Star Trek: 20 Worst Episodes Ever
No television behemoth makes it through more than 700 episodes without producing a few clunkers.
The Star Trek franchise may be best known for Hugo-Award winning episodes like The City On The Edge of Forever, The Inner Light, and The Trouble With Tribbles, but no television behemoth makes it through more than 700 episodes without producing a few clunkers.
What follows is a list of twenty of those failures, misfires, and disappointments, including episodes from all five live action series. For simplicity's sake, I've left out the movies, and ranked the following twenty instalments from "best" to worst. Without further ado, let's take a look at the list.
20. Spock's Brain (TOS)
"Brain, brain...what is brain?"
Perhaps the most infamous episode of the original series, Spock's Brain is certainly a head-scratcher. Intended to capitalise on Dr. Christiaan Barnard's recent success at performing the first human heart transplant, the episode has a group of aliens one-upping Dr. Barnard by surgically removing Mr. Spock's brain and plugging it in to run their vast underground layer.
For some reason, Spock is able to survive without this organ for twenty-four hours, which is enough time for Kirk and company to track down the elusive cerebrum, and have McCoy (with the help of a device called "The Teacher") transplant it back into the good Vulcan's head. McCoy's surgery is so fantastic, in fact, that it doesn't seem to touch a single hair on top of Mr. Spock's head!
Fan lore has long suggested that this episode was originally written as a comedy, only to be butchered into being a "serious" script when the series' new producer - Fred Freiberger, who reportedly didn't like Star Trek played as a comedy - had it rewritten. This is a nice theory, but as anyone who has read Gene !*$%'s original story outline can tell you, Spock's Brain was always intended as as serious piece of action-adventure.
Spock's Brain was later seen and parodied on a 1989 episode of The Wonder Years. It's certainly bad (although Fred Steiner's score is nice, providing what little excitement can be found in the episode), but unfortunately, there are episodes of Star Trek that are worse. Read on if you dare.
19. These Are The Voyages... (ENT)
"So, I guess we're through here."
At first glance, the premise of this episode - to date, the final hour of Star Trek produced for television - isn't bad. While trying to make an important career decision, Commander Riker (with a little help from Counselor Troi) uses the holodeck to replay a key moment from Federation history to help him come to a decision.
Set ten years after the first episode of the Star Trek: Enterprise (and six years after the rest of season four), the moment in question is the final voyage of the NX-01 as she travels home to attend the founding ceremonies for the United Federation of Planets. Unfortunately, the way the premise plays out is mostly a failure. The crew of the NX-01 end up being minor characters in the finale to their own series, and the drama over Riker's decision is mostly lifeless, since we already know how it is going to play out.
Setting the episode six years after the rest of the series is mostly wasted, too, since outside of a minor aesthetic change or two, it appears that the crew is exactly the same as when we last saw them in "Terra Prime."
The low point of the episode, though, has to be the ham-fisted way in which Commander "Trip" Tucker dies. The plotting that sets in motion the Engineer's empty sacrifice makes for some of the most contrived writing ever to appear in the Star Trek franchise. It's no wonder disgruntled fans began displaying avatars with Tucker's image and the words "Not. Dead." after the broadcast of the episode. Later, these complaints led the (non-canon) Enterprise novels to jump through a series of narrative hoops to resurrect the good Engineer.
All of this in a finale that, as hard as it is to believe, was promoted as a "Valentine to the fans" from executive producers Rick Berman and Brannon Braga when it was first broadcast in 2005.
18. Threshold (VOY)
"I don't know what to say, except I don't remember very much about, er, you know."
You can call me crazy, but a part of me actually likes "Threshold," which is usually derided as the nadir of Star Trek: Voyager (there's even a special feature on the DVD devoted to apologizing for the whole affair). I wouldn't call it a good episode, but for about half of the running time it is a fun romp that captures the essence of Tom Paris, who until this point had been mostly reduced to a background character.
Unfortunately, no viewing of "Threshold" can come without the second half of the episode's running time, which is bizarre, tedious, awkward, and totally illogical, often all at once. Part of the problem with the episode can be neatly summarised by recounting the second half of the episode's plot, which is, for lack of a better word, insane.
After successfully breaking the Warp 10 barrier, Tom Paris begins to undergo a bizarre transformation into some sort of salamander-like creature. At the last minute, The Doctor discovers a treatment, but before he can act, Paris escapes, kidnaps Captain Janeway, and takes her on a Warp 10 flight. By the time Voyager locates them, three days later, they have fully "evolved" into the salamander creatures, mated, and produced salamander offspring together. No worries, however. The Doctor successfully returns them to their human form, which leads to an awkward scene between the Lieutenant and the Captain in sickbay.
