The Boys: Every Episode Ranked Worst To Best

Ranking the first sixteen episodes of Amazon's daring superhero drama, ready for season three.

By Aidan Whatman /

Published between 2006 and 2012, Garth Ennis's masterful comic book series The Boys ran for 72 issues, introducing readers worldwide to a superhero story unlike any other. Rife with violence, sex, complex characters, morally ambiguous vigilantes and genuinely detestable superheroes, the series set a benchmark for just how fun, risky and unconventional the superhero genre could be.

Advertisement

Originally planned to be adapted into a movie by Columbia Pictures back in 2008, the series finally hit Amazon Prime as a TV show, developed by Eric Kripke and starring the likes of Karl Urban, Jack Quaid, Antony Starr, Erin Moriarty, Elizabeth Shue and more.

Though not a direct adaptation of the comics that gave it life, The Boys has nonetheless done a remarkable job of capturing the timely themes, stylish action and complexities of Ennis's source material, and by mixing things up the cast and crew have crafted one of the best shows currently on air.

As of this writing, two seasons and 16 episodes have aired, with season three on the horizon. Every episode has something to offer, though as with all shows some aren't quite as strong as others in the series. With that in mind, here are all 16 f*cking diabolic episodes of The Boys ranked worst to best.

Major spoilers throughout.

16. The Big Ride (Season 2, Episode 1)

Season two's premiere kicks off sometime after season one's maddening cliffhanger. Butcher is missing and presumed dead, whilst Hughie, Frenchie, MM and Kimiko are hiding out from the Seven and more isolated than ever. Meanwhile, Ashley Barrett has taken control of Vought Industries and Homelander is trying to keep a hold on his sanity and his leadership.

Advertisement

The Big Ride is a great episode, filled with some striking character interactions, the first instance of someone's head blowing up inexplicably, and the introduction of bubbly but mysterious hero Stormfront. We also get to see more of The Deep and his increased isolation, as well as Hughie and Annie's fractured relationship.

Though all of this is well and good, and the episode is typically striking in its performances, twists and entertainment, The Big Ride is a bit too exposition-filled compared to others in the series. It seems in parts to slightly meander, and though it's all worth it in the long run, the momentum of the episode and its need to set up what's to come does let it down in the rankings.

15. Get Some (Season 1, Episode 3)

The Boys, despite its action and thriller-like pace, is at its heart a meticulous character study, digging into the often twisted psyches of its main characters with startling results. In the first few episodes, it is A-Train who takes centre stage, first by accidentally killing Hughie's girlfriend and then by desperately attempting to cling to his title as the world's fastest man.

Advertisement

In Get Some, it's finally time for A-Train to go up against fellow speedster Shockwave, in a showdown dubbed the Race of Century. In the background of this development, The Boys are all geared up and eager to get their hands on some of A-Train's Compound V, using the race as the cover for the perfect heist.

Between Jessie Usher's scene-stealing performance and Butcher and Homelander's sinister stare-down, Get Some is an episode of tension, but little action. It seems, at this early point in the show, things are still being mapped out and aren't yet ready to hit us with a big twist. The characters are still being developed, and the stage still being set for what is to come, and for that reason it's not quite as strong as the episodes surrounding it.

14. The Innocents (Season 1, Episode 6)

In hopes of allowing the Seven a place in the military, Vought Industries sets up a promotional video to boost public support, showing the heroes participating in acts of kindness and telling touching stories about their lives. The Innocents gives deeper insight into just how fake the Seven's public personas are, and paints Vought as a company revelling in their control of the superheroes.

Advertisement

The themes of commercialisation, image and power are expertly crafted in the episode, though its strongest aspect comes courtesy of Billy Butcher, who is finally given the opportunity to share his tragic past with both Hughie and the audience.

Throughout The Innocents, there is a palpable sense that everyone is dealing with inner turmoil but not yet able to move on. Homelander is distraught about the promotional video; Hughie is falling in love with Annie but feels guilty because of Robin; and Butcher doesn't want to move on until he cleans up the Seven. It's cruel, slow-burning, moving, harsh and brilliant, but once more is let down in the rankings for being almost all set-up, saving the major shocks for the next two episodes.

