Star Trek: Picard - 8 Ups & 2 Downs From The Impossible Box

The Romulans Send Their Regards...

By Adam Clery /

To steal a line from another show (and, ironically literally a Star Trek actor), we're in the endgame now.

Advertisement

After an opening few episodes that divided the audience with its insistence on meticulously positioning every piece at the expense of a far more interesting narrative about rogue synths, double-agents, murderous cyborgs, and a conspiracy that connects all three, we're now rattling through Star Trek: Picard at some high velocity I can't quite place the name for.

However, it's not been all smooth sailing. The show's most intriguing narrative thread - that of Soji's origins and her connection to the Borg Cube - has been left dangling for two whole episodes now, and failure to move profoundly in that direction could stall the show as a whole. Basically, these are the show's most critical episodes, where patience has to be rewarded and an enthralling ending has to be correctly structured.

Advertisement

But can it finally deliver on its exciting premise, or will the whole show descend into a bit of a mess as we race towards a conclusion that was never given enough time to really work? I can't think of a good Star Trek pun for this bit but let's push on regardless...

Downs...

2. Raffi

CBS

I'm trying not to be overly sensitive about his because the show, admittedly, isn't exactly glamorizing the situation, but the use of Raffi in this episode was... not good. Last week we got one of the most striking points of character development in the entire series, and a really three-dimensional look at the damage done to society by the Synth attack. This week, not so much.

Advertisement

What we got instead was simply wheeling her out of her quarters, bottle and pipe in hand, to do everyone else a huge favour (at, quite literally, the cost of her own career and friendships) before being dumped back into bed. This is one of Jean-Luc's closest friends, who has just had her entire world collapse around her after meeting her son, and he's basically exploiting her.

I've said before that one of the show's greatest strengths is its shades of grey - for both Picard and Starfleet itself - but having seemingly the entire crew happy to use someone like this is jarring. Hopefully, redemption is on the way, and Rios at least seems to care, but this week it was a genuine "wait, hang on..." moment.

Advertisement

1. A (Transporter) Jump In Logic

WWE

A petty gripe this, but when the show previously has done such good work in this regard, moments when it lets itself down with convenient shortcuts are really noticeable. Despite being instructed to stay on the ship, Elnor senses that Picard is in trouble and decides that he needs to honour his bond to him by beaming into the cube to aid his escape.

Advertisement

This is the same Elnor who, as implied last week, has no idea how to operate the transporter by himself. An Elnor who, having grown up in a nunnery and only just joined the crew, would almost certainly have no idea how to operate the ship's systems well enough to pinpoint where Picard was. Suddenly dropping in out of thin air was a lazy, lazy move.

As I say, a very small gripe this one, but something that the show is usually much better than.

Advertisement

Ups...

8. Starting Strong

CBS

Two whole weeks the show has left us hanging on where we're going with Soji. Two long, frustrating weeks. While both Stardust City Rag and Absolute Candor really did elevate the show's overall quality, they also left the story's most interesting narrative thread just dangling in the wind. Opening this week with a flashback to Soji's "childhood" and an excellent ball-rolling exchange between her and Narek was the smartest possible move.

Advertisement

They've kept this on the boil for just about long enough that we're all still with it, but holding back on it this week would have lost almost all of the momentum. Instead though we immediately knew we were arriving in the business end of this story, with all the places finally positioned well enough to just press on with the adventure.

7. There He Is...

CBS

Jean-Luc Picard has felt different in this show. Gone is the man who'd straighten his uniform and cut very matter of fact speeches while staring out of the window of his Ready Room, replaced by a man who simply seen it all now and is considerably softer around the edges. Retirement hasn't suited him, but he's always felt like he just needed a little push.

Advertisement

That little push arrived in the shape of Agnes who, accidentally or otherwise, set him off about his history with the Borg. Flying straight past the humanitarian of The Next Generation and into the vengeful survivor of First Contact, it was one of the show's best moments thus far. Even if I did have to google what "metastasize" meant.