The other problem, of course, is that the episode is a complete betrayal of its own premise. You see, travelling at Warp 10 means going so fast you occupy every point in the universe at once. In other words, you can go anywhere you want to at the push of a button. The only side-effect is that you begin to transform into a salamander, but thanks to The Doctor, that can be completely reversed! The only logical place for this to go is for Voyager to hit Warp 10, make it back to Earth in a split-second, and then treat the crew before they begin to exhibit the same mutations Paris and Janeway did. But, since that would mean ending the series, no one ever speaks of it again. Actually, given the rest of the episode, maybe that's for the best.
17. A Night In Sickbay (ENT)
"The Kreetassans consider the Alvera trees cultural treasures. Apparently, Porthos urinated on one of them."
I'm not the first one to make this pun, but it's so easy, I'll do it. This one is just a dog. What's it about, you ask? After botching a diplomatic mission, Archer learns that his beloved beagle, Porthos, contracted a disease while on the planet (because Porthos comes along for important diplomatic missions, you see). Archer is furious, because the aliens of the week didn't warn him that Porthos could get sick.
The rest of the episode sees him spending a night in sickbay with his trusted dog while Phlox tries to find a cure before it is too late (spoilers: the dog makes it). Oh, and that diplomatic mission I mentioned? Archer blew it because he couldn't control his pet beagle, who peed all over one of the Kreetassans' sacred trees. Whoops. If only that could have been avoided somehow.
16. Justice (TNG)
"Neat as pins, ultra-lawful, and make love at the drop of a hat."
If this episode were simply devoted to the over-sexed people of Edo, who run around scantily clad when they're not busy oiling each other up, it would simply be a forgettable trifle not unlike the subsequent episodes the franchise spends on Risa, the Federation Pleasure Planet.
Instead, this early episode (which has Gene Roddenberry's fingerprints all over it, even if he isn't a credited writer) takes a dark turn when Wesley slips and falls into a flower bed and is sentenced to death. Yes, you read that correctly. It seems Edo has a randomly selected punishment zone which changes daily. If you commit any crime in a punishment zone, no matter how minor, there's only one sentence -- the death penalty. Apparently, in their haste to get down to a planet where the natives "make love at the drop of a hat," the crew neglected to read the only local law that actually mattered.
If Kirk were the Captain, he'd simply beam up the boy and the Enterprise would be off to its next adventure. This, however, is Star Trek: The Next Generation, and Picard is a stickler for following the Prime Directive, no matter the cost. And, not only does he have the Prime Directive to contend with in Justice, but he's also faced with a powerful lifeform the Edo recognize as "God." Whatever the lifeform really is, it ominously warns the Enterprise not to interfere with its "children below." What follows all of these silly plot mechanics is an unconvincing and talky finale, which does little to salvage a premise which borders on self-parody.
15. The Omega Glory (TOS)
Gene Roddenberry originally wrote The Omega Glory as a potential second pilot for Star Trek, after his first pilot failed to sell. The network, however, wisely chose the far superior Where No Man Has Gone Before, and the rest is history.
Roddenberry's script, however, was still sitting around, although not many people around the office seemed to like it. It remained shelved throughout season one, even as the production was in dire need of scripts that were ready to go before the cameras. Near the end of the second season, however, Roddenberry finally got his pet script into production.
It starts off promisingly enough, with the Enterprise finding the U.S.S. Exeter in orbit of Omega IV. They beam aboard to find the entire crew dead, reduced to piles of salt crystals after all of the water from their bodies has been somehow removed. A log entry leads the crew down to the planet, where they find the Exeter's commanding officer, Ronald Tracy. It seems that Tracy has become involved in a civil war between the planet's two factions -- the Kohms and the Yangs -- and has been arming the Kohms with phasers (a violation of the Prime Directive) to tilt the balance of power in the conflict. Kirk is aghast when he learns of this, since upholding the Prime Directive is "a star Captain's most solemn oath," even if it means death.
It's the last act's attempt to make a political statement, however, in which The Omega Glory falls totally to pieces. It's bad enough that the Kohms and the Yangs turn out to be Communists and Yankees, but the finale involves a waving American flag, the star-spangled banner, and a perfect reproduction of the U.S. Constitution. The patriotism is over the top, and Kirk's ultimate solution - he tells the Yangs the right way to interpret the Constitution - sure seems like a violation of the Prime Directive to me. I guess that solemn oath wasn't so important, after all.
