The Simpsons: All 13 Christmas Episodes Ranked

Tis the season to reflect on a baker's dozen of Simpsons Christmas episodes!

By Jay Anderson /

The Simpsons started, as far as the family you know and love is concerned, as a Christmas special. Back in 1989, the debut episode of Fox's The Simpsons, a thirty minute animated sitcom based on the Tracey Ullman short created by Matt Groening, was the classic Simpsons Roasting On An Open Fire, which saw the Simpson family, led by hapless father figure Homer, get a greyhound for Christmas - the simple but loving Santa's Little Helper. The episode was a hit, connecting with audiences, and a franchise unlike any other on prime time television was born. Twenty-five years later, The Simpsons just aired yet another Christmas special in time for the holidays, so what better time is there to look back at just over a dozen of their best holiday-themed episodes? Really, over a dozen? While not as iconic as Halloween€™s Treehouse of Horror series, there have been more Christmas Simpson episodes than you think! Not every episode set in winter with a mention of Christmas really counts, either. There will be no Mr. Plow in the pages to come, in case you were wondering. Nor will there be Dude, Where's My Ranch - included in The Simpsons Christmas 2 collection on DVD, but with only a tenuous link to the holiday. While various sources will tell you there have been seventeen Simpsons Christmas episodes, those that only mention Christmas have been excluded. Instead, lets take a look at episodes actually focusing on Christmas that try to reach the heights of that original episode, and see if any came close - or surpassed it. So with no further adieu, here are the thirteen Simpsons Christmas episodes, ranked from "meh" to "best episode ever!"

13. She Of Little Faith

Season 13's She Of Little Faith is almost more of a Lisa episode than a Christmas episode, and is known as the episode in which Lisa converts to Buddhism. Nominated for an Emmy (it lost to an episode of Futurama), the episode sees Lisa become disenchanted with the commercialization of Christianity, and eventually turning to Buddhism when she happens across Springfield's Buddhist temple, where she finds Lenny, Carl, plus actor Richard Gere, the latter of whom teaches her the basics of the belief system. She Of Little Faith gets high marks for its portrayal of Buddhism, and it's a character trait for Lisa that has lasted through the seasons, but, really, Christmas doesn't come into the equation until Marge tries to bribe Lisa back to Christianity with it. Of course, it's pointed out that being Buddhist allows practitioners to take part in other religious traditions, and therefore Lisa is free to continue celebrating Christmas with her family. Oh, and Marge initially tries to bribe Lisa with a pony (cue "it's been done!" comments). It's an episode that functions better as character development for Lisa, and less as a holiday story, and for that, it's on the bottom of the list. As a Christmas story, it ranks a solid "meh."

12. Simpsons Christmas Stories

Simpsons _____ Stories are basically the new clip shows. Simpsons Bible Stories anyone? While they don't recycle footage, they're sort of a cop-out. It's almost as if the writers couldn't come up with a full episode, and decided to go with smaller segments instead. Simpsons Christmas Stories is a mixed bag as a result. The first story is a retelling of the birth of Christ, while the second sees Grandpa out for revenge on Santa Claus. The final segment starts with Springfield elementary performing the Nutcracker, and ending with Marge giving Homer a present - a present wrapped and labelled as being to herself, because she knew Homer would forget to get her something. The gift gag was pretty classic, but the rest of this seventeenth season episode was pretty weak, also placing it in the "meh" category.

11. 'Tis The Fifteenth Season

A retelling of the Charles Dickens classic A Christmas Carol, Simpsons style. Sort of. Unfortunately for The Simpsons, Season 15 was one of the worst seasons of the show's history, and it didn't produce the most memorable Christmas special. The plot, such as it is, sees Homer forgetting that he's Lenny's Secret Santa at work. He winds up giving him a pack of Certs, then Burns cancels the Christmas bonus but gives Homer a Joe DiMaggio rookie card for Bart, which Homer in turn sells to Comic Book Guy. Lost yet? The family uses the money from the baseball card to go shopping, and Homer promises them a Christmas tree, but spends the cash on himself. The family is peeved, Homer winds up watching a version of A Christmas Carol, then goes out and tries to become the nicest guy in town - bringing him into conflict with Flanders. The convoluted plot highlights everything wrong with mid-teen years Simpsons, making this one a bit of a Christmas dud.

