The Office: 10 Worst Things Michael Scott Ever Did

The times when Michael Scott was the boss from hell!

By Michael John-Day /

Being a boss is no easy feat, as you can never have your cake and eat it too. While being popular and beloved by your workforce is possible, it's also statistically challenging, as you're always going to have to make harsh decisions that lead to someone disliking you. Even the most well-liked boss has an enemy or two.

Advertisement

Then, there are people like Michael Scott, who focus so much on being a friend rather than a boss that they create an incredibly uncomfortable work environment.

Michael Scott is one of the funniest sitcom characters ever, and that's thanks to the fact that his constant need for attention and lack of boundaries led to some of the most amusing and painful moments of awkward comedy in TV history.

His lack of self-awareness took the concept of being a boss and turned it into what seemed like a nightmare for his workers, yet still managed to charm the viewers into loving him, as his joyful naivety and blissful optimism was always a joy to behold. Yet, there were a fair few moments where he may have stepped too far over the line.

10. Indulged In Nepotism

Michael Scott genuinely cared for his workers, that much is indisputable. While he abused his power often and struggled with boundaries, he can never be accused of hating his staff. However, that doesn't mean he wasn't perfectly willing to set their concerns and issues aside for the sake of nepotism.

Advertisement

The issue of giving preference to family members is all over jobs and businesses, so it's no surprise that it made its way to The Office. This moment came during the appropriately titled episode "Nepotism" after Michael hired a young man called Luke Cooper.

Luke wasn't just any old employee. He was the son of Michael's estranged half-sister and was only hired so Michael could get back in favour with her. Sadly for him, this plan didn't work as Luke was an absolute disaster in the workplace. He deliberately goofed around, messed up drink orders and had the worst work ethic possible.

Despite the protestations of his other workers, Michael defended Luke time and time again, for no reason other than the fact that they were related. However, this all came to a head after Luke annoyed everyone with a laser pointer, and Michael stepped in by spanking him in front of the entire office.

9. Poured Coffee On Holly's Woody Doll

There are a lot of things that can bring out the worst in people, and jealousy is undoubtedly one. If even the most reasonable people can respond poorly to this emotion, then bet your bottom dollar Michael Scott's going to go overboard with it.

Advertisement

During the episode "Classy Christmas", Michael acted anything but classy, as his former fling Holly Flax returned to the office and brought the news that she was still dating A.J - much to Michael's dismay. In an immature response, he waited until he was alone and then took a Woody toy that A.J had bought for Holly, threw it in the trash and poured coffee on it.

Naturally, Holly was devastated by this, yet in response, when Michael admitted his crime, he ended up guilt-tripping her into feeling bad for him, as he was sad that she was willing to work long distance with A.J but not him.

Being heartbroken is always an awful thing to go through, but that gave Michael no right to act like such a jealous jerk. Even if he was sad, he shouldn't have sought to do something that he knew would hurt someone he cared for.

8. Bullied Toby

This entry isn't focused on one specific moment, rather on the constant relationship between Michael Scott and Toby Flenderson.

Advertisement

There were loads of hilarious couplings in The Office, such as Dwight/Jim or Mindy/Ryan, but one of the best had to be these two. Michael's constant irritancy and lack of concern for Toby and Toby's reluctant involvement in Michael's life was a continual source of laughs. But when you step back and look at it, it was actually workplace harassment.

Here's a highlight reel of some of Michael's worst behaviour towards Toby: constantly belittling him, refusing to let him have a doughnut, pushing his lunch tray on the floor, mocking him in his leaving interview, his iconic "No!" reaction when Toby returned to the office and this horrifying quote...

"If I had a gun, with two bullets, and I was in a room with Hitler, Bin Laden, and Toby, I would shoot Toby twice."

The irony comes from the fact that Toby was the Human Resources Representative, meaning that his job was to ensure a safe and healthy work environment. Although, as he was constantly at odds with such issues, that might have been why Michael hated him so much.

7. His Entire Relationship With Jan

It's safe to say that Michael and relationships didn't blend too well. His way with women was less like a smooth ride and more a car wreck. He constantly overstepped boundaries and struggled to take responsibility for anything he did wrong. This was abundantly clear in his toxic relationship with Jan Levinson.

Advertisement

At first, these two seemed like a great opposites attract moment, but that soon faded. Michael was way too eager initially, especially as Jan insisted they were not a thing and that their drunken kiss was a mistake. His insistence somehow paid off, as they eventually did become something, but Michael soon learned that her coldness and mistreatment wasn't what he wanted.

However, after breaking up with her, she revealed that she'd had breast augmentation surgery, and against his better judgement, he ran right back to her. It all culminated with the utterly horrifying episode "The Dinner Party", in which the duo hosted an evening at their home and let all the issues in their relationship slip out.

While Jan certainly didn't come out of this looking great, Michael had strong-armed this relationship into being and then realised that he never even wanted it. It wasn't all his fault, but his behaviour fanned the flames that burned them down.

6. His Diwali Day Proposal

To continue the trend of Michael Scott and his abysmal relationships comes the terrible moment when he caused havoc at the Diwali Day celebration. Not only was his lack of understanding the celebration's tradition and meaning bad enough, but his grand romantic gesture went down like a wet firecracker.

Advertisement

After Kelly invited the office to a Diwali celebration, an overly excited Michael got very vocal about it. He mistakenly believed that Diwali was essentially an Indian Halloween, and thus told his date, Carol, to turn up in a costume. Sadly, she was distraught to discover that it wasn't a costume party at all, and was now at the party dressed as a cheerleader.

