Star Trek: 10 Times Spock Abandoned Logic

There were several occasions in Star Trek where Mr. Spock's famous logic wasn't what saved the day.

By John Wilson /

Spock is the half Vulcan-half Human character portrayed legendarily by Leonard Nimoy for several decades, by Zachary Quinto in the Star Trek Reboot films, and currently by Ethan Peck in Star Trek Strange New Worlds. Each portrayal plays on the portrayal of the stoic, analytical, and logical Vulcan learning to live and work on a ship with primarily professional but emotional human beings.

Advertisement

Spock’s half-human physiology, his human mother and recently adopted human sister Michael Burnham was a source of constant teasing and bullying throughout his childhood, with bullies often attempting to get an emotional reaction from him. He also suffered from L’tak Terai, a Vulcan form of dyslexia. Despite all this, Spock excelled at the Vulcan Science Academy and was set to join the Vulcan Expeditionary Group but instead chose Starfleet.

Due in part to an incident with his sister, Spock developed a closed-off and aloof manner with people early on. He embraced logic, analytics, and science over intuition and feelings. Doctor McCoy often called Spock unfeeling but the truth is that Vulcans have very strong emotions and Spock sometimes lets his emotions override his logic.

10. Spock’s Love Life

Spock’s first and possibly longest-lasting love was T’Pring, with whom he had an arranged relationship at age seven. In Amok Time, Pon Farr had overtaken the first officer and he had eight days to mate or he would die. However, the son of Sarek had become something of a celebrity on Vulcan and that wasn’t something that T’Pring wanted. She invoked kal-if-fee, the right for her betrothed to fight for her, and Kirk was chosen as her champion.

Advertisement

Christine Chapel was assigned to the Starship Enterprise in 2259 as part of the medical staff. Her open and gregarious nature was a contrast to Spock’s quiet and stoic controlled one. When the pirate Angel took over the Enterprise in The Serene Squall, the First Officer and the Nurse had to fake a relationship to prevent T’Pring from releasing Angel’s lover.

In the Kelvin Universe, Spock and Lt. Nyota Uhura had a strong if occasionally strained relationship. In Star Trek (2009), Uhura openly consoled her Captain after the death of his planet and mother and he looked at her with shame when he lost control on the bridge. Uhura became angry with her Vulcan boyfriend in Star Trek Into Darkness when she thought he was going to sacrifice his life with no thought of her but he assured her that she was paramount in his thoughts.

9. His “Complicated” Relationship With His Family

Spock had an often strained relationship with his father Sarek, who spent much of his life devoted to logic and service to his people. Sarek had to choose between his biological son and his adopted daughter on who to send to the Vulcan Expeditionary Group. Despite the Vulcan path being the more logical one, Spock chose Starfleet. A rift of many decades emerged between the two men due to this decision.

Advertisement

Spock was extremely unhappy when human Micheal Burnham was made his foster sister. But he eventually developed genuine affection and began to idolize her. Logical extremists targeted her because is human and Micheal ran away. Spock wanted to go with her, stating he loved her. Not wanting him to get hurt, she said heinous things about his biology which caused Spock to become cold and distrusting. Even though he logically deduced what Michael had done, he held onto the animosity for years.

Sybok was Sarek’s first son with a Vulcan princess. He was a gifted and highly intelligent student but abandoned logic and embraced emotion as the key to knowledge. Sybok was sent to a rehabilitation center and Spock did not speak of his half-brother even to his closest friends. Spock was clearly embarrassed by his half-brother, an emotion that serves no logical purpose.

8. The Anger And Forced Mind Meld With Lt. Valeris

In Star Trek: The Undiscovered Country, The Klingon moon of Praxis was destroyed and will make the Klingon homeworld unlivable in fifty years. Spock has begun working with Klingon Chancellor Gorkon to end hostilities between his people and Starfleet. Spock volunteered the Enterprise to accompany the Chancellor to Earth to begin negotiations.

Advertisement

On the Enterprise, the crew meets Lt. Valeris, a Vulcan female who will act as helmsman. Spock had followed her career closely and was impressed by her, intending to choose her as his replacement. She questions her mentor about the logic of their mission and he informs her that logic is the beginning of wisdom, not the end. Over the course of the trip, Gorkon’s ship was attacked and he was killed.

Surmising that the assassins had to have come from Enterprise, Spock puts Valeris in charge of the investigation but it is discovered that she was behind the crime. She is revealed as a member of a larger group of Starfleet officers who are against the Klingons being let into Federation space.

