Star Trek: Picard - 7 Ups & 5 Downs From Season 1

Boldly gone.

By Adam Clery /

Well, that's it.

Advertisement

Star Trek: Picard, the first thing to move the lore of the franchise forward since the opening scenes of Star Trek 2009, and the first one to do it substantially since Star Trek: Nemesis has concluded its first season. For some, it was a brave new direction, for others too far a departure, but regardless it's been a hell of a ride.

A story that started off with one man quietly slipping further into retirement as the galaxy moved on without him, the ghosts of his past and the memory of his friend drag him back into the action and the cosmos. 20 years have passed since the death of Data, but he still plays on the mind of Jean-Luc Picard and the appearance of a woman who may indirectly be his daughter sets us on our way.

Advertisement

From there we've assembled a new crew, become embroiled in intergalactic conspiracies, threatened by a synthetic alien superpredator race that seeks to wipe out all organic life in the galaxy, and even stopped by The Riker's for pizza. But how well did all of this land? How boldly did it go where no Star Trek show had gone in decades? Let's find out...

DOWNS

5. The Borg

CBS

The Borg are easily one of the best things about Star Trek. They were, sadly, not one of the best things about Star Trek: Picard.

Advertisement

It's maybe more a case of unrealistic expectations (more on that later) but the show's decisions to feature them so prominently in the marketing and the opening episodes set the bar higher than they were ever going to live up to. We think of them as an unstoppable, all-conquering force but, here, they were set dressing.

It's understandable, given that the story was ostensibly not about them, but they're such an integral part of Picard's story I think we all expected a showdown with them at some point. In the end, Picard faced his own internal demons over them, and not the collective itself.

Advertisement

4. Starfleet

CBS

It's worth saying at this point that I am absolutely bang-up for a Mandolorian-esque Star Trek show that just takes the usual players out of the equation entirely. Something that sets up a brand new character who zips around the Star Trek universe getting on everyone's bad side on their own personal journey.

Advertisement

But until they do that, Starfleet remains the beating heart of Star Trek, and the problem with Picard was that it could never really make its mind up over how to utilise them. First they try and work with them, then we discover they've been infiltrated by Romulans, then the gang attempt to work around them but, in the end, fall back on them entirely to save the day.

It was a muddled approach and one that'll have been particularly frustrating to fans who really wanted to see what the organisation looked like some decades after their last great voyage. Basically, most of them are spies, everyone who isn't swears, and they only have one class of ship.

Advertisement

3. Not Following Through

Amazon

There have been few lines in Star Trek that sounded quite as exciting as "If your gradient badge starts to blink green… run". Here we are on a mysteriously "deactivated" Borg Cube that, we're told, just randomly shut down one day but still has thousands of drones on board in stasis, and where things could potentially go so catastrophically wrong that everyone needs to walk around wearing an early warning sign.

Advertisement

But the badge never flashed green.

The show routinely tells us that Narek's true feelings are going to put him directly between his sister and Soji, and the latter two never even meet. This Romulan conspiracy to attack Mars feels like it underpins the entire narrative, but nobody besides Raffi seems all that bothered when it's finally proved. There's even a glaring "This facility has gone 5843 days without an assimilation" sign in a show where, somehow, nobody gets assimilated.

Advertisement

While nobody wants a series littered with obvious plot points, routinely teasing big moments and then not making good on them was a real problem with Picard's first season. Hopefully, some of them can be readdressed in Season 2 but, in the here and now it made for frustrating viewing.

2. No Big Twist

CBS

If you'll permit me to quote the Ups and Downs article from last week...

Advertisement
Lore, Q, The Enterprise, V'Ger, Worf, Geordi, The Origin Of The Borg, Seven Becoming Their New Queen, Starfleet Being The Real Bad Guys, Data Coming Back From The Dead, you name it, someone's suggested it as the big twist that was going to make the Picard season finale an absolutely seminal moment in Trek history. In the end, though, there was absolutely nothing in the way of a jaw-dropper in our final 54 minutes. A twist purely for the sake of a twist would have been worse, but the show has put in genuine effort with its mysterious prophecies and shadowy conspiracies to give you the impression that nothing was as it really seemed. In the end though, it was, disappointingly.

The bottom line here, a week removed from the end of the show, it doesn't really feel like there's one giant hook on which to recommend it to your Trek loving friends. It's a great show, it's entertaining, and it should appeal to fans of all persuasions, but there's nothing in it that makes it essential viewing.

1. Disposable Stakes

CBS

And, yes, sorry, once more. This time on the subject of the show's three main antagonists...

Advertisement
First Commodore Oh, the shadowy Romulan double-agent who is responsible for both the Synth attack on Mars and the subsequent ban on synthetic life that forms the dramatic core of the story. Then Narissa, her deadly right-hand woman who's shadowy, sinister, and lethal in combat. Finally Sutra, an earlier model of Andriod to Soji who, through killing one of her own sisters, has manipulated the entire colony into bringing about a mechanical armageddon that'll wipe out all organic life in the galaxy. Just to clarify for you all how these three primary antagonists were ultimately defeated. The political mastermind was sent packing by quoting a treaty, the lethal weapon had a short fistfight followed by a long fall, and the Synth harbinger of doom came face to face with the off button on a remote control.