To make matters worse, at some point during the evening, in what seemed like a romantic gesture - but was likely just a desire for attention - Michael publicly proposed to Carol. This could have been romantic if it weren't for the fact that it was only their ninth date.

Michael's optimism and ignorance can often be adorable, but acting so selfishly and lacking any self-awareness made this one of his worst moments. However, on one nice note, the actor playing Carol was Steve Carell's real-life wife, Nancy Carell. So at least they got a happy ending in reality.

5. Pretended To Fire Pam

No one can say that Michael didn't give them a fair warning for the awful behaviour he was going to emit, as this terrible moment came from the pilot episode and still holds up as one of his worst actions in the whole show.

Advertisement

In this inaugural episode, Michael took the time to show the new temporary worker Ryan around the office and tried to show him how he works as a boss, i.e. friend first, boss second. To do so, he decided to bring the receptionist Pam in for a prank.

But, his idea of a prank was far away from Jim's funny shenanigans, as he told her that she was being fired for stealing post-it notes, which she adamantly denied. Rather than letting her know he was joking as she started to get emotional, he continued the gag, leading to awkward tension in the room and poor Pam bursting into tears.

Keen Office fans will also likely recall when he played the same trick on the new receptionist Erin. However, while that was bad too - and he should have learnt his lesson - he revealed the truth of the joke quickly enough to relieve the tension, whereas here it went on for far too long.

4. Outing Oscar Then Forcibly Kissing Him

The Office was no stranger to cringe-inducing episodes, as the show's awkwardness was always one of its key selling points. Amongst the series' catalogue of horrible episodes comes the ever difficult to watch "Gay Witch Hunt", in which Michael makes himself out to be a fool and does some awful things to Oscar.

Advertisement

During this outing, Michael got into trouble for calling Oscar a homophobic slur. He's told that the term is offensive due to Oscar being gay. To quell this, he tried to apologise to Oscar but inadvertently ended up outing him in front of the entire office. As this was a personal matter for Oscar, it caused him significant distress, especially after receiving a backlash from Angela.

Oscar soon revealed that he no longer wanted to work in this environment, and to stop him from going, Michael tried to hug him. The scene soon devolved as, after an altercation, Michael decided to prove a point by forcibly kissing Oscar in front of everyone, with no concern for the fact that Oscar didn't want to.

If you look at his actions in this episode on paper, it's terrifying. So it's a miracle that the show managed to make this such a memorable moment.

3. Almost Ruined Phyllis' Wedding

A person's wedding day is the one time in their life when they can unabashedly hog all the attention. That should have been Phyllis' experience when she walked down the aisle to marry her beloved Bob Vance of Vance Refrigeration. Sadly, it wasn't so simple, as Michael Scott had to make the entire ordeal about him.

Advertisement

During this episode, Phyllis reveals that she has granted Michael a position in the ceremony in exchange for six weeks off for her honeymoon. His job is to wheel her father down the aisle, and as expected, he accepts as he unrightfully thinks of himself as the father of the bride.

However, he's distraught when her father stands from his wheelchair in a beautiful moment to walk her down the aisle himself. Soon, he tries desperately to recapture the limelight that he falsely thinks he deserves. It all culminates in an overdrawn toast in which he discusses far too personal matters and ends up getting ejected from the ceremony.

What's worst about this whole ordeal is that he's completely blind to his actions. After being kicked out, he sulks and feels sorry for himself, with no remorse or understanding of his atrocious behaviour.

2. Led The Abysmal Diversity Day

Michael Scott is a very likeable guy, despite all of his flaws. He tried too hard to be loved by everyone, but that often gave him this weirdly sweet and pitiful energy that made viewers forgive him easily. But, oh boy, it was tough to do that with this one.

Advertisement

This entire episode was painful from start to finish as Michael Scott had barely any credentials to be leading a trip to the supermarket, let alone a sensitive day of diversity training.

The episode began with a guest speaker coming to Dunder Mifflin to deliver sensitivity training, to which Michael also attempted to join in and ruined it completely. He even performed an offensive Chris Rock impression and was upset when the speaker highlighted his problematic behaviour.

To try and redeem himself - and probably "prove" he isn't racist - Michael decided to run his own session and forced all of his staff to wear post-it notes labelling them as certain ethnicities/nationalities and racially profiling each other.

Thankfully, he did get a small amount of comeuppance after delivering an incredibly racist Indian stereotype to Kelly and getting promptly slapped in the face. Still, he probably deserved way worse for this one.

1. Pledged To Pay For Children's College Tuition

This episode is so painful to sit through that many viewers can't even do it, such is the cringe-inducing power of Scott's Tots. It's a great moment for the show, but one quite easily ranks as the worst decision Michael Scott has ever made.

Advertisement

Scott's Tots reveals that during a trip to an elementary school a decade prior, Michael pledged to pay for a class of third-graders college tuition if they graduated high school. Of course, he made this promise thinking he'd be able to do so in ten years, but it was an utterly hollow pledge as he doesn't have the means to do so now.

Things only get worse as he arrives at the school to let them down, but is treated by an array of special thank you messages, including a room named after him, heartfelt speeches and even an entire song about how he will "make their dreams come true". Then, it all comes crashing down as he admits his fault to them.

Unlike many of his other decisions, this one was made with good intentions. Still, it's safe to say that Pam's reaction upon hearing about Scott's Tots was absolutely right.

"Michael. This is a terrible, terrible thing you've done. It's terrible, just terrible".
Advertisement