10. White Christmas Blues

After snow falls in Springfield following an unusual heatwave, the town begins to cash in on being a winter tourist destination. White Christmas Blues shows the ugly side of Christmas consumerism, but as the town begins to gouge and Marge opens up a bed-and-breakfast for out of towners, viewers are most likely to be reminded of how Springfield gouged the makers of the Radioactive Man movie in an earlier, better episode. That said, White Christmas Blues isn't a bad episode, it's just sort of there. Skipping it, you're not missing anything classic, but you're still better off viewing it over Tis The Fifteenth Season.

9. Grift Of The Magi

The highlight of Grift of the Magi would be Homer, dressed as Santa, breaking into the Hibbert residence to steal back a Funzo doll while Lisa and Bart ran interference by singing Christmas carols at the front door. That moment, which has Homer knocking over the Christmas tree and being attacked by the Hibbert family mutt, was a true classic Simpsons moment. However, the rest of the episode, including a Gary Coleman guest spot, Moe opting out of suicide, and Mr. Burns suddenly become a post-ghost-visit Scrooge, was a bit tedious. And yes, this is the Funzo episode. For those who haven't watched it in a few years (it aired as part of season 11), it sees Springfield Elementary taken over by a corporation (Kid First Industries) who use the children for market research, eventually coming up with the Funzo doll, basically a Furby parody. The Funzos were programmed to destroy competing toys, so the Homer, Bart, and Lisa teamed up to eliminate them. It wasn't a bad episode, it just wasn't as classic as it could have been. Things are still a little "meh" - but looking up!

8. The Fight Before Christmas

The Fight Before Christmas - like Simpsons Christmas Stories before it - is an anthology episode broken into several segments, in this case four dream segments based in and around Christmas. However, unlike Season 17's special, this Season 22 Christmas special knocks it out of the park for the most part. While it may not be as good as earlier Simpsons Christmas classics, The Fight Before Christmas still brings the laughs, starting with Bart plotting to kill Santa for not bringing him the gift he really wanted, and ending with a live-action appearance by Katy Perry alongside Simpsons muppets that has a rather naughty oral sex joke between her and Moe the Bartender. Santa no doubt had Perry on the naughty list for that one, but she's probably been on there most years.

7. Kill Gill Volumes I & II

Kill Gill Volumes I & II wasn't just the show's first Gil-centric episode, it was also a Christmas episode, with Gil staying with the Simpson family over the holidays after once again being down on his luck. With Gil being the newest "classic" character on the show, it was a welcome change, though there were some missteps, such as the "who cares" cameo of figure skater Elvis Stojko. It does get quite a few things right however, like Gil refusing to take back the gift he had accidentally sold for Lisa (which gets him fired from his job at Costington's, necessitating his staying with the Simpson clan), Marge taking eleven months to grow a backbone and kick Gil out (only to find he's already gone), and Gil serving as a mall santa (just the concept works, given he's such a lovable loser). Again, not on part with the best Simpsons Christmas episodes, but a solid middle-of-the-pack effort.

6. Holidays Of Future Passed

Season twenty-three's Holidays Of Future Passed is not only a decent Christmas Simpsons episode, it's also one of the better "glimpse into the future" episodes of the series. Featuring the Simpson kids taking their own children to see Homer and Marge for the holidays, the episode manages to avoid many of the failings of past "future" episodes, or at least downplays them (Lisa, for example, is still involved with Milhouse, but the situation isn't mined for awkward humour as badly as usual). Over the course of the show, we find Bart trying to grow up and be a real dad, Lisa learning that her daughter really does respect and admire her, Maggie once again finding an excuse not to talk even as a grown up (despite being a singer), and in a stroke of genius, Grandpa being cryogenically frozen despite the disease he was suffering from already having been cured (he was too rude for Homer to want to thaw him out, leading to a hilarious thaw/freeze/thaw/freeze segment of grandpa mouthing off). Sight gags work well in this episode as well - Moe's being a continuous crime scene, and the cryogenics facility being in a graveyard, for example. This is one of those episodes where a modern Simpsons tale outshines many of the earlier efforts.