6. This. F***ing. Shot.

CBS

For all its faults (and there have been plenty), some of the cinematography in Star Trek: Picard has been absolutely stunning. The action sequences have looked at him with the high-budget sensibilities of the Abramsverse, the sets and worlds have been constructed with a level of detail and thought never previously seen in Star Trek, and there's been some staggering one of moments.

Advertisement

Retiring to his holographic Chateau after his outburst over The Borg, Picard begins to read up on their destination. He sees several images that recall his previous encounters with the Collective, before pausing on still lifted straight from The Next Generation episode The Best of Both Worlds. With the camera slowly rotating around the shot we see Locutus of Borg overlayed with Picard, and an immortal piece of visual poetry is born.

5. In Orbit, Again

CBS

I say this every week, but the supporting cast of new characters has been excellent in this show. Each week they're allotted one or two small scenes in which to gently nudge their own stories forward, never detracting from the main narrative, and every single time they're a low-key highlight of the episode. This week saw Rios lending emotional support to Raffi and Agnes in two very different ways (ey lads?), but the star of the show by a mile was Narek.

Advertisement

He's a spy, and he's been plugging Soji as part of a sinister Tal Shiar plot to uncover her origins - this much we've known since the start - but he's also clearly fallen in love with her. The duality of the performance, in particular the meticulous way he exploits her dreams in the closing stages but is then overwhelmed by the impact it has on him, is stunning.

What looked like being a shallow and predictable double-agent role is emerging as one of the show's most interesting parts.

Advertisement

4. The Romulans Send Their Regards

CBS

And speaking of shallow and predictable things that are, in actual fact, becoming quite interesting, the relationship between Jaime and Cersei Romulan feels a more compelling reason to tune in every single week now. Will they betray each other? Will they kill each other? Will they just get it over with and smash? It really shouldn't work but the constant tension between the two is Very Good TV.

Advertisement

Somewhere down the line, Narek will atone for his sins against a woman he's clearly fallen madly in love for, and it'll likely be his sister who bears the brunt of this. It would be an unspectacular trope to have him simply lay down his life to save Soji, but if handled right it might not be as bad as it sounds. Either way, the inevitable showdown between these two is going to be explosive.

3. Unraveling

CBS

Fundamentally, Soji's story is a horrifying mirror image of Data's. He was an android who sought desperately to learn more about his humanity, whereas she is a "human" who wants nothing more than for these revelations about being an android to not be true. In a cruel twist, she has everything her father ever aspired to attain but would give everything for it not to be true.

Advertisement

The small clues about the call logs with her mother, the carbon dating of all her possessions, and there being no record of her being on the ship that allegedly brought her to the artifact. It's just enough that the audience can piece the puzzle together, but still not enough for the mystery to feel like it's over. There's still more to

2. Hugh

CBS

It can't have been easy for Jonathan Del Arco to step back into a role he played literally only twice back in the early 90s, but my word does he manage it. In fact, despite his relatively sparse few minutes of screentime, it's a performance that highlights the folly in having Icheb and Bruce Maddox recast. Yes, they're all relatively small parts, but the extra impact of having the actual Hugh here is noticeable.

Advertisement

His inclusion is one that made perfect sense at the time it was announced, but feels like a perfect fit in the context of the story. As Picard struggles to reconcile his history with the Borg with his loss of humanity, meeting a man who had a far deeper connection with the Collective, and has managed to overcome it, is a huge moment in the show.

1. Daddy's Home

CBS

Probably the best scene in the entire show so far, and arguably the moment that everything has been leading to, saw Picard step foot on a Borg Cube for the first time since he was assimilated. He's been there in his nightmares, and arguably a part of him never actually left, but it's a huge moment for the character, the show, and Star Trek as a whole.

Advertisement

The way it's pitched delivers on the lofty premise. Clearly still traumatized and unable to even meet the gaze of the X-Bs walking the corridors, the entire scene flashes back to episodes of The Next Generation and First Contact before kicking into action with Soji's escape. The producers deserve major credit or integrating the old footage without making it look dated, but for Patrick Stewart's part in it alone it's a tremendous scene.