Supernatural: 10 Spin-Offs We’d Love To See

Because 15 seasons just wasn't enough!

By Michael John-Day /

Supernatural is a show so great that even after a whopping fifteen seasons, fans are still desperate to see more. That's probably why rumours about spin-offs have been as common as action shots of the Impala. Even though the saga of the Winchesters might have drawn to a close, they are not the only characters in this wild, scary, action-packed world.

Advertisement

There's an endless number of stories that deserve to be told on Earth, Heaven and Hell. The show's lengthy runtime meant it could explore tonnes of themes and settings. This led to a plethora of characters who could easily fill up their own TV shows, alongside others who could benefit from a little more fleshing out/development.

Of course, spin-offs are very much a gamble, as their track record of quality is up and down like a roller coaster; for every Fraiser, there are about twelve Joeys. However, with the right approach, they can be an absolute blast that add more depth to the world of the show.

It's safe to say that fans would be in for a treat if these coming Supernatural staples were given some time in the limelight.

10. The Story Of John And Mary Winchester

This idea sits right at the top of the list, as it's the most likely to happen - how very exciting!

Advertisement

As of right now, this spin-off is in development. The CW even ordered a pilot in February of this year. So, as long as things work out, Supernatural fans should get the chance to see how this loving couple came to be and what they've gone through.

The choice of characters is spot-on here. There's so much potential in bringing their story to life, as the Winchesters already have such a beautiful narrative arc. Their relationship went through so much struggle and turmoil, and although the show explored plenty of it, there's still so much depth to be found.

Seeing some of Mary's hunting past would be awesome, and watching how their relationship was shaped would massively accentuate their journey in the original series. It would be tender, heartfelt and highly romantic whilst likely still chucking in some kick-ass action.

The proposed series even has the iconic Jensen Ackles signed on to narrate the show as Dean Winchester. Now, that's something fans want to see.

9. The Legacy Of Samuel Colt

No Supernatural fan in their right mind would say no to a series based on the figure who many consider the greatest hunter of all time. This was something on the mind of Eric Kripke, as the writers would allegedly float this idea around quite often. Seeing as the thought is already out there, what's keeping it from coming true?

Advertisement

Using real-life historical figures in the series was a fun way to explore an alternate version of history, and Samuel Colt was a perfect example of that. This real-life inventor had a significant impact on the show, as he created The Colt - which would lead to the death of Azazel - and the Devil's Gate in Wyoming, all while hunting demons, monsters and more.

One of the biggest appeals to this spin-off would be the old west setting. Fans are used to seeing hunters operate in the modern-day, but seeing how the old school guys got it done could be full of surprises and fun.

Overall, this character has a massive legacy, so seeing how he made his name would be nothing short of amazing.

8. The Fall Of Lucifer

This is a story people have obsessed over since John Milton's Paradise Lost, and Supernatural has a perfect opportunity to cash in on that - it's a no-brainer. Plus, with Netflix's Lucifer coming to an end soon, there will be a real shortage of God's former favourite son on the screen, so it's the perfect time to strike.

Advertisement

Naturally, in a story about brothers fighting the forces of Hell, Lucifer was going to make an appearance at some point, and that he certainly did. Supernatural's incarnation of The Devil, Morning Star, Light Bringer, Satan himself was enthralling. His mixture of charm, manipulation, humour and cruelty was magnetic, and fans would love to see how he became that way.

A series that explored his early days in Heaven would be compelling, as fans could see first-hand what caused the Archangel to be driven out of God's paradise. The slow build-up of his growing frustrations with God and Heaven would be full of tension, and the final explosion of conflict could make for one of the most exciting in the whole franchise.

7. Gabriel's Time In "Witness Protection"

Supernatural was hardly starved for fan-favourite characters, but Gabriel was one of the most unique. There are plenty of people who can relate to the idea of wanting to run and hide from their dysfunctional family, but Gabriel took the initiative to do it. Besides his circumstances, he was also a barrel of laughs thanks to his sarcasm and likeability.

Advertisement

When Gabriel revealed his true self, not as the Trickster but as an archangel, he talked about how he spent most of his life hiding after skipping out of heaven. Those years - spanning millennia - must have featured some thrilling adventures, and fans would very much like to be privy to them. Watching him take the place of Loki would be particularly exciting, as everyone loves the Norse trickster god.

There are endless possibilities with this, as the setting could travel all throughout history, and plenty of mythologies could be explored. Plus, seeing what drove Gabriel to run away in the first place would be an excellent way to deepen his character and make his final moments in the show all the more poignant.

6. Garth's Return To Action

There's plenty more people who need to be "Garth'ed".

Advertisement

A dentist turned hunter, turned werewolf, turned dentist again. It's safe to say that Garth has a somewhat mixed resume on his hands. This character was a great addition to the show. He was the perfect unconventional hunter and charmed the audience with his quaint personality and goodness.

His life (naturally) changed dramatically after he was turned into a werewolf. But, this decision gave the character a fascinating sense of duality as he was both hunter and hunted. Thankfully, things worked out for Garth in the end, as he got married to another werewolf (Bess) and settled into a fairy tail like happily-ever-after.