13. Nothing Like It In The World (Season 2, Episode 4)

Nothing Like it in the World is a road-trip episode, following Hughie, Annie and MM as they look into the mystery of the long-lost superhero Liberty. On the open road, Annie and MM finally get a chance to bond, and Hughie gets a chance to atone for his actions in season one, officially reconciling with Annie and giving the show one of its most wholesome moments.

Advertisement

The episode gives more insight into Stormfront, who up until this point has proven to be a violent, evil but still ambiguous character, and allows Annie the chance to shine outside of the Seven and their constant terror and drama.

The Boys is great when toning things down for a more character-driven adventure, and Nothing Like It drives that home without fault. Frenchie is high as a kite; Kimiko is vengeful as hell; and MM gives some insight into why he's part of The Boys as Homelander teeters on the edge of insanity. Not as action-packed or daring as others in the show, but tension at its finest all the same, and a necessary plot-driver.

12. The Name Of The Game (Season 1, Episode 1)

Watching The Name of the Game again after two seasons, it's more striking than ever just how confident The Boys was from the get-go. The opening scene shows Homelander and Queen Maeve in typical, wholesome hero mode, and things seem relatively normal (if ominous) until A-Train obliterates Hughie's girlfriend by running through her on the street.

Advertisement

From the image of Robin's severed hands in Hughie's to the snarling introduction of Karl Urban's Billy Butcher, The Name of the Game is a top-tier series premiere, putting most of the main players on the board and making it clear what they're all about, despite the amount of manipulation, lying and deceiving that goes on between them.

By focussing on Hughie and Starlight, the show's two most endearing figures, The Boys came out the gate swinging, crafting an almost fully-realised world and balancing the drama with the violence in the process. The only reason it ranks in the lower half of the list is because, as the first episode, thing are only just being set-up and the best has yet to come.

11. Good For The Soul (Season 1, Episode 5)

Despite only running for 16 episode thus far, it's incredible to think just much the writers have managed to fit in without forcing things or tripping over themselves. In Good For the Soul, The Boys head to the Believe Expo so they can get in contact with superhero preacher Ezekiel and learn about Compound V.

Advertisement

Not only is Good for the Soul a great character piece, allowing Starlight to stand up against the corporate machine and question her faith in very public fashion, it also comes with one of the show's biggest twists - that superheroes aren't born, but made in a lab using Compound V.

A game-changer of the highest order, the episode comes complete with Hughie admitting to Starlight his girlfriend just died and the iconic scene in which Butcher uses a baby as a laser gun. The reason it ranks here isn't because of any major flaws, but because the rest of the show is at such a high calibre.

10. Cherry (Season 1, Episode 2)

Speaking of game-changers, Cherry was the first episode to show The Boys (save MM and Kimiko) in action, as Hughie and Butcher team-up with Frenchie to deal with a kidnapped Translucent. Cherry is a turning point episode, in which Hughie has to decide whether he really wants revenge on the Seven or if he needs to pack up and return home to his dad.

Advertisement

The episode also sees Starlight confront The Deep about their interaction in the previous episode, standing up to the manipulative supe and vowing to never be pushed around like that again.

In the end, Starlight finds her footing on the team and begins to feel okay about her work, whilst Hughie blows Translucent up when he tries to escape Frenchie's compound. Between this dark and gory twist and more insight into Homelander's relationship with the Seven and Madelyn Stillwell, Cherry solidified The Boys as a show to watch, and not one that would take its subject lightly.

9. We Gotta Go Now (Season 2, Episode 5)

The Boys has never strayed from its whip-smart social satire. Season two's We Gotta Go Now features real-life celebrity callouts, an intense criticism of the Hollywood machine and timely assessments of how the media and big companies try to increase representation for their audiences.

Advertisement

Outside of all these excellently handled themes, the episode also has a top-tier narrative, following Butcher as he grapples with his self-deprecation and his recent inability to save Becca. Along the way, he, Hughie and MM are attacked by Black Noir, and Butcher realises that he needs Hughie in his life more than he first thought.

