Star Trek: 10 Most Underrated Characters
Can they get some non-holosuite love from anyone?
When it comes to memorable characters, the Star Trek universe is an embarrassment of riches. From Kirk and Spock to Picard and Data, audiences experience Star Trek's image of the future through some of television's most iconic characters. We're spoiled, to say the least.
Yet with so many great characters to choose from, somebody's bound to be forgotten. Even among Star Trek's series regulars, certain characters felt neglected by writers and fans, or in some cases, both. That's ignoring the outright bile directed at a few of Star Trek's supporting players through alt.wesley.crusher.die.die.die and the like. From hell's heart, they stabbed at thee, all right.
Aside from the occasional story arc being thrown at them like scraps to a targ, these characters were usually relegated to Starfleet's bench. Always a synthale, never an ale - or something like that. When they were an episode's primary focus, audiences often resented their presence - because reasons?
Despite facing ill will and patchy writing, these characters still reached the stars, eventually becoming integral parts of their respective series. They might be underrated, but they deserve plenty of admiration.
Here are 10 of the Star Trek franchise's unsung heroes.
10. Dr. Phlox
Enterprise's chief medical officer embodied so many of Starfleet's best qualities, yet he's often overlooked on account of the show's lacklustre run. What a shame.
Phlox's calm demeanor and excellent bed-side manner made him one of the Star Trek franchise's most skilled physicians. With grace under pressure like his, if given the choice, we'd all be lining up for hyposprays at the Phlox Clinic.
Never one to pass judgment on other cultures, his inquisitive and open-minded spirit would be the envy of any Federation diplomat. Eat your heart out, Ambassador Spock.
Phlox's Denobulan culture and physiology, especially his multiple wives and penchant for playing matchmaker, led to some hilarious moments about the Enterprise NX-01. From his rude awakening from hibernation to seeing him puff up like a blowfish, Phlox is one of the Star Trek universe's best-kept secrets.
Who can ever forget Phlox practically shaming Commander Tucker for not doing the nasty with his wife Feezal? Your loss, mate.
9. B'Elanna Torres
Beginning Voyager as a member of the Maquis Rebellion, the half-Klingon, half-human B'Elanna Torres was known for her fiery nature and strength of will. She could hold her own in any scrap and wasn't opposed to rearranging a mouthy engineer's face over a power grid.
B'Elanna quickly became Voyager's chief engineer almost by default, but her abilities confirmed the wisdom of Captain Janeway and Commander Chakotay's faith in her. Not bad for a Starfleet dropout.
Unlike other Star Trek characters of mixed background, B'Elanna was routinely at war with herself, struggling to reconcile her Klingon and human sides. After being bullied for her cranial ridges and abandoned by her human father, is it any wonder B'Elanna felt self-conscious of her Klingon heritage?
It's a brave depiction of her, and one that echoed the experiences of many biracial fans. Thankfully, with a bit of help, B'Elanna was able to accept her Klingon side and trust that her husband Tom Paris wouldn't follow in her father's footsteps by taking off like a Pyrithian bat out of hell.
8. Wesley Crusher
Come on, he's not that bad. Wesley Crusher, The Next Generation's boy wonder, was the subject of needless harassment and hatred from day one. We would've thought bullying would be extinct by the 24th century.
Although portrayed as an unrealistic Mary Sue in season one, The Next Generation's Wesley Crusher gradually matured into an important part of the Enterprise-D crew. He was still brilliant enough to solve almost any puzzle, yet his demeanour calmed, becoming less childish and annoying as the show progressed.
Even at his worst, audiences were supposed to live vicariously through Wesley's curiosity and wonderment in being aboard the Federation flagship. Surely, we could all relate to him on that level. There was no reason to resent him for it.
His later questionable judgment in performing a prohibited flight maneuver with his squadmates served to further humanize Wesley and make us realize that he could screw up just like the rest of us. Plus, his problematic relationship with the Traveler still creeps us out. Stay away from him, Wesley!
