Supernatural: 10 Most Hated Episodes
The Winchester brothers may have won over our hearts, but not every episode was a winner.
It only makes sense for a show that's run as long as Supernatural to have its fair share of terrible episodes, and boy, does Supernatural have its fair share of terrible episodes. There was once a time when Supernatural was considered one of the best series on TV, but as the show went on, it was getting harder and harder to remember the great show Supernatural once was.
With 15 seasons to its name, what used to be a beloved and well-written show became a boring, dull, and repetitive snoozefest, with many of its most hated episodes being that of the later seasons. However, even during its prime, Supernatural still had its number of bad episodes, many of which are on this list.
The Winchester brothers may have won over our hearts since season one, but not every episode in their 15 seasons of running was a winner. Here are the 10 most hated episodes of Supernatural.
10. Route 666 (Season 1, Episode 13)
Ask any Supernatural fan about "the racist truck" and they'll know exactly what you're talking about. Yes, this Supernatural episode features a racist killer truck killing African-American men and then vanishing into the night. It's a ridiculous concept, to say the least, and a rather difficult one to suspend your disbelief for. It's actually funny to imagine what the episode meeting for this one must've been like.
And really, with a premise that ridiculous, you really need exceptional writing in order to make the episode work. With Route 666, however, we get sloppy writing made even worse by the overacting done by one of the episode's main cast member, Cassie. While Cassie Robinson could've made for an interesting character, especially in the first Supernatural season, the horrid acting by Megalyn Echikunwoke made us glad the character never appeared in the show again.
However, while the episode is laughably bad, it's laughably bad in the way you'll only get from the earlier seasons of Supernatural — ridiculous premises and attempts to be scary that fall insanely flat. The terrible episodes of the later episodes of Supernatural are all bad because of the same reason: they're pointless boring filler, repeating the same formulas we've seen in the show over and over again.
9. Dark Dynasty (Season 10, Episode 21)
The first of many season 10 episodes on this list, Dark Dynasty is a particularly controversial episode due to the death of a fan-favorite character, Charlie. Charlie was one of the first openly gay characters in Supernatural, which made her death receive so much backlash from the fandom.
The problem here is how unnecessary her death felt, feeling more like a product of lazy writing rather than something that actually contributed to the plot. Killing a beloved character just for the shock value is bound to piss off many of the fans of your show and get your episode on the "Most Hated Episodes" list.
Beyond her death, Dark Dynasty features the same formula the show has had for several episodes at that point, making the episode still terrible even if Charlie hadn't died. Many of the fans had wondered at this point if the show was even worth following anymore given how repetitive and formulaic each episode has been. With Dark Dynasty, it became clear that the show had officially jumped the shark.
8. Paint It Black (Season 10, Episode 16)
Crowley's mom is easily one of the worst characters in Supernatural history; plenty of fans couldn't stand her the moment she appeared on the show. Many viewers thought she was annoying, overdone, and worthless to the plot. The show writers must have not gotten the memo, however, because season 10 seems to be obsessed with featuring her.
Paint It Black is one of those episodes and boy, is it a bad one. Good god, were they running Rowena's storyline like a marathon at this point of the show. Sam and Dean felt pushed to the side, almost like they were guest stars instead of the protagonists of the show. This episode was also painfully boring and slow to watch and featured too much coincidence and exposition.
Paint It Black is again just a nothing of an episode and it made it very apparent that the writers no longer knew what they were doing and were just writing stuff up in order to keep the show going. Season 10 featured some of the worst episodes of Supernatural and was all-around just a boring, repetitive, and formulaic experience, giving viewers the same thing every week.
7. Paper Moon (Season 10, Episode 4)
Of all the things a show entitled Supernatural should be, boring should not be one of them, and yet many of the later season episodes can be described as just that: boring. We used it to describe the previous episode on this list and we're using it again to describe this episode. This episode features the reappearance of Kate, a character from a previous episode named Bitten which is also on this list.
The entire episode is really just so boring. It doesn't offer anything new, refreshing, or exciting, and is really only there to be filler. There is a scene in this episode that takes place in a diner that was so slow and filled with so much exposition, it felt like the episode was so much longer than it actually was.
Given that Bitten is also considered one of the worst episodes of Supernatural, it's strange the writers would dedicate a later episode following up on it. It's no surprise, then, that the episode turned out to be one of the most boring and uninteresting episodes of the series.
6. Drag Me Away (From You) (Season 15, Episode 16)
When you're four episodes away from the final episode of a series you love, a filler episode is not what you want. But that's what we got from Supernatural whose final season seems to be three fourths of just filler episodes.
For the last season of a long-time running beloved series, it's disappointing that most of the episodes seem to be completely lacklustre, almost like the writers have completely run out of ideas and are just recycling plot points at this point.
Drag Me Away (From You) takes the cake for the worst filler episode of Season 15, with the whole episode feeling like the writers were stretching out the plot in order to fill the episode's runtime.
You would expect the last season of Supernatural to filled with so much excitement and energy, but instead we get episodes like this. This really feels like a wasted episode — why have a monster of the week episode at this point of the series? The final season should not be filled with this much lazy writing, but instead that's what we got.