14. Meridian (DS9)
"Satisfaction is not guaranteed."
While in the Gamma Quadrant, the U.S.S. Defiant comes across the planet Meridian. It turns out this planet (and its inhabitants) are rather unique in that they spend their time going back and forth between two dimensions. In one, ours, they exist as matter, but in the other, they exist as pure energy.
As in much of the franchise, the techno-babble explaining this phenomena is best ignored. Unfortunately, the same could be said of the love story it is a backdrop for, which is entirely forgettable. Jadzia Dax falls for a Meridian named Deral. Sure, he's handsome enough, but the two hardly spend enough time together (and the love scenes they do have together are utterly generic and without passion) for a seasoned adult like Dax (who has centuries of experience, thanks to being a joined Trill) to commit to being pure energy for decades-- if not forever.
None of this matters, of course, since Terry Farrell is a series regular in the middle of a six season contract. Rather than come off as tragic, the episode's conclusion (in which techno-babble explains that Dax cannot join Meridian) comes off as a forgone conclusion. To be fair, the episode does have an amusing (if nonessential) B-story involving Quark's attempt to create an erotic hologram of Kira for a creepy client, but it's hardly enough to save this from being a disappointment.
13. Time's Orphan (DS9)
Originally conceived as an episode of Star Trek: The Next Generation (where Worf's son Alexander would have fallen into a time portal only to emerge as an adult), Time's Orphan made its way to Star Trek: Deep Space Nine late in the sixth season when executive producer Ira Steven Behr needed a bottle show to balance the budget. While that's perfectly fine - some of Star Trek's best episodes, like Duet, have been bottle shows - this is a story of little consequence, and it feels especially slight in light of the greater drama of the Dominion War which had consumed the series by this point.
To briefly summarise, Miles O'Brien and his family are enjoying a picnic on the planet Golana when their eight year old, Molly, falls into a time portal while playing and disappears (O'Brien just can't get an even break). When she re-emerges from the portal, Molly is ten years older, frightened, and unable to speak.
This results in some drama as the Miles and his wife Keiko try to adjust to this new situation, and eventually the requisite moral dilemma of whether or not to let Molly return to the time portal. She eventually does, and through the convenience of the plot, the O'Briens have the 8 year old Molly returned to them, and the series moves on to more important stories.
12. Zero Hour (ENT)
"What the hell?"
Zero Hour would be a perfectly serviceable conclusion to a season-long arc if not for the last sixty seconds, which present the most nonsensical, outrageous, unrelated cliffhanger this side of Farscape's Bad Timing. Having at last defeated the Xindi threat, the Enterprise returns to Earth, only to discover that the planet is now overrun with World War II era planes, and of course, Nazis! (Also, alien Nazis).
This makes about as much sense on screen as it does in print (in other words, none). It would be bad enough if this were simply the cliffhanger ending a single episode, but as a cliffhanger ending a season-long arc, it is difficult to express how unsatisfying the whole thing is. Enterprise fans should thank their lucky stars that the series was renewed for one more season.
As hotly debated as These Are The Voyages... is among fans, it made sense compared to the finale of Zero Hour.
11. Fury (VOY)
The character of Kes was dumped at the beginning of the fourth season of Star Trek: Voyager when Jeri Ryan was added to the cast as Seven of Nine. Her departure involved her reaching another plane of existence, turning into pure energy, and launching Voyager 10,000 lightyears closer to home.
So, it was a little odd that when the writers decided to bring her back for a single episode two and a half years later, they had the character go on a senseless rampage throughout the ship. What could her motivation possibly be for this act of violence (and whatever happened to her evolution into pure energy?). A better episode might have made sense of this nonsense, but Fury seems content to dump all over a character who was unceremoniously abandoned by the show, rather than provide her with any reasonable motivation.
There's some time travel theatrics and (another) heartfelt farewell for Kes at the end of it all, but it's hard to be moved by an episode that wastes the character and makes little sense. It seems best to remember her previous farewell episode, The Gift, and just pretend that Fury never existed.
10. Unexpected (ENT)
"Just how I always wanted to get into the history books."
When it was first broadcast, Unexpected was widely derided by fans. The Enterprise episode - only the fourth broadcast of the prequel series, set a century before the original series - features the holodeck, a story-telling device that was already tired by the end of Star Trek: The Next Generation, and only got worse over the course of the next two spin-offs.