Spock violently forces a mind meld to get the names of her co-conspirators and the new location of the conference. This questionable act goes against Spock’s nature as he laments to Kirk that he was blinded by her accomplishments as a Vulcan and should have realized Valeris’ involvement in the conspiracy. Kirk lamented that he had been blinded by his own prejudices and asked his friend to forgive himself.

7. Nearly Killing Kirk

In the Original Series' second season episode called Amok Time, Spock was gripped with Pon Farr, the Vulcan time of mating, and must return to Vulcan and marry his betrothed within eight days or he will die.

Advertisement

Defying a direct order from Starfleet, the Enterprise arrived at Vulcan where Kirk, Spock, and McCoy beam down. T’Pring and Spock are drawn together through their psychic bond to their marriage ceremony of koon-ut-kal-if-fee. It will be officiated by T’Pau, one of the most revered and respected Vulcans in history. However, T'Pring invoked the kal-if-fee, the right for her betrothed to fight for her and she chose Kirk as her champion.

Spock was so crazed with brain fever that he did something that he never would have done if he had been in control of his faculties, he killed his friend. In fact, at that moment, killing the Captain may have seemed the only logical thing to do. This was how far into the depths of Pon Farr Spock had fallen. But the realization of killing his superior officer and friend broke him out of his brain fever and he returned to the Enterprise to face murder charges. There, he finds Kirk alive and elatedly embraced him before collecting himself and returning to his previous stoic demeanor.

6. Both Student And Commander Spock Gave Into Anger When Taunted

In the 2009 reboot Star Trek film, young Spock was tormented by three Vulcan boys. They berate him about his mixed Vulcan and human heritage as Spock noted that this was the 34th time that they tried to get an emotional response out of him. One of the boys called Spock’s father Sarek a traitor and his mother Amanda Grayson a “human whore.” The young Vulcan became enraged, abandoning his logic, knocked the boy into a skill dome, and beat him severely.

Advertisement

Later, the Romulan Nero from the Prime Universe destroyed Vulcan, killing most of its population, including Spock’s mother. Spock and James T. Kirk argued about how to deal with Nero. Spock ordered Kirk removed from the ship but he returned due to the aid of Prime Universe Spock and Montgomery Scott.

At Elder Spock's suggestion, Jim insulted the younger Vulcan, claiming that the death of his mother and his world meant nothing to him until he cracked, beating Kirk savagely until Sarek stopped him. Spock instructed McCoy to judge him as unfit and Jim took over. It was the younger Spock’s mistake to remain in command when the death of his mother had affected him and trying to compartmentalize it when that emotion was so quickly triggered by Kirk. If the emotional break had happened during a command decision, it could have had devastating consequences.

5. Dropped Out Of Kolinahr To Talk To V’Ger

At the end of the five-year mission, Spock chose to return to Vulcan to undergo training in the Kolinahr ritual. Kolinahr was the near monastic ritual for the purging of all emotion and learning the mental discipline to keep that state. The training can run anywhere from two to six years in length. Two and a half years into his training, Spock feels the presence of a vast consciousness and abandons his training.

Advertisement

Spock returned to Starfleet and returned to the Enterprise along with the returning Admiral Kirk where he immediately assumed the role of Science Officer once again. Within three hours of his arrival, Spock helped Scotty fix the issues with the malfunctioning warp drive. Otherwise, Spock was very cold to his former shipmates and did not interact with them any more than necessary.

Spock stole a thruster suit and broke out of an airlock. He attempted a mind meld with V’Ger but was knocked unconscious by the sheer enormity of its intellect. Spock discovered that V’Ger had learned all that could be learned in this universe and needed to evolve.

William Decker merged with V’Ger and went on to another dimension. Spock stayed with Starfleet, realizing that pure logic would not answer his questions. He began to realize that the Vulcan way was not his way and that he would have to find his own logical path.

4. Resorted To Emotion To Save Galileo

In the thirteenth episode of the Original Series, aptly named The Galileo Seven, Spock, McCoy, Scotty, and four other crewmen are in the shuttle Galileo investigating quasars while the Enterprise is preparing to head to a pandemic on New Paris. Something in the phenomenon knocks the shuttlecraft off course and they are forced to make an emergency landing in the middle of an electromagnetic phenomenon called Murasaki 312. Vicious giant creatures attack the crew on the planet Taurus II.