We Gotta Go Now is equal parts riveting tension and seamless character building, as Butcher shows his human side and Homelander grows increasingly detached from a world he no longer seems to recognise, in one scene imagining himself massacring some protesters. At this point, season two's final stretch was shaping up to be something really special, and on top of that we finally get some more time with Stan Edgar being sinister as all hell.

8. Proper Preparation And Planning (Season 2, Episode 2)

Proper Preparation and Planning is, at its core, all about family. Butcher is still reeling from learning his missing wife Becca is still alive, and will do seemingly anything to get her back; Kimiko comes face to face with the new supe-terrorist in town, her own estranged brother; and Homelander spends some quality time with his son, Ryan.

Advertisement

The episode digs into what's driving the characters forward, be it Butcher's anger over losing his wife, MM's desire to finally get back to his family, or Homelander's constant need to have people love him in spite of his passive aggressive nature and cold demeanor.

The biggest strength of Proper Preparation, as with all the best episodes, lies in its ability to balance the quieter character moments with the high-octane action. A major step-up from the season two premiere, the episode features multiple twists, all executed perfectly right up until the final scene's ambiguous cliffhanger.

7. The Self-Preservation Society (Season 1, Episode 7)

The Boys' first season spends a lot of time building up the characters, introducing new faces, dropping names, putting all the pieces in play and promising some major revelations. The Self-Preservation Society is really the episode where everything comes to a head, as Starlight ends up in the crosshairs of an enraged Homelander and Butcher pushes his role as the show's anti-hero to its breaking point.

Advertisement

The Society introduces Grace Mallory, the original leader of The Boys, and in some striking flashbacks we learn more than ever about Butcher and his vendetta against Homelander. It also comes complete with a perfect twist, in which Homelander finds out The Boys' identities and accuses Starlight of being their accomplice.

As a whole, the episode is sometimes disjointed by the flashbacks and the present-day story, shifting between tones with each subplot, but with Butcher's brutal murder of Mesmer and Hughie's confession to Annie about who he is, there really is more than enough to love with season one's penultimate affair. Plus, Homelander threatening Starlight? Chills.

6. The Female Of The Species (Season 1, Episode 4)

Looking back, Kimiko really stole the show from her very first scene. Found in this episode by Frenchie, MM and Hughie, The Female is caged up and being experimented on. At least, that's the case until she is freed by Frenchie, and she proceeds to kill all of her captors and flee into the night.

Advertisement

As The Boys race through the city in hopes of capturing The Female, another story begins to unfold around it. Here, Homelander and Queen Maeve are sent to save a hijacked plane, only the rescue goes wrong and the plane's controls are wrecked. Unwilling to save anyone, Homelander pulls Maeve from the plane and they watch as it crashes into the sea, killing everyone on board.

A harsh and sadistic twist, the tragedy ends up working in Homelander's favour, as he uses it to speak to Congress about letting the Seven serve with the military. As Frenchie shows his soft side to Kimiko and A-Train goes on the warpath, Homelander shows his true colours - and none of them are pretty.

5. You Found Me (Season 1, Episode 8)

The strongest episode of season one, You Found Me is a perfect finale, tying up loose ends whilst creating some maddening plot twists. Hughie races to save Frenchie and MM from Vought, whilst Butcher heads out to confront Madelyn Stillwell, and Starlight grapples with her need to be a hero and her pain over Hughie's recent betrayal.

Advertisement

As Butcher pushes Hughie away and heads out to take on Homelander, A-Train, high as a kite on Compound V, fights with Starlight when she races to save Hughie and the others. Homelander, meanwhile, slips further into depravity when he kills Stillwell for lying to him.

You Found Me, directed by Eric Kripke, is a culmination of all the previous episodes had been building to, with The Boys becoming more fractured than ever, Butcher becoming consumed by his need for revenge, and Annie facing off with her identity crisis. Plus, it ends on the best cliffhanger of the show, as Homelander reveals to Butcher that Becca is still alive. Ouch.

4. Over The Hill With The Swords Of A Thousand Men (Season 2, Episode 3)

Following Proper Preparation and Planning, The Boys in this episode take to the sea, keeping Kimiko's brother prisoner and ready to be turned over to Mallory. Meanwhile, The Deep uses this as an opportunity to win favour with the Seven and the news about Compound V hits the news worldwide, jeopardising the heroes' images and Vought's reputation.

