Star Trek: 12 Biggest Ever Retcons

Establishing Star Trek's history sometimes resulted in time being rewritten.

By Paula Luther /

The original Star Trek is undoubtedly one of the most recognizable TV shows of all time. The colorful costumes, memorable characters, and thought-provoking stories all worked together to create a phenomenon that shaped our culture in unexpected ways. As subsequent shows set in the Star Trek universe began to emerge, it was safe to say that Star Trek had contributed its own unique legacy to the television landscape.

Advertisement

What a lot of people may not realize, though, is that Star Trek's legacy could have looked much different than what we know today. In the early days (and sometimes later days) of the show, a lot of the history and world-building was a work-in-progress. As a result, something that was established in one episode might be retconned in a later episode.

Looking at some of Star Trek's biggest retcons gives an interesting insight into the show's past as well as a future we never got to see.

12. Shuttlecrafts

Shuttlecrafts are often used as an alternative means of transportation. They are especially useful for survey missions to newly-discovered planets. But in some of the early episodes, they are conspicuously absent.

Advertisement

The best example of this appears in The Enemy Within. A landing party is trapped on a planet where the temperature is plummeting dangerously low, but they can't be transported up because of a malfunction that split Kirk into his good and evil halves. In spite of the life-threatening temperatures, though, nobody suggests sending a shuttlecraft down to get the landing party. In fact, there's nothing to suggest that shuttlecrafts even exist. Only in subsequent episodes do they begin to appear, and everyone acts as if they've always been around. But if the shuttlecrafts were always around, why didn't they use them earlier?

11. Starship Emblems

Not every ship in Starfleet used the delta symbol that is associated with Star Trek today. The crews of the different ships had different emblems on their uniforms as a way of signifying which ship they served on. Episodes like The Doomsday Machine and The Ultimate Computer are excellent examples of the variety of starship emblems.

Advertisement

However, in future series, virtually everything associated with Starfleet used the delta symbol that was originally just reserved for the Enterprise. While this could be viewed as a natural change in Starfleet's logo design, everyone uses the same delta symbol even in the prequel shows. There is no indication that other ships, past or future, ever use their own emblems again.

10. Ponn Farr's Secrecy

Amok Time was a landmark episode, famous for delving into the Vulcans' mysterious culture. The focal point of the episode is the Ponn Farr, the Vulcans' seven-year mating cycle. Spock is very clear that Ponn Farr is seldom discussed among themselves and practically never mentioned to outsiders (except for "the very few who have been involved").

Advertisement

We see a reversal of this policy of secrecy in The Cloud Minders as Spock openly discusses Ponn Farr with Droxine, the daughter of the High Advisor of Stratos. Why Spock is sharing such a personal matter with a woman he literally just met is never quite explained and is a jarring disconnect from what was previously established.

9. Spock's Human Ancestry Was Much Farther Back

In Where No Man Has Gone Before, Spock makes a comment to Kirk during a chess game about one of his ancestors marrying a human woman. Kirk then jokes about how tough it must be having "bad blood" in the family like that. This would suggest that Spock was not directly half human but that his human ancestry was originally much farther back in his family tree.

Advertisement

Later episodes would establish Spock's mother as Amanda Grayson, a human woman who married the Vulcan abassador Sarek. This changed Spock's background from a random human woman marrying a Vulcan ancestor several generations back to the the more immediate half human and half Vulcan.

8. McCoy's Wife Natira

During a visit to the spaceship/asteroid world of Yonada in For The World Is Hollow And I Have Touched The Sky, McCoy fell in love with Natira, the high priestess of the Fabrini. At the time, McCoy had been diagnosed with xenopolycythemia, a blood disease that left him with only one year to live. McCoy's feelings for Natira were so strong that he chose to stay aboard Yonada as her husband and spend his remaining year with her instead of returning to the Enterprise.

Advertisement

An examination of Yonada's main computer, known as the Oracle, revealed a cure for McCoy's xenopolycythemia, and he resumed his duties aboard the Enterprise as its chief medical officer. Despite making plans with Natira to come visit her when Yonada finally arrived at its destination world, we never see or hear anything alluding to McCoy's marriage in future episodes or movies.

