series episode but nothing canon.

3. He Walked Among Us (Star Trek: The Original Series)

For such an unreligious show, Star Trek: The Original Series liked to talk about God in metaphors quite a lot. A staple plot was some sort of robot is a god-like entity on a planet. Then of course you have the canned film project Star Trek: Planet of the Titans where the Enterprise crew are effectively God themselves, giving fire to mankind and of course Star Trek V: The Final Frontier with that bid disembodied head. Star Trek doesn't really do God, with the exception of the Bajoran religion in Deep Space Nine (and as I said in a previous article, even there they had to show that the gods actually existed €“ they weren't allow to have blind faith in the future). Even there they were prophets and they never said the big "G" word. So He Walked Among Us should have slotted right into the normal framework, especially considering that it was written by Norman Spinrad who won the Hugo Award for Best Dramatic Presentation for his 1968 episode The Doomsday Machine €“ said to be one of the best episodes of the series. Essentially the plot was roughly that a Federation scientist loses it on a new planet and after using advanced technology, the local inhabitants consider him their god. Actually, that sounds familiar... I'll re-watch Into Darkness at some point, I'm sure. Anyway, the staff did a re-write and made it funny. Spinrad didn't take kindly to his script being re-written into a comedy and told them to pull it. They did. The End. Which is a shame because Spinrad was a good writer, and I'm sure they could have gotten another episode out of him before the end of the series if they'd gone with his script. Who knows, maybe we could have missed out on Turnabout Intruder.

2. William Shatner In Star Trek: Enterprise

At various points during Star Trek: Enterprise's run, there were rumours about William Shatner reprising his role as James T. Kirk. Before both the third and fourth seasons there were official statements about how ideas were being formulated and considered etc... but it seems that it was only in the fourth season that things were ever serious. You see, William Shatner wanted to be in it. He really did. So much, that he was pitching his own ideas. Shatner's big idea wasn't even to appear as Kirk €“ he wanted to appear as Kirk's counterpart Tiberius from the Mirror Universe. It was effectively a nod to Shatner's Shatnerverse books where the Mirror Universe features fairly heavily. The plot would have been that the Tantalus device didn't actually kill the people placed in it €“ it simply threw them back in time to another universe (the main Star Trek universe). After the Mirror-Kirk returned to his universe following the events of Mirror, Mirror, at some point Mirror-Spock would have usurped him and used the device on him. So he appears older in Enterprise, having survived on some planet for several decades before being discovered by Archer and the Enterprise NX-01. The problem was that this would cause the main timeline to know about the Mirror Universe ahead of the events of Mirror, Mirror. Although, I maintain it would have been a cool episode and perhaps given at least one version of Captain Kirk a death scene that the character was worthy of. Hell, perhaps Kirk could have been Archer's own personal version of Khan. Parts of the concept survived into In A Mirror, Darkly €“ the USS Defiant is pulled back in time into the Mirror universe from the main universe. I even think they offered Shatner an alternative €“ I vaguely remember something about being an ancestor of Kirk who has to pretend to be him for some mission. Wisely, Shatner turned them down.

1. Blood and Fire (Star Trek: The Next Generation)

You can't really have this list without including Blood and Fire as the number one choice. It is a legend around the Star Trek community and pretty much led to a great mind in Star Trek being shown the door due to homophobia and some pretty bad timing. In addition to the two Tribble episodes, he can also be credited with a great deal of the changes made to Star Trek: The Next Generation as compared to The Original Series. Despite Gene Roddenberry putting his name on it, Gerrold actually wrote the series bible. All Roddenberry did was remove certain sections of it. For example, Gerrold suggested that there was no reason why the transporter room couldn't just be off the bridge - why did they always have to take a lift there? Roddenberry didn't include that change as he felt the lift sequences allowed for exposition-type dialogue to take place before away teams were beamed away on their missions. So he was on the writing team in the early years of The Next Generation - at the same time though, Roddenberry was going through a great deal of health issues and his lawyer had become ever present. Despite this, Roddenberry still appeared for the fans. At one panel where both Roddenberry and Gerrold was present, the Great Bird of the Galaxy was asked about homosexuality in Star Trek. He agreed that it was something that needed to be covered in the series and afterwards Gerrold set to work on a script about the subject. He turned in a first draft called Blood and Fire. He received good feedback off on it, and headed off to appear on a Star Trek cruise expecting it to be all fine in his absence. However, on his return it seemed that the lawyer had got his hands to it. Gerrold was informed that the lawyer, Leonard Maizlish, didn't like the idea and had convinced Roddenberry to cancel it. The official story is that Paramount canned it because they thought it would offend children. Mind you, this was at the same time that a great big alien burst out of a decapitated corpse in the episode Conspiracy. Herbert Wright tried to do a re-write, and was told by Maizlish not to let Gerrold anywhere near it. Wright produced a version called Fire and Ice, but that was also unsuccessful. The story would have involved an AIDs allegory in the form of Regulan bloodworms and some gay characters. In fact, it was later reworked as an episode of the fan series Star Trek: New Voyages. As for Gerrold - after the issues with the episode he asked for his contract not to be renewed. He later remarked that the last time he and Maizlish met, the lawyer called him: "a f*cking f*ggot." Heard about any other ideas that were considered for Trek? Let us know below!