Advertisement

Over the Hill features more tension between Butcher and Hughie, and sees Stormfront's true nature begin to slide into view when she massacres a community of African-Americans and kills Kimiko's brother in cold blood. Oh, and Lucy the Whale gets violently impaled by Butcher's stolen yacht, which only gets more grisly when Hughie decides to stay in the dead mammal and seems to give up fighting.

Over the Hill with the Swords of a Thousand Men has more main characters turn up in one place than ever, too, meaning there are some startling revelations and great character interactions. Homelander learns about A-Train's heart condition, Starlight is pushed to kill Hughie, and Butcher risks losing his target to save Hughie at the last second. It's violent, bloody, shocking and cruel, and it's easily one of the show's best misadventures.

3. Butcher, Baker, Candlestick Maker (Season 2, Episode 7)

In many ways, Butcher, Baker, Candlestick Maker might just be the show's most shocking installment. For starters, there's Lamplighter, an old member of the Seven just introduced, who races with Hughie to save Starlight from imprisonment just to commit suicide in the Seven's conference room.

Advertisement

Then there's Stormfront, whose calls to fight the supe-terrorists causes a disillusioned citizen to kill an innocent man. And then, of course, there's Homelander, who continues to push his son to use his powers.

It's an episode that moves effortlessly from one shock twist to the next, never really slowing down but not once trying to force the drama or the violence. Lamplighter, for all his faults, proves increasingly tragic, and Stormfront slides her way into Ryan's life in hopes of manipulating him to realise just how strong he is. It's an uncomfortable watch, and seeing Hughie all alone in the Tower is tension at its finest, but it's also without question one of the show's most entertaining and adrenaline-fuelled episodes.

2. The Bloody Doors Off (Season 2, Episode 6)

For nearly two seasons, there had been chatter amongst The Boys about Mallory, Lamplighter and Frenchie's inability to save Mallory's grandchildren. In The Bloody Doors Off, audiences are finally treated to this story, as flashbacks reveal not only that Frenchie didn't stop Lamplighter because he had to save a friend from an overdose, but that Lamplighter didn't mean to kill the kids at all.

Advertisement

It's a tragic and emotionally charged story, in which Frenchie's rage and grief threatens to overcome him now that he's face to face with Lamplighter once more. Outside of this brilliant development, Hughie gets badly injured and Butcher and Annie race to save him, and Frenchie, MM and Kimiko get caught in a secret compound run by Stormfront that's working to create more superheroes.

As the facility is overrun, we're treated to numerous new (and very bizarre) supes, and Stormfront's evil intentions come more and more into focus. Underneath all the violence and revenge, The Bloody Doors Off also has some great slices of drama, as both Butcher and Annie bond over their feelings for Hughie and Frenchie's rage causes Kimiko to make amends for their fall-out. It's damn near perfection, really.

1. What I Know (Season 2, Episode 8)

The season two finale is the best episode of the show yet, making the upcoming third season all the more exciting and anticipated. Not only does What I Know feature the now-iconic "girls get it done" scene, in which Starlight, Kimiko and Maeve work to defeat Stormfront, it also features Butcher fighting his desire to cut Ryan out of Becca's life and Homelander's desire to have Ryan working by his side.

Advertisement

What I Know is incredibly violent, as Homelander massacres a whole squad of Vought soldiers when he loses his son and The Boys gear up against Stormfront, who has just been publicly ousted as a racist and a Nazi. But it's also incredibly emotional, as Becca dies in Butcher's arms, Hughie and Annie finally get back together, and Butcher manages to put his prejudice to one side after promising to keep Ryan safe.

This being a Boys episode, there are also some startling twists, including the fact that Victoria Neuman is the supe who's been blowing up people's heads and that A-Train and Starlight have been let back into the Seven without The Deep. It does a remarkable job of tying up loose ends, but also does just enough to tease a fresh slate moving forward.

Here's to hoping season three maintains The Boys' momentum, and brings the thrills like never before.

Advertisement