While the quick reappearance of this tired technology is annoying, it doesn't even begin to address what is truly awful about the episode. You see, the plot of Unexpected involves a first contact with an alien race (the Xyrillians, for those keeping score) that results in the Enterprise's intrepid (and male) chief engineer accidentally becoming pregnant.
The result is an episode which leans on a series of offensive pregnancy cliches that make the Arnold Schwarzenegger vehicle Junior (1994) seem positively subtle in comparison. It doesn't help that Trip's pregnancy, which is played for (cheap) laughs, never involved his consent. While the episode might live up to its title, I certainly wouldn't recommend it.
9. Shades Of Gray (TNG)
"We need to isolate memories that generate stronger negative emotions."
At the end of the second season of Star Trek: The Next Generation, the production had to resort to a clip show for their final episode. Paramount had paid extra to complete the episodes Elementary, Dear Data and Q, Who? and now they wanted an episode to come in way under budget. The result was Shades of Gray, which utilised standing sets, had no guest stars (save for semi-regular Chief O'Brien), and was filmed in three days (less than half the time it took to shoot a standard episode of Star Trek: The Next Generation).
Still, even accepting all those limitations, the final result is still tremendously disappointing, and the premise (Riker is infected with a disease, good memories grow the disease, bad memories kill it) would barely be enough to fill out an act break of any other episode. Add to that the usual blunders of clip shows (Riker's memories - of course, scenes from previous episodes - often contain moments he could not have witnessed) and you have yourself a profoundly boring hour.
The Neutral Zone, the first season finale, had problems due to an impending writer's strike, but it was at least a suitable place to wrap up the year. There are a couple of moments of Jonathan Frakes' performance that are worthwhile and the chance to hear Ron Jones score scenes previously tackled by other composers is of minor interest, but on the whole, Shades of Gray is simply an embarrassment that is best forgotten.
8. And The Children Shall Lead (TOS)
On the surface of And The Children Shall Lead there's an interesting premise, but like many third season outings of the original Star Trek, the episode doesn't come close to exploring it in any meaningful way. Instead, it opts for depicting the crew as a bunch of morons and other such nonsense until the episode clocks out at fifty minutes. Worse, still, is Melvin Belii's "performance" as the nefarious Gorgan.
At the time, Belii was a well-known attorney, but hardly an actor, which is painfully obvious in every one of his scenes. To call his performance robotic would be a disservice to mechanised beings everywhere. Star Trek was Belli's first on screen role (one wonders how he even landed it) and he is simply terrible.
7. Precious Cargo (ENT)
Not unlike And The Children Shall Lead, Enterprise's Precious Cargo takes a poorly executed premise (and a warmed over one at that) and adds a terrible guest actor to the mix.
Much of the episode is a two-hander with Trip Tucker (Connor Trinneer) and Kaitaama (Padma Lakshmi), which falls completely flat thanks to Lakshmi's performance. It's obvious that she wasn't hired for her line readings (which are flat) or her chemistry with Trinneer (which is nonexistent). This is especially a shame in light of Trinneer's talents as an actor. His two-hander with Dominic Keating called Shuttlepod One was one of the better episode of the first season, but Precious Cargo just goes to show that one bad actor can bring a whole episode down.
6. Fair Haven (VOY)
"Everyone seems to love Fair Haven. I was thinking we might initiate an open door protocol on the Holodeck, keep the programme running twenty four hours a day. Let people come and go as they please."
The holodeck was a seriously overused plot device by the time of Star Trek: Voyager, and the most egregious use of the technology can probably be found in Fair Haven. Replaying storylines about the holodeck that were better the first time when they were on Star Trek: The Next Generation, it just feels tired and silly. Worse, the romance between Captain Janeway and the holographic Michael Sullivan is undercut by the fact that the two actors have absolutely zero chemistry together.
All of this might have been fine if the episode bothered to set up a fun or interesting atmosphere, but instead it opts for a series of stereotypical and ahistorical Irish cliches. The episode insists this is all good fun, but it's hard to imagine the scenario doing anything other than try one's patience. Well, at least we'll never have to spend anytime in the town of Fair Haven again...
5. Spirit Folk (VOY)
"The cows stopped giving milk. The potatoes grew rotten in the ground."