5. I Won't Be Home For Christmas

The current season's entry into the Christmas special category was actually quite good, with the episode going for heartwarming, which the show often does very well, over topical ideas or just going for laughs. The basic story has Marge furious that Homer is a no-show for Christmas dinner - but he has a very good reason, as a lonely Moe has tricked his pal into spending more time with him on what is, for a guy like Moe, the loneliest day of the year. With this unknown to Marge (at least at the time), she gives Homer the boot, and he winds up wandering Springfield until Marge eventually tracks him down. Airing twenty-five years to the week of the original, it's an episode that reminds you that the show has still got it when it really puts the effort in.

4. Skinner's Sense Of Snow

"Okay Skinner, that's the last time you'll slap your Willie around!" That's just one of the classic lines in Skinner's Sense of Snow - an episode from season twelve that seems to get better and better with age, with the exception of a vision of Lisa as a camel appearing (to Homer, anyway) at the end of the episode to wish everyone a Merry Christmas. Aside from that misstep, however, it's all classic Simpsons. In the episode, Springfield Elementary is the only school open during a bad snow storm just before Christmas, and the kids wind up snowed in (after having been forced to watch the horrible Grinch knock-off The Christmas That Almost Wasn't But Then Was with Skinner). Eventually, they capture Skinner and tie him up in a ball sack, but not before they consider tunneling out, only to be thwarted by their principal. In the end, Skinner sends the class hamster Nibbles for help in his ball, which pays off towards the end, when Skinner exclaims "Nibbles, chew threw my ball sack!" in the hopes of escaping. Yes, it's juvenile, but it's funny. Not "best episode ever" funny, but we're getting there!

3. Simpsons Roasting On An Open Fire

The original is, of course, hard to top, which is why it's so far up on the list. Twenty-five years ago, The Simpsons debuted on Fox with their holiday special Simpsons Roasting On An Open Fire. It was an animated sitcom unlike any ever seen before, without the wholesome, straightforward approach of say The Flintstones or The Jetsons, and with all the moral ambiguity of real life suburban living. It was a show finding its footing, and introducing the basic cast of characters. Animation was crude (though miles ahead of their Tracey Ullman sketches), voices not yet perfected, but the core concept was there, as was its heart. Which makes it a very, very hard episode to top - especially given in the end, you get Santa's Little Helper as part of the deal.

2. Marge Be Not Proud

One of the few Christmas Simpsons episodes to surpass the original, Marge Be Not Proud came in the seventh season, and was only the second Simpsons episode with a Christmas theme. That's right - after the pilot Simpsons Roasting On An Open Fire the show didn't revisit the season for over six years (there are actually seventeen episodes considered Christmas Simpsons episodes, but several of them have only the most tenuous links to the holiday). In any case, the wait was worth it. Marge Be Not Proud is the story of a conflicted Bart, a mother's trust, disappointment, and love, and a look at the Simpson family at a time when Bart was still evolving. His delinquency wasn't taken for granted, but seen as something that could be prevented, and he still frequently showed more heart than he ever would in later seasons. The plot has Bart busted for shoplifting a video game Marge won't buy him for Chrismas, letting down his mother, and ruining a family photo at the local mall. Throughout the episode, Bart, fearing his mom no longer loves him, works to regain her trust, and we get one of the sweetest mother-son moments the show has ever provided. This is an episode from a show that has found its footing, which is why it's ahead of the pilot. Also, Bart winding up with a terrible golf game at the end is just classic.

1. Miracle On Evergreen Terrace

Complete with the Tickle Me Krusty doll ("Hey kid, get your finger out of there!"), season 9'S Miracle On Evergreen Terrace is a true Simpsons Christmas classic. In it, Bart gets into his Christmas presents early, with one being a pretty snazzy fire truck which, ironically, winds up starting a fire, wrecking the family tree and destroying the family's presents. Bart blames it all on a burglar (giving a stereotypical description of a thief in a striped shirt, black mask, and sack with a dollar sign on it), and the citizens of Springfield wind up donating their hard earned money to help the family get their Christmas back. However, when melting snow uncovers the evidence of the mangled presents that Bart had tried to hide, the town discovers that they've been had, and the Simpsons are once again pariahs in Springfield. In the end, all is forgiven - when the townsfolk loot the family homestead. Best episode ever? Okay maybe not, but arguably the best Christmas episode. How would you rank these Christmas tales? Any others you would include?