7. Geordi LaForge
"Mr. LaForge?" How many times have we heard Captain Picard call on his trusty chief engineer to save the stardate? We've lost count.
Providing a steady hand in any crisis, the Enterprise-D's chief engineer was in many ways the ship's bedrock. No matter what anomaly threatened the Enterprise, and there sure were plenty of them, Geordi could be counted on to guide the crew through their worst nightmares.
He wasn't just a first rate engineer, Geordi's character broke ground in its portrayal of disability. Rather than present his blindness as an infirmity, it was instead, with the assistance of Geordi's VISOR, something that made his character and abilities unique.
Geordi's friendship with Data also showcased his kind, open-minded nature. We could all use a friend like him.
Yet compared to The Next Generation's other regulars, Geordi rarely got to enjoy the spotlight on his own. When an episode did focus on him, it was often to poke fun at Geordi's dating misadventures.
Rather than take a deeper dive into his character's hopes and motivations, the show's writers often used Geordi's clunky dialogue as a means of spouting various technobabble. While that was all well and good to advance an episode's plot, it seldom helped in getting to know the man behind the VISOR.
6. Lwaxana Troi
Daughter of the Fifth House, Holder of the Sacred Chalice of Rixx, Heir to the Holy Rings of Betazed, Lwaxana Troi was one of the Star Trek franchise's most decorated characters. Unfortunately, she was also one of its least loved. There's no accounting for taste, we guess.
Lwaxana was a brilliant diplomat and nurturing mother, yet her eccentric and candid personality provided some of The Next Generation's most iconic comic relief.
Admittedly, she could be overbearing on occasion, but her relationship with Deanna was deeply heartfelt. She only wanted the best for her daughter, and it showed.
Lwaxana's telepathic abilities led to more than a few uncomfortable exchanges about the Enterprise. Who didn't enjoy seeing the normally unflappable Picard going out of his way to avoid Lwaxana? Truly, he had met his match.
If that weren't enough, Lwaxana's Deep Space Nine appearances added further depth to her character. Her sensitivity and kindness towards Odo, not to mention his awkward reaction to her advances, made their relationship one of the show's most underrated pairings.
While trapped in a turbolift in "The Forsaken", Odo reverts to his liquid state, something he's never done in front of another person, and Lwaxana reveals that she in fact wears a wig. As far as moments of vulnerability in Star Trek go, it's hard to top.
5. Miles O'Brien
Please, writers, stop hurting him.
Acting as Deep Space Nine's everyman, Miles O'Brien's down to earth nature was designed for audiences to empathize with him. He was an ordinary working stiff and family man who enjoyed the simple pleasures in life.
Yes, despite the wonders of the Star Trek universe, all O'Brien needed to unwind was a decent synthale and a kayaking session in the holosuites. How quaint.
He certainly wasn't the flashiest or sexiest Star Trek character, but he showed up and did the work. Through over 200 episodes of Star Trek, O'Brien was as solid as the rock they call Gibraltar.
Criminally underrated during The Next Generation and Deep Space Nine's original run, O'Brien has since enjoyed something of a renaissance, with Lower Decks recently dubbing him, "perhaps the most important person in Starfleet history." Finally some love for the "Hero of Setlik III".
With his real-life problems and aspirations, it was easy to put ourselves in O'Brien's shoes, which is why the show's writers revelled in making him suffer at every turn.
From a Pah-wraith possessing his wife to enduring years of hard time in brain prison, Deep Space Nine's writers' room sure loved torturing O'Brien. No wonder he gave it all up to teach at Starfleet Academy. Space is scary.
4. Michael Burnham
Discovery's Michael Burnham was a pioneering character, to say the least. The series' first leading black woman and non-captain was also among Star Trek royalty, regardless of what certain angry white fans had to say about the show's diversity. She was Spock's adopted sister, after all. Show her some respect.