7. A Conquered Vulcan?

The planet Vulcan is one of the most famous in Star Trek's history. It is the home of the Vulcan people, best known for the logical lifestyle they adopted to curtail the bloody violence that was a hallmark of their early history. Before becoming pacifists, Vulcans were such powerful warriors that in The Immunity Syndrome, Spock states that Vulcan has never been conquered. The idea of being conquered is completely foreign to them.

Advertisement

Vulcan warriors sound about as strong and terrifying as the Klingons based on that description, but in The Conscience Of The King, McCoy makes a wry observation of understanding why the Vulcans were conquered (being spared "the dubious benefits of alcohol"). This episode actually aired prior to The Immunity Syndrome, so the idea of Vulcan being completely unconquered was a new development.

6. Uhura's Memory Wipe

In The Changeling, the Nomad probe comes aboard the Enterprise to investigate the crew. Its methods of investigation are dangerously destructive, though, as seen when it completely wiped Uhura's memory just to learn what music and singing were. There was no brain damage, but she had lost all of her knowledge and memories, requiring her to be re-educated.

Advertisement

Such a drastic action is never brought up again. In later episodes, you would never even guess that Uhura had lost all of her memories. Re-education is one thing, but Uhura had lost all memories of her childhood, of her hobbies and interests, and yet everything seemed perfectly normal.

5. The Reveal Of Spock's Parents

The reveal of Spock's parents in Journey To Babel came as a great shock to the Enterprise crew and the audience alike. Everyone knew that Spock was half human and half Vulcan, but who knew that his father was an ambassador!

Advertisement

As it turns out, Kirk already learned about it in This Side Of Paradise. In that episode, Spock tells Kirk that his father is an ambassador. By the time Journey To Babel airs, however, Kirk apparently forgot about this conversation with Spock. Instead, he seems just as surprised as everyone else to learn the identity of Spock's parents when they arrive aboard the Enterprise.

4. Vulcan Used To Be Vulcanian

The Vulcans are one of the most iconic species in Star Trek, but they weren't always called Vulcans. Although the planet was called Vulcan, the people who lived there were referred to as Vulcanian in early episodes. Spock referred to himself as half-Vulcanian on a few occasions, and Kirk once referrenced a Vulcanian expedition he had been a part of in Court Martial.

Advertisement

In later episodes, the term Vulcanian was dropped and exchanged for the regular term Vulcan. Ever since, it has been the accepted practice to refer to both the planet and its inhabitants by the single term of Vulcan.

3. Kirk Has A Nephew

Operation: Annihilate marked the first time Kirk's family was introduced on the show. His older brother Sam appeared briefly (albeit already dead from an alien parasite), and his sister-in-law Aurelan and nephew Peter feature more prominently in the episode. After Aurelan dies from the same parasite that killed Sam, Kirk is the only family Peter has left.

Advertisement

Kirk having an orphaned nephew seems like a pretty important development, but after this episode, Peter is never referenced again. What happened to him? It seems unlikely that he would have stayed on the Enterprise, but to never hear from him again seems like a pretty big oversight on the part of the writers. And speaking of disappearing family members...

2. The Number Of Kirk's Nephews

Operation: Annihilate was the first time Kirk's family was introduced in the series, but he first referred to them in What Are Little Girls Made Of? When testing the memories of a duplicate version of himself made by Dr. Corby, he mentions his brother Sam. The duplicate supplies that Sam's full name is George Samuel Kirk and also mentions that Sam has three sons. This would imply that Peter Kirk, Sam and Aurelan's son in Operation: Annihilate, has two brothers.

Advertisement

However, there is no indication that Peter has any siblings in Operation: Annihilate. Everything about that episode suggests that Peter is an only child. So Kirk goes from having three nephews to just having one to seemingly not having any nephews at all.

1. Kirk's Middle Name

Everyone knows the iconic name of James T. Kirk, captain of the Enterprise on Star Trek. He was not the first captain on the show--that was Christopher Pike in the show's original pilot episode The Cage--but he was certainly the most memorable. Yet his name was almost very different from the one we know today.

Advertisement

When Kirk faces off against Gary Mitchell in Where No Man Has Gone Before, Mitchell creates a headstone to mark Kirk's grave. The name on the headstone shows James R. Kirk, not James T. Kirk. In subsequent episodes, Kirk's middle initial was changed to T for Tiberius, and his middle name has remained Tiberius ever since.

What other retcons has Star Trek seen? Let us know in the comments!

Advertisement