Advertisement

Due to loss of fuel, it was determined that it would be necessary to lose three hundred pounds from the shuttle for it to take off, or the equivalent of two adult males. Spock’s cold, calm, analytical demeanor unnerved his crewmates. After briefly using the phasers to scare the giants away, Spock decided that Scotty should use them as a means of propulsion to get the broken ship off the ground.

Realizing that they have exceeded the timetable that the Enterprise could wait for them and that the crew disobeying him to save him from a giant attack delayed their takeoff, Spock used all their fuel in one big burst of fire in the hopes that the Enterprise will notice them. It works but it wasn’t the logical course of action. It was an emotional “shot in the dark” that could have doomed his fellow crew and himself if it had not worked.

3. Giving Up True Happiness

In the Original Series episode This Side of Paradise the Starship Enterprise is sent to Omicron Ceti III to research the destruction of a colony due to deadly berthold rays. When they arrive, they find that the colonists are not only alive but at the peak of human health. One of the botanists, Leila, is a woman who was formerly in love with Spock but his Vulcan nature and dedication to his work prevented him from reciprocating.

Advertisement

The euphoric colonists claimed that their subspace antenna broke, preventing them from contacting Starfleet. They also claimed that they now embraced a simple life and they refused to leave the planet despite Kirk’s insistent demands. The Away Team succumbs to the euphoria and Leila took Spock over to a planet that sprays him, causing him pain, then joy and he begins kissing Leila. McCoy has several plants beamed aboard the ship and it quickly infects the entire crew.

With only Kirk left aboard, he becomes infected but can’t leave his one true love, the Enterprise, alone. He tricks Spock to return to the ship and insults his friend until he becomes angry and begins beating Kirk. Finally free of the spores, Spock creates a device to create anger in the crew and freed them. Spock is forced to leave Leila and the opportunity for true happiness, albeit chemically induced, for his captain and crew.

2. Engaged In “Cowboy Diplomacy” To Unite Vulcans And Romulans

In the Star Trek: The Next Generation two-part episode Unification I and II, it is 2368 and Spock has stepped out of semi-retirement and back into his role as a Federation Ambassador. He undertook a secret mission to Romulus, the homeworld of the Romulan race, to meet with progressive Ambassador Pardek about the Romulan and Vulcan people, two races that share a common ancestry.

Advertisement

Captain Jean-Luc Picard and Lt. Commander Data were surgically altered to resemble Romulans and were sent by Starfleet to confront and possibly retrieve Spock. When Picard located the Ambassador, he accused him of engaging in the “cowboy diplomacy” that his own former Captain, James T. Kirk, often employed. Spock stated that it was the consequences of getting Kirk and McCoy involved in the Khitomer incident with the Klingons that caused him to go alone to Romulus. It wasn’t the logical decision but it was the right one.

After Spock’s plans for unification are stymied by the emergence of Sela, the half-human, half-Romulan daughter of a time-displaced Tasha Yar, and the realization that Pardek had lied to him, Spock determined it might take years or even centuries for the two races to come together and decides to stay to work with the planet’s underground. Before they leave Picard mind melds with the Ambassador to share the memories and feelings his father once shared with Picard.

1. Spock Beat Khan Nearly To Death

In the alternate Kelvin Universe, Captain James T. Kirk saved the Starship Enterprise by kicking a portion of the engine back into place. Because of his closeness to the dilithium that powers the engine, Kirk dies of extreme radiation poisoning, but not before saying a few goodbye words to his friend and second in command, Spock. The normally stoic Vulcan becomes so enraged at the death of his friend that he yelled the name of the architect of all the carnage that was befalling the Enterprise crew: KHAN!

Advertisement

Khan Noonien Singh escaped into San Francisco with Spock in pursuit of him. They ran through the streets and ended up on a pair of flying barges. They began beating each other violently. Singh attempted to crush the Commander’s skull, but he broke it with a mind meld. Spock used a nerve pinch but Khan painfully pulled his hand away.

Meanwhile, on the Enterprise, McCoy realized that a dead Tribble that he had previously injected with Khan’s blood had come back to life. Uhura beamed down to the fight and the pair were just beating on each other now. Uhura stunned Khan several times with a phaser as she begged the Vulcan not to kill him. Spock is so overcome with rage that he is nearly beyond hearing but, at the last moment, ripped a piece of metal from the barge free and knocked Khan out. McCoy used Khan’s “super blood” to revive Kirk.

Advertisement