Star Trek: 10 Times Captain Janeway Was Right And Everyone Else Was Wrong

With no Starfleet, no backup, and sometimes no coffee, Janeway managed to make the right calls.

By Jack Kiely /

When you and your crew are stranded further away than any other ship, and Starfleet (the fungicidal maniacs) still won’t declassify the spore drive, you’d better have the constitution to make some strong decisions and stick by them: popular or not.

With no means of two-way communication with her superiors in the Alpha Quadrant until the sixth year of the trip back home, the buck always stopped with Captain Janeway. No one else could make the final call. Sure, she relied – as any good captain would – on her senior staff, but this is a Starship, not a democracy!

Janeway encountered a fair bit of contestation during the first couple of years in the Delta Quadrant, in particular from members of the Maquis who were frequently not too happy with her vision for survival. Later, faced with Chakotay’s sting-in-the-tail opposition, with Seven’s more direct 'Captain-you-are-in-error' moments, or Tuvok’s well-intentioned, but very Vulcan scepticism, Janeway stood her ground.

The following command decisions may not have all been moral victories, the Captain would be the first to admit, but they were the correct course of action in the moment, especially with a bunch of doubters in the background who she had to prove wrong.

10. Rejecting Villainy In The Void

When Voyager is pulled in to an area of subspace in the titular episode, the crew realise that the place is quite literally a void. There are no stars, no planets, and especially no deuterium. The only matter of any kind is the other ships that are unwittingly trapped there, and the competition for resources is, hence, ferocious and deadly. Even worse, being in the Void is draining the warp core, and Voyager is immediately attacked.

When it becomes clear that ship’s resources aren’t going to last long in these circumstances, Chakotay and Tuvok, wondering if they should be more 'opportunistic' whilst in the Void, gang up on Captain Janeway. When they ask if the crew should be willing to die for their principles, Janeway delivers one of the best, most just ripostes of any captain:

If the alternative means becoming thieves and killers ourselves, yes. […] We may lose a little weight, gentlemen, but we won’t lose who we are.

She proposes forming a sort of 'mini-Federation' ('the Alliance') to share food, supplies, and relevant technology with anyone willing to play by the rules: no stealing, no killing, and no giving up! Chakotay and Tuvok (again!) are immediately sceptical, and later Seven expresses her frustration before making a rapid about-turn with Fantome.

In the end, Janeway is right and her detractors are wrong. Despite the odd speedbump, the Alliance is such a success that all the ships within it escape the Void with Voyager.

9. Keeping Seven On Board

By the end of Scorpion Part II, Seven of Nine has been disconnected from the Borg Collective. When Chakotay goes to see Janeway in the holodeck, he asks incredulously, "You plan to keep her on board?" doubting that she will even want to stay. Janeway’s reply is simple: they "pulled the plug" and so are responsible for her now. Moreover, they can offer one thing the Borg can’t: friendship.

In the year or so that followed, Janeway and Seven were often at loggerheads. Seven more than once openly contradicted Janeway, and even disobeyed direct orders. Under the influence of a Borg homing signal, she fled Voyager before being rescued, and she may have jumped ship of her own free will had the Dauntless not proven to be a hoax. Seven was an unknown risk for the crew, and B'Elanna definitely took a while to warm to her.

How many Borg hitchhikers are we gonna pick up on this trip? ~ Lt. Torres, Drone

At each stage, however, and often despite her own frustrations, Janeway supported, protected, and nurtured Seven in her development as an individual. Janeway’s decision to keep her on board was proven right. Seven became a vital member of the crew, a friend to all (and even lover to Chakotay), a mentor for Naomi, and, later, partner to Raffi and essential to Picard’s missions.

Even B'Elanna came around eventually: "Mild shock. Not bad!"

8. Trusting Torres

Things could have turned out very differently between the two crews – Maquis and Starfleet – in the Delta Quadrant. There was nothing, other than a common set of circumstances, to suggest that these diametrically opposed groups could and would integrate as they did.

In the beginning, Captain Janeway equally had little reason to trust the 'hot-headed' Torres, and the feeling was mutual. There were also a few who would have been right to expect a promotion or two over the newcomer. (Looking at you Carey and Harry!) Let us not forget that it was around this time that Tuvok created his training holoprogram depicting a Maquis insurrection aboard Voyager.

When Janeway did promote Torres to the role of chief engineer, somewhat against her own instincts and against expected protocol, she was right to do so. Chakotay, as a former Starfleet lieutenant commander, was the obvious choice for First Officer, but the nomination of an Academy dropout with a troubled past to a key post was a symbolic act. It showed that Janeway was willing to place her faith in, and work with, the diversity of backgrounds within the Maquis.