...except the episode has a sequel, in which everything that was annoying about Fair Haven is dialled up to eleven. Luckily, the producers realised their mistake after Spirit Folk and never returned to the Irish town in the holodeck again. Unfortunately, it took them two patience-testing episodes before they realized what the audience did after the five minutes. Although there are many things to dislike on Star Trek: Voyager, these two episodes have to represent the series' low point.
4. Profit And Lace (DS9)
"I've only been a male again for six hours. My hormones must still be out of balance. My emotions are raging out of control."
The Ferengi episodes of Star Trek: Deep Space Nine have long drawn the ire of fans. I've never shared this view, but I certainly make an exception for the abysmal Profit and Lace, which turns the concept of putting Quark in drag into a vehicle for a handful of bad, sexist jokes... and little else. If that's bad, imagine how awful the original version of the episode would have been, which Armin Shimmerman (Quark) refused to play because he felt it negatively stereotyped women!
3. The Alternative Factor (TOS)
"There is, of course, no escape."
The Alternative Factor was a troubled episode before it even went before the cameras. The script, by Roddenberry's friend and former policeman Don Ingalls, never quite came together.
A romantic subplot between Lazarus and Lieutenant Charlene Masters was cut during scripting (possibly due to similarities to Space Seed, possibly due to concerns over depicting an interracial romance) and suitable material was never found to put in its place. As a result, the episode is replete with several sequences of Lazarus wandering around a desert planet and falling off cliffs that have little purpose other than to pad out the running time.
When the episode finally went before the cameras, things got even worse. Guest star John Drew Barrymore had signed a contract to appear in the role of Lazarus, but later he decided he didn't want to do the episode, and never showed up to set. Robert Brown was therefore cast at the very last minute and dragged to the set as fast as was possible. His lack of preparation is evident, although the script is confusing enough that it probably wouldn't have made much of a difference.
Then, when the episode was finally finished, it was such an incoherent mess that the producers elected to push the episode as far back in the season as possible. They were finally forced to air The Alternative Factor, which was filmed 20th, as the 27th episode of the season. It wasn't re-run over the summer.
Given the behind-the-scenes trouble, it's a miracle the episode is as coherent as it is, but that doesn't mean it makes a whole lot of sense, or is particularly good. It's definitely the worst episode of Star Trek's freshman season, and I suspect few fans would quibble with naming it as one of the worst episodes of the entire franchise.
2. Code Of Honor (TNG)
"How could you not love him? Every woman loves him."
Rather than say much about this episode, which not only tries to repeat the finale of Amok Time, but is rife with uncomfortable racial stereotyping, I'll simply let the cast speak for it.
Jonathan Frakes told convention audience in 2007 that, "The worst and most embarrassing and one that even Gene would have been embarrassed by was that horrible racist episode from the first season... Code of Honor, oh my God in heaven!"
When Garret Wang said the episode "stunk" at a convention in 2010, Levar Burton added, "Without question."
Finally, in a 2012 interview, Brent Spiner said, that, "["Code of Honor"] was just a racist episode. Maybe not intentionally but it felt that way and looked that way. It was the third episode so it was fortuitous that we did our worst that early on and it never got quite that bad again."
In the final analysis, the only redeeming aspect may be Fred Steiner's melodic score, and since that is now available on CD, there's no reason for Star Trek fans to ever have to sit through this one again!
1. The Way To Eden (TOS)
"Gonna live like a king on whatever I find, eat all the fruit and throw away the rind."
The Way to Eden began life as a remarkably different story outline called Joanna, written by D.C. Fontana. Joanna would have introduced Doctor McCoy's estranged daughter of the same name to the series, and put the characters on a path towards reconciliation.
Third season producer Fred Freiberger, however, insisted that McCoy wasn't old enough to have an adult daughter, and had the episode dramatically rewritten by Arthur Heinemann. Fontana so disliked the changes that she used her pseudonym (Michael Richards) rather than put her name on the final episode. It's not hard to see why.
The Way To Eden is a complete mess that fails to offer any meaningful commentary on the hippie movement, weirdly turns the youthful Chekov into a conservative and by-the-book officer (try squaring that with his passionate and inexperienced behaviour in, say, Spectre Of The Gun") and bombards the senses with a series of musical numbers which are outright embarrassing.
The episode's core storyline - a misguided religious guru with fantastic powers of persuasion leads a cult of followers in a search for Eden - is remarkably similar to Star Trek V: The Final Frontier, which, to be honest, says a lot right there. The episode has its defenders, but in my book, its easily the worst episode of Star Trek ever produced.
What's your least favourite Star Trek episode? Share your pick down in the comments.