Yes, this is by no means final for any of them (in science fiction, falling down a bit hole never automatically means you're dead, does it Darth?), but the season played out in hugely underwhelming fashion for its three biggest threats. The manner in which they were seen off makes it hard to get excited about them coming back next time as well.

UPS

6. The Abrams Influence

CBS

A relatively short point this to simply say that, no matter what you thought about the rest of the show, it looked absolutely stunning. From how well the planet-level sets were fleshed out, to how alive locations like Freecloud were, and even the Very-Star-Trek-2009 veneer to the visual effects, it was a treat for the senses.

Advertisement

In particular, that brief moment of the Borg Cube emerging from the Trans-Warp hub was simply something no other Star Trek show has had the scope to do before, and hopefully sets a new standard for the franchise going forward. The show let itself down with the Cmd+C Cmd+V 400 ship standoff at the end, but otherwise, it was almost visually faultless.

5. To Explore Strange New Worlds

CBS

Free from the shackles of Starfleet, the show was always going to be heading to new and exciting locations. There was always a sort of idyllicism to the worlds we visited where either it was a wonderful human utopia or, some troubled alien world comprised mostly of styrofoam rocks. Picard, instead, went fully into sci-fi noir.

Advertisement

Freecould, in particular, was a world unlike anything we've ever seen in the franchise before. Invoking the obvious comparisons to Blade Runner and the like it presented a corner of the Star Trek universe that's a melting pot of commerce (and easter eggs) not constrained by the predictable tropes of the usual major species.

The presentations of Earth were far more in keeping with those of the more recent movies, and locations like Vashti, Nepenthe and Coppelius were understated but nonetheless impressive.

Advertisement

4. And Seek Out New Life

CBS

If Picard never returned for a second season then, without question, its greatest accomplishment would have been the work it did in gradually, subtly, profoundly fleshing out its entire supporting cast. Across just a handful of episodes, it's given us one of the most interesting crews in the show's history.

Advertisement

Rios is a man overlayed with cliches but immensely broken beneath the surface, Raffi is a striking presentation of strength in the face of overwhelming loss, Agnes a far-harder-to-write-than-you'd-think redemptive pillar of the show, Soji a brilliant continuation of Data's quest to discover what it means to be human, and also Elnor was there.

Even the villains were (until their cheap endings) well developed, with Narissa and Narek in particular two of the better and more complex threats in recent Trek history.

Advertisement

3. Easter Eggs

CBS

As anyone who's read our weekly Easter Eggs articles will be aware, the show has delighted in giving fans things to find every single week. From referencing characters from other shows, to calling back to famous moments in Trek history, right down to invoking old memories through musical cues, it's all been in there.

Advertisement

I'll link to the most recent articles here so you can have a full look at them but a few personal favourites have included evolving Seven of Nine's theme into that of Star Trek: Voyager, and Quark apparently running some sort of Intergalactic Wetherspoons. They're subtle, but the volume of them shows that the people in the writing chair understood exactly what the show means to people.

2. The Next Generation

CBS

For all Star Trek: Picard is its own show - and should be judged as such - it's impossible not to view it through the lens of a Next Generation legacy piece. It stars its most prominent figure, and its story picks up the narrative threads that ended with its last movie.

Advertisement

It took a while for us to get there, but the episode on Nepenthe will have given fans of the show a terrific and nostalgic trip down memory lane. The lives of The Rikers and their young daughter acted a perfect pre-finale refuge for Picard and a timely reminder of why so many fans loved TNG in the first place.

From centering the story around Bruce Maddox, to the way Data's ghost haunted every narrative beat, the big and small elements of the old show were present throughout Picard. It did enough to stand on its own two feet, but there was enough for long-term fans to still get excited about.

Advertisement

1. Patrick Stewart

CBS

For nearly 20 years, Patrick Stewart resisted the temptation to return to this role. There were, allegedly, no shortage of offers for him to reprise it parts both big and small, but he always felt like the time had passed and Jean-Luc Picard's story was over. Until, that is, he read the script for Picard.

Advertisement

If his heart hadn't been in it, if he'd gone into the role with anything less than the enthusiasm and energy he had in 1987, this was never going to work. For a nearly 80-year-old man, that's not something you can take for granted, but he's been wonderful at both channeling the Picard of old and showing a more weary, vulnerable side of him.

Even if the story did nothing else for you, even if you found the episodes unengaging, even if you loudly threw up your arms and cried out "this isn't MY Star Trek", even if your poor mother is paying for your internet just so you can cry-arse on a website's comment section about a TV show nobody is forcing you to watch, it was surely worth it to spend a few more hours in the company of this character.

Advertisement

How far we go with all of this beyond the imminent next season remains to be seen, but with an enthusiasm for the part and a brand new crew at his back, Patrick Stewart ensures we'll be here to see it.