After a bit of a learning curve, Torres, in her position as chief engineer, would contribute more than most to the successful merging of the crews. Evident from the start, her expertise would continue to prove Janeway right throughout as a crucial factor in saving the ship on numerous occasions.

7. Refusing To Share Technology With The Kazon

In the first two years of its journey home, Voyager was under near constant attack by the Kazon – a kind of low-rent Klingon, more orange than a night out with the cast of TOWIE. The Kazon’s technology was vastly inferior to that of Voyager, but they were much greater in number.

By the time of the events of the episode Alliances, Voyager was almost permanently disabled by a Kazon onslaught, and members of the crew (Maquis in particular) became extremely vocal in their views on sharing technology. Basically, just 'give them what they want'.

Janeway categorically refused any notion of an exchange of technology. This would be a flagrant violation of the Prime Directive, radically altering the balance of power in the region. The crew had also seen the devastating effects their technology could have, if misused, when Cardassian spy Seska leaked replicator plans and equipment to the Kazon.

Janeway is, nonetheless, strongarmed against her better judgement into trying to form an alliance, first with one of the Kazon sects, and then with all of them in peace talks with the Trabe. In turns out, however, that the Captain’s instincts were right; the Trabe attempt to massacre the first Majes present at the talks. Using Voyager as a bargaining point to obtain increased stability in the region has only led to more conflict.

On this occasion, Janeway should have trusted her own savvy throughout, and not the misplaced suggestions of a good number of the crew.

6. Stopping The Equinox Whatever The Cost

This one is going to prove extremely controversial, and Captain Janeway didn’t entirely agree with herself by the end of the whole saga.

When Voyager encountered the USS Equinox, it was under attack by a race of interdimensional aliens. At first, the two crews play happy reunions. It is soon discovered that Captain Ransom and his cronies have been capturing and killing the nucleogenic lifeforms to power their ship and improve their warp factor. Janeway is rightfully appalled and locks them up. They escape back to their ship, leaving Voyager defenceless against the aliens in the process.

When Janeway decides to go after the Equinox rather than focussing on Voyager, Chakotay accuses her of pursuing a 'vendetta' – a sexist trope that a woman must be seeking revenge and not justice. Was Chakotay’s method as 'moral arbiter' somehow more noble? Eventually, Janeway relieves him of duty and later threatens to do the same to Tuvok.

It is true that Janeway takes some arguably reckless risks and plays fast-and-loose with a few moral boundaries despite her crew’s protestations. BUT, she is right to go after Ransom, and hang the consequences! Ransom is a Starfleet officer and he has been committing mass murder to get his crew home. If Janeway hadn't stopped him in his tracks, there would have been no other relevant authority to do so within thousands of lightyears. Like it or not, Captain Janeway’s decisions stopped the killings and saw Voyager through the day.

5. Disarming The Nanoprobe Warheads

In season five’s In the Flesh, the Delta Flyer happens across a perfect recreation of Starfleet Headquarters, which even comes with its own Boothby, and just enough Vulcan literature to ensure you won’t need to replicate a doorstop. Practically indistinguishable from the original, the fabrication is the work of Species 8472.

It seems like conflict or all-out-war is inevitable, and Captain Janeway orders the creation of bio-molecular warheads that use Borg nanoprobes to attack 8472. However, Janeway can’t get Starfleet directive 010 – every attempt at a nonmilitary solution must be made before combat – out of her head. Seven thinks this option is impossible: "It’s time you resisted your Starfleet philosophy".

Janeway proves both Seven and 8472 wrong when she de-escalates the situation and proposes a "class reunion" with the Boothby duplicate. The meeting is extremely tense, and neither side seems to be trusting each other, until the Captain decides to take her finger off the trigger. She orders Seven to disable the nanoprobe warheads. The dramatic move convinces 8742 to keep talking, and a conflict is avoided. Seven later admits that she anticipated immediate attack in response to the Captain’s "human weakness," but that she was wrong to think so. Were it not for Janeway having a little "faith" in her decisions being the right ones, an unprepared Alpha Quadrant might have been invaded.

Now, we really must figure out how to shake hands with an 8472!

4. Leaving That Damn Nebula

Technically speaking, the events of this entry happened and never happened. They are, nonetheless, a fine example of a win for the Captain when those around her were dubious.

In the two-parter Year of Hell, Voyager is under near constant attack by the Krenim who seem intent on proving they do have something big in their torpedo tubes. The damage gets so bad that most of the crew are forced to abandon ship and go it alone until Voyager can meet up with them again.