Criticism of Burnham's character has often felt linked with broader antipathy towards Discovery. The show's refusal to emulate The Next Generation's episodic model means certain fans won't give her a chance. That's on them.
Granted, Burnham's on-screen career as First Officer of the USS Shenzhou did get off to a rough start. Committing an act of mutiny against her captain and mentor, Philippa Georgiou, in the hope of avoiding war with the Klingons, Burnham was court-martialed and sentenced to life in prison.
Although later released and given a chance to redeem herself, Burnham's betrayal cast a pall over Discovery's first season. That was even before all the moody Gabriel Lorca/mirror universe stuff, but let's not get into that right now.
Much like her adopted brother, Burnham occasionally struggled to reconcile her Vulcan and human sides, yet she was decisive as all Sto-vo-kor when it counted. Plus, she was warm to those around her and not afraid to show her emotions.
Possessing Vulcan brilliance and human intuition, Burnham has grown into a worthy officer, earning the admiration and respect of her colleagues. Give her a break, will you?
3. Quark
Quark had his share of flaws, but would you rather be anywhere else when in search of a drink in Bajoran space? We didn't think so.
The heart of Deep Space Nine's community, Quark's provided a place to relax, play a few rounds of Dabo, and cut loose. Although his Ferengi culture often clashed with his patrons, they typically relied on Quark for advice in solving their problems - or just a shoulder to cry on. We're looking at you, Bashir.
The Ferengi bartender's wry observations of "hu-mon" culture served as the perfect foil to the Federation's utopian ideals. Even when he was being a total pest, Quark could see past the Federation's gleam to know most of its citizens would turn into ravenous wolves if denied their holosuites and root beer.
Unlucky in love and even unluckier in profit, Quark's follies provided the perfect comic relief to lighten Deep Space Nine's darker tone. Maybe tone down the raging sexism, though.
2. Deanna Troi
Possessing empathy and compassion in spades, Deanna Troi was a patient counselor for the crew of the Enterprise-D. Although she experienced her fair share of personal tribulations, Troi was always willing to help those in need of her assistance.
Sadly, Troi was often depicted as an overly emotional woman who couldn't control her feelings - or her sweet tooth. Despite her half-Betazoid status, much of the writing for her character felt plagued by misogyny. Those early outfits sure didn't help, now did they?
How many times did we need to hear Troi cry out, "pain!" when asked if she sensed anything? She was an empath, we got the idea.
Thankfully, by The Next Generation's later seasons, Troi had overcome these problems, establishing herself as a capable bridge officer and eventually earning the rank of commander.
The fifth season standout "Disaster" gave Troi the opportunity to flex her leadership muscles while taking command of the Enterprise during a shipwide, er, um, disaster. She showed considerable grace under pressure, especially when dealing with some of Ensign Ro's more uppity suggestions. Somebody get Troi another chocolate mousse. She earned it.
1. Dr. Katherine Pulaski
Replacing Beverly Crusher as the Enterprise-D's Chief Medical Officer for The Next Generation's second season, Dr. Katherine Pulaski had big shoes to fill, to say the least.
That's not to say Crusher was especially well-utilized during The Next Generation's first season, but taking over from an existing character was always going to be a difficult prospect.
Fans resented the loss of Crusher, and Pulaski sadly bore the brunt of those frustrations, although we suppose calling Data an "it" and mispronouncing his name didn't help the matter.
Still, there was a lot to like about Pulaski from her short run about the Enterprise. Sure, she could be brash at times, but her direct approach was refreshing next to the constant politeness of her fellow crewmates. She just never really clicked with the rest of the cast.
On the bright side, Pulaski did flex her medical chops on more than one occasion, performing heart surgery on Picard in "Samaritan Snare" and saving the captain's life, much to his embarrassment.
"Unnatural Selection", in particular, highlighted Pulaski at her best. Risking her life to learn more about a virus causing rapid aging, Pulaski's actions helped save the staff of an infected research station. She did good.