5. Bitten (Season 8, Episode 4)
It makes sense for a show that's run as long as Supernatural to try something different every now and then, especially since Supernatural has already tried doing the "found footage" style in their earlier Ghostfacers episodes. However, Bitten misses the mark completely when it comes to the found footage genre, giving us an episode not scary or engaging but instead annoying and gimmicky.
The episode also featured characters that are hard to care about played by actors that are just so awful to watch. Why so many of the worst episodes of Supernatural feature such painful-to-watch overacting is beyond us, but boy, were the young actors in this episode some of the worst cast members of the show. Maybe the showrunners thought they could get away with it with the "found footage" gimmick of the episode, but really, the gimmick only made the episode worse.
Plenty of scenes are downright unrealistic at times, with camera angles that don't make sense, moments that are conveniently filmed, and the zooming in of cameras being able to amplify the sound. The shaky camera also makes for a headache-inducing experience. It's a boring filler episode that will literally give you a headache.
4. There's Something About Mary (Season 12, Episode 21)
Remember how we said Dark Dynasty was the point where it became clear that the series had jumped the shark? There's Something About Mary is a great example of how the series continued to jump the shark since then. At this point of the show's run, many of its fans continued on clinging to the hope that even if the show would never return to its original quality, it would at least go back to being good. There's Something About Mary made it clear how unlikely that was going to happen.
Much like Dark Dynasty, There's Something About Mary features the death of another fan-favorite minority character, Eileen. You would think the writers would know better given the backlash Charlie's death received, and yet here There's Something About Mary is, killing off a minority character in a lazy, unnecessary, and undignified manner. This episode also features the death of Crowley, another upsetting death given how intelligent of a character he is.
Beyond the deaths, the episode featured such ludicrous plot points as Mary being brainwashed in less than a week to the point where she wouldn't care about killing her sons. All in all just a terrible episode, one that made it very clear the show was no longer the great show it once was.
3. Bugs (Season 1, Episode 8)
Neither the episode Bugs nor the bugs in the episode are very scary, especially since the bugs on screen are very clearly fake. With spiders that are obviously plastic and bugs that are blatantly CGI, the episode is admittedly pretty funny to watch given how fake everything looks. This is especially true when the Winchester brothers fight a swarm of tiny bugs, looking more awkward than heroic.
Even if the production side of the episode was decent, the script still fell short, especially towards the ending. The storyline is weak and filled with clichés and the ending is illogical — the passing of the night seemed to happen almost immediately. Sam and Dean also don't solve anything in this episode, instead just abandoning the case, which is not something we want to see the Winchester brothers do, especially during their first season.
Still, just like Route 666, we need to give Bugs some credit — it's terrible not because it's a boring waste of an episode but because it's a result of the writers trying to take a ridiculous idea and make it scary when it's so clearly not. Maybe if the episode had better special effects, the episode would've been more noteworthy, but we doubt realistic-looking bugs would make the brothers fighting them be less awkward to watch.
2. Bloodlines (Season 9, Episode 20)
By their very nature, backdoor pilots are usually a terrible idea because they steal a week off a beloved show with a fanbase that might not be interested in watching a new series and they're only given 40 minutes to convince viewers to be interested in their show. Some backdoor pilots work well, like The Flash's introduction in Arrow, and some, while not working well as an episode, still manage to get their show picked up, like Ravenswood in Pretty Little Liars; however short-lived.
Bloodlines, though, is a backdoor pilot that falls spectacularly flat on its face, so much so that no spin-off series ever happened. This episode was meant to be the backdoor pilot for a spin-off series entitled Supernatural: Bloodlines, but that spin-off ultimately didn't happen and for good reason. This episode is painful to watch and felt like a horrible rip-off of popular teen supernatural films and series such as Twilight, Teen Wolf, and The Vampire Diaries.
Not to mention, this episode was Supernatural in name only. It barely had the Winchester brothers in it and the story contributed nothing to the Supernatural episode. This is made even worse by the fact that the characters this episode decides to focus on instead are terribly written and one-dimensional, with acting wooden, emotionless, and unengaging.
The whole fandom can agree — if you're binge-watching the Supernatural series, Bloodlines is the episode you ought to skip.
1. Carry On (Season 15, Episode 20)
When you have a show as popular and beloved as Supernatural, with 15 years of running and a plethora of dedicated fans, you know your series finale has to deliver and deliver well. Unfortunately, the only thing the Supernatural series finale seemed to deliver was disappointment in its highest form.
Everything about this series finale is shockingly bad. It's as if the writers had taken fifteen years of character development and completely threw it out the window. This episode is not only an insult to the show's characters, it's an insult to the show's fans, especially those who stuck with it for most or all of its 15 years.
This was it? This was what 15 years of the show ended with? Supernatural was a show that featured such amazing episodes like Swan Song, Changing Channels, and The French Mistake. During its prime, this show had amazing seasons with epic finales that had us on the edge of our seats waiting impatiently for the next season. Granted, it was getting harder and harder to remember that the more Supernatural went on, but for such a once well-written show, it deserved a much better finale. Instead, we got everything that turned Supernatural terrible: unnecessary deaths just for shock factor and boring, underwhelming, and lazy writing.
The fans deserved a better finale. The characters deserved a better finale. The cast deserved a better finale. Carry On is a terrible, terrible ending to what used to be a great show.