By the start of the second episode, Voyager has taken refuge inside a nebula, but it is proving more trouble than it’s worth. Janeway makes the executive decision that "we’re leaving this damn cloud first thing tomorrow morning". The look on Kim, Torres, and The Doctor's faces tells us that they are sceptical, but they say nothing as she’s the Captain. With no such inhibitions, Seven bluntly states, "You are in error". Tuvok, even though he disagrees with disagreeing, clearly thinks the decision is the wrong one.

If they had waited in the nebula for weeks on end, it is unlikely that they would have amassed enough allies with whom to share their temporal shield technology before Annorax could alter the timeline. They also may have missed the message sent by the captured Paris.

Ultimately, leaving the nebula when they did was crucial to destroying the timeship. Janeway's decision was so right (including taking the temporal shields offline at the last moment) that everyone got a do-over as the timeline was restored.

3. Flying The Ship Through A Binary Pulsar

She may have been driven to the edge by alien experiments, but she’s a badass!

In the episode Scientific Method, Voyager’s crew are experimented upon by a group of aliens who are using microscopic tags to inflict ever more severe genetic mutations. When the plan to disable the tags fails, and a Voyager crewmember dies horrendously on the bridge, Captain Janeway is pushed to breaking point and flies the ship between a binary pulsar.

This ends NOW!

Not only is this one hell of an epic scene, but Janeway is proven right to the likes of Tuvok, Kim, and the aliens themselves (one of whom materialises on the bridge in an attempt to stop the Captain). Tuvok, after suggesting a course change to avoid the pulsars, comments that "this is a far more reckless course of action" than he has come to expect. (WRONG!) Kim suggests diverting all remaining power to shields when things get really sticky. (WRONG!) The aliens’ interventions come to nought as Janeway has locked in the ship’s course with her access codes. Neither can the aliens kill everyone, because the work of the entire crew will be needed to get through the stars’ gravity.

With a decisive speech – "[...] you are not in control here anymore" – Janeway vanquishes the aliens, transfers all remaining power to engines (sorry, Kim!), and leaves the pulsars in the dust.

If she’d listened to anyone else, Voyager might still be a flying laboratory or, worse, the third wheel of a binary system.

2. Taking Responsibility For Moset

In the episode Nothing Human, the Doctor creates a hologram to aid him in removing a parasitic alien from B’Elanna Torres. When it is learnt that the program is based on a Cardassian war criminal (Crell Moset) who tortured Bajorans for his own medical experiments, the crew are justifiably up in arms. Torres herself refuses any treatment that would come from Moset, and a fierce ethical debate ensues.

We can’t simply descend into the Manichaeism of right and wrong concerning the morality behind the use of hologram Moset in saving B’Elanna’s life. The situation is far too nuanced for such a dichotomy. What we can discuss in similar terms is whether Captain Janeway, as leader, was correct to make a choice to use him or not.

After hearing the arguments, Janeway does decide to use Moset, as her only concern there and then is the "well-being of [her] crew member". They will wrestle with the morality of the situation after B’Elanna has recovered. She clearly states that "any consequences of this decision will be my responsibility".

Later, when B’Elanna tells Janeway, "you had no right to make that decision for me!" the latter replies, "I’m the Captain. You’re my crewman. I did what I thought best". The point here is that Janeway was right, and well within her rights, to make the decision. There is no hard moral line in this case, only the choice to act or to not and accept the consequences.

1. Hedging Her Bets On Kashyk

In the episode Counterpoint, Voyager must traverse a region of space controlled by the Devore Imperium, an alien civilisation that outlaws telepaths. To save the telepathic members of her own crew, and a group of refugees they have rescued, Captain Janeway must play a careful game of wits with Devore inspectors.

Whilst Janeway certainly gets no opposition from her shipmates, she must still prove herself right against an entire authoritarian government, and particularly against lead inspector Kashyk.

Janeway’s success lies in playing note against note with Kashyk. Each are performing a piece of deception: the latter defects to Voyager but is really only there to capture the telepaths; the former does not know Kashyk’s true intentions, so adeptly plays both melody and countermelody to their resolution.

It is no coincidence that the music which bookends the episode is the second movement of Mahler’s First Symphony. The piece is written in the form of a Ländler, a popular folk dance that preceded the 'more sophisticated' Viennese Waltz. At the start of the episode, it is Kashyk’s choice of music as his team are ransacking Voyager, and he is boasting about his knowledge of Earth culture. At the end, Janeway is victorious over the Devore; she has ensured the safety of the telepathic refugees whatever Kashyk’s motives. She switches the music back to Mahler as if to mock him for his civilised façade, and to let him know that she has outdanced him.

Advertisement