However, while the idea of this lovely ending being stolen from him is sad, it's safe to say that Garth has a perfect avenue for a dark spin-off, which sees him return to the world of hunting after losing his beloved Bess.

Just imagine a show with a werewolf who is a hunter. It wouldn't just be kick-ass but also emotionally conflicting. Plus, DJ Qualls is a great actor, and he's long overdue a leading role in a hit series. That's just the cherry on top of this already tasty looking sundae.

5. The Wonderful Charlie Of Oz

There are tonnes of Supernatural fans who would be willing to die on a hill, proclaiming that Charlie was awesome and her untimely demise was one of the show's biggest mistakes. The truth is that it's hard to argue with that. So, maybe it's time viewers got some justice for Charlie and witnessed her on a magical adventure.

Advertisement

This character was a delightful slice of nerdy pie, bringing a light-hearted quality to the series and geeky references galore. But, there was also the seeding of conflict within her. One of the most interesting things to come from this was her desire to find a quest of her own.

She found this in Oz after helping Dorothy destroy The Wicked Witch and deciding to stay and assist in freeing the magical land. Sadly, although that sounds amazing, viewers never got to go with her, as the next time they saw her was in her return to the real world.

It's easy to see how this empty gap in Charlie's life could be filled. A series showing her time in Oz and the origins of Dark Charlie would be full of magic and wonder. So, pretty cool all around.

4. The History Of Men Of Letters

The Men of Letters is such a great concept, and it was a lot of fun to see Sam and Dean re-forge the organisation. However, while fans got to see the newly created version and the, let's say, less helpful British Men of Letters, they never got a chance to see how the organisation came into being. That's something that could change.

Advertisement

It's true that the mystery of Men of Letters' origin is part of the charm. Still, a period fantasy that showed how the "preceptors" became a unit and gathered all of their esoteric, arcane knowledge would be a blast.

One of the most appealing things about this spin-off concept is that there are plenty of grounds for creativity. The writers don't need to adhere to any specific characters or continuity. They could create their own original ideas, so long as they don't tread on the toes of the original series.

It's a perfect foundation for some high-class hunting. Plus, it could have a life of its own that's not too heavily connected to the original series, giving it the chance to deepen the lore well past even the depths of Hell itself.

3. The Origins Of Heaven, Earth And Hell

The current Supernatural spin-off in the works is a prequel about the family life of the Winchesters. But why stop there? Why should the life of these iconic brothers be the only prequel on the bill? Why not go back to the brink of existence and the creation of The Attic, Hades and the Earth itself.

Advertisement

A series like this would indeed need a lot of scope, as encompassing the creation of the universe is no easy feat. However, there would be a lot to gain from it. The show could focus on God's journey creating the angels and Earth itself, the conflict with Lucifer, God's disappearance, the early stages of God/Death and more.

What makes this one all the more exciting is that it can encompass some of the previous entries into it. For example, the fall of Lucifer and the escape of Gabriel could be pivotal moments in the series and could even lead to those spin-offs spinning off of this spin-off. Wow, that's a lot of spinning.

This kind of thing could also draw in new viewers, as who wouldn't want to watch a show with such high ambition?

2. The Wayward Sisters

The thing that hurts most about this is that the show was so close to happening. A pilot for this very spin-off was produced during the thirteenth season of Supernatural and even had multiple writers/producers from the original series behind it. But, the ball got dropped after the show failed to get greenlit. All fans have to say to that is, why?!

Advertisement

A Wayward Sisters series could have explored the lives of these characters after supernatural tragedies brought them together. Seeing as Sherriff's Jody Mills and Donna Hanscum helped turn a group of young women into an elite hunting force. What's not to love here?

Supernatural is primed for this kind of story, as the mixture of action, horror and girl-power from this spin-off would please existing fans and bring in a whole new set of viewers. It seems perfect for their target audience and is far enough removed from the original series to feel like a cheap cash grab.

It's a shame it didn't already happen, as the CW was on the cusp of greatness. Still, here's hoping it finds new life again someday.

1. Young Bobby And Rufus

It seems that the theme of prequels is prominent in this list. But, of all the stories from the past fans want to see, it's hard to imagine one better than this.

Advertisement

Bobby and Rufus are the bickering, old-married-couple duo everyone knows and loves, and there's endless scope in seeing their early days. The circumstances that brought these two together were incredibly tragic, meaning this spin-off has a solid emotional hook right off the bat. However, it's not all doom and gloom, as there's a great mentor/student dynamic to this pair that has plenty of humour.

Seeing Rufus introduce a naïve version of Bobby to the world of the supernatural would, no doubt, be funny and watchable. Focussing on their time as hunters could also see a nice set of new threats appear, making the show seem fresh despite coming before the story you already know.

These two have fantastic chemistry and are both beloved by fans, so it looks like there are no drawbacks to seeing this happen. Just cast the right actors, hire the best writers and make a classic.

Advertisement